The Natural Course of Musculoskeletal Symptoms and Clinical Findings in Upper Extremities of Female Milkers

Abstract

To explore milkers' state of health with regard to symptoms in the wrists and hands, a study of 80 female milkers was carried out 12 months after a Nordic questionnaire study of these subjects. Of these 80, 41 had reported pain and discomfort in the wrists and hands at the time of the questionnaire study, whereas the remaining 39 had had no such symptoms. To determine the sensitivity and specificity of the Nordic questionnaire, the follow-up study included examination by an unbiased clinician. The occurrence of symptoms in the wrists and hands during the preceding 12 months was found to have been rather stable—30 of the 41 milkers still reported pain, aching, and discomfort, and eight new cases were recorded. On clinical examination, symptoms including numbness, tingling, and coldness in the forearms and hands were reported by 51 of the 80 milkers, 14 of whom had clinical symptoms and signs indicating median nerve entrapment. Peritendinitis was diagnosed in four subjects and a ganglion cyst in one. The findings in the remaining group did not meet diagnostic criteria. All subjects with wrist and hand symptoms were still at work a year after the initial study. The sensitivity of the Nordic questionnaire when it came to identifying subjects with clinical findings was found to be unsatisfactory. The actual incidence of wrist and hand disorders may be underestimated if the Nordic questionnaire is used as the only instrument in epidemiologic screenings.

Keywords:

• milkers
• females
• upper extremity
• musculoskeletal symptoms
• clinical examination