Power Hand Tool Kinetics Associated with Upper Limb Injuries in an Automobile Assembly Plant

Abstract

This study investigated the relationship between pneumatic nutrunner handle reactions, workstation characteristics, and prevalence of upper limb injuries in an automobile assembly plant. Tool properties (geometry, inertial properties, and motor characteristics), fastener properties, orientation relative to the fastener, and the position of the tool operator (horizontal and vertical distances) were measured for 69 workstations using 15 different pneumatic nutrunners. Handle reaction response was predicted using a deterministic mechanical model of the human operator and tool that was previously developed in our laboratory, specific to the measured tool, workstation, and job factors. Handle force was a function of target torque, tool geometry and inertial properties, motor speed, work orientation, and joint hardness. The study found that tool target torque was not well correlated with predicted handle reaction force (r = 0.495) or displacement (r = 0.285). The individual tool, tool shape, and threaded fastener joint hardness all affected predicted forces and displacements (p < 0.05). The average peak handle force and displacement for right-angle tools were twice as great as pistol grip tools. Soft-threaded fastener joints had the greatest average handle forces and displacements. Upper limb injury cases were identified using plant OSHA 200 log and personnel records. Predicted handle forces for jobs where injuries were reported were significantly greater than those jobs free of injuries (p < 0.05), whereas target torque and predicted handle displacement did not show statistically significant differences. The study concluded that quantification of handle reaction force, rather than target torque alone, is necessary for identifying stressful power hand tool operations and for controlling exposure to forces in manufacturing jobs involving power nutrunners. Therefore, a combination of tool, work station, and task requirements should be considered.

Keywords:

• musculoskeletal disorders
• nutrunners
• power hand tools
• repetitive motion injuries
• screwdrivers
• tool force
• tool torque

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

This study was sponsored by a grant from the UAW-DaimlerChrysler Joint Committee on Occupational Safety and Health.

Notes

^A p < 0.05.

^A p < 0.05.   

^B p < 0.01.