Blood-pressure variability in patients with obstructive sleep apnea: current perspectives

Abstract

Obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is often associated with hypertension and other cardiovascular diseases. Blood pressure (BP) variability is part of the assessment of cardiovascular risk. In OSA, BP variability has been studied mainly as very short-term (beat-by-beat) and short-term (24-hour BP profile) variability. BP measured on consecutive heartbeats has been demonstrated to be highly variable, due to repeated peaks during sleep, so that an accurate assessment of nocturnal BP levels in OSA may require peculiar methodologies. In 24-hour recordings, BP frequently features a “nondipping” profile, ie, <10% fall from day to night, which may increase cardiovascular risk and occurrence of major cardiovascular events in the nocturnal hours. Also, BP tends to show a large “morning BP surge”, a still controversial negative prognostic sign. Increased very short-term BP variability, high morning BP, and nondipping BP profile appear related to the severity of OSA. Treatment of OSA slightly reduces mean 24-hour BP levels and nocturnal beat-by-beat BP variability by abolishing nocturnal BP peaks. In some patients OSA treatment turns a nondipping into a dipping BP profile. Treatment of arterial hypertension in OSA usually requires both antihypertensive pharmacological therapy and treatment of apnea. Addressing BP variability could help improve the management of OSA and reduce cardiovascular risk. Possibly, drug administration at an appropriate time would ensure a dipping-BP profile.

Keywords:

• sleep apnea
• ambulatory blood-pressure monitoring
• beat-by-beat measurements
• blood-pressure dipping
• morning blood-pressure surge

Introduction

Obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is a well-known cardiovascular risk factor. In patients with OSA, cardiovascular diseases have increased incidence and are associated with worse functional outcomes and increased mortality.¹ Systemic hypertension, which is often found in OSA, can importantly affect cardiovascular health. Also, altered blood pressure (BP) variability may carry some additional risk for higher incidence and faster progression of cardiovascular disease.^2,3 Both the degree and pattern of BP variability have prognostic implications. Many methods and calculations have been proposed for assessment of BP variability, but physiological and clinical meanings of each of them are not always clear.^4,5 In this article, after a brief review of assessment and implications of BP variability in the general population, we focus on BP variability in adult OSA, taking into account methodological, clinical, and therapeutic aspects.

Types of BP variability

BP variability can be defined as BP fluctuations occurring over time. It can be studied in the very short term (beat to beat), short term (24 hours), midterm (day to day), or long term (visit to visit).² Whatever the time scale, sympathetic activity is a determinant of BP variability in response to a variety of external and internal stimuli. In the very short term, respiratory influences, postural changes, emotional factors, or environmental conditions are a source of BP changes, while arterial and cardiopulmonary reflexes, arterial compliance, blood viscosity, and humoral factors modulate their amplitude.² Twenty-four-hour BP changes are affected by endocrine influences, genetic factors, degree of diurnal physical and mental activity, and more than anything else by the wake–sleep cycle.^6,7 In normal subjects, BP decreases when falling asleep, reaches its lowest values and highest stability during slow-wave sleep (SWS), and shows the highest variability during rapid eye movement (REM) sleep.⁸ Midterm and long-term BP variability are representative of BP burden and reflect the degree of control of BP over longer periods. Similarly to very short- and short-term variability, their increase is considered an unfavorable prognostic sign.²

Measurement techniques should be appropriately chosen to study each kind of BP variability. Very short-term variability can be studied invasively by means of measurements performed with intra-arterial catheters, or noninvasively by means of a photoplethysmographic sensor applied at a finger using the volume-clamp methodology.^9,10 In addition, a new noninvasive method to measure beat-to-beat BP at the wrist by applanation tonometry has been recently described.¹¹ Twenty-four-hour changes can be detected by BP measurements taken at different times of the day, eg, morning and evening, preferably with home measurements taken by patients themselves (home BP monitoring [HBPM]), or by instruments that automatically measure BP at fixed intervals during the 24 hours (ambulatory BPM [ABPM]). However, HBPM may provide information only on waking BP, whereas BP measurements during sleep can be obtained only with ABPM. For assessment of midterm BP variability, HBPM may be a better choice than ABPM, as ABPM may not be easily tolerated on consecutive days. Patients should preferably use validated automatic devices and receive appropriate training and instructions about the correct modalities to perform the measurements.¹² Similarly to midterm variability, long-term BP variability may be best monitored by HBPM. Whatever the type of BP assessment to perform, office BP measurements are far from ideal, mainly due to the common “white-coat effect”, which can lead to an overestimation of patients’ usual BP levels.² Evaluation of mid- and long-term variabilities is particularly useful in the management of hypertensive patients, but very little is known about their behavior in OSA. Therefore, we focus our attention on very short- and short-term variability.

Beat-to-beat BP measurements: very short-term BP variability

Beat-to-beat BP measurements are ideal to monitor fast changes in autonomic modulation, eg, in awake subjects performing the Valsalva maneuver, which is part of the assessment of patients with autonomic disorders, eg, orthostatic hypotension.¹³ Among the most common applications of beat-to-beat BP recordings is the measurement of cardiac baroreflex sensitivity, which can be assessed both during wakefulness and during sleep. Its evaluation may be useful for prognostic purposes and to assess therapy effectiveness in several diseases, although present knowledge has not yet allowed us to adopt it in clinical routine.¹⁴ During sleep, beat-to-beat measurements reveal sudden BP rises when events disturbing sleep occur, especially when associated with electroencephalography changes (cortical arousals).¹⁵ BP surges can be a cause of increased nocturnal BP variability, as is usually observed in OSA. In this condition, beat-to-beat BPM may reveal important aspects of BP behavior that would be undetected by any other BP assessment method.

Twenty-four-hour BP: short-term BP variability

Many types of analyses may be done on 24-hour BP values, including separate measurements of waking and sleeping BP and the 24-hour BP profile. Today, it is commonly agreed that mean BP levels have a higher influence on cardiovascular risk than the 24-hour BP profile.^2,16,17 In particular, nocturnal BP levels are the most useful predictors of cardiovascular disease.^16,18–20 Thresholds for normal BP values, assessed by ABPM, have changed over time. Until recently, diurnal values ≥135/85 mmHg and nocturnal values ≥120/70 mmHg have been considered representative of diurnal and nocturnal hypertensive BP levels.²¹ According to new guidelines, diurnal values ≥130/80 and nocturnal values ≥110/65 mmHg should be considered hypertensive.¹²

However, some types of circadian BP changes also carry an independent risk, and the evaluation of the circadian BP profile helps to understand mechanisms governing BP changes better and establish more appropriate therapy in each hypertensive subject. In normal subjects, BP usually exhibits one peak early in the morning and one peak late in the afternoon or early evening.^6,7 Either higher morning or evening BP have been reported, as some studies, mainly in Asian subjects, found higher values in the morning, while other studies, mainly in European subjects, in the evening.²² It has been claimed that morning BP better predicts cardiovascular risk than evening BP,²³ particularly when the morning:evening BP ratio increases.²⁴

The 24-hour BP profile is evaluated mainly as change in mean BP from day to night. Since sleep is a major determinant of the diurnal change, usually causing a decrease in BP, BP measurements taken during waking and sleeping should be considered separately. For the sake of simplicity, fixed time ranges relevant to estimated waking and sleeping time are often used. They can be set as wide-fixed or narrow-fixed intervals. With the first method, all 24-hour measurements are taken into account and subdivided into waking and sleeping values. According to the other method, periods estimated as transition times between waking and sleeping are discarded.²⁵ Ideally, waking and sleeping measurements should be estimated individually based on sleep diaries or (better) on results of monitoring by instruments helping to define waking and sleeping times, like actigraphs.²⁶

Although definitions may vary,¹⁹ the following BP 24-hour profiles are commonly considered: “dipping”, mean nocturnal reduction in BP by 10%–20%; “nondipping”, nocturnal reduction in BP between 0 and 10%; “reverse dipping” or “riser” pattern, increase in mean BP during the night; “extreme dipping”, nocturnal reduction in BP >20%. While the dipping pattern is considered physiological and associated with the lowest risk, nondipping and extreme-dipping patterns carry an intermediate risk and the reverse-dipping profile carries the highest risk of cardiovascular events.²⁷

Another way to look at the 24-hour BP variability is to compare nocturnal and morning BP to measure the “morning BP surge” (MBPS). BP normally increases after morning awakening.⁶ An increase in cardiac output in young subjects and increased arterial stiffness in the elderly play a role in determining MBPS.²⁸ Elderly subjects usually have higher MBPS compared to young subjects. The definition of a normal MBPS rise is lacking, but a J- or U-shaped relationship between the degree of MBPS and cardiovascular risk has been proposed.²⁸

MBPS can be calculated following different criteria (Figure 1). The most commonly used are: sleep-trough morning surge, defined as the difference between the average BP over 2 hours after waking and the average of three consecutive BP recordings, centered on the lowest reading during sleep; and the prewaking morning surge, defined as the difference between the average BP recordings 2 hours after waking and average BP recordings over 2 hours before waking up.^28,29 The MBPS has been proposed as a potential contributor to the increased incidence of cardiovascular events in the morning hours. However, while some authors have confirmed the importance of the MBPS as a cardiovascular risk factor,^29–31 others have reported opposite findings, with less risk in subjects with elevated MBPS.^32–34

Figure 1 Measurements of morning blood pressure surge (MBPS).

Notes: Sleep-trough MBPS definition: mean blood pressure in the 2 hours following morning awakening – lowest nocturnal blood pressure (measured as the mean of three measurements centered on the lowest nocturnal value). Prewaking MBPS definition: mean blood pressure in the 2 hours following morning awakening – mean blood pressure in the 2 hours preceding morning awakening. Copyright ©2003. American Heart Association, Inc. Reproduced from Kario K, Pickering TG, Umeda Y, et al. Morning surge in blood pressure as a predictor of silent and clinical cerebrovascular disease in elderly hypertensives: a prospective study. Circulation. 2003;107(10):1401–1406 (https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/01.cir.0000056521.67546.aa).²⁹

An apparently obvious objection raised to the MBPS concept is that subjects with high MBPS may actually show low nocturnal BP levels, which is difficult to reconcile with the well-known risk represented by nocturnal hypertension. Along the same lines, a high MBPS may be the effect of extreme dipping, such that it could be associated with increased cardiovascular risk due to very low nocturnal BP and not to high morning BP. Although an elevated MBPS is more common among extreme dippers, only a fraction of them have a high MBPS. According to one study, only 24% of extreme dippers have a high MBPS. Also, when extreme dipping and high MBPS coexist, increased cardiovascular risk appears to be associated more with the morning BP rise than with excessively low nocturnal BP.²⁹ Finally, a high MBPS, assessed by sleep-trough morning surge, may be associated with nocturnal hypertension in subjects who show a progressive increase in BP from the beginning to the end of the night (Figure 2).³⁵

Figure 2 Different blood-pressure profiles in two subjects with high sleep-trough morning blood pressure surge (MBPS).

Notes: High MBPS may or may not be associated with low nocturnal blood pressure. Copyright ©2005. American Journal of Hypertension, Ltd. Reproduced from Kario K. Time for focus on morning hypertension: pitfall of current antihypertensive medication. Am J Hypertens. 2005;18(2 Pt 1):149–151, by permission of Oxford University Press.³⁵

In clinical practice, ABPM is typically used in specialized hypertension clinics, especially for patients who have resistant or refractory hypertension. However, the importance and usefulness of ABPM measurements should lead to it being used clinically more often than it is at present.

BP variability in OSA

Patients with OSA are characterized by a high prevalence of arterial hypertension, which may exceed 50%,³⁶ and by high BP variability. In fact, OSA is frequently associated with factors, often interrelated, with important influences on the cardiocirculatory system, like oxidative stress, inflammation, endothelial dysfunction, and high sympathetic tone,¹ which increase during sleep as an immediate effect of respiratory disorders and remain high during wakefulness.³⁷ These factors may increase BP levels and variability chronically.

The greatest peculiarities in BP behavior in OSA are seen during sleep. Pulsus paradoxus, ie, inspiratory reduction in BP ≥10 mmHg, occurs in obstructed breaths with strong respiratory efforts.^38,39 More importantly, obstructive apnea termination is characterized by a BP peak lasting only a few seconds that is followed by a return of BP to or below baseline.⁴⁰ Therefore, the higher the number of apneas during sleep, the higher the number of BP oscillations. However, the amplitude of BP peaks is highly variable in relationship to sympathetic reactivity, which in turn is related to end-apneic hypoxemia, occurrence and strength of arousals at the end of each event, age of patients, and normotensive/hypertensive state.^41–43 The rate and amplitude of BP peaks during sleep are fundamental determinants of the degree of variability of BP during the night and of the mean change in BP from day to night. Apneic events are less frequent in SWS,⁴⁴ and are usually longer and associated with worse hypoxemia in REM sleep.⁴⁵ Therefore, the respective duration of the various sleep stages may also influence nocturnal BP behavior in OSA through rate and severity of events in each of them. Due to the numerous, large, and rapid changes in BP during the night, information on BP in OSA is heavily affected by the method used for its assessment. Optimal detection of different parameters describing BP levels or variability may take advantage of different monitoring techniques.

Role of frequent diurnal and nocturnal BP measurements: very short-term variability

Continuous BP monitoring is not easily tolerated for prolonged periods of time, and may give rise to frequent artifacts, eg, due to limb movements. Therefore, beat-by-beat BP measurements are often performed during short representative time lapses. When recorded during wakefulness, their analysis is not more useful in OSA than in normal subjects, whereas they provide valuable and unique information on BP behavior in sleeping OSA subjects.

Intra-arterial measurements were already obtained in very early studies in OSA patients, and revealed the rapid oscillations associated with apneic events⁴⁰ that were later confirmed with the use of noninvasive techniques.^{41,43,46–50} Beat-by-beat evaluation of BP showed that during sleep, compared to the immediately preceding quiet wakefulness, mean BP falls if breathing is unobstructed, while it changes little during nonapneic snoring.⁴⁷ Conversely, in OSA, mean BP during sleep can be higher than during quiet wakefulness, with a trend to highest values during REM sleep.^46,51

The advantage of beat-by-beat BP measurements in OSA is that they provide accurate information about very short-term variability in BP, although they are less accurate in the assessment of absolute BP values. During wakefulness, beat-by-beat measurements show increased variance in BP proportional to the severity of OSA.⁵² Progression from quiet waking to non-REM to REM sleep is associated with an increasing coefficient of variation in BP values.⁴⁶ The SD of BP values during sleep is higher in OSA than in non-OSA subjects, although in both groups BP variability is similarly modulated by sleep stage, being lowest during SWS. Frequency of arousals and respiratory events are correlated with systolic and diastolic BP SD, although they do not fully explain them.⁴⁹

We used beat-by-beat BP measurements to compare accuracy of different sampling rates in the assessment of mean nocturnal BP in subjects with severe OSA and in non-OSA controls. In each subject, mean systolic and diastolic BP were calculated, averaging measurements taken on all heartbeats of one night. Then, mean BP values of the same night were measured, averaging values of heartbeats sampled each 5, 10, 15, 20 and 30 minutes. The mean values obtained from heartbeats sampled at each rate were compared to values calculated on all heartbeats. At all sampling intervals in both patients and controls, mean differences between mean systolic and diastolic nocturnal BP values calculated on sampled and all-night heartbeats were small, but the scatter of the differences was higher in the OSA group, especially when long sampling intervals were used (Figure 3). In the OSA subjects, a sampling rate about three times that in the non-OSA subjects was necessary for a similarly accurate assessment of mean nocturnal BP.⁵³

Figure 3 Means ± SD of (A) ΔPs and (B) ΔPd values in control (□) and obstructive sleep apnea (◊) subjects for each sampling interval.

Notes: ΔPs and ΔPd: differences in mmHg between the mean nocturnal blood pressure values, respectively systolic and diastolic, obtained from sampled single heart beats and from all heart beats. Copyright ©2000. ERS Journals Ltd. Reproduced from Marrone O, Romano S, Insalaco G, Bonsignore MR, Salvaggio A, Bonsignore G. Influence of sampling interval on the evaluation of nocturnal blood pressure in subjects with and without obstructive sleep apnoea. Eur Respir J. 2000;16(4):653–658.⁵³

It has been claimed that cuff inflations for ABPM measurements can cause arousals, transiently increasing BP, so that BP levels detected by ABPM are higher than during undisturbed sleep.⁵⁴ In OSA subjects, this result proved true for systolic pressure, which is measured soon after brachial cuff inflation, but not for diastolic pressure, which is measured later so that it is less affected by the arousal.⁵⁵ Our experience with five sleepy patients with severe OSA was that the time taken by ABPM to perform each measurement was usually longer than an apneic cycle, ie, an apnea and the following ventilation interval, and rarely caused arousals prematurely interrupting the apnea occurring during the measurement (Figure 4).⁵³ Therefore, frequent BP measurements by ABPM may not significantly disturb sleep and BP behavior in severe OSA patients.

Figure 4 Fragment of a polygraph recording in a representative sleepy patient with severe obstructive sleep apnea.

Notes: Patient undergoing simultaneous continuous finger blood pressure monitoring and ambulatory blood pressure monitoring (ABPM). Top to bottom: pressure detected by an open hose placed under the cuff for ABPM measurements; beat-by-beat blood pressure (BP); nasal airflow; oxyhemoglobin saturation (SaO₂). A flat airflow signal identifies apnea time. In this patient, apnea duration was similar before and during ABPM measurement, which indicates that the cuff inflation did not cause any arousal shortening habitual apnea duration. ABPM measurement required a time exceeding the duration of an apnea cycle, ie, of an apnea and following ventilation. During that period, BP values largely varied, but only one systolic and one diastolic value were obtained by ABPM.

Whatever the time between measurements obtained at fixed intervals, ABPM may hardly be able to reveal extreme BP levels, which are often (but only transiently) reached in OSA at night. To overcome this problem, a nocturnal BPM method triggered by occurrence of oxygen desaturation has been developed.⁵⁶ This method shows a fair degree of reproducibility,⁵⁷ but the time required for a measurement and the short duration of the BP rise may reduce the accuracy of detection of BP peaks. However, it represents a clear advancement in the assessment of nocturnal BP in OSA with respect to ABPM.

Twenty-four-hour BP profile: short-term BP variability

Some information about the diurnal BP changes in OSA has been obtained with measurements taken in the evening and the next morning, after awakening. According to this methodology, the morning BP levels in OSA tend to exceed the evening ones. Most studies have reported that the evening-to-morning BP difference was correlated with OSA severity (Table 1).^48,58–64

Table 1 Studies based on morning and evening BP measurements

Authors	Subjects under study	Findings
Hoffstein and Mateika^Citation58	611 suspected OSA	If AHI <10: BP morning < BP evening If AHI 10–≤50: BP morning = BP evening If AHI >50: BP morning > BP evening
Sforza and Lugaresi^Citation48	253 suspected OSA	In both simple snorers and OSA: BP morning > BP evening SBP evening-to-morning rise correlated to AHI
Stradling et al^Citation59	448 subjects from general population	ODI4 and mean nocturnal respiratory effort independently correlated with evening-to-morning BP rise
Lavie-Nevo and Pillar^Citation61	2,009 suspected OSA	SBP and DBP evening-to-morning rise correlated with AHI in men, but not in women
Ting et al^Citation63	263 simple snorers, UARS or OSA	Subjects with morning:evening BP ratio >11% (“morning surge” pattern) or with mean both morning and evening BP >130 mmHg (“constant high”) had higher AHI, lower lowest SaO2, longer T<90% and higher arousal index than subjects with morning:evening BP ratio <11% (“morning drop”) or both morning and evening mean BP <130 mmHg (“constant low”); similar percentage of sleep stages in all groups
Huang et al^Citation64	105 positional and 266 non- positional OSA	Morning BP higher in nonpositional OSA; evening BP and evening-to-morning BP difference similar in positional and nonpositional OSA
Wang et al^Citation60	3246 OSA + 354 controls	Progressive increase in morning/evening mean BP with increasing OSA severity
Mokros et al^Citation62	454 normotensive suspected OSA	AHI linearly correlated with evening-to-morning DBP rise, but not SBP rise

Note: Arousal index, number of arousals per hour; ODI₄, number of oxyhemoglobin saturation falls ≥4% per hour.

Abbreviations: AHI, apnea/hypopnea index; BP, blood pressure; DBP, diastolic BP; ODI, oxygen desaturation index; OSA, obstructive sleep apnea; SaO₂, oxyhemoglobin saturation; SBP, systolic BP; T<90%, time spent with oxyhemoglobin saturation <90%; UARS, upper airway resistance syndrome.

A large number of studies have been based on ABPM, with nocturnal BP measurements taken every 15, 20, or 30 minutes. Surprisingly, the first ABPM studies did not demonstrate increased nocturnal BP in OSA.^65,66 Rather, one underscored the occurrence of large drops in BP in some subjects with mildly elevated apnea/hypopnea index (AHI) values, but large oxygen saturation falls. This observation remained isolated and unexplained. However, recruited patients were old, and increased arterial stiffness could be responsible for high diurnal BP values and blunted BP reactivity to sleep-respiratory disorders and arousals.⁶⁵ Instead, most of the following studies reported that patients with OSA showed a nondipping more commonly than a dipping BP pattern.^67–72

In OSA, use of ABPM has also proved useful in highlighting high prevalence of masked hypertension, ie, normal office BP values with high mean values at the ABPM assessment. Masked hypertension in OSA could be a consequence of mean nocturnal BP exceeding normal levels.⁷³ However, two studies found that it could frequently also be due to high diurnal BP values detected only by ABPM.^74,75

Other studies extended analysis of ABPM recordings beyond mean diurnal and nocturnal BP (Table 2).^76–79 Altogether, OSA, and especially severe OSA, was associated not only with increased nocturnal but also with increased morning BP. Differences in diurnal and evening BP observed between subjects with and without OSA were milder, confirming the results obtained with waking evening and morning measurements described earlier.

Table 2 24-Hour BP characteristics in obstructive sleep apnea: beyond dipping and nondipping

Authors	Subjects under study	Profiles
Noda et al^Citation76	21 OSA + 123 non-OSA	Type 1: normal BP throughout the 24-hour period with nocturnal BP fall (OSA + non-OSA) Type 2: progressive BP elevation from onset of sleep to early morning (hypertensive OSA) Type 3: elevated BP at any time (hypertensive OSA)
Nagata et al^Citation77	5 non-OSA, 10 mild OSA, 12 moderate OSA, 27 severe OSA	Nocturnal BP: moderate and severe OSA > non OSA Morning BP: severe OSA > non OSA Nocturnal BP fall: severe OSA < non OSA Diurnal and evening BP: OSA = non OSA
Sasaki et al^Citation78	103 OSA	Sustained type: both diurnal and nocturnal hypertension; profile related to OSA severity and sleep disruption Surge type: only morning hypertension; profile related to reduced SWS Control type: neither diurnal nor nocturnal hypertension Nocturnal hypertension only: not analyzed, few patients
Cho et al^Citation79	Hypertensives, 35 OSA + 23 non-OSA	Sleep-trough morning SBP surge: OSA > non-OSA

Abbreviations: BP, blood pressure; OSA, obstructive sleep apnea; SBP, systolic BP; SWS, slow-wave sleep.

Factors associated with high BP levels and nondipping profile observed at ABPM have been investigated in several cross-sectional studies. Significant relationships between increased AHI or oxygen desaturation index (number of oxygen saturation dips per hour of sleep) and reduced nocturnal BP dipping have been found in community and OSA populations.^59,68,69,80 Other studies on OSA, while confirming a role of nocturnal hypoxemia, stressed the importance of arousals as possible determinants of nocturnal BP and 24-hour BP profile.^76,81 By contrast, another study could not demonstrate differences between dippers and nondippers in the rate of arousals or SWS duration.⁷¹ Differences between studies could be at least partially accounted for by variable relationships of the nondipping phenomenon in different subjects. In fact, according to some authors, in young OSA patients nondipping was correlated with the severity of respiratory disorders, and in elderly patients with reduced SWS and REM and increased stage 1 duration.⁸² In a subsequent study, the same authors demonstrated that while a sustained high BP profile was associated with both OSA severity and altered sleep architecture, the MBPS was associated only with altered sleep architecture.⁷⁸ Morning BP was the object of another study that found that the severity of sleep-respiratory disorders in hypertensive subjects, though not directly affecting morning BP, was independently correlated with the MBPS.⁸³

Two longitudinal studies evaluated the incidence of a nondipping BP pattern in relationship to OSA in a general population cohort (the Wisconsin Sleep Cohort). In the first, an independent relationship between AHI values and incidence of systolic nondipping was demonstrated.⁸⁴ In the second, the risk of developing systolic and diastolic nondipping was significantly correlated with AHI values in REM, but not in non-REM sleep.⁸⁵

In summary, cross-sectional studies have shown that high-severity sleep-respiratory disorders and altered sleep architecture may be related to increased BP, especially at night, and to reduced nocturnal BP dipping, but data were inconsistent, possibly due to numerous confounding factors. Longitudinal studies, coming from only one cohort, support a role of sleep-respiratory disorders, especially if occurring during REM sleep, as determinants of nondipping BP.

Other measurements of BP variability

Besides the BP pattern over 24 hours, the SD of the measurements taken with ABPM has been commonly used as a parameter of variability.^{68,74,86–91} Other parameters have been coefficient of variation,⁸⁹ average real variability (ie, average of absolute differences between consecutive measurements),⁸⁹ time rate index (ie, rate of change of BP over time, defined as the first derivative values of BP by time).⁸⁷ Heterogeneous studies designs were evident. Two studies compared subjects with and without OSA,^87,88 two compared hypertensive subjects with and without OSA,^89,90 one compared subjects with mild–moderate and severe OSA,⁹¹ one evaluated patients with moderate–severe OSA before and after continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) treatment,⁸⁶ and one evaluated OSA subjects with normotension, established hypertension, or masked hypertension.⁷⁴ Therefore, results of these studies are hard to compare. Some relationship between OSA and BP variability was observed in most of them. However, depending on the study, an effect of OSA was variably apparent on systolic or diastolic BP or on 24-hour, diurnal, or nocturnal BP. We believe that ABPM may roughly catch BP variability in the nocturnal hours in OSA for the reasons explained, which could account for some disagreement among studies. Little information is available on mid- and long-term BP variability in OSA. No effect on morning-to-morning BP was reported during CPAP withdrawal for 2 weeks, which suggested that OSA does not significantly influence midterm BP variability.⁹²

Twenty-four-hour BP profile and cardiovascular risk

The characteristics of BP variability in OSA likely contribute to cardiovascular risk and to a peculiar temporal pattern of occurrence of cardiovascular events. Little direct evidence is available of a relationship between BP profile and cardiovascular risk in OSA. Among OSA patients studied with repeated morning and evening BP measurements, those with an MBPS showed higher high-sensitivity C-reactive protein levels.⁶¹ Similarly, among OSA patients studied by ABPM, nondippers showed higher levels of IL2 and high-sensitivity C-reactive protein than dippers.^93,94 Patients with both moderate–severe OSA and reverse-dipping BP profile showed worse brain white matter lesions than subjects with one condition alone.⁹⁵ In a retrospective study, it was observed that OSA patients who had shown a nondipping-BP profile had a higher incidence of stroke, coronary artery disease, and heart failure in a 43-month period.⁹⁶

A support to the role of the BP profile is also given by indirect evidence. While in the general population major cardiovascular events and sudden death occur preferentially in the morning hours,⁶ in OSA their distribution in the 24-hour period seems to be different. Among subjects who had been studied by polysomnography and died from sudden cardiac death, the fatal events had a peak during the night if OSA had been diagnosed, and a nocturnal nadir in non-OSA subjects.⁹⁷ According to a recent larger investigation, sudden cardiac deaths were evenly distributed in the 24 hours in OSA patients, whereas non-OSA subjects died preferentially in the morning.⁹⁸ Two studies pointed out that in OSA patients, the onset of acute coronary syndrome was more frequent in the nocturnal hours, differently from subjects without OSA.^99,100 In addition, a few studies showed that wakeup strokes were strongly associated with OSA.^101,102 Multiple factors may be responsible for triggering cardiovascular events at night, but it is likely that the altered BP profile plays an important role. All these findings indicate that risk associated with OSA increases especially at night and not in the morning. Therefore, in OSA nocturnal hypertension and a nondipping or reverse-dipping pattern might influence cardiovascular risk more than MBPS.

OSA treatment and BP variability

In the management of OSA, the main focus is usually on the elimination of respiratory disorders during sleep. Treatment of OSA can reduce many symptoms and risk factors, usually to an extent that is proportional to the correction of the respiratory disorders.¹⁰³ It would also be important to reduce cardiovascular risk factors, including abnormal BP during sleep. For a long time, treatment of hypertensive patients has been aimed almost exclusively at maintaining normal BP levels, not rarely measured just as office diurnal BP values, which are often misleading. More recently, BP variability, including the 24-hour profile of BP, has been brought to the attention of clinicians as a possible target of treatment. A chronotherapy of hypertension, aimed at more carefully controlling nocturnal BP levels and converting a nondipping into a dipping BP profile, has been proposed as a convenient treatment strategy.¹⁰⁴

In OSA, antihypertensive drugs may reduce BP levels, but have at most a limited effect, if any, on sleep-respiratory disorders, such that they cannot substantially reduce nocturnal BP variability. Instead, elimination of respiratory disorders during sleep may be expected to prevent BP peaks and to reduce variability in BP during the night. Meta-analyses have consistently shown that on average, OSA treatment reduces BP by a small amount, with somewhat larger reduction in nocturnal levels.^105–108 Effects are more evident in patients with severe OSA and with high compliance with treatment.^105,107 CPAP treatment and pharmacological therapies have additive effects on BP,^109,110 so the best strategy to treat hypertension and improve characteristics of BP variability in OSA usually includes both kinds of therapy.

A timely administration of antihypertensive drugs might reduce nocturnal BP and restore normal dipping, but few data are available on chronotherapy for altered BP in OSA. A crossover study demonstrated that when antihypertensive therapy was administered in the evening, nifedipine was more effective than carvedilol in decreasing mean and minimum nocturnal systolic BP, but only carvedilol decreased sleep BP peak.¹¹¹ A similar decrease in nocturnal BP peak was observed in a patient with evening administration of doxazosin.¹¹² A crossover study demonstrated that evening administration of valsartan, associated or not with amlodipine, was more effective than morning administration in reducing nocturnal BP and converting a nondipping into a dipping BP profile.¹¹³ Instead, no advantage was found with evening compared to morning administration of perindopril in a randomized controlled trial conducted on hypertensive OSA patients.¹¹⁰

Several studies, largely differing in design and objectives, have investigated effects of CPAP on BP variability (Table 3). One group of studies evaluated nocturnal BP by means of beat-by-beat measurements. They demonstrated that BP variability during sleep acutely decreased while CPAP was applied,^39,46,114 which is a consequence of a reduction in the number of BP peaks.¹¹⁵ Furthermore, beat-by-beat BP variability before CPAP initiation was higher than immediately after CPAP withdrawal, following an approximately 5-month treatment period,¹¹⁶ in agreement with the observation of lower postapneic BP peaks at CPAP withdrawal.⁵⁰ A second group of studies used ABPM and analyzed the change in 24-hour BP variability.^{67,70,117–123} The period of observation ranged between 1 day and 3 months, depending on the study. In all cases, some of the patients who were nondippers before CPAP initiation were found to be dippers after treatment, but the proportion of patients showing this change largely differed among studies. No effect of ≤1-week CPAP treatment on BP measurement SD during the day or night was reported.⁸⁶ Finally, a group of investigations evaluated BP variability with office or home BP measurements, and found some effect of CPAP treatment on waking systolic BP variability.^92,124 In summary, CPAP treatment acutely decreases nocturnal very short-term BP variability. A few weeks of CPAP treatment may convert a nondipping into a dipping 24-hour BP profile in some patients and cause some decrease in diurnal BP variability, but more data are necessary to explore these aspects better. CPAP treatment may also decrease BP reactivity to sleep apneas,⁵⁰ such that acute CPAP withdrawal does not immediately revert BP variability to the level observed before treatment initiation.

Table 3 Changes in BP variability associated with CPAP treatment

Methodology	Authors	Subjects, design	BP variability changes
Beat-by-beat BP measurements	Ali et al^Citation39	8 OSA with and without CPAP	In a 30-minute period during sleep, lower coefficient of variation of SBP and DBP with than without CPAP
	Sforza et al^Citation46	25 OSA with and without CPAP	During first night with CPAP, decreased coefficient of variation of SBP and DBP in all sleep stages
	Bonsignore et al^Citation116	10 normotensive OSA before OSA treatment and after treatment withdrawal	In the first night of CPAP withdrawal after a 5.5±3.7-month treatment, lower SD of SBP and DBP during stage NREM2, but not during waking, than before CPAP initiation
	Marrone et al^Citation50	13 OSA under no pharmacological therapy before OSA treatment and after treatment withdrawal	In apneic cycles during the first night of CPAP withdrawal after a 4.9±3.4-month treatment, smaller SBP and DBP surges than in apneic cycles occurring before CPAP initiation
	Bonsignore et al^Citation114	18 OSA with and without CPAP	In the first night with CPAP, decrease in SD of both SBP and DBP in stages NREM2 and REM, and decrease only in SD of DBP during nocturnal waking
	Carter et al^Citation115	17 OSA with OHS with and without CPAP	During the first night (titration) and after 6 weeks with CPAP, similar reduction in the rate of nocturnal BP surges
ABPM measurements	Pankow et al^Citation67	34 OSA with and without CPAP	After 2–4 nights with CPAP, 17 of 27 who were nondippers at baseline showed dipping
	Engleman et al^Citation117	13 OSA with placebo and CPAP (crossover RCT)	After ≥3-week treatment, nonsignificant change in prevalence of nondipping BP pattern
	Akashiba et al^Citation70	38 OSA without and with CPAP	15 of 22 nondippers at baseline showed dipping at the third day of CPAP therapy
	Bao et al^Citation86	41 OSA with placebo or CPAP (parallel RCT)	In patients receiving CPAP for either 1 or for 7 nights and in patients receiving placebo, similar decrease in SD of SBP, DBP, and MBP both during the day and during the night
	Dursunoğlu et al^Citation118	12 OSA with and without auto- CPAP	The first day with autoadjusting CPAP, reduction in SD of SBP, DBP and MBP at night, but not during the day
	Campos-Rodriguez et al^Citation119	68 hypertensive OSA with placebo or CPAP (parallel RCT)	After a 4-week treatment, proportion of patients turning BP pattern from nondipper to dipper not significantly different between placebo and CPAP
	Wang et al^Citation120	60 mild OSA and 48 moderate–severe OSA with hypertension with and without CPAP	After 3-month CPAP or surgery, 23 of 31 mild OSA and 19 of 28 moderate–severe OSA patients turned from nondippers to dippers
	Martínez-García et al^Citation121	194 OSA with resistant hypertension with and without CPAP (parallel RCT)	After 12 weeks, fewer patients treated by CPAP than controls showed nondipper or riser profiles
	Muxfeldt et al^Citation122	117 moderate–severe OSA with resistant hypertension with placebo or CPAP (parallel RCT)	After 6 months, NS difference between CPAP and placebo treatment in prevalence of nondipping and riser BP patterns
	Lemmer et al^Citation123	17 OSA with and without CPAP	5 of 14 nondippers at baseline showed dipping after 8 weeks with CPAP
Office or home BP measurements	Pengo et al^Citation124	78 OSA with and without auto- CPAP	After a 3-week autoadjusting CPAP therapy, decrease in SD of three repeated waking SBP but not DBP measurements
	Lettau et al^Citation92	175 OSA continuing or withdrawing CPAP (parallel RCT)	After a 2-week CPAP withdrawal, increased SD of three consecutive office morning SBP but not of DBP measurements; in the same period, no effect on day-to-day BP variability

Abbreviations: ABPM, ambulatory blood pressure monitoring; CPAP, continuous positive airway pressure; DBP, diastolic BP; MBP, mean BP; NREM, non-rapid eye movement; OSA, obstructive sleep apnea; RCT, randomized controlled trial; SBP, systolic BP.

Conclusion

Current knowledge suggests that BP behavior in OSA plays a role in the increased cardiovascular risk that is typical of this disorder, not only through its high diurnal and even more its nocturnal BP values but also through the characteristics of its variability. In fact, high very short-term variability, nondipping BP profile and high MBPS, which are all common in OSA, are known risk factors.

Among the characteristics of BP variability in OSA, the most peculiar is the periodic recurrence of short BP peaks. However, this is not exclusive to OSA, as nocturnal BP peaks can be observed in other conditions with periodicity, in particular in patients with periodic leg movements.¹²⁵ Sometimes, BP peaks reach very high levels. It is conceivable that a precise assessment of nocturnal BP that accurately takes into account values and duration of peaks carries prognostic significance. In fact, it has been found that maximum BP values measured over several days may be better related to several cardiovascular outcomes than mean values.¹²⁶ Today, a precise detection of hypertensive peaks is not easy in common clinical practice. Research of new monitoring systems is in progress. The new techniques appear promising,^56,57 although they still need to be better validated and probably refined.

Once BP variability is evaluated, effective strategies should be applied to improve it. BP variability may be reduced with treatment of disordered breathing events or with a pharmacological treatment directly addressing BP. As described earlier, many studies have observed a reduction in BP variability and an improvement of BP profile with CPAP treatment, but not all findings have been in agreement. It is unknown whether differing interindividual effects of CPAP on BP variability contribute to the variable efficacy of CPAP. Knowledge on pharmacological treatment of hypertension to be preferentially used in OSA is still limited,^127,128 and the few available data on chronotherapy for hypertension in OSA are inconsistent. Besides, more experience is required with regard to combined effects of treatment of OSA by CPAP, weight loss, or other treatments and antihypertensive pharmacological therapy.

Today, although OSA is believed to increase cardiovascular risk, cardiovascular benefits of OSA treatment are questioned, based on the results of randomized controlled trials.¹²⁹ Research is on the way for a personalized approach to the treatment of several diseases, including OSA.¹³⁰ Individual characteristics of BP variability could be one factor to take into consideration in the management of OSA patients and in the choice of a specific therapeutic approach to reduce the cardiovascular burden of the disease.

Disclosure

The authors report no conflicts of interest in this work.