The Estimation of Prediction Error

Abstract

Having constructed a data-based estimation rule, perhaps a logistic regression or a classification tree, the statistician would like to know its performance as a predictor of future cases. There are two main theories concerning prediction error: (1) penalty methods such as C_p, Akaike's information criterion, and Stein's unbiased risk estimate that depend on the covariance between data points and their corresponding predictions; and (2) cross-validation and related nonparametric bootstrap techniques. This article concerns the connection between the two theories. A Rao–Blackwell type of relation is derived in which nonparametric methods such as cross-validation are seen to be randomized versions of their covariance penalty counterparts. The model-based penalty methods offer substantially better accuracy, assuming that the model is believable.

KEY WORDS :

• C_p
• Degrees of freedom
• Nonparametric estimates
• Parametric bootstrap
• Rao-Blackwellization
• SURE