The Trump presidency: Democratic fatigue or fascism?

ABSTRACT

Donald Trump became the president that the American system of government was designed to avoid and that America’s founders feared; an anti-democratic leader who positioned himself as an alternative to that system. This critical rhetorical analysis initially deconstructs the founders’ vision of a system configured to vet, counter and neutralise anti-constitutional demagogues with leadership aspirations. The essay suggests such leadership as Donald Trump’s is the prototype of a legitimately elected leader who rhetorically deconstructs the political system which initially elevates them to office. In so doing, it becomes difficult if not impossible for that system to hold such a leader and their political organisation accountable for their actions, at least through democratic means. The essay also examines the impact of such dysfunctional political discourse on American democracy as well its global significance. It concludes speculatively by suggesting the enactment of a rhetorical narrative of constitutional patriotism as a counterpart to demagogic populism.

KEYWORDS:

• Presidents politics rhetoric democracy fascism

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).

Additional information

Notes on contributors

Colleen Kelley

Dr. Kelley is an Associate Professor of Rhetoric and Communication at Penn State-Erie, The Behrend College (U.S.) Her primary research areas are political communication, global media and democratic rhetoric.