Commentary on “Gay and Lesbian Clients' Ratings of Psychiatrists, Psychologists, Social Workers, and Counselors”

Abstract

Becky Liddle's study is criticized, in part because its conclusions are based on only five individuals. Nonetheless, 5 of the psychiatrists reported on in this study were perceived by respondents to be homophobic. It is important to distinguish between what is a group phenomenon and what should be, more accurately, labeled a subgroup phenomenon. Furthermore, the author's selective discussion of findings seems to create an impression of greater bias within psychiatry that is only partially supported by the data. The findings are extraordinary in depicting so little homophobia in all of the mental health professions and should be replicated. In addition, diminishing inadequate practice behaviors is not synonymous with establishing exemplary, or perhaps even adequate, practice behaviors. All of the mental health professions need to help therapists become more knowledgeable about lesbian and gay issues. Having achieved an enormous change in attitudes about homosexuality and gay and lesbian persons, we now need to assure that all mental health professionals have sufficient knowledge and skills to help these individuals.

Key Words:

• Psychiatry
• homophobia
• homosexuality
• residency training