Respiratory Protection for Firefighters— Evaluation of CBRN Canisters for Use During Overhaul

Abstract

In the United States, there are approximately 366,600 structural fires each year. After visible flames are extinguished, firefighters begin the overhaul stage of firefighting to smother remaining hot spots and initiate investigations. Typically during overhaul significant ambient concentrations of chemical contaminants remain. However, previous research suggests that the use of air purifying respirators (APR) fitted with chemical, biological, radiological, and nuclear (CBRN) canisters may reduce occupational respiratory exposures. This pilot study used large-scale prescribed burns of representative structural materials to perform simultaneous, side-by-side, filtering and service-life evaluations of commercially available CBRN filters. Three types of CBRN canisters and one cartridge were challenged in repetitive post live-fire overhaul exposure tests using a sampling manifold apparatus. At a flow rate of 80L/min, nine tests were conducted in the breathing zone for three different exposure durations (0–15 min, 0–30 min, and 0–60 min). Fifty different chemicals were identified for evaluation and results indicate that 21 of the 50 chemicals tested were in the air of the overhaul environment. Respirable particles and formaldehyde were consistently present above the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH®) recommended exposure level (REL) and threshold limit ceiling value (TLV_c), respectively. Each filter effectively reduced concentrations for respirable particulates below the maximum recommended level. Formaldehyde was reduced, but not consistently filtered below the TLV_c. These results were consistent across all exposure durations. This study indicates that, regardless of brand, CBRN filters provide protection from the vast majority of particle and gas-phase contaminants. However, due to formaldehyde breakthrough, CBRN filters do not provide complete protection during firefighter overhaul.

Keywords:

• firefighter
• overhaul
• protection
• respiratory

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

This work could not have been conducted without the partnership of professional firefighters of the Northwest Fire District and scientific collaboration of the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health, National Personal Protective Technology Laboratory team (Contract #200-2012-M-53198). Also, a special thanks to Tony “TMFR” Raley for the fabrication of the sampling manifold.