Advanced search
Publication Cover
Combustion Science and Technology Volume 180, 2007 - Issue 1
Submit an article Journal homepage
899
Views
89
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Effect of Syngas Composition and CO2-Diluted Oxygen on Performance of a Premixed Swirl-Stabilized Combustor

Timothy C. Williams Combustion Research Facility, Sandia National Laboratories, Livermore, California
,
Christopher R. Shaddix* Combustion Research Facility, Sandia National Laboratories, Livermore, CaliforniaCorrespondence[email protected]
&
Robert W. Schefer Combustion Research Facility, Sandia National Laboratories, Livermore, California
Pages 64-88 | Received 21 Sep 2006, Accepted 24 May 2007, Published online: 14 Dec 2007

Citations (89)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (3)

Z. Y. Sun. (2020) Laminar Explosion Properties of Syngas. Combustion Science and Technology 192:1, pages 166-181.
Read now
Okjoo Park & Elizabeth M. Fisher. (2016) Effect of Oxycombustion Diluents on the Extinction of Nonpremixed Methane Opposed-Jet Flames. Combustion Science and Technology 188:3, pages 370-388.
Read now
Hanyu Chen, Chengji Zuo, Haichun Ding, Zuofeng Wang & Duidui Wang. (2013) Numerical simulation on combustion processes of a diesel engine under O2/CO2 atmosphere. HKIE Transactions 20:3, pages 157-163.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (86)

Ahmed Abdelhafez. (2024) Stability and Emission Characteristics of a Stratified Hydrogen-Enriched Oxy-Methane Flame on a Multihole Burner: An Experimental Study. ACS Omega.
Crossref
Xinran Wang, Shiquan Shan, Zhihua Wang, Zhijun Zhou & Kefa Cen. (2024) Review on thermal-science fundamental research of pressurized oxy-fuel combustion technology. Frontiers in Energy.
Crossref
A. Abdulnaim, A. Elkholy, M. Elmously, H. Moneib, W. L. Roberts & A. M. Elbaz. (2023) On the Stability and Characteristics of Biogas/Methane/Air Flames Fired by a Double Swirl Burner. Flow, Turbulence and Combustion 112:3, pages 751-767.
Crossref
Ji Hun Jeong, Ho Seong Park, Young Kwang Park & Tong Seop Kim. (2024) Analysis of the influence of hydrogen co-firing on the operation and performance of the gas turbine and combined cycle. Case Studies in Thermal Engineering 54, pages 104061.
Crossref
Alessandro Porcarelli, Boris Kruljević & Ivan Langella. (2024) Suppression of NOx emissions by intensive strain in lean premixed hydrogen flamelets. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 49, pages 413-431.
Crossref
M. Froissart & T. Ochrymiuk. (2023) Novel wet combustion chamber concept CFD studies with triple water inlet. Energy 278, pages 127854.
Crossref
F. Pignatelli, S. Derafshzan, D. Sanned, N. Papafilippou, R.Z. Szasz, M.A. Chishty, P. Petersson, X.-S. Bai, R. Gebart, A. Ehn, M. Richter, D. Lörstad & A.A. Subash. (2023) Effect of CO dilution on structures of premixed syngas/air flames in a gas turbine model combustor . Combustion and Flame 255, pages 112912.
Crossref
Medhat A. Nemitallah, Abdulhammed K. Hamzat & Kehinde G. Ismaila. (2023) Role of Oxidizer Mixture Composition on Stabilizing Stratified Oxy-Flames in Dual Lean Premixed Combustors for Gas Turbines. Journal of Energy Resources Technology 145:3.
Crossref
Medhat A. Nemitallah, Mohamed S. Elzayed, Abdulrahim Alshadidi, Mohanad Abualkhair, Ahmed Abdelhafez, F. M. Alzahrani & Abdul Gani Abdul Jameel. (2023) Stratified Flames in Dual Annular Counter-Rotating Swirl Burner for Wider Operability Gas Turbines. Journal of Energy Resources Technology 145:1.
Crossref
S. Kwak, J. Choi, M. Ahn, M. C. Lee & Y. Yoon. (2022) Effects of flame-flame interaction on emission characteristics in gas turbine combustors. The Aeronautical Journal 126:1302, pages 1414-1429.
Crossref
Shang-Ru Yao & Hsin-Yi Shih. (2022) Dilution effects analysis on NOx emissions of opposed-jet H2/CO syngas diffusion flames. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 47:35, pages 15896-15908.
Crossref
Arunaporn Boonchuay & Patcharin Worathanakul. (2022) The Diffusion Behavior of CO2 Adsorption from a CO2/N2 Gas Mixture on Zeolite 5A in a Fixed-Bed Column. Atmosphere 13:4, pages 513.
Crossref
Medhat A. Nemitallah, MD Azazul Haque, Muzafar Hussain, Ahmed Abdelhafez & Mohamed A. Habib. (2022) Stratified and Hydrogen Combustion Techniques for Higher Turndown and Lower Emissions in Gas Turbines. Journal of Energy Resources Technology 144:2.
Crossref
Ayman M. Elbaz, Ossama Mannaa & William L. Roberts. (2021) Flame flow field interaction in non-premixed CH4/H2 swirling flames. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 46:59, pages 30494-30509.
Crossref
Paola Costamagna. (2021) Three-pipeline gas grid: A new concept for power-to-gas associated with complete carbon capture and utilization. Energy Conversion and Management 229, pages 113739.
Crossref
Binash Imteyaz, Mohamed Habib, Medhat Nemitallah, Ahmed Abdelhafez & Rached Ben‐Mansour. (2020) Operability of a premixed combustor holding hydrogen‐enriched oxy‐methane flames: An experimental and numerical study. International Journal of Energy Research 45:2, pages 3049-3063.
Crossref
Muzafar Hussain, Ahmed Abdelhafez, Medhat A. Nemitallah, Abdulrazaq A. Araoye, Rached Ben-Mansour & Mohamed A. Habib. (2020) A highly diluted oxy-fuel micromixer combustor with hydrogen enrichment for enhancing turndown in gas turbines. Applied Energy 279, pages 115818.
Crossref
Asif Ali, Medhat A. Nemitallah, Ahmed Abdelhafez, Binash Imteyaz, M. Mustafa Kamal & Mohamed A. Habib. (2020) Numerical and experimental study of swirl premixed CH4/H2/O2/CO2 flames for controlled-emissions gas turbines. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 45:53, pages 29616-29629.
Crossref
Md. Azazul Haque, Medhat A. Nemitallah, Ahmed Abdelhafez, Ibrahim B. Mansir & Mohamed A. Habib. (2020) Review of Fuel/Oxidizer-Flexible Combustion in Gas Turbines. Energy & Fuels 34:9, pages 10459-10485.
Crossref
Kedar G. Bhide & S. Sreedhara. (2020) A DNS study on turbulence-chemistry interaction in lean premixed syngas flames. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 45:43, pages 23615-23623.
Crossref
Harun Yilmaz, Omer Cam & Ilker Yilmaz. (2020) A comparison study on combustion and emission characteristics of actual synthetic gas mixtures. Fuel 263, pages 116712.
Crossref
Harun Yilmaz, Omer Cam & Ilker Yilmaz. (2020) Experimental investigation of flame instability in a premixed combustor. Fuel 262, pages 116594.
Crossref
Medhat A. Nemitallah, Ahmed A. Abdelhafez & Mohamed A. HabibMedhat A. Nemitallah, Ahmed A. Abdelhafez & Mohamed A. Habib. 2020. Approaches for Clean Combustion in Gas Turbines. Approaches for Clean Combustion in Gas Turbines 165 257 .
Medhat A. Nemitallah, Ahmed A. Abdelhafez & Mohamed A. HabibMedhat A. Nemitallah, Ahmed A. Abdelhafez & Mohamed A. Habib. 2020. Approaches for Clean Combustion in Gas Turbines. Approaches for Clean Combustion in Gas Turbines 99 164 .
Medhat A. Nemitallah, Ahmed A. Abdelhafez & Mohamed A. HabibMedhat A. Nemitallah, Ahmed A. Abdelhafez & Mohamed A. Habib. 2020. Approaches for Clean Combustion in Gas Turbines. Approaches for Clean Combustion in Gas Turbines 13 97 .
SUAT ÖZTÜRK. (2019) The Effects of CO2, N2, and H2O Dilutions on NO Formation of Partially Premixed Synthesis Gas Combustion. Cumhuriyet Science Journal 40:4, pages 813-818.
Crossref
Serhat Karyeyen, Joseph S. Feser & Ashwani K. Gupta. (2019) Hydrogen concentration effects on swirl-stabilized oxy-colorless distributed combustion. Fuel 253, pages 772-780.
Crossref
Nor Afzanizam Samiran, Cheng Tung Chong, Jo-Han Ng, Manh-Vu Tran, Hwai Chyuan Ong, Agustin Valera-Medina, William Woei Fong Chong & Mohammad Nazri Mohd Jaafar. (2019) Experimental and numerical studies on the premixed syngas swirl flames in a model combustor. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 44:44, pages 24126-24139.
Crossref
Medhat A. Nemitallah, Binash Imteyaz, Ahmed Abdelhafez & Mohamed A. Habib. (2019) Experimental and computational study on stability characteristics of hydrogen-enriched oxy-methane premixed flames. Applied Energy 250, pages 433-443.
Crossref
Serhat Karyeyen, Joseph Feser & Ashwani K. Gupta. (2019) Effect of Fuel Dilution in a Hydrogen-Methane Blended Fuel Under Oxy-Distributed Combustion. Effect of Fuel Dilution in a Hydrogen-Methane Blended Fuel Under Oxy-Distributed Combustion.
Harun Yilmaz & Ilker Yilmaz. (2019) Effects of synthetic gas constituents on combustion and emission behavior of premixed H2/CO/CO2/CNG mixture flames. Journal of the Energy Institute 92:4, pages 1091-1106.
Crossref
Medhat A. Nemitallah, Ahmed A. Abdelhafez, Asif Ali, Ibrahim Mansir & Mohamed A. Habib. (2019) Frontiers in combustion techniques and burner designs for emissions control and CO 2 capture: A review . International Journal of Energy Research.
Crossref
Amir Mardani & Hamed Karimi Motaalegh Mahalegi. (2019) Hydrogen enrichment of methane and syngas for MILD combustion. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 44:18, pages 9423-9437.
Crossref
Stavros Michailos, David Parker & Colin Webb. (2017) Design, Sustainability Analysis and Multiobjective Optimisation of Ethanol Production via Syngas Fermentation. Waste and Biomass Valorization 10:4, pages 865-876.
Crossref
Xiao Sen Hou, Xin Zhang & Zhun Qing Hu. (2019) Experimental and numerical study on engine fueled with different fractions of natural gas–carbon dioxide-hydrogen blends. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 44:11, pages 5599-5606.
Crossref
Ahmed F. Ghoniem, Zhenlong Zhao & Georgios Dimitrakopoulos. (2019) Gas oxy combustion and conversion technologies for low carbon energy: Fundamentals, modeling and reactors. Proceedings of the Combustion Institute 37:1, pages 33-56.
Crossref
Juan-Rodrigo Bastidas-Oyanedel, Fabian Bonk, Mette Hedegaard Thomsen & Jens Ejbye Schmidt. 2019. Biorefinery. Biorefinery 375 412 .
Medhat A. Nemitallah, Mohamed A. Habib & Hassan M. BadrMedhat A. Nemitallah, Mohamed A. Habib & Hassan M. Badr. 2019. Oxyfuel Combustion for Clean Energy Applications. Oxyfuel Combustion for Clean Energy Applications 43 89 .
Medhat A. Nemitallah, Mohamed A. Habib & Hassan M. BadrMedhat A. Nemitallah, Mohamed A. Habib & Hassan M. Badr. 2019. Oxyfuel Combustion for Clean Energy Applications. Oxyfuel Combustion for Clean Energy Applications 1 41 .
Shaoshuai Li, Suhui Li, Daniel Mira, Min Zhu & Xi Jiang. (2018) Investigation of dilution effects on partially premixed swirling syngas flames using a LES-LEM approach. Journal of the Energy Institute 91:6, pages 902-915.
Crossref
Suliman Abdelwahid, Medhat Nemitallah, Binash Imteyaz, Ahmed Abdelhafez & Mohamed Habib. (2018) Effects of H 2 Enrichment and Inlet Velocity on Stability Limits and Shape of CH 4 /H 2 –O 2 /CO 2 Flames in a Premixed Swirl Combustor . Energy & Fuels 32:9, pages 9916-9925.
Crossref
Hadi Nazem-Bokaee & Costas D. Maranas. (2018) A Prospective Study on the Fermentation Landscape of Gaseous Substrates to Biorenewables Using Methanosarcina acetivorans Metabolic Model. Frontiers in Microbiology 9.
Crossref
Ahmed Abdelhafez, Medhat A. Nemitallah, Sherif S. Rashwan & Mohamed A. Habib. (2018) Adiabatic Flame Temperature for Controlling the Macrostructures and Stabilization Modes of Premixed Methane Flames in a Model Gas-Turbine Combustor. Energy & Fuels 32:7, pages 7868-7877.
Crossref
Serhat Karyeyen & Mustafa Ilbas. (2018) Experimental and numerical analysis of turbulent premixed combustion of low calorific value coal gases in a generated premixed burner. Fuel 220, pages 586-598.
Crossref
Ilker Yilmaz, Harun Yilmaz & Omer Cam. (2018) An experimental study on premixed CNG/H2/CO2 mixture flames. Open Engineering 8:1, pages 32-40.
Crossref
A. Valera-Medina, M.O. Vigueras-Zuniga, H. Baej, N. Syred, C.T. Chong & P.J. Bowen. (2017) Outlet geometrical impacts on blowoff effects when using various syngas mixtures in swirling flows. Applied Energy 207, pages 195-207.
Crossref
Nor Afzanizam Samiran, Jo-Han Ng, Mohammad Nazri Mohd Jaafar, Agustin Valera-Medina & Cheng Tung Chong. (2017) Swirl stability and emission characteristics of CO-enriched syngas/air flame in a premixed swirl burner. Process Safety and Environmental Protection 112, pages 315-326.
Crossref
Medhat A. Nemitallah, Mohamed A. Habib, Hassan M. Badr, Syed A. Said, Aqil Jamal, Rached Ben-Mansour, Esmail M. A. Mokheimer & K. Mezghani. (2017) Oxy-fuel combustion technology: current status, applications, and trends. International Journal of Energy Research 41:12, pages 1670-1708.
Crossref
Suresh Aggarwal. (2017) Effects of Stretch and Preferential Diffusion in Laminar Syngas Premixed Flames. Journal of Energy Engineering 143:5.
Crossref
Ahmed E.E. Khalil & Ashwani K. Gupta. (2017) Flame fluctuations in Oxy-CO2-methane mixtures in swirl assisted distributed combustion. Applied Energy 204, pages 303-317.
Crossref
Raghu Veera Manikantachari Kancherla, Scott M. Martin, Jose O. Bobren & Subith Vasu. (2017) The Influence of Elevated Pressures on the Methane Combustion in N2 and Co2 Dilutions. The Influence of Elevated Pressures on the Methane Combustion in N2 and Co2 Dilutions.
Ahmed E. Khalil Hasan & Ashwani K. Gupta. (2017) Acoustic and Heat Release Signatures for Oxy-fuel Swirl Assisted Distributed Combustion. Acoustic and Heat Release Signatures for Oxy-fuel Swirl Assisted Distributed Combustion.
Patrícia A.P. Mendes, Ana M. Ribeiro, Kristin Gleichmann, Alexandre F.P. Ferreira & Alírio E. Rodrigues. (2017) Separation of CO 2 /N 2 on binderless 5A zeolite. Journal of CO2 Utilization 20, pages 224-233.
Crossref
Ahmed E.E. Khalil & Ashwani K. Gupta. (2017) Acoustic and heat release signatures for swirl assisted distributed combustion. Applied Energy 193, pages 125-138.
Crossref
Mohamed A. Habib, Sherif S. Rashwan, Medhat A. Nemitallah & Ahmed Abdelhafez. (2017) Stability maps of non-premixed methane flames in different oxidizing environments of a gas turbine model combustor. Applied Energy 189, pages 177-186.
Crossref
Ahmed E.E. Khalil & Ashwani K. Gupta. (2017) The role of CO2 on oxy-colorless distributed combustion. Applied Energy 188, pages 466-474.
Crossref
Sherif S. Rashwan, Medhat A. Nemitallah & Mohamed A. Habib. (2016) Review on Premixed Combustion Technology: Stability, Emission Control, Applications, and Numerical Case Study. Energy & Fuels 30:12, pages 9981-10014.
Crossref
Nor Afzanizam Samiran, Jo-Han Ng, Mohammad Nazri Mohd Jaafar, Agustin Valera-Medina & Cheng Tung Chong. (2016) H2-rich syngas strategy to reduce NOx and CO emissions and improve stability limits under premixed swirl combustion mode. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 41:42, pages 19243-19255.
Crossref
Tamer Panagiotis DossChristos KeramiotisGeorge VourliotakisGeorge ZannisGeorge SkevisMaria A. Founti. (2016) Experimental Investigation on the Influence of Simulated EGR Addition on Swirl-Stabilized CH4 Flames. Journal of Energy Engineering 142:2.
Crossref
Suhui Li, Xiaoyu Zhang, Di Zhong, Fanglong Weng, Shaoshuai Li & Min Zhu. (2016) Effects of inert dilution on the lean blowout characteristics of syngas flames. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 41:21, pages 9075-9086.
Crossref
Zhihua Wang, Yajun Zhou, Ronald Whiddon, Yong He, Kefa Cen & Zhongshan Li. (2016) Investigation of NO formation in premixed adiabatic laminar flames of H2/CO syngas and air by saturated laser-induced fluorescence and kinetic modeling. Combustion and Flame 164, pages 283-293.
Crossref
F. Hampp & R. P. Lindstedt. 2016. Fractal Flow Design: How to Design Bespoke Turbulence and Why. Fractal Flow Design: How to Design Bespoke Turbulence and Why 75 102 .
Dominik Bongartz, Santosh J. Shanbhogue & Ahmed F. Ghoniem. (2015) Formation and Control of Sulfur Oxides in Sour Gas Oxy-Combustion: Prediction Using a Reactor Network Model. Energy & Fuels 29:11, pages 7670-7680.
Crossref
Rohan Stanger, Terry Wall, Reinhold Spörl, Manoj Paneru, Simon Grathwohl, Max Weidmann, Günter Scheffknecht, Denny McDonald, Kari Myöhänen, Jouni Ritvanen, Sirpa Rahiala, Timo Hyppänen, Jan Mletzko, Alfons Kather & Stanley Santos. (2015) Oxyfuel combustion for CO2 capture in power plants. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control 40, pages 55-125.
Crossref
S. Taamallah, K. Vogiatzaki, F.M. Alzahrani, E.M.A. Mokheimer, M.A. Habib & A.F. Ghoniem. (2015) Fuel flexibility, stability and emissions in premixed hydrogen-rich gas turbine combustion: Technology, fundamentals, and numerical simulations. Applied Energy 154, pages 1020-1047.
Crossref
Juan-Rodrigo Bastidas-Oyanedel, Fabian Bonk, Mette Hedegaard Thomsen & Jens Ejbye Schmidt. (2015) Dark fermentation biorefinery in the present and future (bio)chemical industry. Reviews in Environmental Science and Bio/Technology 14:3, pages 473-498.
Crossref
Mohamed A. Habib, Medhat A. Nemitallah, Pervez Ahmed, Mostafa H. Sharqawy, Hassan M. Badr, Inam Muhammad & Mohamed Yaqub. (2015) Experimental analysis of oxygen-methane combustion inside a gas turbine reactor under various operating conditions. Energy 86, pages 105-114.
Crossref
Dominik Bongartz & Ahmed F. Ghoniem. (2015) Chemical kinetics mechanism for oxy-fuel combustion of mixtures of hydrogen sulfide and methane. Combustion and Flame 162:3, pages 544-553.
Crossref
Irvin Glassman, Richard A. Yetter & Nick G. Glumac. 2015. Combustion. Combustion 477 536 .
Sang Kyu Choi, Eun-Seong Cho & Suk Ho Chung. (2014) Quantification of extinction mechanism in counterflow premixed flames. Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology 28:9, pages 3863-3871.
Crossref
A. A. A. Abuelnuor, M. A. Wahid, H. A. Mohammed & A. Saat. (2014) Flameless combustion role in the mitigation of NO X emission: a review . International Journal of Energy Research 38:7, pages 827-846.
Crossref
. 2014. Combustion of Pulverised Coal in a Mixture of Oxygen and Recycled Flue Gas. Combustion of Pulverised Coal in a Mixture of Oxygen and Recycled Flue Gas 159 170 .
Medhat A. Nemitallah & Mohamed A. Habib. (2013) Experimental and numerical investigations of an atmospheric diffusion oxy-combustion flame in a gas turbine model combustor. Applied Energy 111, pages 401-415.
Crossref
Alberto Amato, Jerry M. Seitzman & Timothy C. Lieuwen. 2013. Gas Turbine Emissions. Gas Turbine Emissions 209 234 .
Jeongjae Hwang, Nicolas Bouvet, Kitae Sohn & Youngbin Yoon. (2013) Stability characteristics of non-premixed turbulent jet flames of hydrogen and syngas blends with coaxial air. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 38:12, pages 5139-5149.
Crossref
Mohamed A. Habib, Medhat Nemitallah & Rached Ben-Mansour. (2012) Recent Development in Oxy-Combustion Technology and Its Applications to Gas Turbine Combustors and ITM Reactors. Energy & Fuels 27:1, pages 2-19.
Crossref
Lei Chen, Sze Zheng Yong & Ahmed F. Ghoniem. (2012) Oxy-fuel combustion of pulverized coal: Characterization, fundamentals, stabilization and CFD modeling. Progress in Energy and Combustion Science 38:2, pages 156-214.
Crossref
Bhavin KapadiaPeter KutneJames GounderWolfgang Meier. (2011) Combustion behaviour of swirl stabilised oxyfuel flames at elevated pressure. Combustion behaviour of swirl stabilised oxyfuel flames at elevated pressure.
Yinhe Liu, Manfred Geier, Alejandro Molina & Christopher R. Shaddix. (2011) Pulverized coal stream ignition delay under conventional and oxy-fuel combustion conditions. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control 5, pages S36-S46.
Crossref
A. Amato, B. Hudak, P. D’Carlo, D. Noble, D. Scarborough, J. Seitzman & T. Lieuwen. (2011) Methane Oxycombustion for Low CO2 Cycles: Blowoff Measurements and Analysis. Journal of Engineering for Gas Turbines and Power 133:6.
Crossref
Hannes Stadler, Dominik Christ, Martin Habermehl, Peter Heil, Arno Kellermann, Andreas Ohliger, Dobrin Toporov & Reinhold Kneer. (2011) Experimental investigation of NO emissions in oxycoal combustion. Fuel 90:4, pages 1604-1611.
Crossref
Hugo J. Burbano, Jhon Pareja & Andrés A. Amell. (2011) Laminar burning velocities and flame stability analysis of H2/CO/air mixtures with dilution of N2 and CO2. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 36:4, pages 3232-3242.
Crossref
A. Amato, B. Hudak, P. D’Souza, P. D’Carlo, D. Noble, D. Scarborough, J. Seitzman & T. Lieuwen. (2011) Measurements and analysis of CO and O2 emissions in CH4/CO2/O2 flames. Proceedings of the Combustion Institute 33:2, pages 3399-3405.
Crossref
Peter Kutne, Bhavin K. Kapadia, Wolfgang Meier & Manfred Aigner. (2011) Experimental analysis of the combustion behaviour of oxyfuel flames in a gas turbine model combustor. Proceedings of the Combustion Institute 33:2, pages 3383-3390.
Crossref
Maja B. Toftegaard, Jacob Brix, Peter A. Jensen, Peter Glarborg & Anker D. Jensen. (2010) Oxy-fuel combustion of solid fuels. Progress in Energy and Combustion Science 36:5, pages 581-625.
Crossref
Irvin Glassman & Richard A. Yetter. 2008. Combustion. Combustion 495 550 .

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.