The Association Between Exposure to the Oil and Gas Industry and Beef Calf Mortality in Western Canada

Abstract

Researchers assessed the association between exposure to emissions from oil and gas field facilities and newborn calf survival and health status by determining the risks of calf mortality and treatment reported for 27,511 beef calves born to cows in 203 herds, which were followed from the beginning of the 2001 breeding season through the 2002 calving season. They prospectively measured exposures to sulfur dioxide, hydrogen sulfide, and volatile organic compounds (VOCs) by using data from passive air monitors. They also used the density of oil and gas well sites surrounding each pasture as an additional measure of exposure. The researchers found that well-site density as well as exposures to hydrogen sulfide and VOCs measured as benzene or toluene were not associated with the odds of calf mortality in the first 3 months of life. After adjusting for cow-and herd-level risk factors, they found that exposure to sulfur dioxide near the time of calving was associated with an increased risk of calf mortality during this period. Exposure to sulfur dioxide in the 3-month period before calving was most suggestive of a causal exposure-response relationship (the odds ratio for every 1 ppb increase in sulfur dioxide = 1.32; 95% confidence interval = 1.13-1.54; p =.0004). Exposure to sulfur dioxide, hydrogen sulfide, and VOCs measured as benzene or toluene during gestation was not associated with the odds of calf treatment in the first 3 months of life. However, exposure to sulfur dioxide, hydrogen sulfide, and VOCs measured as benzene or toluene, and sulfur dioxide in the first month after calving, was associated with a small increase in the odds of calf treatment after the first month of life when risk was compared across quartiles for exposure; only the association between hydrogen sulfide exposure and the odds of treatment was consistent with a causal exposure.

Keywords:

• beef cows
• benzene
• calf mortality
• calf treatment
• cattle
• hydrogen sulfide
• sulfur dioxide
• toluene
• volatile organic compound