A Decade of Research on the Environmental Impacts of Pulp and Paper Mill Effluents in Canada: Field Studies and Mechanistic Research

Abstract

Studies conducted in Sweden in the early 1980s provided some of the first evidence that effluents from some pulp mills were capable of inducing toxic responses in fish at very low concentrations in the receiving environment. In response to these findings, studies were initated in Canada and impacts of primary treated bleached kraft mill effluent on reproductive function in fish were found. Reproductive impacts in fish were not limited to mills that used chlorine in the bleaching process and were also evident at some mills that employed secondary effluent treatment. In 1992, new federal regulations were passed under the Canadian Environmental Protection Act to control releases of dioxins and furans, and a new Pulp and Paper Effluent Regulation under the Fisheries Act set stricter limits for biological oxygen demand and total suspended solids. Very importantly, the new regulations included requirements for environmental effects monitoring (EEM) at all mill sites. This allowed the effectiveness of the control limits in protecting fish, fish habitat, and human use of fisheries resources to be assessed. At the same time, the Minister of the Environment launched an intensive government, industry, and university research program. Results from this research program along with feedback from the EEM program would then be used to define what additional control actions might be necessary. This article reviews the field studies and mechanistic research conducted in Canada following the implementation of the new federal regulations. Great progress has been made in this area, first demonstrating reproductive effects at various locations, then determining the mechanisms responsible for the reproductive effects at specific sites, followed by the demonstration of partial recovery in reproductive function following process and treatment changes in response to the new regulations. However, it is clear from the results of the first two cycles of the EEM program that mill effluents still affect the local receiving environments at a number of locations across Canada, and that continued research combining field studies, bioassay application, and chemical identification is required.

Completion of this assessment would not have been possible without the helpful comments and scientific reviews provided by Drs. John Carey, Jim Maguire, Kelly Munkittrick, Glen Van Der Kraak, Jim Sherry, and Olöf Sandstrom.

Notes

Completion of this assessment would not have been possible without the helpful comments and scientific reviews provided by Drs. John Carey, Jim Maguire, Kelly Munkittrick, Glen Van Der Kraak, Jim Sherry, and Olöf Sandstrom.

CEPA. 1999. Canadian Environmental Protection Act. The House of Commons of Canada, Bill C-32, as passed by the House of Commons, June 1

Gibbons, W. N., Munkittrick, K. R., and Taylor, W. D. 1996. Characteristics of Spoonhead sculpins and Lake chub in the Athabasca river near sites which discharge pulp mill effluents. Northern Rivers Study Board Report 100, Project 2353-D1 (Forage fish collections in the Athabasca River)

Jardine, J. J. 1994. Impacts of physical stressors on physiological fitness of white sucker at a bleached kraft pulp mill site. MSc thesis, Department of Zoology, University of Guelph, Guelph, ON

McMaster, M. E. 1995. Mechanisms of reproductive dysfunction in fish exposed to various pulp mill effluents, and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon contamination. PhD thesis, University of Guelph, Guelph, Ontario

McMaster, M. E. and Munkittrick, K. R. 2000. Final report “Papier Masson mill field studies examining reproductive function in feral fish—Research program for Cycle II of the Environmental Effects Monitoring Program for the Papier Masson mill in Masson, Quebec.” March 31, 2000. Cycle Two Environmental Effects Monitoring Program

McMaster, M. E., Munkittrick, K. R., Cobden, C., and Groves, M. 2000a. Final Report “Field studies examining reproductive function in feral fish downstream of the Bowater Pulp and Paper Canada Inc. newsprint mill in Gatineau, Quebec.” March 31. Cycle Two Environmental Effects Monitoring Program

McMaster, M. E., Hewitt, L. M., Kohli, M., and Van Der Kraak, G. J. 2002b. Detailed endocrine assessment of wild fish and characterization of responsible EDCs at pulp mill sites. Final report for TSRI Project 199

Richard, Y. 1996. Le bassin versant de la rivière Saint-Francçois: Les communautés ichtyologiques et l'integrité biotique du milieu. Ministère de l'Environnement et de la Faune, Direction des ecosystems aquatiques, Envirodoq no. EN960254, rapport no. EA-3

Robinson, R. D. 1994. Evaluation and development of laboratory protocols for estimating reproductive impacts of pulp mill effluent on fish. PhD thesis, University of Guelph, Guelph, Ontario

Swanson, S. M., Schyer, R., Shelast, B., Holley, K., Berbekar, I., Kloepper-Sams, P., Owens, J. W., Steeves, L., Birkholtz, D., and Marchant, T. 1993. Wapiti–Smokey River Ecosystem Study. Final report, Weyerhauser Canada, Grande Prairie, Alberta