Advanced search
Publication Cover
Educational Psychologist Volume 51, 2016 - Issue 2
Submit an article Journal homepage
9,495
Views
241
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Examining Productive Failure, Productive Success, Unproductive Failure, and Unproductive Success in Learning

Manu KapurDepartment of Psychological StudiesThe Hong Kong Institute of EducationCorrespondence[email protected]
Pages 289-299 | Published online: 07 Apr 2016

Citations (241)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (32)

Brian J. Hess, Nathan Cupido, Shelley Ross & Brent Kvern. (2024) Becoming adaptive experts in an era of rapid advances in generative artificial intelligence. Medical Teacher 46:3, pages 300-303.
Read now
Monyka L. Rodrigues, Eden S. Jing & Sandra Martin-Chang. (2024) When more is more: effect of context and stimulus set size on orthographic learning. Journal of Cognitive Psychology 36:2, pages 183-204.
Read now
Almaz Mesghina, Guanglei Hong & Adelle Durrell. (2024) Cooperative Learning in Introductory Statistics: Assessing Students’ Perceptions, Performance, and Learning in Heterogeneous and Homogeneous Groups. Journal of Statistics and Data Science Education 0:0, pages 1-26.
Read now
Eisuke Saito, Jennifer Mansfield & Richard O’Donovan. (2024) Information economics of teaching: a transactional perspective on pedagogical reasoning to provide a typology of pedagogical equilibrium. Interactive Learning Environments 32:1, pages 20-33.
Read now
Antje Boomgaarden, Katharina Loibl & Timo Leuders. (2023) The trade-off between complexity and accuracy. Preparing for computer-based adaptive instruction on fractions. Interactive Learning Environments 31:10, pages 6379-6394.
Read now
Jennifer L. Nimtz. (2023) Illustrating Productive and Unproductive Cognitive Interactions in an Online Intermediate Algebra Course. PRIMUS 33:9, pages 997-1021.
Read now
Zohar Snapir, Galit Karadi & Michal Zion. (2023) Inquiry practices and types of knowledge, with paths of logical associations between inquiry questions, presented as part of an open inquiry process. Journal of Biological Education 57:5, pages 1062-1082.
Read now
David DeLiema, Yejin Angela Kwon, Andrea Chisholm, Immanuel Williams, Maggie Dahn, Virginia J. Flood, Dor Abrahamson & Francis F. Steen. (2023) A Multi-dimensional Framework for Documenting Students’ Heterogeneous Experiences with Programming Bugs. Cognition and Instruction 41:2, pages 158-200.
Read now
Qian Zhang & Logan Fiorella. (2023) An integrated model of learning from errors. Educational Psychologist 58:1, pages 18-34.
Read now
David DeLiema, Ashley Hufnagle, V.N. Vimal Rao, Justin Baker, Jesslyn Valerie & Jasmine Kim. (2023) Methodological innovations at the intersection of video-based educational research traditions: Reflections on relevance, data selection, and phenomena of interest. International Journal of Research & Method in Education 46:1, pages 19-36.
Read now
Antonia Larrain, Valeska Grau, María José Barrera, Paulina Freire, Patricia López, Sebastián Verdugo, Marisol Gómez, Francisca Ramírez & Gabriel Sánchez. (2022) Productive failure and learning through argumentation: Building a bridge between two research traditions to understand the process of peer learning. Journal of the Learning Sciences 31:4-5, pages 673-688.
Read now
Hitomi Kambara. (2022) Exploring constructivism in Japan through textual analysis. Asia Pacific Journal of Education 42:3, pages 605-616.
Read now
Marcus Law, Paula Veinot, Maria Mylopoulos, Pier Bryden & Ryan Brydges. (2022) Applying activity theory to undergraduate medical curriculum reform: Lessons in contradictions from multiple stakeholders’ perspectives. Medical Teacher 44:7, pages 800-811.
Read now
Tanmay Sinha. (2022) Enriching problem-solving followed by instruction with explanatory accounts of emotions. Journal of the Learning Sciences 31:2, pages 151-198.
Read now
Jennifer M. Klasen, Pim W. Teunissen, Erik W. Driessen & Lorelei A. Lingard. (2022) ‘It depends’: The complexity of allowing residents to fail from the perspective of clinical supervisors. Medical Teacher 44:2, pages 196-205.
Read now
Kathleen M. Quinlan. (2021) Towards an educational humanities for teacher education: Building the relational, emotional, and ethical bases of teaching practice. Oxford Review of Education 47:6, pages 752-769.
Read now
Bryce E. Hughes, William J. Schell, Brett Tallman, Tessa Sybesma, Monika B. Kwapisz, Emma Annand, Shannon Ranch, Caroline Krejci, Christy Bozic & Daria Kotys-Schwartz. (2021) Entering the community of practice: changes in engineering students’ engineering identities and perceptions of the field. European Journal of Engineering Education 46:6, pages 968-986.
Read now
Edwin Creely, Michael Henderson, Danah Henriksen & Renee Crawford. (2021) Leading change for creativity in schools: mobilizing creative risk-taking and productive failure. International Journal of Leadership in Education 0:0, pages 1-24.
Read now
Chris A. B. Zajchowski, Michael J. Riley & Lisa Meerts-Brandsma. (2021) Situating and Sequencing Quagmire: The Role of Simulation-Based Gaming in Preparing Students for Future Learning at Capitol Reef National Park, Utah. SCHOLE: A Journal of Leisure Studies and Recreation Education 36:1-2, pages 75-90.
Read now
W. Monty Jones, Matt Caratachea, Micheal Schad & Jonathan D. Cohen. (2021) Examining K–12 teacher learning in a makerspace through the activity–identity–community framework. Journal of Research on Technology in Education 53:3, pages 317-332.
Read now
Susan Carter, Sean Sturm & Emmanuel Manalo. (2021) Coaxing success from failure through academic development. International Journal for Academic Development 26:2, pages 190-200.
Read now
Ying-Chih Chen & Xue Qiao. (2020) Using students’ epistemic uncertainty as a pedagogical resource to develop knowledge in argumentation. International Journal of Science Education 42:13, pages 2145-2180.
Read now
Mark Thorley. (2020) Failing to learn and learning to fail – exemplars of practice from the creative industries. International Journal for Academic Development 25:1, pages 71-82.
Read now
Deidre Popovich & Erika Brooks-Hurst. (2019) ASSESSING THE PERCEIVED EFFECTIVENESS OF A MARKETING RESEARCH SERVICE LEARNING PROJECT: THE MR-SL SCALE. Marketing Education Review 29:3, pages 164-181.
Read now
Steve Black & James D. Allen. (2019) Part 9: Planning Instruction. The Reference Librarian 60:2, pages 93-108.
Read now
Sarah Shi Hui Wong & Stephen Wee Hun Lim. (2019) Prevention–Permission–Promotion: A Review of Approaches to Errors in Learning. Educational Psychologist 54:1, pages 1-19.
Read now
Rachel Lam & Manu Kapur. (2018) Preparation for Future Collaboration: Cognitively Preparing for Learning From Collaboration. The Journal of Experimental Education 86:4, pages 546-559.
Read now
Maria Mylopoulos, Naomi Steenhof, Amit Kaushal & Nicole N. Woods. (2018) Twelve tips for designing curricula that support the development of adaptive expertise. Medical Teacher 40:8, pages 850-854.
Read now
Yong Zhao. (2018) The Changing Context of Teaching and Implications for Teacher Education. Peabody Journal of Education 93:3, pages 295-308.
Read now
Kulamakan Kulasegaram, Maria Mylopoulos, Paul Tonin, Stacey Bernstein, Pier Bryden, Marcus Law, Jana Lazor, Richard Pittini, Sanjeev Sockalingam, Glendon R. Tait & Patricia Houston. (2018) The alignment imperative in curriculum renewal. Medical Teacher 40:5, pages 443-448.
Read now
Candace Walkington & Matthew L. Bernacki. (2018) Personalization of Instruction: Design Dimensions and Implications for Cognition. The Journal of Experimental Education 86:1, pages 50-68.
Read now
Hesham Fathi Marei, Jeroen Donkers, Mohamed Mostafa Al-Eraky & Jeroen J. G. van Merrienboer. (2017) The effectiveness of sequencing virtual patients with lectures in a deductive or inductive learning approach. Medical Teacher 39:12, pages 1268-1274.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (209)

Kate M. Xu, Sarah Coertjens, Florence Lespiau, Kim Ouwehand, Hanke Korpershoek, Fred Paas & David C. Geary. (2024) An Evolutionary Approach to Motivation and Learning: Differentiating Biologically Primary and Secondary Knowledge. Educational Psychology Review 36:2.
Crossref
Jochem E. J. Aben, Mayra Mascareño Lara, Anneke C. Timmermans, Filitsa Dingyloudi & Jan-Willem Strijbos. (2024) The impact of interpersonal perceptions on the process of dealing with errors while providing and processing peer-feedback on writing. Instructional Science.
Crossref
Jinju Lee, Jongchan Park & Dongsik Kim. (2023) Exploring when learners become aware of their knowledge gaps: Content analyses of learner discussions. Instructional Science 52:2, pages 171-205.
Crossref
Rafi Safadi & Nadera Hawa. (2023) Learning from erroneous examples in the mathematics classroom: do students with different naïve ideas benefit equally?. Instructional Science 52:2, pages 277-308.
Crossref
Annalisa Soncini, Maria Cristina Matteucci, Carlo Tomasetto & Fabrizio Butera. (2024) Supportive error feedback fosters students' adaptive reactions towards errors: Evidence from a targeted online intervention with Italian middle school students. British Journal of Educational Psychology.
Crossref
Satyaki Sarkar, Kritika Kumari & Prashant Prasad. (2024) Approaching Planning for New Areas Based on Environmental Suitability and Accessibility: A Study of Navi Mumbai, India. Journal of Urban Planning and Development 150:1.
Crossref
Silvia Di Battista. (2024) ‘She is failing; he is learning’: Gender‐differentiated attributions for girls' and boys' errors. British Journal of Educational Psychology.
Crossref
David DeLiema, Ashley Hufnagle & Miguel Ovies‐Bocanegra. (2024) Contrasting stances at the crossroads of debugging learning opportunities. British Journal of Educational Psychology.
Crossref
Pi-Sui Hsu, Eric Monsu Lee & Thomas J. Smith. (2023) Exploring non-dominant youths’ engineering identity through productive struggle in a making summer program. Educational technology research and development 72:1, pages 83-107.
Crossref
Alan da Silveira Fleck & Tingting Zhu. (2024) Impact of Embedded Learning Strategy Activities: Student Engagement and Performance. Technology, Knowledge and Learning.
Crossref
İpek Saralar-Aras & Belma Türker-Biber. (2024) Enhancing technological pedagogical content knowledge of prospective teachers through mathematics lesson plan development. Education and Information Technologies.
Crossref
Fengfeng Ke, Chih‐Pu Dai & Luke West. (2024) Mathematical experience in game‐based problem‐solving. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning.
Crossref
Almaz Mesghina. 2024. Instructional Strategies for Active Learning [Working Title]. Instructional Strategies for Active Learning [Working Title].
Peipei Mao, Zhihui Cai, Zhikeng Wang, Xin Hao, Xitao Fan & Xiaojun Sun. (2024) The effects of dynamic and static feedback under tasks with different difficulty levels in digital game-based learning. The Internet and Higher Education 60, pages 100923.
Crossref
Victoria Macann & Aman Yadav. (2023) Debugging Beyond the Code: Teachers' Perceptions of Debugging as a CT Practice Impacting Interdisciplinary Teaching and Learning. Debugging Beyond the Code: Teachers' Perceptions of Debugging as a CT Practice Impacting Interdisciplinary Teaching and Learning.
Katharina Loibl & Christian Leukel. (2023) Problem-solving prior to instruction in learning motor skills - Initial self-determined practice improves javelin throwing performance. Learning and Instruction 88, pages 101828.
Crossref
Sue-ann Lim, Jae Yup Jung & Slava Kalyuga. (2023) Effectiveness of invention tasks and explicit instruction in preparing intellectually gifted adolescents for learning. Instructional Science 51:6, pages 921-952.
Crossref
Anna Gorbunova, Jeroen J. G. van Merrienboer & Jamie Costley. (2023) Are Inductive Teaching Methods Compatible with Cognitive Load Theory?. Educational Psychology Review 35:4.
Crossref
Vladimir Macko, Pascal Felber, Kristoffer Bergram & Adrian Holzer. (2023) Using Educational Robotics to Support Active Learning Experiences and Foster Computational Thinking Skills among Non-STEM University Students. Using Educational Robotics to Support Active Learning Experiences and Foster Computational Thinking Skills among Non-STEM University Students.
Alejandro Gonzalez Ojeda, Douglas Fisher & Nancy Frey. 2023. Instructional Leadership Efforts and Evidence-Based Practices to Improve Writing Instruction. Instructional Leadership Efforts and Evidence-Based Practices to Improve Writing Instruction 1 20 .
Annita Nugent, Annemaree Carroll, Jason M. Lodge, Kelly E. Matthews, Stephanie MacMahon & Pankaj Sah. (2023) A qualitative exploration of expert perspectives on applying the science of learning to higher education. Frontiers in Education 8.
Crossref
Lynn Keets, Pedro Boscan, Logan Arakaki, Benjamin Schraeder, Cyane Tornatzky, Marie Vans, Wenjing Jiang & Sangeeta Rao. (2023) Interactive Virtual Reality with Educational Feedback Loops to Train and Assess Veterinary Students on the Use of Anesthetic Machine. Journal of Veterinary Medical Education.
Crossref
Erminia Pedretti & Ana Maria Navas Iannini. (2023) Vers des musées scientifiques de quatrième génération : changer les objectifs, changer les rôles. Culture & musées:41, pages 151-186.
Crossref
Samuel O. ClarkeJonathan S. IlgenGlenn Regehr. (2023) Fostering Adaptive Expertise Through Simulation. Academic Medicine 98:9, pages 994-1001.
Crossref
Di Sima. (2023) The Long-Term Effects of External Examinations on Entrepreneurship: Evidence from Global Entrepreneurship Monitor. Journal of Human Capital 17:3, pages 387-433.
Crossref
Sebastian Fischer & Philipp Alexander Freund. (2021) Fehlermanagementkultur und Fehlervermeidungskultur in SchulklassenError management culture and error avoidance culture in school classes. Unterrichtswissenschaft 51:3, pages 315-337.
Crossref
Anttoni Kervinen & Tuomas Aivelo. (2023) Secondary school students' responses to epistemic uncertainty during an ecological citizen science inquiry. Science Education 107:5, pages 1352-1379.
Crossref
Marci S. DeCaro, Raina A. Isaacs, Campbell R. Bego & Raymond J. Chastain. (2023) Bringing exploratory learning online: problem-solving before instruction improves remote undergraduate physics learning. Frontiers in Education 8.
Crossref
Adrian Wierzchowski & Donald J. Wink. (2023) Categorizing Student Learning about Research, Nature of Science, and Poster Presentation in a Workshop-Based Undergraduate Research Experience. Journal of Chemical Education 100:8, pages 2873-2883.
Crossref
Masoumeh Rahimi, Lauren E Margulieux, James Prather, Gozde Cetin Uzun & Bailey Kimmel. (2023) Benefits of Failure on Neuroplasticity and Tools for Persistence. Benefits of Failure on Neuroplasticity and Tools for Persistence.
Logan Fiorella. (2023) Making Sense of Generative Learning. Educational Psychology Review 35:2.
Crossref
Manu Kapur, Janan Saba & Ido Roll. (2023) Prior math achievement and inventive production predict learning from productive failure. npj Science of Learning 8:1.
Crossref
Ton de Jong, Ard W. Lazonder, Clark A. Chinn, Frank Fischer, Janice Gobert, Cindy E. Hmelo-Silver, Ken R. Koedinger, Joseph S. Krajcik, Eleni A. Kyza, Marcia C. Linn, Margus Pedaste, Katharina Scheiter & Zacharias C. Zacharia. (2023) Let's talk evidence – The case for combining inquiry-based and direct instruction. Educational Research Review 39, pages 100536.
Crossref
Amy Debbané, Ken Jen Lee, Jarvis Tse & Edith Law. (2023) Learning by Teaching: Key Challenges and Design Implications. Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction 7:CSCW1, pages 1-34.
Crossref
Joseph H. Donroe, Sarita Soares & André N. Sofair. (2023) Strategies to Improve Teaching Point-of-Care Ultrasound at the Bedside. Medical Science Educator 33:2, pages 577-581.
Crossref
Campbell R. Bego, Raymond J. Chastain & Marci S. DeCaro. (2022) Designing novel activities before instruction: Use of contrasting cases and a rich dataset. British Journal of Educational Psychology 93:1, pages 299-317.
Crossref
A. M. Phillips, E. J. Gouvea, B. E. Gravel, P.-H. Beachemin & T. J. Atherton. (2023) Physicality, modeling, and agency in a computational physics class. Physical Review Physics Education Research 19:1.
Crossref
Sarah Shi Hui Wong. (2023) Deliberate Erring Improves Far Transfer of Learning More Than Errorless Elaboration and Spotting and Correcting Others’ Errors. Educational Psychology Review 35:1.
Crossref
Selcuk Acar, Harun Tadik, Recep Uysal, Danielle Myers & Betul Inetas. (2022) Socio‐Economic Status and Creativity: A Meta‐Analysis. The Journal of Creative Behavior 57:1, pages 138-172.
Crossref
Xinhong Zhang, Boyan Zhang & Fan Zhang. (2023) Student-centered case-based teaching and online–offline case discussion in postgraduate courses of computer science. International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education 20:1.
Crossref
Teemu Lehtinen, Lassi Haaranen & Juho Leinonen. (2023) Automated Questionnaires About Students’ JavaScript Programs: Towards Gauging Novice Programming Processes. Automated Questionnaires About Students’ JavaScript Programs: Towards Gauging Novice Programming Processes.
Masyhuri Masyhuri. 2023. Proceedings of the First Conference of Psychology and Flourishing Humanity (PFH 2022). Proceedings of the First Conference of Psychology and Flourishing Humanity (PFH 2022) 154 167 .
Christian Walsh. (2022) Encouraging intelligent failure in an MBA class. Decision Sciences Journal of Innovative Education 21:1, pages 37-46.
Crossref
Sue Swaffield & Roszalina Rawi. 2023. International Encyclopedia of Education(Fourth Edition). International Encyclopedia of Education(Fourth Edition) 21 34 .
Jun Oshima, Jan van Aalst, Jin Mu & Carol K. K. Chan. 2023. International Handbook on Education Development in the Asia-Pacific. International Handbook on Education Development in the Asia-Pacific 1277 1300 .
Jun Oshima, Jan van Aalst, Jin Mu & Carol K. K. Chan. 2022. International Handbook on Education Development in Asia-Pacific. International Handbook on Education Development in Asia-Pacific 1 24 .
Stanislaw Schukajlow & Werner Blum. 2023. Advancing and Consolidating Mathematical Modelling. Advancing and Consolidating Mathematical Modelling 327 339 .
Camille Dickson-Deane, Keith Heggart & Robert Vanderburg. 2023. Design Education Across Disciplines. Design Education Across Disciplines 125 142 .
Shigehiro Kinda. (2022) Effects of Instructor’s “Task Knowledge” and “Learning-Process Knowledge” on Educational Desirability Judgment教授者の課題知識と学習過程知識が教授学習法の望ましさ判断に及ぼす影響. The Japanese Journal of Educational Psychology 70:4, pages 333-346.
Crossref
Mark A. McDaniel, Michael J. Cahill, Regina F. Frey, Lisa B. Limeri & Paula P. Lemons. (2022) Learning Introductory Biology: Students’ Concept-Building Approaches Predict Transfer on Biology Exams. CBE—Life Sciences Education 21:4.
Crossref
Josef Buchner, Martina Rüter & Michael Kerres. (2022) Learning with a digital escape room game: before or after instruction?. Research and Practice in Technology Enhanced Learning 17:1.
Crossref
Dean Davey. (2022) Responding to Failure: A Transformative Process. Christian Education Journal: Research on Educational Ministry 19:3, pages 370-384.
Crossref
Dragan Trninic, Tanmay Sinha & Manu Kapur. (2022) Comparing the effectiveness of preparatory activities that help undergraduate students learn from instruction. Learning and Instruction 82, pages 101688.
Crossref
Seyedahmad Rahimi, Valerie J. Shute, Curt Fulwider, Katie Bainbridge, Renata Kuba, Xiaotong Yang, Ginny Smith, Ryan S. Baker & Sidney K. D'Mello. (2022) Timing of learning supports in educational games can impact students’ outcomes. Computers & Education 190, pages 104600.
Crossref
Stella L Ng, Jacquelin Forsey, Victoria A Boyd, Farah Friesen, Sylvia Langlois, Kori Ladonna, Maria Mylopoulos & Naomi Steenhof. (2022) Combining adaptive expertise and (critically) reflective practice to support the development of knowledge, skill, and society. Advances in Health Sciences Education 27:5, pages 1265-1281.
Crossref
Jessica Lynch, Angela Orsino & Anne Kawamura. (2022) Productive struggle and failing safely: implications for developing adaptive expertise in communication. Advances in Health Sciences Education 27:5, pages 1331-1344.
Crossref
Evelyn Palominos, Tracy Levett-Jones, Tamara Power & Roberto Martinez-Maldonado. (2022) A conceptual model to inform the design of healthcare simulations that promote errors as a catalyst for learning: A discussion paper. Nurse Education in Practice 65, pages 103500.
Crossref
Ronald A. Beghetto & Ed Madison. (2022) Accepting the Challenge: Helping Schools Get Smarter about Supporting Students’ Creative Collaboration and Communication in a Changing World. Journal of Intelligence 10:4, pages 80.
Crossref
Hongzhi Yang, Linda Tsung & Lu Cao. (2022) The Use of Communication Strategies by Second Language Learners of Chinese in a Virtual Reality Learning Environment. SAGE Open 12:4, pages 215824402211418.
Crossref
Julian Roelle, Judith Schweppe, Tino Endres, Andreas Lachner, Claudia von Aufschnaiter, Alexander Renkl, Alexander Eitel, Detlev Leutner, Ralf Rummer, Katharina Scheiter & Andreas Vorholzer. (2022) Combining Retrieval Practice and Generative Learning in Educational Contexts. Zeitschrift für Entwicklungspsychologie und Pädagogische Psychologie 54:4, pages 142-150.
Crossref
Yong Zhao. (2021) Build back better: Avoid the learning loss trap. PROSPECTS 51:4, pages 557-561.
Crossref
Manu Kapur, John Hattie, Irina Grossman & Tanmay Sinha. (2022) Fail, flip, fix, and feed – Rethinking flipped learning: A review of meta-analyses and a subsequent meta-analysis. Frontiers in Education 7.
Crossref
Xuesong Du & Pei Sun. (2022) Generating distant analogies facilitates relational integration: Intermediary role of relational mindset and cognitive load. Frontiers in Psychology 13.
Crossref
Justin Baker, David DeLiema, Ashley S. Hufnagle, Stephanie M. Carlson, Anna Sharratt & Sheila Williams Ridge. (2022) Impasses in the wild: Autonomy support in naturalistic, parent-child outdoor play. Frontiers in Education 7.
Crossref
Daniel Yiorgios Rigney & Yong Zhao. (2021) Side effects in education: Taxonomy of educational outcomes. PROSPECTS 52:1-2, pages 33-39.
Crossref
Einat Tenenboim, Antonio Lucas-Alba, Óscar M. Melchor, Tomer Toledo & Shlomo Bekhor. (2022) Car following with an inertia-oriented driving technique: A driving simulator experiment. Transportation Research Part F: Traffic Psychology and Behaviour 89, pages 72-83.
Crossref
Julian Roelle, Linda Froese, Rebecca Krebs, Niklas Obergassel & Julia Waldeyer. (2022) Sequence matters! Retrieval practice before generative learning is more effective than the reverse order. Learning and Instruction 80, pages 101634.
Crossref
Lanqin Zheng, Yuanyi Zhen, Jiayu Niu & Lu Zhong. (2022) An exploratory study on fade-in versus fade-out scaffolding for novice programmers in online collaborative programming settings. Journal of Computing in Higher Education 34:2, pages 489-516.
Crossref
Nashat Cassim, Maria Mylopoulos, Karen Campbell & Laura Dempster. (2022) Dental student's perceptions and experience treating adults with developmental disabilities. Journal of Dental Education 86:8, pages 990-997.
Crossref
Ottilie Tilston, Adrian Bangerter & Kristian Tylén. (2022) Teaching, sharing experience, and innovation in cultural transmission. Journal of Language Evolution 7:1, pages 81-94.
Crossref
Jochem E.J. Aben, Anneke C. Timmermans, Filitsa Dingyloudi, Mayra Mascareño Lara & Jan-Willem Strijbos. (2022) What influences students' peer-feedback uptake? Relations between error tolerance, feedback tolerance, writing self-efficacy, perceived language skills and peer-feedback processing. Learning and Individual Differences 97, pages 102175.
Crossref
Regina F. Frey, Cynthia J. Brame, Angela Fink & Paula P. Lemons. (2022) Teaching Discipline-Based Problem Solving. CBE—Life Sciences Education 21:2.
Crossref
Robb Lindgren & David DeLiema. (2022) Viewpoint, embodiment, and roles in STEM learning technologies. Educational technology research and development 70:3, pages 1009-1034.
Crossref
Inga Glogger-Frey, Anne-Katrin Treier & Alexander Renkl. (2022) How preparation-for-learning with a worked versus an open inventing problem affect subsequent learning processes in pre-service teachers. Instructional Science 50:3, pages 451-473.
Crossref
Ji-Yun Kim, Jae Seon Seo & Kwihoon Kim. (2022) Development of novel-engineering-based maker education instructional model. Education and Information Technologies 27:5, pages 7327-7371.
Crossref
T. Tepsa, M. Haavikko, O. Li, V-M. Ruismaki, S. Kangas, J. Kattelus & H. Vaataja. (2022) A Digital Twin of a Heat Pump with a Game Engine for Educational Use. A Digital Twin of a Heat Pump with a Game Engine for Educational Use.
Young Kyun Sim, Hak Hwan Kim, Joon Ha Shin, Eun Chul Seo & Min-Seong Ha. (2022) Importance of Perception of Errors and Challenges for Improving Psychological Conditioning: Mediating Effect of Expectancy-Value Using the Phantom Model for Taekwondo Athletes. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 19:10, pages 6112.
Crossref
Ryan Brydges, Andrea Fiume & Lawrence Grierson. (2022) Mastery versus invention learning: impacts on future learning of simulated procedural skills. Advances in Health Sciences Education 27:2, pages 441-456.
Crossref
Allan Collins & Manu Kapur. 2022. The Cambridge Handbook of the Learning Sciences. The Cambridge Handbook of the Learning Sciences 156 174 .
. 2022. The Cambridge Handbook of the Learning Sciences. The Cambridge Handbook of the Learning Sciences 25 174 .
Linda Regan, Laura R. Hopson, Michael A. Gisondi & Jeremy Branzetti. (2022) Creating a better learning environment: a qualitative study uncovering the experiences of Master Adaptive Learners in residency. BMC Medical Education 22:1.
Crossref
Oluwakemi Ola. (2022) Music, Stories, and Progress Clickers. Music, Stories, and Progress Clickers.
Radek Pelanek & Tomas Effenberger. (2022) Improving Learning Environments: Avoiding Stupidity Perspective. IEEE Transactions on Learning Technologies 15:1, pages 64-77.
Crossref
Katie Bainbridge, Valerie Shute, Seyedahmad Rahimi, Zhichun Liu, Stefan Slater, Ryan S. Baker & Sidney K. D'Mello. (2022) Does embedding learning supports enhance transfer during game-based learning?. Learning and Instruction 77, pages 101547.
Crossref
Tanya Evans & Heiko Dietrich. (2022) Inquiry-based mathematics education: a call for reform in tertiary education seems unjustified. STEM Education 2:3, pages 221.
Crossref
Sara Abercrombie, Kira J. Carbonneau & Carolyn J. Hushman. (2022) (Re)Examining academic risk taking: Conceptual structure, antecedents, and relationship to productive failure. Contemporary Educational Psychology 68, pages 102029.
Crossref
Annelies Raes. (2021) Exploring Student and Teacher Experiences in Hybrid Learning Environments: Does Presence Matter?. Postdigital Science and Education 4:1, pages 138-159.
Crossref
Victoria Bleck & Frank Lipowsky. 2022. Handbuch Schulforschung. Handbuch Schulforschung 959 977 .
Trey Conatser. 2022. The Palgrave Handbook of Digital and Public Humanities. The Palgrave Handbook of Digital and Public Humanities 237 256 .
Kristina Lisk, Maria Mylopoulos & Nicole N. Woods. 2022. Technologies in Biomedical and Life Sciences Education. Technologies in Biomedical and Life Sciences Education 559 580 .
Ronald A. Beghetto & Vlad P. Glăveanu. 2022. The Palgrave Handbook of Transformational Giftedness for Education. The Palgrave Handbook of Transformational Giftedness for Education 23 42 .
Josef Buchner, Anne-Cathrin Vonarx, Peter Pfänder & Michael Kerres. 2022. Orchestration of Learning Environments in the Digital World. Orchestration of Learning Environments in the Digital World 21 34 .
Tai McClellan Maaz, Nhu H. Nguyen, Angel R. Del Valle Echevarria, Michael B. Kantar, Yuriy Mileyko & Michael G. Muszynski. (2022) Design and implementation of a cohort‐based undergraduate research experience in the agricultural sciences. Natural Sciences Education 51:1.
Crossref
Jay Jennings & Kasia Muldner. (2020) When Does Scaffolding Provide Too Much Assistance? A Code-Tracing Tutor Investigation. International Journal of Artificial Intelligence in Education 31:4, pages 784-819.
Crossref
Chrysanthos Socratous & Andri Ioannou. (2021) Structured or unstructured educational robotics curriculum? A study of debugging in block-based programming. Educational Technology Research and Development 69:6, pages 3081-3100.
Crossref
Zihe Zhou, Shijuan Wang & Yizhou Qian. (2021) Learning From Errors: Exploring the Effectiveness of Enhanced Error Messages in Learning to Program. Frontiers in Psychology 12.
Crossref
Logan Fiorella. 2021. The Cambridge Handbook of Multimedia Learning. The Cambridge Handbook of Multimedia Learning 487 497 .
. 2021. The Cambridge Handbook of Multimedia Learning. The Cambridge Handbook of Multimedia Learning 437 565 .
April Schweinhart & Holly Raffle. (2020) Productive Struggle: How Community Coalitions Developed Capacity to Conduct Qualitative Research Through CBPR. Health Promotion Practice 22:6, pages 735-740.
Crossref
Tanmay Sinha & Manu Kapur. (2021) Robust effects of the efficacy of explicit failure-driven scaffolding in problem-solving prior to instruction: A replication and extension. Learning and Instruction 75, pages 101488.
Crossref
Ying‐Chih Chen & Ratrapee Techawitthayachinda. (2021) Developing deep learning in science classrooms: Tactics to manage epistemic uncertainty during whole‐class discussion. Journal of Research in Science Teaching 58:8, pages 1083-1116.
Crossref
John Kerrigan, Keith Weber & Clark Chinn. (2021) Effective collaboration in the productive failure process. The Journal of Mathematical Behavior 63, pages 100892.
Crossref
Kyungbin Kwon, Jongpil Cheon & Hyunchang Moon. (2021) Levels of problem-solving competency identified through Bebras Computing Challenge. Education and Information Technologies 26:5, pages 5477-5498.
Crossref
Lauren Margulieux, Paul Denny, Kathryn Cunningham, Michael Deutsch & Benjamin R. Shapiro. (2021) When Wrong is Right: The Instructional Power of Multiple Conceptions. When Wrong is Right: The Instructional Power of Multiple Conceptions.
Anna McLean Phillips, Meagan Sundstrom, David G. Wu & N. G. Holmes. (2021) Not engaging with problems in the lab: Students’ navigation of conflicting data and models. Physical Review Physics Education Research 17:2.
Crossref
Qian Zhang & Logan Fiorella. (2021) Learning by drawing: When is it worth the time and effort?. Contemporary Educational Psychology 66, pages 101990.
Crossref
Ronald A. Beghetto. (2021) My Favorite Failure: Using Digital Technology to Facilitate Creative Learning and Reconceptualize Failure. TechTrends 65:4, pages 606-614.
Crossref
T. Logan Arrington, Alison L. Moore & Lauren M. Bagdy. (2021) K12 Practitioners’ Perceptions of Learning from Failure, Creativity, and Systems Thinking: a Collective Case Study. TechTrends 65:4, pages 636-645.
Crossref
Tim Kühl. (2021) Prerequisite knowledge and time of testing in learning with animations and static pictures: Evidence for the expertise reversal effect. Learning and Instruction 73, pages 101457.
Crossref
T. Logan Arrington & Lara Willox. (2021) “I Need to Sit on My Hands and Put Tape on My Mouth”: Improving Teachers’ Design Thinking Knowledge, Skills, and Attitudes Through Professional Development. Journal of Formative Design in Learning 5:1, pages 27-38.
Crossref
Jong-Baeg Kim, Kyoung-Suk Moon & Soowon Park. (2021) When is a performance-approach goal unhelpful? Performance goal structure, task difficulty as moderators. Asia Pacific Education Review 22:2, pages 261-272.
Crossref
Esther Ziegler, Dragan Trninic & Manu Kapur. (2021) Micro productive failure and the acquisition of algebraic procedural knowledge. Instructional Science 49:3, pages 313-336.
Crossref
Kristen N. Howard, Emma K. Stapleton, April A. Nelms, Kelsee C. Ryan & Miriam Segura-Totten. (2021) Insights on biology student motivations and challenges when reading and analyzing primary literature. PLOS ONE 16:5, pages e0251275.
Crossref
Teemu Lehtinen, Andre L. Santos & Juha Sorva. (2021) Let’s Ask Students About Their Programs, Automatically. Let’s Ask Students About Their Programs, Automatically.
Sujane Kandasamy, Meredith Vanstone, Eamon Colvin, Teresa Chan, Jonathan Sherbino & Sandra Monteiro. (2021) “I made a mistake!”: A narrative analysis of experienced physicians' stories of preventable error. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 27:2, pages 236-245.
Crossref
Alexander Repenning & Ashok Basawapatna. (2021) Smacking Screws with Hammers: Experiencing Affordances of Block-based Programming through the Hourglass Challenge. Smacking Screws with Hammers: Experiencing Affordances of Block-based Programming through the Hourglass Challenge.
Heather H. Aiken, Mary Bratsch‐Hines, Steve Amendum & Lynne Vernon‐Feagans. (2021) Targeted Reading Instruction: Four Guiding Principles. The Reading Teacher 74:5, pages 505-515.
Crossref
Gabriel Raubenheimer, Bryn Jeffries & Kalina Yacef. (2021) Toward Empirical Analysis of Pedagogical Feedback in Computer Programming Learning Environments. Toward Empirical Analysis of Pedagogical Feedback in Computer Programming Learning Environments.
Hiroko K. Warshauer, Christina Starkey, Christine A. Herrera & Shawnda Smith. (2019) Developing prospective teachers’ noticing and notions of productive struggle with video analysis in a mathematics content course. Journal of Mathematics Teacher Education 24:1, pages 89-121.
Crossref
Yong Zhao & Jim Watterston. (2021) The changes we need: Education post COVID-19. Journal of Educational Change 22:1, pages 3-12.
Crossref
Marcus Kubsch, Sebastian Opitz, Jeffrey Nordine, Knut Neumann, David Fortus & Joseph Krajcik. (2021) Exploring a pathway towards energy conservation through emphasizing the connections between energy, systems, and fields. Disciplinary and Interdisciplinary Science Education Research 3:1.
Crossref
Victoria Bleck & Frank Lipowsky. 2020. Handbuch Schulforschung. Handbuch Schulforschung 1 19 .
Adeela Arshad-Ayaz, M. Ayaz Naseem & Dania Mohamad. (2020) Engineering and humanitarian intervention: learning from failure. Journal of International Humanitarian Action 5:1.
Crossref
Ryan Brydges, Judy Tran, Alberto Goffi, Christie Lee, Daniel Miller & Maria Mylopoulos. (2020) Resident learning trajectories in the workplace: A self‐regulated learning analysis. Medical Education 54:12, pages 1120-1128.
Crossref
Erminia Pedretti & Ana Maria Navas Iannini. (2021) Towards Fourth-Generation Science Museums: Changing Goals, Changing Roles. Canadian Journal of Science, Mathematics and Technology Education 20:4, pages 700-714.
Crossref
Valentina Nachtigall, Katja Serova & Nikol Rummel. (2020) When failure fails to be productive: probing the effectiveness of productive failure for learning beyond STEM domains. Instructional Science 48:6, pages 651-697.
Crossref
Naomi Steenhof, Nicole N. Woods & Maria Mylopoulos. (2020) Exploring why we learn from productive failure: insights from the cognitive and learning sciences. Advances in Health Sciences Education 25:5, pages 1099-1106.
Crossref
Andreas H. AagesenRune D. JensenJeffrey J.H. CheungJohn B. ChristensenLars KongeRyan BrydgesEbbe ThinggaardKulamakan M. Kulasegaram. (2020) The Benefits of Tying Yourself in Knots: Unraveling the Learning Mechanisms of Guided Discovery Learning in an Open Surgical Skills Course. Academic Medicine 95:11S, pages S37-S43.
Crossref
Stephanie M. Halmo, Cheryl A. Sensibaugh, Peter Reinhart, Oleksandra Stogniy, Logan Fiorella & Paula P. Lemons. (2020) Advancing the Guidance Debate: Lessons from Educational Psychology and Implications for Biochemistry Learning. CBE—Life Sciences Education 19:3, pages ar41.
Crossref
Jennifer M Klasen, Erik Driessen, Pim W Teunissen & Lorelei A Lingard. (2020) ‘Whatever you cut, I can fix it’: clinical supervisors’ interview accounts of allowing trainee failure while guarding patient safety. BMJ Quality & Safety 29:9, pages 727-734.
Crossref
Ouhao Chen & Slava Kalyuga. (2019) Exploring factors influencing the effectiveness of explicit instruction first and problem-solving first approaches. European Journal of Psychology of Education 35:3, pages 607-624.
Crossref
Maggie Dahn, David Deliema & Noel Enyedy. (2020) Art as a Point of Departure for Understanding Student Experience in Learning to Code. Teachers College Record: The Voice of Scholarship in Education 122:8, pages 1-42.
Crossref
Jay Jennings & Kasia Muldner. (2020) Assistance that fades in improves learning better than assistance that fades out. Instructional Science 48:4, pages 371-394.
Crossref
Dragan Trninic, Manu Kapur & Tanmay Sinha. (2020) The Disappearing “Advantage of Abstract Examples in Learning Math”. Cognitive Science 44:7.
Crossref
Anne KawamuraIlene HarrisKaren ThomasBriseida MemaMaria Mylopoulos. (2019) Exploring How Pediatric Residents Develop Adaptive Expertise in Communication: The Importance of “Shifts” in Understanding Patient and Family Perspectives. Academic Medicine 95:7, pages 1066-1072.
Crossref
Richard E. Mayer. (2020) Advances in designing instruction based on examples. Applied Cognitive Psychology 34:4, pages 912-915.
Crossref
Wing Shing Lee. (2020) An Experimental Investigation Into the Application of a Learning-From-Mistakes Approach Among Freshmen Students. SAGE Open 10:2, pages 215824402093193.
Crossref
Katharina Loibl, Marcel Tillema, Nikol Rummel & Tamara van Gog. (2020) The effect of contrasting cases during problem solving prior to and after instruction. Instructional Science 48:2, pages 115-136.
Crossref
Ying-Chih Chen. (2020) Dialogic Pathways to Manage Uncertainty for Productive Engagement in Scientific Argumentation. Science & Education 29:2, pages 331-375.
Crossref
J. Madden, S. Pandita, J. P. Schuldt, B. Kim, A. S. Won & N. G. Holmes. (2020) Ready student one: Exploring the predictors of student learning in virtual reality. PLOS ONE 15:3, pages e0229788.
Crossref
Greg Ashman, Slava Kalyuga & John Sweller. (2019) Problem-solving or Explicit Instruction: Which Should Go First When Element Interactivity Is High?. Educational Psychology Review 32:1, pages 229-247.
Crossref
Anthony Sayster & Duncan Mhakure. 2020. Pedagogy in Basic and Higher Education - Current Developments and Challenges. Pedagogy in Basic and Higher Education - Current Developments and Challenges.
Michael J. Jacobson, Micah Goldwater, Lina Markauskaite, Polly K. Lai, Manu Kapur, Gareth Roberts & Courtney Hilton. (2020) Schema abstraction with productive failure and analogical comparison: Learning designs for far across domain transfer. Learning and Instruction 65, pages 101222.
Crossref
Amber Simpson, Alexandra Burris & Adam Maltese. (2017) Youth’s Engagement as Scientists and Engineers in an Afterschool Making and Tinkering Program. Research in Science Education 50:1, pages 1-22.
Crossref
Chong Ho Yu & Hyun Seo LeeChong Ho Yu & Hyun Seo Lee. 2020. Creating Change to Improve Science and Mathematics Education. Creating Change to Improve Science and Mathematics Education 101 124 .
Frank Lipowsky. 2020. Pädagogische Psychologie. Pädagogische Psychologie 69 118 .
Alexander Atanasyan, Dennis Kobelt, Marvin Goppold, Torben Cichon & Michael Schluse. 2020. Augmented Reality in Education. Augmented Reality in Education 71 86 .
Nina Bonderup Dohn, Lina Markauskaite & Roland Hachmann. 2020. Handbook of Research in Educational Communications and Technology. Handbook of Research in Educational Communications and Technology 73 96 .
Jason K. McDonald, Richard E. West, Peter J. Rich & Brad Hokanson. 2020. Handbook of Research in Educational Communications and Technology. Handbook of Research in Educational Communications and Technology 375 399 .
N. G. Holmes. 2020. Active Learning in College Science. Active Learning in College Science 271 290 .
Patricia Zagallo, Jill McCourt, Robert Idsardi, Michelle K. Smith, Mark Urban-Lurain, Tessa C. Andrews, Kevin Haudek, Jennifer K. Knight, John Merrill, Ross Nehm, Luanna B. Prevost & Paula P. Lemons. (2019) Through the Eyes of Faculty: Using Personas as a Tool for Learner-Centered Professional Development. CBE—Life Sciences Education 18:4, pages ar62.
Crossref
Samantha Yang, Zarah Chaudhary, Maria Mylopoulos, Rida Hashmi, Yvonne Kwok, Sarah Colman, Thirumagal Yogaparan & Sanjeev Sockalingam. (2019) Using simulation to explore medical students’ understanding of integrated care within geriatrics. BMC Medical Education 19:1.
Crossref
Meredith Young. (2019) The utility of failure: a taxonomy for research and scholarship. Perspectives on Medical Education 8:6, pages 365-371.
Crossref
Stella L Ng, Emilia Kangasjarvi, Gianni R Lorello, Lori Nemoy & Ryan Brydges. (2019) ‘There shouldn't be anything wrong with not knowing’: epistemologies in simulation. Medical Education 53:10, pages 1049-1059.
Crossref
J. Elizabeth Richey, Juan Miguel L. Andres-Bray, Michael Mogessie, Richard Scruggs, Juliana M.A.L. Andres, Jon R. Star, Ryan S. Baker & Bruce M. McLaren. (2019) More confusion and frustration, better learning: The impact of erroneous examples. Computers & Education 139, pages 173-190.
Crossref
Qian Zhang & Logan Fiorella. (2019) Role of generated and provided visuals in supporting learning from scientific text. Contemporary Educational Psychology 59, pages 101808.
Crossref
Amber Simpson, Alice Anderson & Adam V. Maltese. (2019) Caught on Camera: Youth and Educators’ Noticing of and Responding to Failure Within Making Contexts. Journal of Science Education and Technology 28:5, pages 480-492.
Crossref
Naomi Steenhof, Nicole N. Woods, Pascal W. M. Van Gerven & Maria Mylopoulos. (2019) Productive failure as an instructional approach to promote future learning. Advances in Health Sciences Education 24:4, pages 739-749.
Crossref
Yong Zhao, Michael Wehmeyer, James Basham & David Hansen. (2019) Tackling the Wicked Problem of Measuring What Matters: Framing the Questions. ECNU Review of Education 2:3, pages 262-278.
Crossref
Antonia Larrain, Paulina Freire, Valeska Grau, Patricia López & Camila Moran. (2019) The intertwined effect of collaborative argumentation and whole-class talk on the process of scientific concept learning: A case study. Learning, Culture and Social Interaction 22, pages 100249.
Crossref
Jan Olsson & Carina Granberg. (2018) Dynamic Software, Task Solving With or Without Guidelines, and Learning Outcomes. Technology, Knowledge and Learning 24:3, pages 419-436.
Crossref
Ying‐Chih Chen, Matthew J. Benus & Jaclyn Hernandez. (2019) Managing uncertainty in scientific argumentation. Science Education 103:5, pages 1235-1276.
Crossref
Phillip M. Newman & Marci S. DeCaro. (2019) Learning by exploring: How much guidance is optimal?. Learning and Instruction 62, pages 49-63.
Crossref
Andreas Lachner, Mona Weinhuber & Matthias Nückles. (2019) To teach or not to teach the conceptual structure of mathematics? Teachers undervalue the potential of Principle-Oriented explanations. Contemporary Educational Psychology 58, pages 175-185.
Crossref
Young-Jae JO. (2019) Development of Maker Education Program with Creative Problem Solving(CPS). JOURNAL OF FISHRIES AND MARINE SCIENCES EDUCATION 31:3, pages 856-876.
Crossref
Evelyn Palominos, Tracy Levett-Jones, Tamara Power & Roberto Martinez-Maldonado. (2019) Healthcare students' perceptions and experiences of making errors in simulation: An integrative review. Nurse Education Today 77, pages 32-39.
Crossref
Adrienne Tan, Zarah Chaudhary, Sanjeev Sockalingam & Maria Mylopoulos. (2019) When Strangers MEET: Making Every Encounter Therapeutic. Academic Psychiatry 43:3, pages 328-331.
Crossref
Rachel Lam. (2019) What students do when encountering failure in collaborative tasks. npj Science of Learning 4:1.
Crossref

Displaying 200 of 241 citing articles. Use the download link below to view the full list of citing articles.

Download full citations list

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.