Expression of PD-L1 in cervical carcinoma and its impact on survival associated with T-cell infiltration and FoxP3 expression

Abstract

Background: The PD-1/PD-L1 signaling axis is currently the most elucidated mechanism for tumor evasion of T-cell-mediated immunity. Nevertheless, few data are available regarding its impact on cervical cancer and the relationship with lymphocytic infiltrates.

Methods: A retrospective assessment of all cases of cervical neoplasia treated in Caxias do Sul General Hospital, Brazil, between 2012 and 2016 was performed. Clinical and pathological data were collected from electronic records and analyzed. Original slides were independently reviewed by three pathologists to confirm diagnoses and to assess the immunohistochemical expression of PD-L1 and FoxP3 in tumor cells and lymphocytic infiltrates.

Results: PD-L1 staining was present in 32.2% of the 59 cervical samples. Median overall survival time of the PD-L1-negative group was 47.8 months, a time point not yet reached by the PD-L1-positive group (p=0.968). Median progression-free survival was 24.3 months for PD-L1-negative and 11.5 months for PD-L1-positive patients (p=0.263). PD-L1 staining was found in 27.1% of the lymphocytic infiltrates, and survival analysis revealed no difference between PD-L1-positive and PD-L1-negative samples. There was no impact on survival related to FoxP3 staining in neither tumor samples nor lymphocytic infiltrates.

Conclusion: Although the median progression-free survival times differed, the difference was not statistically significant. Our study corroborates the rationale that PD-L1 expression in cervical neoplasms has no impact on survival. PD-L1 expression in peritumoral lymphocytes revealed no impact on infiltration volume nor survival.

Keywords: uterine cervical neoplasms, tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes, cancer, tumor microenvironment, survival

Introduction

Cervical cancer is the fourth most frequent cancer in woman worldwide with an estimated 570,000 new cases in 2018, representing 6.6% of all female cancers. ¹ Most cases are squamous cell carcinoma followed by adenocarcinomas. Approximately 90% of deaths from cervical cancer occur in low- and middle-income countries. In Brazil, cervical cancer is the 2^nd most common cancer in women aged 15–44 years and about 16,000 new cervical cancer cases are diagnosed annually. ²

Human papillomavirus (HPV) infection is a well-established cause of cervical cancer. ^3–5 The immune system plays an important role in HPV infections under conditions of high immunogenic reactivity. ⁶ Immunosuppressed women have an increased incidence of HPV infection, cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) and progression to invasive neoplasia. ^7–9

The programmed cell death protein-1/programmed death-ligand 1 (PD-1/PD-L1) signaling axis is currently the most elucidated mechanism for tumor evasion of T-cell-mediated immunity. PD-1/PD-L1 antibody blockade has been widely proven to be effective against several cancers. Retrospective analyses have successfully associated PD-L1 expression to oncologic prognosis regardless of therapeutic strategy in melanoma, ovarian and kidney cancer. ^10,11 However, few data are available regarding its expression in cervical cancer. ¹²

Recently, tumor infiltration by regulatory T lymphocytes (Treg) positive for forkhead box protein P3 (FoxP3) expression has been investigated as a potential prognostic immune biomarker. Nevertheless, discrepant results have been reported and its relationship with the PD-1/PD-L1 axis remains unclear. ^13,14

We assessed the impact of PD-L1 and FoxP3 expression in cervical tumor cells and intratumoral lymphocytes on survival outcomes.

Methods

A search for cases of cervical cancer in Caxias do Sul General Hospital database covering 2012 through 2016 was performed. Clinical and pathological data collected are summarized in Table 1. Study endpoints were date of diagnosis, progression-free survival (PFS) and overall survival (OS).

Table 1 Clinical and pathological data

Age at diagnosis (median)		44 years
Smoking history	Yes	28.8% (n=17)
No	71.2% (n=42)
Histologic subtype	Squamous cell	86.4% (n=51)
Adenocarcinoma	13.6% (n=8)
PS	0	28.8% (n=17)
	1	62.7% (n=32)
	2	5.1% (n=3)
	3	3.4% (n=2)
4	–
CS (FIGO, 2009)	I	10.1% (n=6)
	II	30.5% (n=18)
	III	40.7% (n=24)
	IVA	13.6% (n=8)
IVB	5.1% (n=3)
Treatament	Surgery (frontline)	27.1% (n=16)
	CT-RT	64% (n=38)
	Brachytherapy	32.2% (n=19)
RT (exclusive)	16% (n=9)
Endpoint	Progression	47.5% (n=28)
	Death	33.9% (n=20)
Follow-up (median)	26.2 months

Abbreviations: PS, performance status; CS, clinical stage.

The original hematoxylin-eosin (HE) slides were reviewed for diagnosis confirmation. Immunohistochemistry (IHC) slides were independently scored by 3 pathologists. Discordant cases were reviewed and consensus was achieved for all cases.

Briefly, IHC was carried out using 3-μm-thick sections obtained from formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded tissue. The slides were deparaffinized and rehydrated. Antigen retrieval was performed in Tris-EDTA (Thermo Fischer, Waltham, MA) at 95°C for 20 mins. The slides were incubated with primary antibodies PD-L1 (1:50 dilution, RTB-PDL1, Bio SB^®) and FoxP3 (1:100 dilution, EP340, Cell Marque^®) overnight. These antibodies were marked with dark brown chromogen (DAB) to allow its observation in light microscopy. Human placenta (trophoblasts) was used as positive control.

PD-L1 and FoxP3 expression levels were assessed based on percentage and intensity of staining. Staining for PD-L1 was considered positive in a membrane pattern only and FoxP3 was considered positive in nuclear pattern only. Other staining patterns were disregarded. Intratumoral lymphocytes were quantified, and infiltration was classified into weak, moderate or strong categories.

Absolute and relative frequencies were used for the descriptive statistical analysis of variables. Fisher’s exact test and a two-tailed χ² test were performed when applicable. Survival rates were calculated with the Kaplan–Meier method and analyzed with the log-rank test. Univariate Cox proportional models were used to determine hazard ratios (HRs), which represent the risk of death or progression among the different groups. All statistical analyses were conducted with the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) version 22.0.

All researchers signed a secrecy and confidentiality agreement after receiving approval by the Institutional Scientific Council and by the National Research Ethics Committee. Our study of biomarkers was conducted according to REMARK recommendations. ¹⁵

Results

We found 155 patients diagnosed with cervical cancer in our institution. Twenty-five patients were excluded due to diagnostic discrepancies, and 57 patients had no paraffin tissue blocks available. After revision of original HE slides, 13 patients were excluded due to insufficient material for analysis, and one patient was excluded due to diagnostic nonconformity. The flowchart of the studied cohort is shown in Figure 1.

Figure 1 Flowchart of cohort recruitment.

The median age of the patients was 44 years, and 28.8% had a history of smoking. Squamous cell carcinoma was the most commonly diagnosed histological type, accounting for 86.4% (n=51) of the cases, followed by adenocarcinoma (n=8). At the time of diagnosis, 28.8% (n=17) of the patients exhibited Performance status (PS) score of 0 and 62.7% (n=32) PS 1; three patients exhibited PS 2, and two PS 3. Six (10.1%) patients presented with Clinical stage (CS) I, 18 (30.5%) CS II, 24 (40.7%) CS III, eight (13.6%) CS IVA and three (5.1%) CS IVB.

Primary surgical treatment was provided to 27.1% of the patients (n=16), whereas 64% (n=38) received definitive chemoradiotherapy; 19 (32.2%) patients underwent complementary brachytherapy. Nine patients (16%) received radiotherapy exclusively. The median follow-up was 26.2 months. Disease progression was objectively documented in 47.5% (n=28) of the cases. Twenty (33.9%) deaths occurred in the cohort during the follow-up period.

Cervical tumoral tissue assessment

Of all the evaluated clinical and pathological variables (age, smoking, PS, histological subtype, CS, treatment modality and response outcome), none alone had an impact on the variability of PD-L1 expression among the studied neoplastic specimens. PD-L1 expression was observed in 32.2% (n=19) of the cervical samples, five of which (8.5%) exhibited PD-L1 expression above 50% (Figure 2). The median OS time of the PD-L1-negative group was 47.8 months, a time point not reached yet by the PD-L1-positive group (p=0.968; Figure 3). The median progression-free survival was 24.3 months for the PD-L1-negative group and 11.5 months for the PD-L1-positive group (p=0.263; Figure 4).

Figure 2 Immunohistochemical staining of PD-L1 was considered positive if cell membrane staining was detected, and FoxP3 staining was considered positive if nuclear staining was detected. Black arrows point to staining detection areas. PD-L1-positive squamous cell cervical neoplasia (A); 400× magnification. PD-L1-positive peritumoral inflammatory infiltrate (B); 400× magnification. FoxP3-positive squamous cell cervical neoplasia (C); 200× magnification. FoxP3-positive peritumoral inflammatory infiltrate (D; 400× magnification).

Figure 3 Kaplan–Meier curves and log-rank test analysis of the overall survival of patients with cervical neoplasia based on PD-L1 expression.

Figure 4 Kaplan–Meier curves and log-rank test analysis of the progression-free survival of patients with cervical neoplasia based on PD-L1 expression.

Immunohistochemistry for FoxP3 revealed upregulation in 64.4% (n=38) of the tumor specimens; however, tumoral FoxP3 expression had no impact on survival outcomes (data not shown). Analysis of the PD-L1/FoxP3 ratio revealed that 57.9% (n=11) of PD-L1-positive tumors were positive for FoxP3 versus 67.5% (n=27) of the PD-L1-negative specimens (p=0.56).

Peritumoral lymphocytic infiltrate assessment

Weak peritumoral lymphocytic infiltration was found in 57.6% (n=34) of the samples, moderate infiltration in 23.7% (n=14) and strong infiltration in 18.6% (n=11). Stratification by lymphocytic infiltrate volume showed no significant association with survival outcomes (Figure 5). Positive PD-L1 staining was observed in 27.1% (n=16) of lymphocytic infiltrates, and survival analysis showed no difference between positive and negative infiltrates.

Figure 5 Kaplan–Meier curves and log-rank test analysis of overall survival (left) and progression-free survival (right) of patients with cervical neoplasia based on quantification of peritumoral lymphocytic infiltration.

A total of 93.2% (n=55) of lymphocytic infiltrates expressed FoxP3, with no impact on survival outcomes (data not shown). Furthermore, 94.7% of PD-L1-positive tumors exhibited positive staining for FoxP3 in their respective peritumoral infiltrates versus 92.5% (n=40) of infiltrates associated with PD-L1-negative cervical neoplasms (p>0.99).

Discussion

Cervical tumoral tissue assessment

PD-L1 expression in cervical tumor cells has been previously evaluated; nonetheless, conflicting results have been reported regarding its impact on survival outcomes.

In 2017, Enwere et al assessed tumoral PD-L1 expression in patients with locally advanced cervical cancer. Their data regarding prevalence of PD-L1 expression are intriguing: 87.9% of their samples were considered positive at a cutoff point of ≥1% and 39.7% at ≥50%. ¹² Applying a cutoff point of ≥50%, PD-L1 exhibited positive staining in only 8.5% of our samples. There was no association between PD-L1 expression and clinicopathological characteristics – age, CS, tumor size and lymph node status. Similarly, clinical and pathological variables of the present study had no impact on prognosis or on PD-L1 tumoral expression. In agreement with our results and with the findings of Heeren et al,¹⁶ their study also failed to detect an association between survival and tumoral expression of this biomarker. Karim et al¹⁷ found similar results. Only patients in CSs IB-II were included in their analysis and the authors suggest that PD-L1 expression can be different at more advanced disease stages. Nevertheless, PD-L1 expression was found in 19% of their samples and in 32.2% (n=19) of our specimens. Our study included patients at CSs III and IV, and subgroup analysis still also failed to show an impact on the expression of this biomarker and on survival outcomes.

We noted a distinct trend towards shorter progression-free survival in patients expressing PD-L1 – 11.5 months versus 24.3 months for PD-L1 negative patients. Yet, no statistical significance was met (p=0.263). Overall, by itself, IHC detection of tumoral PD-L1 does not seem to be an adequate biomarker for prediction of survival in cervical cancer.

Recently, the expression of FoxP3 has been examined in non-hematopoietic cells – including cancer cells; however, variable relationship between its tumoral expression and prognosis has been reported. In concordance with Huang et al, we found high levels of FoxP3 expression in tumoral cervical cells. ¹⁸ While no impact on survival was met, previous studies observed that FoxP3 expression was positively related to the invasiveness of cervical lesions. ¹⁹ These findings support the hypothesis that FoxP3 upregulation by tumor cancer cells might endow them with the immunosuppressive power of Treg, facilitating an escape from immune surveillance by downregulating T-cell function. ²⁰

Peritumoral lymphocytic infiltrate assessment

As previously stated, PD-L1 tumoral expression alone has failed to be associated with survival outcomes in cervical cancer. Conversely, Wang et al found that it seems to have a predictive value when combined with other immune features, such as the CD8+/CD4+CD25+FoxP3+ T lymphocyte ratio. ²¹

Evidence suggests that neoplasms associated with HPV exhibit a lack of an HPV-specific response by cytotoxic and type 1 helper T (Th1) lymphocytes. Also, scarce intratumoral infiltrates of CD8+ lymphocytes and abundant Treg seem to represent an independent prognostic factor for OS. ^9,16–25,26 Matsumoto et al examined intratumoral neutrophil infiltration (CD66b+ cells) in 250 cervical cancer specimens. Recurrence rate was significantly associated with density of neutrophilic infiltrates. Five-year OS was 77.5% for the “TAN-low” group (low-density infiltration), 58.7% for the “TAN-med” group (moderate infiltration) and 17% for the “TAN-high” group (high-density infiltration). Progression-free survival was estimated at 73.8%, 50.7% and 11.3%, respectively, over the same period. ²⁷ Applying the same stratification for lymphocytic infiltration, we found no impact on survival.

Regulatory T cells FoxP3+ are a class of immune-suppressive lymphocytes involved in tumoral immune evasion. ¹⁸ Shang et al conducted a meta-analysis to assess the prognostic effect of Treg FoxP3+ infiltration across different cancers. The overall pooled analysis found an unfavorable prognostic effect, and this association was unanimous and particularly strong among studies of cervical cancer. ¹⁴ In fact, 93.2% (n=55) of our lymphocytic infiltrates revealed FoxP3+, possibly corroborating the rationale that Treg might consist of an escape mechanism of cervical neoplasms to immune response.

The PD-1/PD-L1 axis and FoxP3 may work together for maintenance of peripheral tolerance but through nonoverlapping pathways. PD-1 is involved in rheostatic modulation of TCR signaling, preventing activity from effector T cells, whereas FoxP3 is sufficient for maintaining the integrity of Treg function. ²⁸ It has been suggested that PD-L1 and Treg FoxP3+ may work synergistically in tumoral microenvironments; PD-L1 may exert its inhibitory effects, at least in part by inducing Treg cell development, maximizing tumoral immune escape. ²⁹ Although increased Treg FoxP3+ infiltration and PD-L1 tumoral expression have been revealed in several malignancies, their correlation is yet undetermined. This relationship has been consistently associated with worst prognosis in breast, gastric and colorectal cancers. ^30–32 Our FoxP3+ lymphocyte infiltration was not impacted by tumoral PD-L1 expression (p>0.99).

Karim et al were the first to examine the relationship between the PD-1/PD-L1 axis and lymphocytic biomarkers in cervical cancer. ¹⁷ The volume of infiltration by each T-cell was divided into low and high categories, determined by the 50th percentile, and 66% of the samples exhibited a high rate of infiltration by CD8+ lymphocytes, 54% by CD4+ lymphocytes and 59% by FoxP3+ lymphocytes. The CD8+/FoxP3+ T lymphocyte ratio represented an independent positive prognostic factor for survival. Tumoral PD-L1 was associated with the greatest infiltration by FoxP3+ T cells (p=0.022). OS of patients with PD-L1-positive tumors and a low rate of CD8+/FoxP3+ lymphocyte infiltration was significantly better than that of patients with PD-L1-negative tumors with a low CD8+/FoxP3+ lymphocyte ratio (p=0.033). In contrast, our lymphocyte analyses are not in agreement with the findings of the above authors: FoxP3+ immune infiltrates did not modify oncologic endpoints. Furthermore, PD-L1 expression in the cervical tumor specimens did not seem to affect immune infiltration degree, FoxP3 expression, nor survival outcomes.

Regarding current therapies, the results for checkpoint inhibitors in cervical neoplasia are scarce and preliminary. A Phase I trial in progress (NCT01711515) is assessing the effect of ipilimumab in patients with cervical cancer at CSs IB2-IIA (if only the para-aortic lymph nodes are compromised) or CSs IIB, IIB and IVA after chemoradiotherapy (including brachytherapy). ASCO’s 2017 edition revealed the first results of Phase I/II multicohort trial (in progress) for nivolumab (CHECKMATE-358) for patients with virus-associated metastatic tumors of the cervix, vulva and vagina. Patients were not PD-L1-selected. Among the 24 treated patients, 19 (79.2%) had cervical neoplasia. At a median follow-up of 31 weeks, the objective response rate was 20.8% – all recorded responses were from patients with cervical cancer and they were not related to PD-L1 expression, HPV status nor exposure to previous lines of therapy. ³³ Dr. Lheureux et al published in 2017 the results for their Phase I/II trial evaluating ipilimumab in cervical cancer. The anti-CTLA-4 therapy did not show significant single-agent activity. In addition, no increase in intratumoral CD3, CD4, CD8 and FoxP3 expression was observed before and during treatment with ipilimumab. The presence of baseline immune infiltrate was not associated with response or stable disease. ³⁴ In 2018, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved pembrolizumab for recurrent or metastatic cervical cancer on or after chemotherapy whose tumors express PD-L1 based on a single cohort of KEYNOTE-158. The reported objective response rate was 14.3%.

Conclusion

The lack of studies regarding cervical cancer and the immune context has led to a paucity of contemporary antineoplastic strategies that is inconsistent with the high prevalence and morbidity of this disease. Consequently, an immune checkpoint inhibitor has been approved for this scenario based on unimpressive responses, regardless of a biologic rationale uncertainty. Therefore, identification of potentially responsive patients is imperative, and thus, searching for biomarkers that predict therapeutic benefit is crucial.

Our findings must be considered with caution. Similarly to previous studies on cervical malignancy, our sample size is limited and might have impaired power to draw robust conclusions. Moreover, the controversy regarding PD-L1’s predictive value has been widely discussed. IHC-based detection presents technical issues, different assays present discordant results, and it can fail to reveal the dynamic interaction of the tumoral microenvironment. Nevertheless, it remains relevant.

The results reported here reinforce that PD-L1 tumoral expression alone might be an inadequate biomarker for prediction of survival in cervical cancer. Notwithstanding, the high prevalence of FoxP3+ lymphocytic infiltrates, irrespective of PD-L1 expression, suggests that FoxP3 pathway inhibition can be a potential therapeutic approach. Furthermore, PD-L1 and Treg FoxP3+ may work synergistically and their upregulated expressions may promote tumoral evasion from immunity. Combinatorial immunotherapeutic approaches aiming PD-L1 blockage and Treg depletion might improve therapeutic efficacy. To clarify the immune escape mechanism of this neoplasm and explore effective therapies, further basic and translational researches evaluating the interactions between immune cells and cervical cancer tissue is imminent.

Ethics declaration

This study’s involvement with human subjects complies with the Declaration of Helsinki.

Disclosure

The authors report no conflicts of interest in this work.

Acknowledgments

All researchers signed a secrecy and confidentiality agreement after receiving approval by the Institutional Scientific Council and by the National Research Ethics Committee.