In vitro human helper T-cell assay to screen antibody drug candidates for immunogenicity

Abstract

Monoclonal antibody (mAb) drugs offer a number of valuable treatments. Many newly developed mAb drugs include artificial modification of amino acid sequences from human origin, which may cause higher immunogenicity to induce anti-drug antibodies (ADA). If the immunogenicity of a new candidate can be understood in the nonclinical phase, clinical studies will be safer and the success rate of development improved. Empirically, in vitro immunogenicity assays with human cells have proved to be sufficiently sensitive to nonhuman proteins, but not to human/humanized mAb. To detect the weaker immunogenicity of human-based mAb, a more sensitive biomarker for in vitro assays is needed. The in vitro study here developed a proliferation assay (T_H cell assay) using flow cytometry analysis that can detect a slight increase in proliferating T_H cells. Samples from 218 donors treated with a low-immunogenic drug (etanercept) were measured to determine a positive threshold level. With this threshold, positive donor percentages among PBMC after treatment with higher-immunogenicity mAb drugs were noted, that is, 39.5% with humanized anti-human A33 antibody (hA33), 27.3% with abciximab, 25.9% with adalimumab, and 14.8% with infliximab. Biotherapeutics with low immunogenicity yielded values of 0% for basiliximab and 3.7% for etanercept. These data showed a good comparability with previously reported incidences of clinical ADA with the evaluated drugs. Calculations based on the data here showed that a T_H cell assay with 40 donors could provide statistically significant differences when comparing low- (etanercept) versus highly immunogenic mAb (except for infliximab). Based on the outcomes here, for screening purposes, a practical cutoff point of 3/20 positives with 20 donors was proposed to alert immunogenicity of mAb drug candidates.

Keywords:

• Immunogenicity
• helper T cells
• T-cell epitopes
• flow cytometry
• antigen presentation
• monoclonal antibody drugs
• stimulation index
• bromodeoxyuridine

Acknowledgements

The authors would like to acknowledge Dr. Tomoaki Inoue of Chugai Pharmaceutical and Dr. Tomoyuki Igawa of Chugai Pharmabody Research for invaluable suggestions. The authors also would like to acknowledge Ms. Sally Matsuura of Chugai Pharmaceutical for her technical editing.

Disclosure statement

The authors declare no conflicts of interest. The authors alone are responsible for the content of this manuscript.