Fragmentation reactions of aromatic cation radicals: a tool for the detection of electron transfer mechanisms in biomimetic and enzymatic oxidations

Abstract

1. Mechanistic criteria, based on the side-chain fragmentation reactions of aromatic cation radicals, involving the cleavage of a β bond (i.e. C-H, C-Si and C-S) have been developed for the detection of electron transfer mechanisms in oxidative processes of alkylbenzenes and aromatic sulphides.

2. For benzylic oxidations, the distinction between electron transfer (ET) and hydrogen atom transfer mechanism (HAT) has been based: (a) on studies of intramolecular selectivity, which, with appropriate substrates (5-Z-1,2,3,-trimethylbenzenes and 4-Z-1,2-dimethylbenzenes, where Z = OMe, alkyl), turns out to be much higher in ET than in HAT processes; and (b) on products studies concerning the reactions of bicumyl and benzyltrimethylsilanes since in these systems, the nature of products can be significantly different for ET and HAT mechanisms.

3. These criteria have been applied to the reactions of alkylbenzenes with an NO₃ radical (shown to be an ET process) as well as to the microsomal and biomimetic (by iron porphyrins in the presence of PhIO) side-chain oxidation of the same compounds, where the mechanistic probes have suggested a HAT mechanism, with the exception of the biomimetic oxidation of 4-methoxybenzyltrimethylsilane in CH₂Cl₂-H₂O-MeOH, which probably occurs by an ET mechanism.

4. For the enzymatic and biomimetic oxidation of aromatic sulphides an oxygen transfer is suggested, since, with cumyl phenyl sulphide and 4-methoxybenzyl phenyl sulphide, these reactions lead exclusively to the corresponding sulphoxides and sulphones, whereas the same substrates, in genuine ET reactions, form cation radicals which undergo C-H and C-S bond cleavage.

5. An oxygen transfer mechanism is also likely in the biomimetic and enzymatic oxidations of sulphoxides since in these reactions 4-methoxybenzyl phenyl sulphoxide is exclusively converted to sulphone, whereas in ET reactions it forms only C-S bond cleavage products