‘Welfare States’ and Social Policies in Eastern Europe and the Former USSR: Where Informality Fits In?

Abstract

Since the end of socialism scholars have been debating whether post-socialist welfare policies in Eastern Europe and the former USSR could be considered converging into Western European patterns, and possibly fit one of Esping-Andersen's (1990) welfare state classifications, or whether they should be considered an exception or sui generis and therefore studied beyond these categories. This article is informed by post-2008 crisis material and contends that neither of the above interpretative frameworks is appropriate because they both miss the role of informal welfare provision and informal renegotiations of the scope of welfare policies. Going beyond the transitional-alternative paradigm, this article situates itself in the structure–agency debate in defining how welfare policies are renegotiated by domestic and local actors and come to form a partially new system. Rather than seeing the former socialist region as an exception, it suggests that the very debate about the welfare state and welfare policies should be revisited in order to consider also informality as a major element of social policy-making.

Keywords::

• Eastern Europe
• informal sector
• Lithuania
• Romania
• social policies
• welfare state

Notes

¹ It has been suggested that squatters often come from privileged families so to question the social role of the squat (we should thank Lea Sgier for this and other useful observation on this paper). While acknowledging the need for a debate on the real function of squats, we have kept our example since its goal is to provide an alternative explanation on a social phenomenon rather than assessing to what extent this is useful to whom.

² Source: http://www.scribd.com/doc/48801903/Swedbank-Analysis-Lithuania-December-2011 (accessed 9 July 2012).

³ See the homepage of the Lithuanian Labour Control: http://www.vdi.lt/index.php?-1371079622 (accessed 9 July 2012).

⁴ The Romanian paid parental leave is available until children's first or second birthdays, depending on the parents' choice.

Additional information

Funding

Funding

This research was supported by the Marie Curie schemes of the Research and Executive Agency of the European Commission [grant numbers 318961, 295232 and 316825].