Pasture access and adaptive capacity in reindeer herding districts in Nordland, Northern Norway

Abstract

Resource access and livelihood flexibility have been identified in the literature as two critical determinants of adaptive capacity. This paper shows that these aspects play important roles in reindeer herding in Nordland County, Norway, in terms of resilience to changes in social-ecological systems. Throughout history, reindeer herders have been able to draw on a broad range of adaptation options, but increased pasture fragmentation and loss of grazing land increasingly affect herders’ adaptability to weather variability and climate change impacts. Our analysis of empirical material from three adjacent reindeer herding districts illustrates the linkages between socio-economic and environmental exposure sensitivities, how the herders adapt by exploring patterns of differential adaptive capacity, and how adaptive capacity is impacted. Two socio-economic (pasture encroachment and insufficient human resources) and two environmental (locked pastures and predation) exposure sensitivities emerged as the most prominent affecting pasture access, which was the most critical factor for ensuring the adaptive capacity of reindeer herders. Flexibility to alternate between adaptation strategies was another important characteristic. Adapting to these exposure sensitivities engenders benefits and unintended negative consequences for the herders. The key components to adaptive capacity identified in this paper provide an evidence-based focus for management action by those seeking to improve resilience of socio-ecological systems at the community level.

Keywords:

• Climate change
• adaptive capacity
• reindeer herding
• Nordland County
• Norway

Notes

¹ IPCC, Climate Change 2013; Climate Change 2014; ACIA, Arctic Climate Impact Assessment; Ford et al., “The Dynamic Multiscale Nature of Climate Change Vulnerability”; and Adger and Barnett, “Four Reasons for Concern about Adaptation to Climate Change.”

² Pape and Löffler, “Climate Change, Land Use Conflicts, Predation and Ecological Degradation as Challenges for Reindeer Husbandry in Northern Europe”; Smit et al., “Introduction to the CAVIAR Project and Framework”; and Bulgakova, “Climate Change, Vulnerability and Adaptation among Nenets Reindeer Herders.”

³ Benjaminsen et al., “Misreading the Arctic Landscape”; Reinert et al., “Adapting to Climate Change in Sami Reindeer Herding”; and Vistnes and Nellemann, “Avoidance of Cabins, Roads, and Power Lines by Reindeer during Calving.”

⁴ Eira, “The Silent Language of Snow: Sami Traditional Knowledge in Times of Climate Change”; Inga, “Traditional Ecological Knowledge among Reindeer Herders in Northern Sweden”; and Vistnes and Nellemann, Impacts of Human Activity on Reindeer and Caribou.

⁵ Solvang, Hver fjerde kalv døde alt for tidlig så Alf fikk en ide.

⁶ Fernandez-Gimenez and LeFebre, “Mobility in Pastoral Systems”; Næss, “Climate Change, Risk Management and the End of Nomadic Pastoralism”; Oba, “Mobility and the Sustainability of the Pastoral Production System in Africa”; and Merkle, “Nomadism: A Social-ecological Mode of Culture.”

⁷ Agrawal, “Mobility and Cooperation among Nomadic Shepherds.”

⁸ Næss, “Climate Change, Risk Management and the End of Nomadic Pastoralism.”

⁹ Lie, Riseth, and Holst, Reindeer Husbandry in a Changing Climate.

¹⁰ Tyler et al., “Saami Reindeer Pastoralism Under Climate Change”; Risvoll et al., “Does Pastoralists’ Participation in the Management of National Parks in Northern Norway Contribute to Adaptive Governance?”; and Oba, “Mobility and the Sustainability of the Pastoral Production system in Africa”.

¹¹ Maynard et al., “Impacts of Arctic Climate and Land Use Changes on Reindeer Pastoralism”; and Eira, “The Silent Language of Snow.”

¹² Eira, “The Silent Language of Snow”; and Reinert et al., “Adapting to Climate Change in Sami Reindeer Herding.”

¹³ Eira, “The Silent Language of Snow”; and Magga et al., EALAT Final Report and Executive Summary.

¹⁴ The three reindeer herding districts all border Sweden.

¹⁵ Risvoll, Fedreheim, and Galafassi, Tradeoffs in Pastoral Governance.

¹⁶ Denevan, “Adaptation, Variation and Cultural Geography”; and Armitage and Plummer, Adaptive Capacity and Environmental Governance.

¹⁷ Smit and Wandel, “Adaptation, Adaptive Capacity and Vulnerability”, 282.

¹⁸ IPCC, Climate Change 2014, 5.

¹⁹ Adger, Arnell, and Tompkins, “Successful Adaptation to Climate Change Across Scales”; Dessai, Lu, and Risbey, “On the Role of Climate Scenarios for Adaptation Planning”; Pitt and Randolph, “Identifying Obstacles to Community Climate Protection Planning”, Hovelsrud et al., “Adaptation in Fisheries and Municipalities”; and Hovelsrud and Smit, Community Adaptation and Vulnerability in Arctic Regions.

²⁰ Amundsen, Berglund, and Westskog, “Overcoming Barriers to Climate Change Adaptation.”

²¹ Ford and Smit, “A Framework for Assessing the Vulnerability of Communities in the Canadian Arctic to Risks Associated with Climate Change”; Smit and Wandel, “Adaptation, Adaptive Capacity and Vulnerability”; Smit, “Adaptation in the Arctic”; and Hovelsrud and Smit, Community Adaptation and Vulnerability in Arctic Regions.

²² Smit and Pilifosova, “Adaptation to Climate Change in the Context of Sustainable Development and Equity”; “From Adaptation to Adaptive Capacity and Vulnerability Reduction.”

²³ Kofinas, Clark, and Hovelsrud, “Adaptive and Transformative Capacity.”

²⁴ Smit et al., “Introduction to the CAVIAR Project and Framework”, 6; and Folke et al., “Resilience Thinking.”

²⁵ Hovelsrud and Smit, Community Adaptation and Vulnerability in Arctic Regions and references therein; Keskitalo et al., “Adaptive Capacity Determinants in Developed States: Examples from the Nordic Countries and Russia.”

²⁶ Keskitalo et al., “Adaptive Capacity Determinants in Developed States: Examples from the Nordic Countries and Russia.”

²⁷ Hovelsrud et al., “Adaptation in Fisheries and Municipalities”, 340; and Keskitalo et al., “Adaptive Capacity Determinants in Developed States: Examples from the Nordic Countries and Russia.”

²⁸ Ford and Smit, “A Framework for Assessing the Vulnerability of Communities in the Canadian Arctic to Risks Associated with Climate Change”; Ford, Smit, and Wandel, “Vulnerability to Climate Change in the Arctic”; Smit and Wandel, “Adaptation, Adaptive Capacity and Vulnerability”; and Nelson, Adger, and Brown, “Adaptation to Environmental Change.”

²⁹ Sixteen case studies described in Hovelsrud and Smit, Community Adaptation and Vulnerability in Arctic Regions.

³⁰ Vorren, Bosetning og ressursutnytting under veidekulturen og dens differensiering; Sande, Villmark i grenseland; and Berg et al., Samisk kulturkunnskap/Sámi kulturoahppu.

³¹ Bjørklund, “The Unpredictable Impact of Hybridization.”

³² Berg et al., Samisk kulturkunnskap/Sámi kulturoahppu; Vorren, Bosetning og ressursutnytting under veidekulturen og dens differensiering; and Bjørklund, “The Unpredictable Impact of Hybridization.”

³³ Berg, “Utviklingen av reindrift i nordre nordland 1750–2000.”

³⁴ NOU, Samisk naturbruk og rettssituasjon fra Hedmark til Troms, 14.

³⁵ Berg, “Utviklingen av reindrift i nordre nordland 1750–2000.”

³⁶ Sande, Villmark i grenseland.

³⁷ Berg, “Utviklingen av reindrift i nordre nordland 1750–2000.”

³⁸ Vorren, Bosetning og ressursutnytting under veidekulturen og dens differensiering; and Berg et al., Samisk kulturkunnskap/Sámi kulturoahppu.

³⁹ Berg, “Mot en korporativ reindrift”; and Sande, Villmark i grenseland.

⁴⁰ Berg, “Utviklingen av reindrift i nordre nordland 1750–2000.”

⁴¹ Sara, “Siida and Traditional Sami Reindeer Herding Knowledge.”

⁴² Paine, Herds of the Tundra; and Turi and Keskitalo, “Governing Reindeer Husbandry in Western Finnmark.”

⁴³ Prestvik, Arbeidsundersøkelse I reindriften.

⁴⁴ Ingold, Hunters, Pastoralists and Ranchers.

⁴⁵ Sande, Villmark i grenseland; and Berg, “Mot en korporativ reindrift.”

⁴⁶ Dankertsen, “Samisk artikulasjon.”

⁴⁷ Skogseid, Reindrift i Salten; and Sande, Villmark i grenseland.

⁴⁸ Sande, Villmark i grenseland.

⁴⁹ Tyler et al., “Saami Reindeer Pastoralism Under Climate Change”; and Maynard et al., “Impacts of Arctic Climate and Land Use Changes on Reindeer Pastoralism.”

⁵⁰ Reindeer Pasture Commission, Norwegian-Swedish Reindeer Pasture Commission.

⁵¹ Risvoll, Fedreheim, and Galafassi, Tradeoffs in Pastoral Governance.

⁵² Risvoll, Fedreheim, and Galafassi, Tradeoffs in Pastoral Governance.

⁵³ Risvoll et al., “Does Pastoralists’ Participation in the Management of National Parks in Northern Norway Contribute to Adaptive Governance?”

⁵⁴ Turunen and Vuojala-Magga, “Past and Present Winter Feeding of Reindeer in Finland.”

⁵⁵ Reindriftsforvaltningen, Nøkkeltall

⁵⁶ Nilsson, Adaption of Semi-domesticated Reindeer to Emergency Feeding.

⁵⁷ Smit et al., “Introduction to the CAVIAR Project and Framework.”

⁵⁸ Hovelsrud et al., “Adaptation in Fisheries and Municipalities”; and Keskitalo, “Climate Change, Vulnerability and Adaptive Capacity in a Multi-use Forest Municipality in Northern Sweden.”

⁵⁹ Fitchett, “Adaptive Co-management in the Context of Informal Settlements”; and Smit et al., “Introduction to the CAVIAR Project and Framework.”

⁶⁰ Sydneysmith et al., “Vulnerability and Adaptive Capacity in Arctic Communities.”

⁶¹ Chapin et al., “Ecosystem Stewardship.”