A Comparison of the Wheeler-Jonas Model and the Linear Driving Force at Constant-Pattern Model for the Prediction of the Service Time of Activated Carbon Cartridges

Abstract

The linear driving force (LDF) model is applied to predict the service life of activated carbon cartridges. It is compared with the currently used Wheeler-Jonas equation, which results from a model of chemical reaction kinetics. The LDF model is based on a mass transfer model of adsorbate into the particle. The two models are studied in constant-pattern conditions. The properties of the two models are first clarified and then compared. It is shown that the Wheeler-Jonas equation leads to symmetrical breakthrough curves, whereas the constant-pattern LDF equation results in asymmetrical curves. Thus, the curvature of the isotherm has no influence on the shape of the Wheeler-Jonas curve. For the LDF breakthrough curve, it is shown that the asymmetry increases with the curvature of the isotherm. Wheeler-Jonas can be used with a Dubinin-Raduskevitch isotherm, whereas the LDF model analytical solution is valid for a Langmuir isotherm only. The LDF model can be used with the DR isotherm, but a numerical solution is required. At very low concentrations where the isotherm is linear, the constant pattern no longer exists and both models fail. The Dubinin-Raduskevitch isotherm must be fitted with a Langmuir isotherm to use the analytical solution of the LDF model.

Keywords:

• adsorption
• activated carbon
• cartridge
• model