The interpretation of children's needs at home and in school

Abstract

Statements of need are used promiscuously by caretakers and children. The term may refer to mere wants (desire), to wants that have become socialized into secondary needs, to needs inferred by adults based on interpretations of future adaptive requirements, as well as to fundamental needs required for a child's well-being. It is important to distinguish the various uses of the term, first, because need carries an imperative–it would be unethical to frustrate a child's basic needs. Second, when confounding meanings, there is the risk that what appears as an expression of concern–‘you need to’–is more arbitrarily coercive than benevolent. Because even genuine needs are multiple and often in tension (protection and independence), separating meanings does not necessarily determine appropriate responses. Caretakers are advised to critically refine and reflect their need statements and, when balancing, remain faithful to the fundamental human need for autonomy.

Keywords:

• Children
• needs
• ethics
• schools
• home

Notes

Notes

1. When an adult and child are mentioned together, I have adopted the convention of using a female pronoun for the adult, a male pronoun for the child.