An effect of linguistic experience :Auditory Word Discrimination by Native and Non-Native Speakers of English

Abstract

In this study, the effect of linguistic experience on the auditory discrimination of words has been examined. 18 subjects, including 6 native and 12 non-native speakers of English, were tested with CID auditory test W-22 in quiet and in the presence of white noise at the signal-to-noise (S/N) ratios of + 12, + 6 and 0 dB. The non-native speakers of English included 6 with 1 year of experience and 6 with 3–4 years of experience speaking English in the USA.

In the absence of noise, the results were essentially equivalent for all three groups. As noise level increased, word discrimination deteriorated for all three groups with non-native speakers of English obtaining results significantly poorer than native speakers of English. Linguistic experience and noise levels were significant at the 0.001 level of confidence. It appears that at 0 dB S/N, individual variability of non-native speakers of English, regardless of their original linguistic background, was much smaller than that found for native speakers of English.

The results of the study tend to indicate that a limited linguistic experience results in a persistent deterioration of auditory word discrimination under impoverished conditions of audition.

Key Words:

• Linguistic experience
• Auditory word discrimination
• Speech-to-noise ratio
• Word familiarity
• Frequency of word usage