Abstract
Background
Quantifying physical activity in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is important as physical inactivity is related to poor health outcomes. This study analyzed the relationship between patients’ self-reported daily walking time and relevant characteristics related to COPD severity.
Methods
Pooled analysis was performed on data from four observational studies on which daily walking time was gathered from a personal interview. Patients were classified as physically inactive if walking time was <30 min/day. Walking times were described and compared according to several markers of disease severity.
Results
The mean daily walking time of 5,969 patients was 66 (standard deviation [SD] 47) min/day; 893 (15%) patients were inactive. A linear dose–response relationship was observed between walking time and the modified Medical Research Council (mMRC) dyspnea score, admissions, COPD assessment test (CAT), body mass index, airway obstruction, dyspnea, exacerbation (BODEx) index, and Charlson index (P<0.001). Daily walking times were lower in patients classified as Global Initiative for Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease (GOLD) B and D (P<0.001). Often, inactive patients had mMRC or Charlson index >3, post-bronchodilator forced expiratory volume in the first second <30% predicted, at least one hospitalization for COPD, classified as GOLD B or D, BODEx >4, and CAT score >30.
Conclusion
Lower self-reported walking times are related to worse markers of disease severity in COPD.
Keywords:
Introduction
COPD has several significant extra-pulmonary effects, such as skeletal muscle impairment and exercise intolerance, which have an important effect on the daily life activities of patients with this disease.Citation1,Citation2 This observation is consistent with the fact that patients with COPD have significantly lower levels of physical activity compared with healthy controls.Citation3 Moreover, reduced levels of physical activity have been found to be related to an increased risk of hospital admissions and mortality in COPD.Citation4–Citation6 Therefore, quantification of physical activity is of great value in these patients.
It has recently been recommended that evaluation of the level of physical activity in COPD should be carried out using movement sensors, which constitute portable equipment that quantify the activity performed by an individual during a given period of time.Citation7 The physical activity of patients with COPD can also be assessed using validated questionnaires, which are less expensive and easier to use than movement sensors, but most of these questionnaires are still time-consuming.Citation7,Citation8 Thus, these instruments are not feasible in clinical practice. Nonetheless, national and international guidelines on the management of COPD recommend evaluation and, if necessary, interventions to promote physical activity in these patients which has led to the need for less sophisticated tools to determine the daily physical activity of patients with COPD.Citation1–Citation9
The American College of Sports Medicine recommends that older adults should perform at least 30 min of physical activity of moderate intensity, such as walking, most days of the week in order to maintain or develop fitness.Citation10 Thus, individuals not fulfilling this recommendation are currently considered to be physically inactive. Self-reporting of walking time by patients would allow easy data collection at all levels of care and could help clinicians to better understand the impact of the disease on the patients’ daily life in order to identify subjects at risk of a sedentary lifestyle and to select candidates for an intervention to promote physical activity.
The present study was aimed at investigating the usefulness of self-reported walking time to identify patients with COPD at high risk of inactivity. It reported and compared the self-reported daily walking times of a large sample of patients with COPD from both primary care and specialized respiratory departments according to the clinical characteristics related to disease severity, such as the degree of airflow limitation, the grade of dyspnea, and different multidimensional scoring systems.
Methods
Study design, participants, and ethics
A pooled analysis of individual-level data from four multicenter, cross-sectional, observational studies described elsewhere was performed: the INSEPOC (Spanish acronym for “Impact of socio-economic status on quality of life of COPD patients”),Citation11 the FYCEPOC (Spanish acronym for “Phenotypes and quality of life of patients with COPD”),Citation12 the NEREA (Spanish acronym for “New severity scale for COPD in primary care”),Citation13 and the DEPREPOC (Spanish acronym for “Depression in patients with COPD”)Citation14 studies. In brief, stable COPD patients were recruited from both primary care and pulmonology departments. All the studies included individuals aged ≥40 years, smokers or ex-smokers of at least 10 pack-years with spirometrically confirmed COPD (post-bronchodilator forced expiratory volume in the first second [FEV1]/forced vital capacity <0.7). All the studies were approved by the Research and Ethics Committee of the Hospital Clinic (Barcelona, Spain), and written informed consent was obtained from each participant.
Measurements
Physical activity defined as patients’ self-reported daily walking time was collected in a personal interview, and patients were classified into three categories of physical activity: low (self-reported walking time <30 min/day), moderate (self-reported walking time of 30–60 min/day), and high (self-reported walking time >60 min/day). Self-reported daily walking time both as a continuous and as a categorical variable was used in the analysis.
Sociodemographic, clinical, and functional data as well as the number of exacerbations and hospital admissions due to COPD in the previous year were collected from all of the patients studied. Forced spirometry was conducted before and after a bronchodilator test, and self-reported comorbid conditions were calculated according to the Charlson comorbidity index.Citation15 Dyspnea was assessed using the modified Medical Research Council (mMRC) dyspnea scaleCitation16 in three studies,Citation12–Citation14 and the COPD assessment test (CAT) scoreCitation17 was available in two of the studies.Citation12–Citation14 Higher values in the CAT questionnaire indicate worse health status.Citation17
Patients were classified according to the FEV1 as mild, moderate, severe, and very severe following the European Respiratory Society and the American Thoracic Society (ERS/ATS) criteriaCitation18 as well as the current Global Initiative for Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease (GOLD) A to D groups, using the highest mMRC or CAT thresholds.Citation1 According to this classification, patients in GOLD B and D have higher symptom scores in common. The BODEx (body mass index, airway obstruction, dyspnea, and exacerbation) index, with which higher values indicate poor prognosis, was also calculated accordingly.Citation19
Statistical analysis
Descriptive data are presented as number and percentage, and the mean and standard deviation (SD), or the median and 25th or 75th percentiles, as appropriate. Self-reported walking time, both as a continuous and as a categorical variable, was described and compared according to various disease severity markers. A test for trends was calculated by using various disease severity markers as an ordinal variable in a linear regression model and the self-reported walking time as a continuous outcome. Finally, bivariate logistic regression models were used to calculate pooled odds ratios (ORs) for self-reported walking time <30 min/day according to disease severity markers. The analyses were performed by using Stata 12.1 (StataCorp, College Station, TX, USA).
Results
Information related to the self-reported daily walking time was available in 5,969 patients. presents the main clinical and functional characteristics of the pooled sample. Most of the patients studied were males (86%) with a mean age of 67.5 (SD 9.6) years and a FEV1 of 50.7% (17.2) predicted. Regarding GOLD groups, the majority of patients (73%) belonged to the GOLD D group.
Table 1 Sociodemographic, clinical, and functional characteristics of the patients included in different studies
Patients reported a mean daily walking time of 66 (SD 47) min/day, with 893 (15.0%) patients being classified as physically inactive (self-reported daily walking time <30 min/day) (). shows the self-reported daily walking times according to different characteristics related to disease severity.
Table 2 Self-reported daily walking time according to different characteristics related to disease severity
Figure 1 Distribution of self-reported daily walking times in the 5,969 COPD study patients.
A linear dose–response relationship was observed between the self-reported daily walking time as a continuous variable and the mMRC dyspnea score, COPD admissions within the previous year, the CAT score, the BODEx index, and the Charlson index (P<0.001). That is, lower walking times were associated with worse markers of disease severity. Self-reported daily walking times were lower in patients classified as GOLD B and D than those in the GOLD A and C groups (P<0.001). There was no dose–response relationship between self-reported daily walking time and FEV1 levels (P=0.080) (). shows the distribution of patients with low, moderate, and high self-reported daily walking times according to different markers of disease severity. Low physical activity was more frequent in patients with severe dyspnea (mMRC ≥3), more than two COPD admissions in the previous 12 months, CAT score >30, and BODEx index >4 points.
Figure 2 Self-reported daily walking times according to (A) mMRC, (B) FEV1% predicted, (C) COPD admissions in the previous 12 months, (D) CAT, (E) GOLD A–D groups, (F) BODEx index, and (G) Charlson index of comorbidities. Data are presented as mean values with 95% confidence intervals.
Abbreviations: BODEx, body mass index, airway obstruction, dyspnea, exacerbation; CAT, COPD assessment test; COPD, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; FEV1, forced expiratory volume in the first second; GOLD, Global Initiative for Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease; mMRC, modified Medical Research Council dyspnea scale.
Figure 3 Percentage of patients with self-reported walking time <30 min/day (), between 30 and 60 min/day (), and >60 min/day () according to (A) mMRC, (B) FEV1% predicted, (C) COPD admissions in the previous 12 months, (D) CAT, (E) GOLD A–D groups, (F) BODEx index, and (G) Charlson index of comorbidities. Abbreviations: BODEx, body mass index, airway obstruction, dyspnea, exacerbation; CAT, COPD assessment test; COPD, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; FEV1, forced expiratory volume in the first second; GOLD, Global Initiative for Chronic Obstructive Lung Disease; mMRC, modified Medical Research Council dyspnea scale.
shows the ORs for lower self-reported daily walking times according to different COPD severity factors. Patients at a higher risk of low self-reported daily physical activity were those with mMRC or Charlson index >3, a FEV1 <30% predicted, at least one COPD admission in the previous year, classified as GOLD B or D, a BODEx >4, and CAT score >30.
Table 3 ORs for the determinants of reduced self-reported walking time
Discussion
The present study investigated the relationship between self-reported daily walking time and relevant characteristics related to COPD severity in a large sample of patients with COPD. The main findings were that patients reporting lower walking times were those with more dyspnea, more comorbidities, higher BODEx index, patients classified as GOLD B or D and with previous hospitalizations due to COPD exacerbation. Furthermore, airflow limitation was poorly related to self-reported daily walking time.
Most patients with COPD spend significantly less time walking in daily life than healthy elderly subjects.Citation3,Citation20 Low physical activity is a marker of poor health outcomes in COPD,Citation4,Citation6 and thus, it is important to detect COPD patients at risk in order to implement specific interventions to prevent inactivity. The use of activity monitors and comprehensive questionnaires to capture physical activity is not feasible in routine clinical practice. Therefore, the utility of a simple clinical measure to predict inactivity in COPD was determined: patients’ self-reported daily walking time. The relationship between self-reported walking time and a number of markers of severity routinely used in the clinical management of patients with COPD. The findings of this study indicate a very consistent association between self-reported walking time and known parameters of COPD severity. Moreover, the results are in line with previous research conducted in this field using objective measures of physical activity, such as pedometers and accelerometers.Citation21–Citation24 Therefore, although it is unlikely for the simple question of “on average how many minutes do you walk per day?” to be an accurate measure of physical activity, it may be a useful tool to stratify COPD patients according to their level of physical activity in the clinical setting. Asking about the number of minutes walked per day is inexpensive and not time-consuming and provides important information to help screen patients with low physical activity that can be confirmed by more specific methods. The use of this simple question may increase the awareness of clinicians of the importance of assessing the level of physical activity of the patients with COPD.Citation25
In this study, 15% of the patients were classified as physically inactive (self-reported walking times <30 min/day). This percentage might be considered low compared with previous studies quantifying daily walking time in COPDCitation3 but may be due to differences in the characteristics of the COPD patient samples studied, differences in localization and climate that have been reported to affect physical activity,Citation26 and the instrument used to capture walking time (eg, self-reported methods have the potential to overestimate the amount of physical activity performed),Citation8,Citation27 among others.
In agreement with previous cross-sectional studies using both directCitation22,Citation23,Citation28 and indirectCitation29,Citation30 measures of physical activity, a strong association between self-reported walking time and dyspnea measured by the mMRC in the COPD patients was found. Indeed, the mMRC dyspnea score was the best factor to detect patients with lower walking times. COPD is characterized by symptoms of dyspnea, cough, wheeze, and sputum production.Citation1 Dyspnea is a particularly dominant symptom in these patients, especially as the disease advances, and usually limits patient mobility.Citation31 Indeed, dyspnea is the reason most frequently reported to prevent patients from exercising,Citation29,Citation32 further supporting our findings. Although dyspnea measured by mMRC is significantly related to self-reported walking time in this study, different aspects of the impact of the disease are, in fact, measured. Thus, these parameters should not be used interchangeably.
In addition, exacerbations requiring hospitalization within the previous 12 months and comorbidities were related to lower walking times in the patients. Several studies have shown that exacerbations have a negative impact on health outcomes of patients with COPD, impairing lung function,Citation33 quality of life,Citation34 exercise capacity,Citation35 and survival.Citation36 Along this line, a fall in daily walking activity following an exacerbation has been reported using pedometry in COPD.Citation21 Since bed rest and physical inactivity following exacerbation periods impair skeletal muscle mass and function,Citation37 it is not surprising that patients presenting the most severe exacerbations are those who are less active.
Accordingly, other markers of disease severity such as the GOLD A–D classification, the BODEx index, and the CAT score which include dyspnea and exacerbation in their calculation were also related to the self-reported walking time in this study. Similar results have been previously reported by using direct measures of physical activity.Citation24
This study found airflow limitation to be poorly related to self-reported walking time. Although in some previous studies, FEV1 has shown a weak–moderate association with objectively measured physical activity in patients with COPD,Citation3,Citation22 other studies have not observed this relationship.Citation38–Citation40 In general, FEV1 is known to explain only a small proportion of the variation in physical activity in subjects with COPD as physical activity is dependent on many factors, including biological, behavioral, social, and environmental factors, among others.Citation7 Therefore, we should go beyond FEV1 to better understand how the disease affects the COPD patients.
The main strengths of this study include the large sample of COPD patients with a large variability of disease severity, the different clinical settings in which the patients were tested (primary care and specialized pneumology departments), and the wide range of outcome variables used in this analysis. However, the results of this study may be affected by several limitations. First, an indirect measure of physical activity (patient self-reported walking time) was used, which may be inaccurate, does not quantify the intensity of the activities, and does not capture other physically activities apart from walking. However, walking is the most common way of exercising in the daily life of the elderly.Citation41 Second, the associations observed between self-reported walking time and markers of COPD severity do not mean that the question “on average how many minutes do you walk per day?” is a valid measure of physical activity in each individual patient. This is not a formal validation study, as no objective measure was used to compare the results obtained; however, the results support the usefulness of the question to identify a subpopulation of patients who may require interventions to promote physical activity (those with self-reported walking times of <30 min/day). Certainly, further studies are needed to validate this question as a reliable measure to identify inactive patients in the clinical setting. In addition, some of the variables tested in these analyses are included in the multidimensional markers of severity, and thus, adjusted multivariate analyses could not be performed. Third, few women were included; therefore, the results cannot be generalized to both the sexes. However, the studies included in this analysis had no exclusion criteria in relation to sex. The lower proportion of women reflects the COPD distribution by sex in this country, as previously reported.Citation42 Finally, the cross-sectional nature of the study does not allow us to establish the direction of the observed associations.
Conclusion
Lower self-reported walking times are related to worse markers of disease severity routinely used in the clinical management of patients with COPD. The use of the question “on average how many minutes do you walk per day?” may provide a simple method for clinicians to identify physically inactive COPD patients.
Acknowledgments
The FyCEPOC and INSEPOC studies were funded by Laboratorios Esteve SA (Barcelona, Spain). The NEREA study was funded by an unrestricted grant from J Uriach y Compañía SA. The DEPREPOC study was funded by Grupo Ferrer (Barcelona, Spain). The funding bodies have no involvement in the analysis and interpretation of data, the writing of the report, or in the decision to submit the article for publication.
Disclosure
JM reports personal fees from Boehringer-Ingelheim, Chiesi, Pfizer, AstraZéneca, Rovi, and Teva and has received grants from Boehringer-Ingelheim, Chiesi, Pfizer, and GlaxoSmithKline outside the submitted work. CL reports receiving research grants from the European Commission (Sixth & Seventh Programme Frameworks and Horizon 2020), Catalan Society of Family Medicine, and Instituto de Salud Carlos III (Spanish Ministry of Health). He also reports having had a grant from the Fundació Jordi Gol i Gurina for a research stage at the University of Cardiff in 2013. CR received grants from Instituto Carlos III (Spanish Government) and Plan Nacional sobre drogas (Spanish Government). The other authors report no conflicts of interest in this work.
References
- VestboJHurdSSAgustíAGGlobal strategy for the diagnosis, management, and prevention of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: GOLD executive summaryAm J Respir Crit Care Med201318734736522878278
- AgustíAGNNogueraASauledaJSalaEPonsJBusquetsXSystemic effects of chronic obstructive pulmonary diseaseEur Respir J20032134736012608452
- PittaFTroostersTSpruitMAProbstVSDecramerMGosselinkRCharacteristics of physical activities in daily life in chronic obstructive pulmonary diseaseAm J Respir Crit Care Med200517197297715665324
- Garcia-AymerichJLangePBenetMSchnohrPAntóJMRegular physical activity reduces hospital admission and mortality in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: a population based cohort studyThorax20066177277816738033
- WaschkiBKirstenAHolzOPhysical activity is the strongest predictor of all-cause mortality in patients with COPD: a prospective cohort studyChest201114033134221273294
- Garcia-RioFRojoBCasitasRPrognostic value of the objective measurement of daily physical activity in patients with COPDChest201214233834622281798
- WatzHPittaFRochesterCLAn official European Respiratory Society statement on physical activity in COPDEur Respir J2014441521153725359358
- PittaFTroostersTProbstVSSpruitMADecramerMGosselinkRQuantifying physical activity in daily life with questionnaires and motion sensors in COPDEur Respir J2006271040105516707399
- MiravitllesMSoler-CataluñaJJCalleMSpanish COPD Guidelines (GesEPOC): pharmacological treatment of stable COPD. Spanish Society of Pulmonology and Thoracic SurgeryArch Bronconeumol20124824725722561012
- Chodzko-ZajkoWJProctorDNFiatarone SinghMAAmerican College of Sports Medicine position stand. Exercise and physical activity for older adultsMed Sci Sports Exerc2009411510153019516148
- MiravitllesMNaberanKCantoniJAzpeitiaASocioeconomic status and health-related quality of life of patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary diseaseRespiration20118240240821778694
- MiravitllesMBarrechegurenMRomán-RodríguezMFrequency and characteristics of different clinical phenotypes of chronic obstructive pulmonary diseaseInt J Tuberc Lung Dis20151999299826162367
- MiravitllesMLlorCde CastellarRIzquierdoIBaróEDonadoEValidation of the COPD severity score for use in primary care: the NEREA studyEur Respir J20093351952719164354
- MiravitllesMMolinaJQuintanoJACampuzanoAPérezJRonceroCFactors associated with depression and severe depression in patients with COPDRespir Med20141081615162525312692
- CharlsonMSzatrowskiTPPetersonJGoldJValidation of a combined comorbidity indexJ Clin Epidemiol199447124512517722560
- BestallJCPaulEAGarrodRGarnhamRJonesPWWedzichaJAUsefulness of the Medical Research Council (MRC) dyspnoea scale as a measure of disability in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary diseaseThorax19995458158610377201
- JonesPWHardingGBerryPWiklundIChenW-HKline LeidyNDevelopment and first validation of the COPD Assessment TestEur Respir J20093464865419720809
- CelliBRMacNeeWStandards for the diagnosis and treatment of patients with COPD: a summary of the ATS/ERS position paperEur Respir J20042393294615219010
- Soler-CataluñaJJMartínez-GarcíaMASánchezLSTorderaMPSánchezPRSevere exacerbations and BODE index: two independent risk factors for death in male COPD patientsRespir Med200910369269919131231
- VorrinkSNWKortHSMTroostersTLammersJ-WJLevel of daily physical activity in individuals with COPD compared with healthy controlsRespir Res2011123321426563
- AlahmariADPatelARCKowlessarBSDaily activity during stability and exacerbation of chronic obstructive pulmonary diseaseBMC Pulm Med2014149824885188
- WatzHWaschkiBMeyerTMagnussenHPhysical activity in patients with COPDEur Respir J20093326227219010994
- HayataAMinakataYMatsunagaKNakanishiMYamamotoNDifferences in physical activity according to mMRC grade in patients with COPDInt J COPD20161122032208
- DemeyerHGimeno-SantosERabinovichRAPhysical activity characteristics across GOLD quadrants depend on the questionnaire usedPLoS One201611e01512555
- MoyMLGouldMKLiuI-LALeeJSNguyenHQPhysical activity assessed in routine care predicts mortality after a COPD hospitalisationERJ Open Res201620006202015
- AlahmariADMackayAJPatelARCInfluence of weather and atmospheric pollution on physical activity in patients with COPDRespir Res2015167126071400
- ThyregodMBodtgerUCoherence between self-reported and objectively measured physical activity in patients with chronic obstructive lung disease: a systematic reviewInt J Chron Obstruct Pulmon Dis2016112931293827932873
- DePewZSGarofoliACNovotnyPJBenzoRPScreening for severe physical inactivity in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: the value of simple measures and the validation of two physical activity questionnairesChron Respir Dis201310192723149382
- KatajistoMKupiainenHRantanenPPhysical inactivity in COPD and increased patient perception of dyspneaInt J Chron Obstruct Pulmon Dis2012774375523152679
- Garcia-AymerichJSerraIGómezFPPhysical activity and clinical and functional status in COPDChest2009136627019255291
- JolleyCJMoxhamJA physiological model of patient-reported breathlessness during daily activities in COPDEur Respir Rev200944114
- DanilackVAWestonNARichardsonCRMoriDLMoyMLReasons persons with COPD do not walk and relationship with daily step countCOPD J Chronic Obstr Pulm Dis201411290299
- DonaldsonGCSeemungalTARBhowmikAWedzichaJARelationship between exacerbation frequency and lung function decline in chronic obstructive pulmonary diseaseThorax20025784785212324669
- DollHMiravitllesMQuality of life in acute exacerbations of chronic bronchitis and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: a review of the literaturePharmacoeconomics20052334536315853435
- RamonMAGimeno-SantosEFerrerJHospital admissions and exercise capacity decline in patients with COPDEur Respir J2014431018102724389867
- Soler-CataluñaJJMartínez-GarcíaMARomán SánchezPSalcedoENavarroMOchandoRSevere acute exacerbations and mortality in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary diseaseThorax20056092593116055622
- SpruitMAGosselinkRTroostersTMuscle force during an acute exacerbation in hospitalised patients with COPD and its relationship with CXCL8 and IGF-IThorax20035875275612947130
- Garcia-AymerichJFélezMAEscarrabillJPhysical activity and its determinants in severe chronic obstructive pulmonary diseaseMed Sci Sports Exerc2004361667167315595285
- HernandesNATeixeiraDDCProbstVSProfile of the level of physical activity in the daily lives of patients with COPD in BrazilJ Bras Pneumol20093594995619918626
- PittaFTakakiMYOliveiraNHRelationship between pulmonary function and physical activity in daily life in patients with COPDRespir Med20081021203120718573647
- Palacios-CeñaDAlonso-BlancoCJiménez-GarciaRTime trends in leisure time physical activity and physical fitness in elderly people: 20 year follow-up of the Spanish population national health survey (1987–2006)BMC Public Health20111179921995560
- MiravitllesMSorianoJBGarcía-RíoFPrevalence of COPD in Spain: impact of undiagnosed COPD on quality of life and daily life activitiesThorax20096486386819553233