742
Views
3
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Review

Personalized skincare: from molecular basis to clinical and commercial applications

&
Pages 161-171 | Published online: 11 Apr 2018

Abstract

Individual responses of human skin to the environmental stress are determined by differences in the anatomy and physiology that are closely linked to the genetic characteristics such as pigmentation. Ethnic skin phenotypes can be distinguished based on defined genotypic traits, structural organization and compartmentalized sensitivity to distinct extrinsic aging factors. These differences are not only responsible for the variation in skin performance after exposure to damaging conditions, but can also affect the mechanisms of drug absorption, sensitization and other longer term effects. The unique characteristics of the individual skin function and, particularly, of the ethnic skin type are currently considered to shape the future of clinical and pharmacologic interventions as a basis for personalized skincare. Individual approaches to skincare render a novel and actively growing area with a range of biomedical and commercial applications within cosmetics industry. In this review, we summarize the aspects of the molecular and clinical manifestations of the environmental stress on human skin and proposed protective mechanisms that are linked to ethnic differences and pathophysiology of extrinsic skin aging. We subsequently discuss the possible applications and translation of this knowledge into personalized skincare.

Melanogenesis as a protective mechanism against photodamage

Clinical evaluations of the effects of sun exposure and photoprotection on skin damage and the classical signs of aging have been documented in a range of studies involving volunteers from different ethnicities, skin type and age groups using multiple criteria and clusters. The studies identified that ultraviolet (UV) exposure can be responsible for as much as 80% of aging sings in Caucasian and Asian skin, with predominance of the changes in pigmentation occurring independently of age, but are strongly linked to such exposure.Citation1 Theoretical calculations of the maximal daily exposures to solar UV radiation that could prevent the development of photoaged skin until old age were estimated at 0.14 minimal erythema dose (MED) of average yearly dose 200 MED for unprotected skin, therefore limiting the exposure to 2.54 min/day.Citation2 Adaptive melanization, known as tanning, protects the skin against UV penetration, and molecular defects in this pathway are associated with epidermal hyperplasia and cancer susceptibility.Citation3Citation7 UV is also responsible for early signs of photoaging, including pigment irregularities, solar elastosis and telangiectasias.Citation1,Citation8,Citation9

Skin color is defined by the Fitzpatrick system that categorizes the skin into six types (I–VI) based on basal complexion, inflammatory response, tanning and sun burning susceptibility, with fair skin being more susceptible to this type of damage than darker skin.Citation10 The color of human skin is largely determined by the amount and type of melanin pigment produced by melanocytes.Citation11,Citation12

Melanins are complex and multifunctional biopolymers represented by several types of pigment that are synthesized within lysosome-related organelles, melanosomes and transferred from melanocytes in the basal layer of epidermis to the surrounding keratinocytes. The amount and type of melanin are the main factors that determine skin complexion and UV sensitivity. Melanin exists in two main isoforms: dark-brown eumelanin that is more efficient at blocking UV photons and light pheomelanin that remains constant between dark- and lightly pigmented skin. Skin complexion and UV sensitivity are, therefore, determined predominantly by the levels of eumelanin in the epidermis.Citation13,Citation14

Melanogenesis is a complex and heterogeneous process that is not organized into simple linear succession, but into multidimensional and overlapping network of biochemical reactions. Central to this process is stimulation of the melanocortin receptor 1 that binds to α-melanocyte stimulating hormone and transmits differentiation signals through activation of adenylyl cyclase and generation of cAMP. This leads to increased levels and activity of tyrosinase (TYR), TYR-related protein 1 (TYRP1, dihydroxyindole [DHI] oxidase) and dopachrome tautomerase (DCT) that catalyze the synthesis of melanin. The major biochemical reactions, substrates and enzymes in the biosynthesis of melanins and the transport and maturation of melanosome involve hydroxylation of phenylalanine, tyrosine hydroxylation (TYR), DOPA oxidation (TYR), dopachrome tautomerization (DCT/TYRP2), DHICA oxidation (TYRP1 or peroxidase), DHI oxidation (TYR or peroxidase), hydrolysis of glutathionyldopa (g-glutamyltranspeptidase), oxidation of cysteinyldopa (peroxidase), intramolecular cyclization of cysteinyldopaquinone (peroxidase), DOPA decarboxylation (AAD), hydroxylation of dopamine (DBH) and methylation of norepinephrine (PNMT).Citation15,Citation16 Melanogenesis has been associated with broad spectrum of ~600 proteins that are present at each stage during melanosome biogenesis.Citation17

Epidermal melanocytes are located in the basal layer above the basement membrane in the epidermal melanin unit comprising ~50 neighboring keratinocytes.Citation18 Initial stages of UV-mediated skin darkening involve actual redistribution of the existing melanin pigment, which is followed by subsequent de novo melanin synthesis that begins several hours or days later.Citation19 Several studies demonstrated decreased DNA damage in the lower epidermis, redistribution of melanin from the lower to the middle epidermis and increase in UV-induced apoptosis in darkly pigmented skin, suggesting the mechanism of both more efficient UV filtration and removal of the permanently damaged cells.Citation20,Citation21

In addition to direct protection from UV, melanogenesis may play other important physiologic roles in epidermal homeostasis. A study aiming at understanding the responses of differently pigmented skin types to UV measured the distribution of DNA damage and melanin content alongside the expression of melanocyte-specific genes after single MED exposure. Interestingly, while such responses were not accompanied by significant changes in both the density of melanocytes at the dermal–epidermal junctions and the melanin content, expression of melanocyte-specific proteins TYR, TYRP1, DCT as well as MART1 and MITF did change significantly within 1 week after UV exposure.Citation20 This suggests that the genes involved in the melanin synthesis pathway also demonstrate the expression patterns regulated in response to the environment, which could be independent from the positive selection for skin pigmentation.

Ethnic variations in the pigmentary traits and phenotypic differences in extrinsic aging

Genetic polymorphism in constitutive pigmentation across worldwide populations

Human skin pigmentation is an atypical trait primarily determined by the quantity and distribution of melanin, which shows a remarkable, latitude-correlated phenotypic variation among continental populations.Citation22 Recent genotype/phenotype association studies have uncovered a spatial distribution in the single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) located within constitutive pigmentation candidate genes alongside gradual increase in skin darkness across worldwide populations from Northern Europe to Southern Europe to Northern Africa, the Middle East and Western Asia geographic regions. Human SNPs represent >9 million DNA sequence variations scattering the entire genome (the National Center for Biotechnology Information dbSNP database) that can alter the response of the individual to environmental exposure. SNPs occur in both gene coding and noncoding regions and can lead to changes in the biologic properties of the encoded protein or affect gene expression levels.Citation23 Using a combination of systematic approaches, including genome-wide association studies, gene expression databases and genotype–phenotype correlations based on skin melanin index, significant variations in SNP pigmentation genes have been found between European, East Asian, South West Asian and African large populations in case–control studies.Citation24Citation26 Many of these genes have been uncovered based on naturally occurring mutations that affect the constitutive pigmentation through the melanin or melanogenic precursor levels. In addition, a number of noncoding SNPs involved in transcriptional regulation of pigmentation genes have also been identified.Citation27Citation30 General interpretation of the inter-and intra-ethnic populations’ SNPs could be proposed to affect the genes involved in dark melanocyte pigmentation, vitamin D status and skin tanning response in Caucasian skin, darker and lighter skin reflectance in Oriental and Asian skin, with constitutive levels or activity of certain markers typically higher in African skin. There is also a profound cross-talk between melanogenic and oxidative stress response signaling pathways ().

Table 1 Genotypic variations underlying diverse functions associated with the melanogenic pathways in major ethnic groups

Genetic polymorphisms underlying phenotypic variation of pigmentation require further understanding of the effects on target proteins and correlation with the cellular functions. This is achieved by combination of biochemical and cellular approaches including mRNA transcription and stability, protein assays, ligand interactions, enzymatic activity and histochemistry. For example, recording of the association between allelic distribution and melanosome density at different stages of biogenesis could provide further insight into the cellular basis of diversity in skin pigmentation.Citation31

Structural differences and aging properties of ethnic skin types

It has been suggested previously that environmental changes could have an impact on selected pigmentation genes.Citation32 One of the major factors that could affect extrinsic aging and, in particular, photoaging is genetically determined skin type with established content and composition of melanin.Citation33 Susceptibility toward extrinsic skin aging is also recognized to be strongly influenced by other endogenous factors such as antioxidant or DNA repair capacity, which may be determined by individual genetic traits and ethnic differences in skin properties.Citation34

It is well established that the number of melanocytes in different skin types remains relatively constant and is defined by the epidermal melanin unit.Citation18,Citation34 Darker skin, however, is characterized by the presence of more dispersed, larger and labile melanocytes that contain more melanin consistent with higher tyrosinase activity and slower rate of melanosome degradation in the epidermis. In contrast, lightly pigmented skin presents with more aggregated and smaller melanosomes that contain less melanin due to the rate of synthesis and enhanced degradation.Citation34,Citation35 The greater ethnic capacity toward melanogenesis in darker skin that is not exposed to UV could suggest additional contribution to the epidermal structure and barrier permeability and function. In addition to better photoprotection against UV through pigmentation, epidermis in the African skin has, indeed, a thicker stratum corneum, with more cornified cell layers and lipid content compared to Caucasian skin.Citation36Citation38 Consequently, the African skin is suggested to have stronger antimicrobial defenses linked to more acidified outer epidermis and rapid barrier recovery after damage.Citation39,Citation40 Consistent with the degree of pigmentation, African skin and Asian skin have thicker and more compact dermis compared to Caucasian skin.Citation41 African skin contains larger, more frequent and active fibroblasts in parallel orientation as well as more macrophages.Citation42 Such phenotype is associated with more pronounced structural integrity of collagen in dermis that is preserved during aging and photoaging.Citation38 In contrast, extrinsically aged Caucasian skin is characterized by profound disorganization of the elastic fibers and decreased expression of collagen in dermis. The atrophic manifestations in dermis are moreover linked to the skin type within the Caucasian population, with multiple telangiectasia (dilated superficial blood vessels) in lightly pigmented skin and solar elastosis (accumulation of abnormal elastin) in darker skin.Citation43,Citation44

In addition to the loss of elasticity and volume, the most common signs of skin aging and, particularly, photoaging are decreased number of melanocytes, dyspigmentation and changes in pigment distribution observed in all skin types. The aging process and sun-induced damage are, however, distinguished by unique structural and functional differences observed between light (types I–II) and dark skin (types III–VI). Darker skin, despite being more resistant to wrinkles, is generally more pronounced to dyspigmentation including both hypopigmentation and hyperpigmentation.Citation34 The changes in pigment distribution are the principal manifestation of photodamage in Oriental and Asian skin, with the former also characterized by hyperpigmentation and increased melanin index with age.Citation45Citation47 Increased occurrence of pigment spots can be partially associated with higher frequency distribution of SLC45A2 gene variant.Citation48 Furthermore, population studies of age-related changes reveal that although uneven pigment distribution is more prevalent in Oriental and Asian skin, solar damage and wrinkle onset are significantly delayed compared to Caucasian skin, which could presumably be correlated with the antioxidant levels in fasting blood.Citation49Citation51

Finally, different skin types have also distinct physiologic responses that are influenced by the environment, such as skin hydration. Transepidermal water loss (TEWL) is indicative of skin surface moisture and defined as the body loss of water that passes via diffusion and evaporation to the atmosphere through the epidermis, and this parameter is increased in African skin compared to Caucasian skin.Citation52 Across all populations, TEWL and skin surface moisture decrease with age, and this is more pronounced in Caucasian skin, coinciding with thinner stratum corneum.Citation43,Citation45,Citation53 Changes in the epidermis are also evident in the rate of desquamation or corneocyte variability, which increases with age and accounts for xerosis, which is frequently more pronounced in African skin.Citation52,Citation54 The conditions can currently be treated with a range of externally applied moisturizing products to restore the integrity of the stratum corneum through replacement of the natural natural moisturizing factor components. The active ingredients, categorized as emollients, occlusives and humectants, provide a barrier that softens the skin, bind water in the stratum corneum and prevent TEWS.Citation55Citation57

Personalized skincare

Transcriptomic data generated from young and old sun-protected and sun-exposed skin provide much information on the gene clusters and hierarchical pathways implicated in intrinsic aging and photoaging. The biomarkers identified in both types of aging are relevant to skin barrier maintenance through lipid biosynthesis and epidermal differentiation as well as oxidative stress and antioxidant defenses. Differences between intrinsically aged and photoaged skin can be detected at the level of extracellular matrix, with reduced expression of collagen genes in intrinsic aging and increased expression of elastic tissue genes in photoaging.Citation58

Much information on skin biology and aging processes obtained through molecular and cell biology-based technologies requires development and applications of advanced statistical and modeling tools. Integrative biology applied to the gene expression data aims at understanding the biological relationships and dynamic processes through the reconstruction of gene regulatory networks. Such networks, representing groups of genes with various functions and the interactions between the groups, have been built using linear and Boolean network models, Bayesian networks and other purpose-built new algorithms. The knowledge gained on the possible gene interactions can be extended further, for instance, to include other parameters such as the transcription–translation feedback or the effect of local environments on the proteins. The outcomes of mathematical modeling are furthermore applicable toward the already established knowledge on gene interactions and the likely overlap between certain genes identified in different independent studies. The need for development of additional computational approaches is also suggested to take into account more subtle changes in gene expression that are specific for single individuals within similar groups.Citation59Citation61

Genetic variations that contribute to the unique characteristics of each individual are currently considered to shape the future of clinical and pharmacologic interventions. This is consistent with the idea of treating the person rather than the particular problem, which gains increasing recognition as a more effective approach.Citation62 Based on this, the concept of “personalized medicine” recognizing underlying forms of genetic variations emerges as an exceptional strategy with unique applications in pharmacogenomics and pharmacoproteomics. This concept can be extended further onto the field of experimental and clinical dermatology and personalized skincare.Citation62,Citation63 Recent progress in molecular assays and diagnostic tests facilitates addressing the physiology of skin processes and the pathogenic mechanisms of specific problems including inflammatory and autoimmune skin conditions.Citation64 Understanding the biology of individual skin structure, sensitivity and hormonal balance and identifying the network of representative genes in the context of specific genetic makeup will drive the design of novel pharmaceuticals and mimetics to modulate appropriate biologic processes.

Skin ethnicity strongly manifests in distinct structural and physiologic traits that can be defined for each major population. In general, Caucasian skin is characterized by smaller melanosomes, less melanin, thinner stratum corneum and dermis and decreased TEWL. These factors contribute further to increased photodamage, loss of collagen and decreased elasticity of dermis as the major outcomes of extrinsic aging process. Darkly pigmented skin of African origin is characterized by bigger melanosomes and more melanin as well as thicker stratum corneum and dermis that is proportional to the degree of pigmentation.Citation41 Both African skin and Asian skin are more resistant to photodamage and demonstrate preserved elasticity that translates into delayed appearance of wrinkles during aging. However, darkly pigmented skin is more prone to age-related changes in pigmentation, which are particularly evident in Oriental and Asian skin. In addition, ethnic differences in skin type may also manifest in regard to relative skin hydration, with dry skin and xerosis frequently more pronounced in African skin in both low relative air humidity and during aging (). Differences between skin phenotypes are also evident within the major ethnic groups. For example, degree of pigmentation and dermal elasticity are the individual characteristics determined by both genetic and environmental factors.

Figure 1 Representative differences within the epidermis and dermis among four ethnic skin types and the age-related changes typical for the traits sensitive to environmental damage.

Abbreviation: TEWL, transepidermal water loss.
Figure 1 Representative differences within the epidermis and dermis among four ethnic skin types and the age-related changes typical for the traits sensitive to environmental damage.

Ethnic and individual diversity in skin structure and physiology may be responsible for different reactivity of the tissue to chemical factors, for instance, it could affect the rate and effectiveness of drug penetration, absorption and sensitization, the parameters important for carefully considered skincare. Whereas Caucasian skin demonstrates stronger resistance to water barrier damage, African skin is more resistant to transcutaneous penetration.Citation52,Citation65 Caucasian skin and Oriental skin have similar basal TEWL, but Oriental skin is more sensitive to mechanical and chemical stress, presumably because of the weaker barrier and thinner stratum corneum in the epidermis. Compared with other ethnic skin types, Oriental skin also demonstrates higher eccrine gland density and smaller pore size, which reflect the activity of the sebaceous glands.Citation43,Citation66 In contrast, African skin frequently shows the most severe damage around facial pores.Citation67 The differences between ethnic skin types in response to the environmental factors can also manifest in the dermis, with Caucasian skin being more prone to inflammatory lesions and African skin presenting more often with hypertrophic scarring and keloids.Citation34,Citation43

The phenotypic variations and challenges in defining specific genome–drug interactions can also be applicable to the field of dermatology. One important aspect of pharmacogenomics is the assessment of individual response efficiency, appropriate dose and adverse effects of the proposed formulations, which have a direct influence on their development, cost-effectiveness and safety regulation.Citation68 The approach to development of skin products usually occurs in stages, commencing with in-depth characterization of raw materials, their nature of exposure to the body and a maximum concentration for use, through in vitro safety tests and clinical trials to product marketing and vigilance procedures.Citation69,Citation70

Current strategies for personal protection against air pollution include topical products that improve skin barrier function for reduced air pollutant penetration and antioxidants to reduce reactive oxygen species, such as vitamins C and E, in formulations. In parallel, substantial progress has been made in topical sunscreen formulations that combine skin moisturizers with broad-spectrum UV filters and sunscreens that filter both UVA and UVB in a ratio that mimics the natural exposure for optimal photoprotection. Effectiveness of the sunscreen is based on the measurements of the sun protection factor in the precisely defined parameters such as application layer (mg/cm2), UV irradiation dose and clinically established changes in the skin in the defined time after exposure.Citation71 For the purpose of personalized skincare, both the skin type and the environment should be taken into account as the skin is exposed to varied levels of air pollutants on a daily basis. On the molecular level, sunscreens with a well-balanced sun protection factor/UVA-PF ratio were demonstrated to prevent UVA-induced expression of the genes associated with oxidative stress response and ECM degradation in the dermis.Citation72 This type of protection would be particularly suitable for lightly pigmented Caucasian skin that is prone to wrinkles. Darkly pigmented and, particularly, Oriental skin could benefit from the sunscreens that filter shorter wavelength UV that affects epidermis and could exasperate the hyperpigmented lesions. Development of new personalized products that support skin barrier renewal and enhance NMF to prevent TEWS could be particularly beneficial for African skin.

Frequently, the knowledge on genetic background, gene/environment interactions and the response to the cosmetic ingredients is not always available. One step toward more complete databases would be gathering the information on the use of personal care products in the studies of consumer use practices, including the amount of the applied product and the frequency of its use. This also provides an exposure assessment of the active ingredients in such products.Citation73,Citation74 For instance, the awareness of the UV-induced damage is reflected by greater photoprotective measurers recorded in clinical studies among volunteers with group I/II compared to III/IV skin types.Citation75 Randomized trials also provide a useful tool to define long-term effects of the product.Citation76

Relevant studies also describe the construction of new models of population exposure to regulated personal care products based on the recorded usage profiles.Citation77,Citation78 Another complementary approach to personalized information is through visualization techniques based on the Electronic Health Records as a summary of individual’s physical health and guidance to optimal health level. Such a system has been described for several case studies and subsequently translated into a model and information visualization tools recommendations to explore multiple Electronic Health Records.Citation79 Interestingly, one important parameter to assess the overall health status is the facial complexion of the individual. Such a factor implemented in the construction of the visualized health report might provide an alternative to the conventional, text-based clinical description as part of the personalized health information.Citation80

Conclusion

Molecular and physiologic responses of the skin to the environmental factors that affect pigmentation, dermal elasticity and epidermal moisture are strongly dependent on the skin type. Ethnic skin phenotypes can be distinguished based on defined genotypic traits, most specifically SNP in the genes involved in biosynthesis of melanin and responsible for pigmentation. Melanin production is stimulated by UV radiation and has an important role in protecting the skin against photodamage. Skin types defined as Caucasian, Oriental, Asian and African origin demonstrate significant differences in the organization and compartmentalized sensitivity to distinct extrinsic factors. This translates further into different demands regarding preventive measures and relevant cosmetic product applications focusing on distinct aspects of skin damage and regeneration. Personalized skincare is an actively growing area with the biomedical and commercial applications that could provide new generation of skin products. Individual approach to skin, based on the recorded profiles and the in silico modeling of unique characteristics such as structural and biometric measurements, dermal/epidermal biomarkers, hormonal and stress response, could be an effective and affordable treatment of many skin conditions in the future.

Disclosure

The authors report no conflicts of interest in this work.

References

  • FlamentFBazinRLaquiezeSRubertVSimonpietriEPiotBEffect of the sun on visible clinical signs of aging in Caucasian skinClin Cosmet Investig Dermatol20136221232
  • IchihashiMAndoHThe maximal cumulative solar UVB dose allowed to maintain healthy and young skin and prevent premature photoagingExp Dermatol201423Suppl 1434625234836
  • D’OrazioJJarrettSAmaro-OrtizAScottTUV radiation and the skinInt J Mol Sci2013146122221224823749111
  • CuiRWidlundHRFeigeECentral role of p53 in the Suntan response and pathologic hyperpigmentationCell2007128585386417350573
  • ScottTLChristianPAKeslerMVPigment-independent cAMP-mediated epidermal thickening protects against cutaneous UV injury by keratinocyte proliferationExp Dermatol2012211077177723078399
  • WidlundHRFisherDEMicrophthalamia-associated transcription factor: a critical regulator of pigment cell development and survivalOncogene200322203035304112789278
  • RouzaudFCostinGEYamaguchiYRegulation of constitutive and UVR-induced skin pigmentation by melanocortin 1 receptor isoformsFASEB J200620111927192916877522
  • FisherGJWangZQDattaSCVaraniJKangSVoorheesJJPathophysiology of premature skin aging induced by ultraviolet lightN Engl J Med199733720141914289358139
  • BattieCJitsukawaSBernerdFDel BinoSMarionnetCVerschooreMNew insights in photoaging, UVA induced damage and skin typesExp Dermatol201423Suppl 1712
  • FitzpatrickTBThe validity and practicality of sun-reactive skin types I through VIArch Dermatol198812468698713377516
  • ThongHYJeeSHSunCCBoissyREThe patterns of melanosome distribution in keratinocytes of human skin as one determining factor of skin colourBr J Dermatol2003149349850514510981
  • MattsPJDykesPJMarksRThe distribution of melanin in skin determined in vivoBr J Dermatol2007156462062817493065
  • ItoSWakamatsuKOzekiHChemical analysis of melanins and its application to the study of the regulation of melanogenesisPigment Cell Res200013Suppl 810310911041366
  • VincensiMRd’IschiaMNapolitanoAPhaeomelanin versus eumelanin as a chemical indicator of ultraviolet sensitivity in fair-skinned subjects at high risk for melanoma: a pilot studyMelanoma Res19988153589508377
  • SlominskiATobinDJShibaharaSWortsmanJMelanin pigmentation in mammalian skin and its hormonal regulationPhysiol Rev20048441155122815383650
  • SettySRTenzaDSviderskayaEVBennettDCRaposoGMarksMSCell-specific ATP7A transport sustains copper dependent tyrosinase activity in melanosomesNature200845472081142114618650808
  • ChiAValenciaJCHuZZProteomic and bioinformatic characterization of the biogenesis and function of melanosomesJ Proteome Res20065113135314417081065
  • NordlundJJThe melanocyte and the epidermal melanin unit: an expanded conceptDermatol Clin200725327128117662893
  • BeattiePEDaweRSFergusonJIbbotsonSHDose-response and time-course characteristics of UV-A1 erythemaArch Dermatol2005141121549155516365256
  • TadokoroTYamaguchiYBatzerJMechanisms of skin tanning in different racial/ethnic groups in response to ultraviolet radiationJ Invest Dermatol200512461326133215955111
  • YamaguchiYTakahashiKZmudzkaBZHuman skin responses to UV radiation: pigment in the upper epidermis protects against DNA damage in the lower epidermis and facilitates apoptosisFASEB J20062091486148816793869
  • ParraEJHuman pigmentation variation: evolution, genetic basis, and implications for public healthAm J Phys Anthropol2007Suppl 458510518046745
  • WangXTomsoDJLiuXBellDASingle nucleotide polymorphism in transcriptional regulatory regions and expression of environmentally responsive genesToxicol Appl Pharmacol20052072 Suppl849016002116
  • StokowskiRPPantPVDaddTA genomewide association study of skin pigmentation in a South Asian populationAm J Hum Genet20078161119113217999355
  • SulemPGudbjartssonDFStaceySNGenetic determinants of hair, eye and skin pigmentation in EuropeansNat Genet200739121443145217952075
  • HanJKraftPNanHA genome-wideassociation study identifies novel alleles associated with hair color and skin pigmentationPLoS Genet200845e100007418483556
  • GuentherCATasicBLuoLBedellMAKingsleyDMA molecular basis for classic blond hair color in EuropeansNat Genet201446774875224880339
  • PraetoriusCGrillCStaceySNA polymorphism in IRF4 affects human pigmentation through a tyrosinase-dependent MITF/TFAP2A pathwayCell201315551022103324267888
  • VisserMPalstraRJKayserMHuman skin color is influenced by an intergenic DNA polymorphism regulating transcription of the nearby BNC2 pigmentation geneHum Mol Genet201423215750576224916375
  • VisserMPalstraRJKayserMAllele-specific transcriptional regulation of IRF4 in melanocytes is mediated by chromatin looping of the intronic rs12203592 enhancer to the IRF4 promoterHum Mol Genet20152492649266125631878
  • SturmRAMolecular genetics of human pigmentation diversityHum Mol Genet200918R1R9R1719297406
  • SturmRADuffyDLHuman pigmentation genes under environmental selectionGenome Biol201213924823110848
  • AlalufSHeathACarterNVariation in melanin content and composition in type V and VI photoexposed and photoprotected human skin: the dominant role of DHIPigment Cell Res200114533734711601655
  • VashiNAde Castro MaymoneMBKunduRVAging diferences in Ethnic skinJ Clin Aesthet Dermatol2016913138
  • BrennerMHearingVJThe protective role of melanin against UV damage in human skinPhotochem Photobiol200884353954918435612
  • BerardescaEde RigalJLevequeJLMaibachHIIn vivo biophysical characterization of skin physiological differences in racesDermatologica1991182289932050240
  • SuginoKImokawaGMaibachHEthnic differences in stratum corneum lipid in relation to stratum corneum functionJ Invest Dermatol19931001594
  • BrissettAENaylorMCThe aging African-American faceFacial Plast Surg201026215416320446209
  • EliasPMMenonGWetzelBKWilliamsJJEvidence that stress to the epidermal barrier influenced the development of pigmentation in humansPigment Cell Melanoma Res200922442043419508412
  • GunathilakeRSchurerNYShooBApH-regulated mechanisms account for pigment-type differences in epidermal barrier functionJ Invest Dermatol200912971719172919177137
  • MontagnaWProtaGKenneyJThe structure of black skinMontagnaWProtaGKenneyJBlack Skin Structure and FunctionGulf Professional Publishing OxfordUnited Kingdom1993
  • MontagnaWCarlisleKThe architecture of black and white facial skinJ Am Acad Dermatol1991246 Pt 19299371714469
  • RawlingsAVEthnic skin types: are there differences in skin structure and function?Int J Cosmet Sci2006282799318492142
  • LoberCWFenskeNAPhotoaging and the skin: differentiation and clinical responseGeriatrics19904543640
  • GalzoteCEstanislaoRSueroMOCharacterization of facial skin of various Asian populations through visual and noninvasive instrumental evaluations: influence of age and skincare habitsSkin Res Technol201319445446523521621
  • de RigalJDes MazisIDiridollouSThe effect of age on skin color and color heterogeneity in four ethnic groupsSkin Res Technol201016216817820456097
  • GohSHThe treatment of visible signs of senescence: the Asian experienceBr J Dermatol1990122Suppl 351051092337528
  • VierkötterAKrämerUSugiriDDevelopment of lentigines in German and Japanese women correlates with variants in the SLC45A2 geneJ Invest Dermatol20121323 Pt 173373622071478
  • Nouveau-RichardSYangZMac-MarySSkin aging: a comparison between Chinese and European populations. A pilot studyJ Dermatol Sci200540318719316154324
  • MorizotFGuehenneuxSDheurleSDo features of aging differ between Asian and Caucasian womenJ Invest Dermatol2004123A67
  • PernerDVierkötterASugiriDAssociation between sun-exposure, smoking behaviour and plasma antioxidant levels with the different manifestation of skin ageing signs between Japanese and German women-a pilot studyJ Dermatol Sci201162213814021458244
  • WesleyNOMaibachHIRacial (ethnic) differences in skin properties: the objective dataAm J Clin Dermatol200341284386014640777
  • DiridollouSde RigalJQuerleuxBLeroyFHolloway BarbosaVComparative study of the hydration of thestratum corneum between four ethnic groups: influence of ageInt J Dermatol200746Suppl 1111417919198
  • ChuMKolliasNDocumentation of normal stratum corneum scaling in an average population: features of differences among age, ethnicity and body siteBr J Dermatol2011164349750721054338
  • LodénMRole of topical emollients and moisturizers in the treatment of dry skin barrier disordersAm J Clin Dermatol200341177178814572299
  • NolanKMarmurEMoisturizers: reality and the skin benefitsDermatol Ther201225322923322913439
  • DraelosZDNew treatments for restoring impaired epidermal barrier permeability: skin barrier repair creamsClin Dermatol201230334534822507050
  • McGrathJARobinsonMKBinderRLSkin differences based on age and chronicity of ultraviolet exposure: results from a gene expression profiling studyBr J Dermatol2012166Suppl 291522670613
  • KimJMJungYSSungurEAHanKHParkCSohnIA copula method for modeling directional dependence of genesBMC Bioinformatics2008922518447957
  • ElBakryOAhmadMOSwamyMNInference of gene regulatory networks with variable time delay from time-series microarray dataIEEE/ACM Trans Comput Biol Bioinform201310367168724091400
  • BenechPDPatatianAFrom experimental design to functional gene networks: DNA microarray contribution to skin ageing researchInt J Cosmet Sci201436651652625066132
  • SchweitzerJMaibachHPharmacogenomics in dermatology: taking patient treatment to the next levelJ Dermatolog Treat2015261949624552417
  • ShoaibMRameezMAHussainSAMadadinMMenezesRGPersonalized medicine in a new genomic Era: ethical and legal aspectsSci Eng Ethics20172341207121227896605
  • HasCSitaruCMolecular dermatology comes of ageMethods Mol Biol201396111623325634
  • BerardescaEMaibachHRacial differences in skin pathophysiologyJ Am Acad Dermatol19963446676728601658
  • RohMHanMKimDChungKSebum output as a factor contributing to the size of facial poresBr J Dermatol2006155589089417034515
  • Sugiyama-NakagiriYSugataKHachiyaAOsanaiOOhuchiAKitaharaTEthnic differences in the structural properties of facial skinJ Dermatol Sci200953213513918990545
  • MaQLuAYPharmacogenetics, pharmacogenomics, and individualized medicinePharmacol Rev201163243745921436344
  • KrutmannJBoulocASoreGBernardBAPasseronTThe skin aging exposomeJ Dermatol Sci201785315216127720464
  • WitorschRJThomasJAPersonal care products and endocrine disruption: a critical review of the literatureCrit Rev Toxicol201040Suppl 3130
  • KimSMOhBHLeeYWChoeYBAhnKJThe relation between the amount of sunscreen applied and the sun protection factor in Asian skinJ Am Acad Dermatol201062221822219962787
  • SeitéSReinholdKJaenickeTBrendenHKrutmannJGrether-BeckSBroad-spectrum moisturizer effectively prevents molecular reactions to UVA radiationCutis201290632132623409485
  • LoretzLJApiAMBarrajLMExposure data for cosmetic products: lipstick, body lotion, and face creamFood Chem Toxicol200543227929115621341
  • BiesterbosJWDudzinaTDelmaarCJUsage patterns of personal care products: important factors for exposure assessmentFood Chem Toxicol20135581723174517
  • GouldMFarrarMDKiftRSunlight exposure and photoprotection behaviour of white Caucasian adolescents in the UKJ Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol201529473273725185510
  • HughesMCWilliamsGMBakerPGreenACSunscreen and prevention of skin aging: a randomized trialAnn Intern Med20131581178179023732711
  • McNamaraCRohanDGoldenDProbabilistic modelling of European consumer exposure to cosmetic productsFood Chem Toxicol200745112086209617804138
  • NohynekGJAntignacEReTToutainHSafety assessment of personal care products/cosmetics and their ingredientsToxicol Appl Pharmacol2010243223925920005888
  • WangTDWongsuphasawatKPlaisantCShneidermanBExtracting insights from electronic health records: case studies, a visual analytics process model, and design recommendationsJ Med Syst20113551135115221541691
  • HsiaoJHChangHVisualizing health: a novel visualization method for personalized health summarization and guidanceStud Health Technol Inform2013192100523920779
  • LiuFVisserMDuffyDLGenetics of skin color variation in Europeans: genome-wide association studies with functional follow-upHum Genet2015134882383525963972
  • KanetskyPASwoyerJPanossianSHolmesRGuerryDRebbeckTRA polymorphism in the agouti signaling protein gene is associated with human pigmentationAm J Hum Genet200270377077511833005
  • SulemPGudbjartssonDFStaceySNTwo newly identified genetic determinants of pigmentation in EuropeansNat Genet200840783583718488028
  • JacobsLCWollsteinALaoOComprehensive candidate gene study highlights UGT1A and BNC2 as new genes determining continuous skin color variation in EuropeansHum Genet2012132214715823052946
  • LaoOde GruijterJMvan DuijnKNavarroAKayserMSignatures of positive selection in genes associated with human skin pigmentation as revealed from analyses of single nucleotide polymorphismsAnn Hum Genet200771Pt 335436917233754
  • AlonsoSIzagirreNSmith-ZubiagaIComplex signatures of selection for the melanogenic loci TYR, TYRP1 and DCT in humansBMC Evol Biol200887418312627
  • JiHSharplessNEWongKKEGFR targeted therapy: view from biological standpointCell Cycle20065182072207616969107
  • SaternusRPilzSGräberSA closer look at evolution: variants (SNPs) of genes involved in skin pigmentation, including EXOC2, TYR, TYRP1, and DCT, are associated with 25(OH)D serum concentrationEndocrinology20151561394725396269
  • NanHKraftPQureshiAAGenome-wide association study of tanning phenotype in a population of European ancestryJ Invest Dermatol200912992250225719340012
  • PicardoMCardinaliGThe genetic determination of skin pigmentation: KITLG and the KITLG/c-Kit pathway as key players in the onset of human familial pigmentary diseasesJ Invest Dermatol201113161182118521566575
  • SuzukiIConeRDImSNordlundJAbdel-MalekZABinding of melanotropic hormones to the melanocortin receptor MC1R on human melanocytes stimulates proliferation and melanogenesisEndocrinology19961375162716338612494
  • KadekaroALKantoHKavanaghRAbdel-MalekZSignificance of the melanocortin 1 receptor in regulating human melanocyte pigmentation, proliferation and survivalAnn N Y Acad Sci200399435936512851336
  • BeaumontKALiuYYSturmRAThe melanocortin-1 receptor gene polymorphism and association with human skin cancerProg Mol Biol Trans Sci20098885153
  • SavageSAGerstenblithMRGoldsteinAMNucleotide diversity and population differentiation of the melanocortin 1 receptor gene, MC1RBMC Genet200893118402696
  • NakayamaKSoemantriAJinFIdentification of novel functional variants of the melanocortin 1 receptor gene originated from AsiansHum Genet2006119332233016463023
  • YuasaIUmetsuKHariharaSOCA2 481Thr, a hypofunctional allele in pigmentation, is characteristic of northeastern Asian populationsJ Hum Genet200752869069317568986
  • DonnellyMPPaschouPGrigorenkoEA global view of the OCA2-HERC2 region and pigmentationHum Genet2012131568369622065085
  • EdwardsMBighamATanJAssociation of the OCA2 polymorphism His615Arg with melanin content in east Asian populations: further evidence of convergent evolution of skin pigmentationPLoS Genet201063e100086720221248
  • Basu MallickCIliescuFMMolsMThe light skin allele of SLC24A5 in South Asians and Europeans shares identity by descentPLoS Genet2013911e100391224244186
  • AlalufSBarrettKBlountMCarterNEthnic variation in tyrosinase and TYRP1 expression in photoexposed and photoprotected human skinPigment Cell Res2003161354212519123
  • RooryckCMoriceFDidierLTaiebAArveilerBGenetic basis of oculocutaneous albinismExpert Rev Dermatol20094611622