Advanced search
Publication Cover
Journal of Motor Behavior Volume 19, 1987 - Issue 2
Submit an article Journal homepage
70
Views
108
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Research Articles

Mechanical Efficiency and Metabolic Cost as Measures of Learning a Novel Gross Motor Task

W. A. SparrowInstitute of Special Education and Paramedical StudiesVictoria College, Burwood
&
V. M. Irizarry-LopezDepartment of Industrial EngineeringUniversity of Purdue
Pages 240-264 | Received 05 Nov 1985, Published online: 13 Aug 2013

Citations (108)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (13)

Gareth Irwin, Genevieve K. R. Williams, David G. Kerwin, Hans von Lieres und Wilkau & Karl M. Newell. (2021) Learning the High Bar Longswing:I. Task Dynamics and Emergence of the Coordination Pattern. Journal of Sports Sciences 39:23, pages 2683-2697.
Read now
Genevieve Kate Roscoe Williams, Gareth Irwin, David George Kerwin & Karl Maxim Newell. (2015) Biomechanical energetic analysis of technique during learning the longswing on the high bar. Journal of Sports Sciences 33:13, pages 1376-1387.
Read now
Albert Busquets, Michel Marina, Alfredo Irurtia, Daniel Ranz & RosaM. Angulo-Barroso. (2011) High Bar Swing Performance in Novice Adults. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport 82:1, pages 9-20.
Read now
John Paul Lenton, Lucas H. V. Van Der Woude, Neil E. Fowler & Victoria Goosey-Tolfrey. (2010) Effects of 4-weeks of asynchronous hand-rim wheelchair practice on mechanical efficiency and timing. Disability and Rehabilitation 32:26, pages 2155-2164.
Read now
S. Bar-Haim, N. Harries, M. Belokopytov, E. Lahat & J. Kaplanski. (2008) Random perturbation: A potential aid in treatment of children with cerebral palsy. Disability and Rehabilitation 30:19, pages 1420-1428.
Read now
W.A. Sparrow, B.S. Lay & N.J. O'Dwyer. (2007) Metabolic and Attentional Energy Costs of Interlimb Coordination. Journal of Motor Behavior 39:4, pages 259-275.
Read now
Brook Galna & WilliamA. Sparrow. (2006) Learning to Minimize Energy Costs and Maximize Mechanical Work in a Bimanual Coordination Task. Journal of Motor Behavior 38:6, pages 411-422.
Read now
Koji Kadota, Tomoyuki Matsuo, Ken Hashizume & Kazushi Tezuka. (2006) Mechanical Power Flow Changes During Multijoint Movement Acquisition. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport 77:3, pages 285-295.
Read now
Deborah Nourrit, Thibault Deschamps, Brice Lauriot, Nicolas Caillou & Didier Delignieres. (2000) The effects of required amplitude and practice on frequency stability and efficiency in a cyclical task. Journal of Sports Sciences 18:3, pages 201-212.
Read now
DavidL. Anderson & Ben Sidaway. (1994) Coordination Changes Associated with Practice of a Soccer Kick. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport 65:2, pages 93-99.
Read now
Beatrix Vereijken, Richard E. A. van Emmerik, H.T. A. Whiting & KarlM. Newell. (1992) Free(z)ing Degrees of Freedom in Skill Acquisition. Journal of Motor Behavior 24:1, pages 133-142.
Read now
StephanP. Swinnen, MarkB. Beirinckx, PaulF. Meugens & CharlesB. Walter. (1991) Dissociating the Structural and Metrical Specifications of Bimanual Movement. Journal of Motor Behavior 23:4, pages 263-279.
Read now
P. V. McDonald, R. E. A. van Emmerik & K. M. Newell. (1989) The Effects of Practice on Limb Kinematics in a Throwing Task. Journal of Motor Behavior 21:3, pages 245-264.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (95)

Lise Storli, Ellen Beate Hansen Sandseter & Håvard Lorås. (2024) Individual differences in children's movement variability in a virtual reality playground task. Human Movement Science 93, pages 103171.
Crossref
Laura M. Oudenhoven, Marjolein M. Van Der Krogt, Sanne Ettema, Karin Roeleveld, Merel A. Brehm & Annemieke I. Buizer. (2023) Fatigue‐related gait adaptations in children with cerebral palsy. Developmental Medicine & Child Neurology 65:12, pages 1629-1638.
Crossref
Rick de Klerk, Gabriëlle van der Jagt, Dirkjan Veeger, Lucas van der Woude & Riemer Vegter. (2022) Learning of Wheelchair Racing Propulsion Skills Over Three Weeks of Wheeling Practice on an Instrumented Ergometer in Able-Bodied Novices. Frontiers in Rehabilitation Sciences 3.
Crossref
Yan Yufik & Raj Malhotra. (2021) Situational Understanding in the Human and the Machine. Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience 15.
Crossref
Yan M. Yufik. 2021. Connectivity and Functional Specialization in the Brain. Connectivity and Functional Specialization in the Brain.
Yan M. Yufik. (2021) Laws of nature in action, perception and thinking. Physics of Life Reviews 36, pages 9-11.
Crossref
Anderson Nascimento Guimarães, Herbert Ugrinowitsch, Juliana Bayeux Dascal & Victor Hugo Alves Okazaki. (2020) Controlling Degrees of Freedom in Learning a Taekwondo Kick. Motor Control 24:4, pages 512-526.
Crossref
Anderson Nascimento Guimarães, Herbert Ugrinowitsch, Juliana Bayeux Dascal, Alessandra Beggiato Porto & Victor Hugo Alves Okazaki. (2020) Freezing Degrees of Freedom During Motor Learning: A Systematic Review. Motor Control 24:3, pages 457-471.
Crossref
Vladimir Michalicka & Radek Pohnan. (2019) BRAIN ENERGETIC DEMANDS DURING COGNITIVE ACTIVITIES IN RELATION TO AEROBIC LOAD. Military Medical Science Letters 88:4, pages 159-165.
Crossref
Sally A. Linkenauger, Veronica Weser & Dennis R. Proffitt. (2019) Choosing efficient actions: Deciding where to walk. PLOS ONE 14:9, pages e0219729.
Crossref
Julie Vaughan-Graham, Kara Patterson, Karl Zabjek & Cheryl A. Cott. (2019) Important Movement Concepts: Clinical Versus Neuroscience Perspectives. Motor Control 23:3, pages 273-293.
Crossref
Rick de Klerk, Thijs Lutjeboer, Riemer J. K. Vegter & Lucas H. V. van der Woude. (2018) Practice-based skill acquisition of pushrim-activated power-assisted wheelchair propulsion versus regular handrim propulsion in novices. Journal of NeuroEngineering and Rehabilitation 15:1.
Crossref
DAVID WEBB & SARA BRATSCH. (2017) EXPERIENCE AND PRACTICE IN CARRYING A HEAVY, UNILATERAL LOAD: FOOTPRINT EVIDENCE. Journal of Mechanics in Medicine and Biology 17:01, pages 1750022.
Crossref
Sudha M. Srinivasan & Anjana N. Bhat. (2016) Differences in object sharing between infants at risk for autism and typically developing infants from 9 to 15 months of age. Infant Behavior and Development 42, pages 128-141.
Crossref
Marika T. Leving, Riemer J. K. Vegter, Johanneke Hartog, Claudine J. C. Lamoth, Sonja de Groot & Lucas H. V. van der Woude. (2015) Effects of Visual Feedback-Induced Variability on Motor Learning of Handrim Wheelchair Propulsion. PLOS ONE 10:5, pages e0127311.
Crossref
Minxuan He, Eric A. Walle & Joseph J. Campos. (2015) A Cross‐National Investigation of the Relationship Between Infant Walking and Language Development. Infancy 20:3, pages 283-305.
Crossref
Riemer J K Vegter, Johanneke Hartog, Sonja de Groot, Claudine J Lamoth, Michel J Bekker, Jan W van der Scheer, Lucas H V van der Woude & Dirkjan H E J Veeger. (2015) Early motor learning changes in upper-limb dynamics and shoulder complex loading during handrim wheelchair propulsion. Journal of NeuroEngineering and Rehabilitation 12:1, pages 26.
Crossref
Riemer J. K. Vegter, Sonja de Groot, Claudine J Lamoth, Dirkjan Hej Veeger & Lucas H. V. van der Woude. (2014) Initial Skill Acquisition of Handrim Wheelchair Propulsion: A New Perspective. IEEE Transactions on Neural Systems and Rehabilitation Engineering 22:1, pages 104-113.
Crossref
Ang?lica Cristiane Ovando, Stella Maris Michaelsen, Natalia Duarte Pereira, Jonathan Ache Dias & Tales de Carvalho. (2013) Frequ?ncia card?aca e percep??o subjetiva de esfor?o durante o andar para tr?s em velocidade confort?vel e m?xima em adultos com hemiparesia. Revista Brasileira de Medicina do Esporte 19:6, pages 431-435.
Crossref
S. Bar-Haim, M.D. Al-Jarrah, I. Nammourah & N. Harries. (2013) Mechanical efficiency and balance in adolescents and young adults with cerebral palsy. Gait & Posture 38:4, pages 668-673.
Crossref
Lydia K. Caldwell, Lloyd L. Laubach & Joaquin A. Barrios. (2013) Effect of specific gait modifications on medial knee loading, metabolic cost and perception of task difficulty. Clinical Biomechanics 28:6, pages 649-654.
Crossref
Jaimie A. Roper, Elizabeth L. Stegem?ller, Mark D. Tillman & Chris J. Hass. (2012) Oxygen consumption, oxygen cost, heart rate, and perceived effort during split-belt treadmill walking in young healthy adults. European Journal of Applied Physiology 113:3, pages 729-734.
Crossref
Shaw Bronner. (2012) Differences in Segmental Coordination and Postural Control in a Multi-joint Dance Movement Développé Arabesque. Journal of Dance Medicine & Science 16:1, pages 26-35.
Crossref
Simona Bar-HaimNetta Harries, Ibtisam Nammourah, Saleh Oraibi, Waddah Malhees, Jack Loeppky, Neil J Perkins, Mark Belokopytov, Jacob Kaplanski & Eli Lahat. (2010) Effectiveness of motor learning coaching in children with cerebral palsy: a randomized controlled trial. Clinical Rehabilitation 24:11, pages 1009-1020.
Crossref
Simona Bar-Haim, Netta Harries, Saleh Al-Oraibi, Eliezer Lahat, Malhis Waddah, Jack A. Loeppky & Mark Belokopytov. (2009) Repeatability of Net Mechanical Efficiency During Stair Climbing in Children with Cerebral Palsy. Pediatric Physical Therapy 21:4, pages 320-324.
Crossref
DANIEL L. EAVES, NICOLA J. HODGES & A. MARK WILLIAMS. (2008) Energetic Costs of Incidental Visual Coupling during Treadmill Running. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise 40:8, pages 1506-1514.
Crossref
Chang-Jin Yoon & Woen-Sik Chae. (2008) The Process of the Kinematic Coordination and Control of Dollyochagi Motion in Taekwondo. Korean Journal of Sport Biomechanics 18:2, pages 95-104.
Crossref
Simona Bar-Haim, Mark Belokopytov, Netta Harries, Jack A. Loeppky & Jacob Kaplanski. (2008) Prediction of mechanical efficiency from heart rate during stair-climbing in children with cerebral palsy. Gait & Posture 27:3, pages 512-517.
Crossref
David Webb & William Anthony Sparrow. (2007) Description of joint movements in human and non-human primate locomotion using Fourier analysis. Primates 48:4, pages 277-292.
Crossref
L.L. Saling & J.G. Phillips. (2007) Automatic behaviour: Efficient not mindless. Brain Research Bulletin 73:1-3, pages 1-20.
Crossref
Mikyong Shin. (2007) A Study of Dynamical Characteristics on Learning of the Golf Putting Using Dynamic Approach. Korean Journal of Cognitive and Biological Psychology 19:1, pages 77-91.
Crossref
Evelyn Bellaud. (2006) Une façon (re)pensée d’agir. Kinésithérapie, la Revue 6:59, pages 33-41.
Crossref
Ambreen Chohan, Geert J. P. Savelsbergh, Paulien van Kampen, Marline Wind & Martine H. G. Verheul. (2006) Postural adjustments and bearing angle use in interceptive actions. Experimental Brain Research 171:1, pages 47-55.
Crossref
Laurence Roux, Sylvain Hanneton & Agn?s Roby-Brami. (2006) Shoulder movements during the initial phase of learning manual wheelchair propulsion in able-bodied subjects. Clinical Biomechanics 21, pages S45-S51.
Crossref
B.S. Lay, W.A. Sparrow & N.J. O’Dwyer. (2005) The metabolic and cognitive energy costs of stabilising a high-energy interlimb coordination task. Human Movement Science 24:5-6, pages 833-848.
Crossref
W. A. Sparrow, S. Parker, B. Lay & M. Wengier. (2005) Aging Effects on the Metabolic and Cognitive Energy Cost of Interlimb Coordination. The Journals of Gerontology Series A: Biological Sciences and Medical Sciences 60:3, pages 312-319.
Crossref
S. de Groot, H.E.J. Veeger, A.P. Hollander & L.H.V. van der Woude. (2005) Influence of task complexity on mechanical efficiency and propulsion technique during learning of hand rim wheelchair propulsion. Medical Engineering & Physics 27:1, pages 41-49.
Crossref
B.S Lay, W.A Sparrow, K.M Hughes & N.J O’Dwyer. (2002) Practice effects on coordination and control, metabolic energy expenditure, and muscle activation. Human Movement Science 21:5-6, pages 807-830.
Crossref
SONJA DE GROOT, DIRKJAN (H. E. J.) VEEGER, A. PETER HOLLANDER & LUCAS H. V. VAN DER WOUDE. (2002) Wheelchair propulsion technique and mechanical efficiency after 3 wk of practice. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise 34:5, pages 756-766.
Crossref
Edward M. Heath, John R. Blackwell, Ursula C. Baker, Darla R. Smith & Kurt W. Kornatz. (2001) Backward walking practice decreases oxygen uptake, heart rate and ratings of perceived exertion. Physical Therapy in Sport 2:4, pages 171-177.
Crossref
Naomichi OGIHARA & Nobutoshi YAMAZAKI. (2001) Effect of Body Structure on Skill Formation in a Force Precision Task Mimicking Cello Bowing Movement.. JSME International Journal Series C 44:1, pages 69-78.
Crossref
David A. Rosenbaum, Ruud J. Meulenbroek, Jonathan Vaughan & Chris Jansen. (2001) Posture-based motion planning: Applications to grasping.. Psychological Review 108:4, pages 709-734.
Crossref
Pascual Marques-Bruna & Paul Grimshaw. (2016) Changes in Coordination during the First 8 Months of Independent Walking. Perceptual and Motor Skills 91:3, pages 855-869.
Crossref
W.A Sparrow, K.M Hughes, A.P Russell & P.F Le Rossignol. (1999) Effects of practice and preferred rate on perceived exertion, metabolic variables and movement control. Human Movement Science 18:2-3, pages 137-153.
Crossref
W. A. Sparrow & K. M. Newell. (1998) Metabolic energy expenditure and the regulation of movement economy. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 5:2, pages 173-196.
Crossref
Roberta Shepherd. (2006) Stephenson et al. – a response. Physiotherapy Research International 3:1, pages 78-81.
Crossref
Jacques Temprado, M. Della-Grasta, M. Farrell & M. Laurent. (1997) A novice-expert comparison of (intra-limb) coordination subserving the volleyball serve. Human Movement Science 16:5, pages 653-676.
Crossref
Allen W. Burton & Walter E. Davis. (1996) Ecological task analysis utilizing intrinsic measures in research and practice. Human Movement Science 15:2, pages 285-314.
Crossref
J. Greg Anson & Mark L. Latash. (2010) Toward peaceful coexistence of adaptive central strategies and medical professionals. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 94-106.
Crossref
C. J. Worringham, G. K. Kerr & C. O'Brien. (2010) Towards functional movement: Implications for research and therapy. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 92-94.
Crossref
Alan M. Wing, Stephen Kirker & John R. Jenner. (2010) Altered bilateral muscle synergies after stroke. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 92-92.
Crossref
C. B. Walter & K. Kamm. (2010) Optimal search strategies for optimal motor solutions: Self-determination or informed guidance?. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 91-92.
Crossref
Michael G. Wade & Jinhua Guan. (2010) Anthropomorphizing the CNS: Is it what or who you know?. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 90-91.
Crossref
R. E. A. van Emmerik & R. C. Wagenaar. (2010) On optimality and movement disorders: A dynamic systems perspective. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 90-90.
Crossref
Paul J. Treffner & J. A. Scott Kelso. (2010) Generic mechanisms of coordination in special populations. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 89-89.
Crossref
Esther Thelen. (2010) Developmental “movement disorders” and problem solving. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 88-89.
Crossref
Stephan P. Swinnen, Sabine M. P. Verschueren & Natalia Dounskaia. (2010) Is motor pathology associated with setting new CNS priorities or with increased difficulty in overcoming or suppressing preexisting CNS priorities?. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 87-88.
Crossref
Jeffery J. Summers & Julie Thomas. (2010) When are adaptive motor patterns nonadaptive?. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 87-87.
Crossref
W. A. Sparrow. (2010) What is the appropriate criterion for therapeutic intervention in the motor domain?. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 86-86.
Crossref
John P. Scholz. (2010) How functional are atypical motor patterns?. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 85-86.
Crossref
J. G. Phillips, J. L. Bradshaw, M. J. Slavin & C. Pantelis. (2010) Abnormal movements can be identified in “atypical” populations. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 84-85.
Crossref
Karl M. Newell & Steven Morrison. (2010) Frames of reference and normal movement. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 83-84.
Crossref
Meg Morris, Thomas Matyas, Robert Iansek & Ross Cunnington. (2010) Rehabilitation promotes functional movement in atypical populations. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 82-83.
Crossref
R. S. W. Masters & R. C. J. Polman. (2010) What are “normal movements” in any population? . Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 81-82.
Crossref
Mathew T. Martin-Iverson. (2010) Theories need data and patients need treatment: Where's the beef?. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 80-81.
Crossref
Mindy F. Levin. (2010) Should stereotypic movement synergies in hemiparetic patients be considered adaptive?. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 79-80.
Crossref
Jürgen Konczak & Johannes Dichgans. (2010) The concept of “normal” movement and its consequences for therapy. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 79-79.
Crossref
Roberta L. Klatzky. (2010) What makes a population atypical–priorities or constraints?. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 78-78.
Crossref
Tatsuya Kasai. (2010) Anticipatory postural mechanisms: Some evidence and methodological implications. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 77-78.
Crossref
Kenneth G. Holt. (2010) “Constraint” versus “choice” in preferred movement patterns. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 76-77.
Crossref
Jennifer M. Gurd. (2010) Thought is action. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 76-76.
Crossref
Gary Goldberg & Nathaniel H. Mayer. (2010) The goal of treatment for motor impairment is not to “normalize” but to “functionalize” through facilitative modulation and enabling context. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 75-76.
Crossref
C. C. A. M. Gielen. (2010) “Abnormal” movements: What are they reflections of?. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 74-75.
Crossref
Daniel M. Corcos, Kerstin D. Pfann & Aron S. Buchman. (2010) Defective preprogramming does not account for the clinical deficits of Parkinson's disease. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 73-74.
Crossref
J. H. Carr & R. B. Shepherd. (2010) “Normal” is not the issue: It is “effective” goal attainment that counts. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 72-73.
Crossref
Allen W. Burton. (2010) Dynamic similarities in action systems. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 71-72.
Crossref
Simon Bouisset. (2010) Posturo-kinetic capacity in the disabled. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 71-71.
Crossref
Elena V. Biryukova, Alexandrez A. Frolov, Yves Burnod & Agnès Roby-Brami. (2010) Evaluation of central commands: Toward a theoretical basis for rehabilitation. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 69-71.
Crossref
A. Berardelli, R. Agostino, A. Currà & M. Manfredi. (2010) Bradykinesia in Parkinson's disease and cocontraction activity in dystonia are unlikely to be due to adaptive changes in the CNS. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 69-69.
Crossref
Alexander S. Aruin. (2010) Adaptive changes in postural reactions after unilateral leg amputation. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 68-69.
Crossref
Mark L. Latash & J. Greg Anson. (2010) What are “normal movements” in atypical populations?. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 19:1, pages 55-68.
Crossref
Marc Durand, Valérie Geoffroi, Alain Varray & Christian Préfaut. (1994) Study of the energy correlates in the learning of a complex self-paced cyclical skill. Human Movement Science 13:6, pages 785-799.
Crossref
Gary D. Heise. (1994) Segment Interactions of the Arm during the Practice of a Novel, Multijoint Throwing Skill. Journal of Applied Biomechanics 10:4, pages 352-373.
Crossref
W.A. Sparrow & K.M. Newell. (1994) The coordination and control of human creeping with increases in speed. Behavioural Brain Research 63:2, pages 151-158.
Crossref
W. A. SPARROW & K. M. NEWELL. (2007) Energy expenditure and motor performance relationships in humans learning a motor task. Psychophysiology 31:4, pages 338-346.
Crossref
Karl M. Newell & P. Vernon McDonald. 1994. Interlimb Coordination. Interlimb Coordination 515 536 .
Charles B. Walter & Stephan P. Swinnen. 1994. Interlimb Coordination. Interlimb Coordination 491 513 .
Winfried Henke & Hartmut RotheWinfried Henke & Hartmut Rothe. 1994. Paläoanthropologie. Paläoanthropologie 625 699 .
MM Abitbol. (1993) Quadrupedalism and the acquisition of bipedalism in human children. Gait & Posture 1:4, pages 189-195.
Crossref
Marc Durand. 1993. Cognition et performance. Cognition et performance 61 78 .
W.A. Sparrow. 1992. Approaches to the Study of Motor Control and Learning. Approaches to the Study of Motor Control and Learning 147 162 .
David A. Rosenbaum. 1991. Human Motor Control. Human Motor Control 79 118 .
Jean-Pierre FamoseJean-Pierre Famose. 1990. Apprentissage moteur et difficulté de la tâche. Apprentissage moteur et difficulté de la tâche 193 208 .
W. A. Sparrow. (2005) Creeping patterns of human adults and infants. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 78:3, pages 387-401.
Crossref
K.M. Newell, P.N. Kugler, R.E.A. Van Emmerik & P.V. Mcdonald. 1989. Perspectives on the Coordination of Movement. Perspectives on the Coordination of Movement 85 122 .

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.