Dear editor
We read with interest the article by Shahid and AdamsCitation1 discussing the effects of time off before commencing medical school on emotional intelligence (EI). The authors concluded that EI was greater in those who had taken a gap year regardless of age, gender or type of medical degree. We feel that EI is important to help doctors manage stressful working environments and wanted to address certain aspects of the paper that we believe should be taken into consideration.
Firstly, residents were asked whether they took time off before medical school to work, carry out research or obtain an advanced degree; however EI of these trainees were not directly compared against each other. This means that it is difficult to determine which factor affects EI the most. Furthermore, the study does not account for other activities carried out during gap years such as travel or physical activity – which have been shown to increase EI.Citation2 Assuming that gap years alone increase EI is perhaps too simplistic a hypothesis as it could be the activity undertaken that increases EI.
Moreover, the authors argue that there was no association between age and EI. These results are confounded by Joseph et al,Citation3 who found a statistically significant increase in EI in medical students aged 22 years or above compared to all younger students (p=0.04), thus highlighting that normal aging may be a greater factor than the gap year itself. The authors reasoned that during a gap year ‘working with a diverse group of people leads to improved communication and relationship building’ – however this can also be achieved during medical school itself. Once again, this indicates that perhaps the activity carried out during the gap year is of greater influence on EI development.
Of note, this research was carried out on trainees: thus the scores achieved may not necessarily reflect the effects of a gap year, but rather all the experience gained throughout medical school. Although the paper discussed that type of medical school did not affect EI, some medical schools emphasise problem-based learning, oral examinations and reflective practise, all of which can increase EI. This means that further research is required to inform medical schools of the best methods of delivering teaching such that universities are aware of how to aid students in developing EI. Utilising the knowledge of what students carried out during their gap year can give universities insight into what should be incorporated into the curriculum.
The authors may wish to consider the effects of undertaking an intercalated degree or taking interruption of study during medical school. Both include taking some time off to pursue other interests and can lead to students working with different groups of people and increasing EI.Citation4,Citation5
Nonetheless, this research informs universities that gap years produce more EI doctors, meaning that students may wish to consider undertaking a gap year should they wish to strengthen their application. It also informs universities that there is perhaps a gap in the teaching that should be filled to reduce this discrepancy.
Disclosure
The authors report no conflicts of interest for this communication.
References
- Shahid R, Adams W. Emotional intelligence level higher in residents who took a gap year before medical school. Adv Med Educ Pract. 2020;11:559–562. doi:10.2147/AMEP.S268464
- Tsaousis I, Nikolaou I. Exploring the relationship of emotional intelligence with physical and psychological health functioning. Stress Health. 2005;21(2):77–86. doi:10.1002/smi.1042
- Joseph N, Panicker V, Nelliyanil M, Jindal A, Viveki R. Assessment and determinants of emotional intelligence and perceived stress among students of a medical college in south India. Indian J Public Health. 2015;59(4):310–313. doi:10.4103/0019-557X.169666
- Graham B, Elbeltagi H, Nelmes P, Jenkin A, Smith J. What difference can a year make? Findings from a survey exploring student, alumni and supervisor experiences of an intercalated degree in emergency care. BMC Med Educ. 2019;19(1):188. doi:10.1186/s12909-019-1579-x
- Agha R, Fowler A, Whitehurst K, Rajmohan S, Gundogan B, Koshy K. Why apply for an intercalated research degree? International journal of surgery. Oncology. 2017;2(6):e27. doi:10.1097/IJ9.0000000000000027