Design spaces and EEG frequency band power in constrained and open design

ABSTRACT

Design space is a common abstraction used in the investigation of design cognition. Characteristic properties of design spaces and how they change are underexplored. Design spaces can vary with the design task and its constraints, which are assumed to result in differences in neurocognitive processes. We review general cognition, creative cognition and design neurocognition EEG studies. We analyzed the brain activity of 32 professional mechanical engineers and industrial designers while performing constrained and open design tasks. The neurophysiological activations during reading the task, earliest reaction, and open externalization stages of constrained and open design are compared based on EEG frequency band power. Significant differences between constrained and open design for the beta bands were found in the earliest reaction stage. Significant differences between constrained and open design for alpha 2 and the beta bands were found in the open externalization stage. We discuss the results and relate the higher brain activity and significant differences in open design to cognitive functions of interest to design cognition. We show that EEG brain activation is sensitive to the level of constraints in designing, in particular alpha 2 and beta bands can act as proxies of the change and expansion of design spaces.

KEYWORDS:

• Design spaces
• constrained and open design
• electroencephalography
• mechanical engineers
• industrial designers
• design spaces index

Acknowledgments

Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation. The 1^st author plans to publish the data open access after completing the analyses of the experiment, and is available to provide data and details upon request.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).

Additional information

Funding

The research was funded by the Portuguese Foundation for Science and Technology (Grant No. SFRH/BPD/104281/2014). The third author acknowledges the support of the US National Science Foundation (Grant Nos CMMI-1762415 and EEC-1929896).