Health services research in heart failure patients treated with a remote monitoring device in Germany—a retrospective database analysis in evaluating resource use

Abstract

Objectives:

Heart failure is an increasing burden for all healthcare systems with prevalence reaching over 20 million patients worldwide and direct costs of disease requiring ∼1% of healthcare budget expenditures. Beyond traditional pharmaceutical treatment, medical devices and remote monitoring tools were introduced to ensure a closely managed control of patients. In this context, a decision-maker needs to know whether the new technology provides clinical benefit towards patients and what resource use is attached to them.

Methods:

Health services research is a complementary approach to clinical trials providing results to the impact of the technology in real life settings. As an example this study reports of a secondary data analysis of one of the largest health insurance companies in Germany, comparing resource use of heart failure patients receiving a cardiac resynchronization therapy (CRT) device coupled with a fluid status monitoring and alert function with patients receiving conventional CRT, ICD (implantable cardioverter defibrillator), or no intervention.

Results:

Disease-associated expenses can be attributed to far more than 50% to heart failure. Although implementation of the CRT device with alert function was most expensive (31,794 Euros compared to 27,659 Euros in the conventional CRT group, 24,128 Euros in the ICD group, and 3735 Euros in the no intervention group) in the first year after implementation, the least costs have been caused in this group (7000 Euros compared to more than 11,000 Euros in all other groups).

Conclusion:

This article highlights potential health services research approaches focusing on the example of a CRT device coupled with a pulmonary diagnostic and alert function. Although this retrospective analysis holds a number of limitations (e.g., small number of patients in intervention group, cost calculations only from the payer perspective), and despite the need for randomized controlled trials, it was shown that secondary data research in this field is a valuable approach.

Keywords::

• Heart failure
• Remote monitoring
• Health services research
• Data analysis.

Transparency

Declaration of funding

This publication was supported by an unconditional grant from Medtronic GmbH.

Declaration of financial/other relationships

The authors have disclosed that they received a grant from Medtronic to conduct this study. They have no other relevant relationships to disclose.

Acknowledgements

The exploratory secondary research study was commissioned by Medtronic Deutschland GmbH and executed by the Institut für Sozialmedizin, Epidemiologie und Gesundheitssystemforschung e.V. (ISEG). Publication rights are held by Medtronic Deutschland GmbH.