Clinical-Based vs Insurance-Based Recommendations for Substance Abuse Treatment Level

Abstract

An exploratory study of 250 patients was conducted at three treatment facilities in Western Pennsylvania, USA, to determine: 1) the extent of disagreement between clinical-based [using American Society of Addiction Medicine (ASAM) criteria] and insurance-based [using Managed Care Organization (MCO) criteria] recommendations for treatment levels, and 2) the extent of ASAM recommendations that become the actual treatment. Cross-tabulations showed: 1) ASAM and MCO recommendations were the same for 85% of the cases, and 2) ASAM recommendations became the actual treatment in 93% of the cases. The exceptionally high level of ASAM-MCO agreement suggests a convergence in ASAM and MCO criteria and a deference to ASAM criteria in practice.

Key Words:

• Substance abuse treatment
• Managed care
• “Levels of care”
• Outpatient treatment