Deviation of the Subjective Vertical in Long-standing Unilateral Vestibular Loss

Abstract

We evaluated changes in the subjectively perceived gravitational vertical as an index of imbalance in the function of the right and left otolith organs. In addition to normal subjects (n =25), we measured patients with a longstanding (mean 4.5 year ± 3.2 SD; range 0.5-11.5 years) unilateral vestibular loss after surgery for acoustic neuroma (n = 32), patients with partial unilateral vestibular loss (n = 7) and patients with bilateral vestibular hyporeflexia (n = 8). Normal subjects could accurately align a vertical luminous bar to the gravitational vertical in an otherwise completely dark room (mean setting –0.14° ± 1.11 SD). Patients with leftsided (complete; n = 13) or rightsided (complete; n = 19 and partial; n = 7) unilateral vestibular loss made mean angular settings at 2.55° ± 1.57 (SD) leftward and 2.22° (±1.96 SD) rightward, respectively. These means differed highly significantly from the normal mean (p < 0.00001). In the time interval investigated (0.5-11.5 years) the magnitude of the tilt angle showed no correlation with the time elapsed since the operation. The mean setting by patients with clinically bilateral vestibular loss (– 1.17° ± 1.96 SD; n = 8) did not significantly differ from the control group. The systematic tilts of the subjective vertical in patients with a unilateral vestibular impairment were correlated with their imbalance in canal-ocular reflexes, as reflected by drift during head-oscillation at 2 Hz (r² = 0.44) and asymmetries in VOR-gain for head-steps (r² = 0.48-0.67). These correlations were largely determined by the signs of the asymmetries; correlation between the absolute values of the VOR gain asymmetries and subjective vertical angles proved to be virtually absent. We conclude that the setting of the subjective vertical is a very sensitive tool in detecting a left-right imbalance in otolith function, and that small but significant deviations towards the defective side may persist for many years (probably permanently) after unilateral lesions of the labyrinth or the vestibular nerve.

Key Words:

• unilateral and bilateral vestibular loss
• human
• acoustic neuroma
• ocular torsion
• otolith
• utricle