1,016
Views
116
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
FEATURES

A National Perspective on the Effects of High-Stakes Testing and Standardization on Elementary Social Studies Marginalization

&
Pages 114-130 | Published online: 31 Jan 2012

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Read on this site (40)

Ryan E. Hughes & Wayne Journell. (2023) Facilitating a Controversial Issues Discussion in Elementary School about Using Indigenous Sports Mascots. The Social Studies 114:5, pages 223-240.
Read now
Sarah J. Kaka & Matthew Hollstein. (2023) Social Studies Teachers as Instructional Gatekeepers for Issues of Race and Justice. The Social Studies 114:2, pages 67-77.
Read now
Pablo Bezem, Anne Piezunka & Rebecca Jacobsen. (2022) School Inspectors’ Decision-making: Evidence from a Comparative Perspective. Leadership and Policy in Schools 0:0, pages 1-22.
Read now
Andrea M. Hawkman, Colby Tofel-Grehl, Kristin Searle & Beth L. MacDonald. (2022) Successes, challenges, and surprises: teacher reflections on using children’s literature to examine complex social issues in the elementary classroom. Teachers and Teaching 28:5, pages 584-602.
Read now
Jeremy Stoddard, Paul Fitchett & Diana Hess. (2022) Teaching the US 2018 midterm elections: a survey of secondary social studies teachers. Journal of Curriculum Studies 54:4, pages 536-558.
Read now
Ryan E. Hughes. (2022) “What is slavery?”: Third-grade students’ sensemaking about enslavement through historical inquiry. Theory & Research in Social Education 50:1, pages 29-73.
Read now
Anna Falkner & Katherina A. Payne. (2021) “Courage to take on the bull”: Cultural citizenship in fifth-grade social studies. Theory & Research in Social Education 49:1, pages 78-106.
Read now
K. Andrew R. Richards, Ben D. Kern, Suzan F. Ayers, Amelia Mays Woods & Kim C. Graber. (2021) A Theoretically Informed Conceptual Framework for Recruitment and Retention in PETE. Quest 73:1, pages 63-81.
Read now
Jack Leonard. (2020) Programmatic Effects of the Massachusetts Performance Assessment for Leaders. Leadership and Policy in Schools 19:3, pages 407-430.
Read now
Andrea S. Libresco. (2018) Noddings’ “Critical Lessons” May be Particularly Critical at the Elementary Level. Theory Into Practice 57:4, pages 281-288.
Read now
Emma S. Thacker, John K. Lee, Paul G. Fitchett & Wayne Journell. (2018) Secondary Social Studies Teachers’ Experiences Planning and Implementing Inquiry Using the Inquiry Design Model. The Clearing House: A Journal of Educational Strategies, Issues and Ideas 91:4-5, pages 193-200.
Read now
Kristy A. Brugar & Annie McMahon Whitlock. (2018) Social Studies Skills or Something Else? An Analysis of How the “Essential Social Studies Skills and Strategies” Reflects Social Studies Instruction. The Clearing House: A Journal of Educational Strategies, Issues and Ideas 91:3, pages 111-117.
Read now
Kristy A. Brugar, Kathryn L Roberts, Laura M. Jiménez & Carla K Meyer. (2018) More Than Mere Motivation: Learning Specific Content Through Multimodal Narratives. Literacy Research and Instruction 57:2, pages 183-208.
Read now
Andrew Hostetler, Pratim Sengupta & Ty Hollett. (2018) Unsilencing Critical Conversations in Social-Studies Teacher Education using Agent-based Modeling. Cognition and Instruction 36:2, pages 139-170.
Read now
Emma S. Thacker, Adam M. Friedman, Paul G. Fitchett, Wayne Journell & John K. Lee. (2018) Exploring How an Elementary Teacher Plans and Implements Social Studies Inquiry. The Social Studies 109:2, pages 85-100.
Read now
Marie Byrd & Bretton A. Varga. (2018) The Manifestation of Campbell's Law: Consequences of Eliminating of Social Studies From the Curriculum. The Social Studies 109:1, pages 27-33.
Read now
Tina L. Heafner. (2018) Elementary ELA/Social Studies Integration: Challenges and Limitations. The Social Studies 109:1, pages 1-12.
Read now
Kathryn L. Roberts & Kristy A. Brugar. (2017) The view from here: Emergence of graphical literacy. Reading Psychology 38:8, pages 733-777.
Read now
Mary Beth Henning & Thomas A. Lucey. (2017) Elementary Preservice Teachers’ and Teacher Educators’ Perceptions of Financial Literacy Education. The Social Studies 108:4, pages 163-173.
Read now
Neil O. Houser, Daniel G. Krutka, Rachael Province Roberts, Kimberly Pennington & Nina Faili Coerver. (2017) Navigating the Reform–Accountability Culture in Oklahoma Social Studies. Theory & Research in Social Education 45:1, pages 7-42.
Read now
Corey Ranshaw Sell & Krista Griffin. (2017) Powerful Social Studies Teaching With Poetry and Primary Sources. The Social Studies 108:1, pages 1-9.
Read now
Judith M. Harrington. (2016) “We're All Kids!” Picture Books and Cultural Awareness. The Social Studies 107:6, pages 244-256.
Read now
Ann Marie Gleeson & Lisa Andries D'Souza. (2016) Reframing a Social Studies Methods Course: Preparing Elementary Teacher Candidates for the Common Core. The Social Studies 107:5, pages 165-170.
Read now
Annie McMahon Whitlock. (2015) Economics through Inquiry: Creating Social Businesses in Fifth Grade. The Social Studies 106:3, pages 117-125.
Read now
Cheryl A. Torrez & Elizabeth Ann Claunch-Lebsack. (2014) The Present Absence: Assessment in Social Studies Classrooms. Action in Teacher Education 36:5-6, pages 559-570.
Read now
Ebony O. McGee & Andrew L. Hostetler. (2014) Historicizing Mathematics and Mathematizing Social Studies for Social Justice: A Call for Integration. Equity & Excellence in Education 47:2, pages 208-229.
Read now
Derek Anderson. (2014) Outliers: Elementary Teachers Who Actually Teach Social Studies. The Social Studies 105:2, pages 91-100.
Read now
Stephanie C. Serriere. (2014) The Role of the Elementary Teacher in Fostering Civic Efficacy. The Social Studies 105:1, pages 45-56.
Read now
Thomas A. Lucey & Barbara B. Meyer. (2013) Does Social Studies Teaching Uphold the Citizenship Values to Which Students Should Aspire? Survey Findings from One State. Action in Teacher Education 35:5-6, pages 462-474.
Read now
Anne-Lise Halvorsen, Nell K. Duke, Kristy A. Brugar, Meghan K. Block, Stephanie L. Strachan, Meghan B. Berka & Jason M. Brown. (2012) Narrowing the Achievement Gap in Second-Grade Social Studies and Content Area Literacy: The Promise of a Project-Based Approach. Theory & Research in Social Education 40:3, pages 198-229.
Read now
TinaL. Heafner & PaulG. Fitchett. (2012) National Trends in Elementary Instruction: Exploring the Role of Social Studies Curricula. The Social Studies 103:2, pages 67-72.
Read now
JudithL. Pace. (2011) The Complex and Unequal Impact of High Stakes Accountability On Untested Social Studies. Theory & Research in Social Education 39:1, pages 32-60.
Read now
Jenni Conrad, Jennifer Lynn Gallagher & Wendy Chan. Getting critical with compelling questions: Shifts in elementary teacher candidates’ curriculum planning from inquiry to critical inquiry. Theory & Research in Social Education 0:0, pages 1-43.
Read now
Katherina A. Payne. Developing mutually respectful research-practice partnerships while engaging young citizens. Theory & Research in Social Education 0:0, pages 1-5.
Read now
Rachel K. Turner, Ryan T. Knowles & Joe Cochran. Profile of an Elementary Teacher—How Instructional Strategies Differ across Elementary Classrooms. The Social Studies 0:0, pages 1-12.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (76)

Colleen Fitzpatrick & Adam Friedman. (2024) “I got knocked down”: factors impacting a novice teacher’s decision making. Social Studies Research and Practice.
Crossref
Julie L Pennington, Kathryn M Obenchain, Hannah Carter & Melissa Bedford. (2019) ‘We have the right to stand up’: Elementary students’ conceptual understandings of civic virtue and engagement. Education, Citizenship and Social Justice 19:1, pages 3-22.
Crossref
İlhan İLTER & Yaşar ÇİMEN. (2023) Öğrencilerin Sosyal Bilgiler Dersini Öğrenme Nedenleri, Öğrenme Sürecinde Karşılaştıkları Sorunlar ve Sosyal Bilgiler Öğretmenlerinden BeklentileriThe Reasons of Students to Learn Social Studies, Problems They Encountered During the Learning Process, and Their Expectations from Social Studies Teachers. Dokuz Eylül Üniversitesi Buca Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi:58, pages 2278-2308.
Crossref
Kristy A. Brugar. (2023) The possibilities of teaching the past: fifth grade teachers' instructional choices. Social Studies Research and Practice 18:3, pages 181-197.
Crossref
Stephen Day, Evelyn Nunes & Bruno Sultanum. (2022) Is It Still an Economics Course? The Effect of a Standardized Personal Finance Test on the Learning of Economics. The American Economist 68:2, pages 277-294.
Crossref
Mary L. Neville & Kaitlin E. Popielarz. (2023) “Living in These Two Places Really Shaped My Life”: Examining Multimodal Playlist Assignments in Social Studies and Language Arts Methods Courses. The Journal of Social Studies Research 47:3-4, pages 173-183.
Crossref
Ryan E. Hughes & Pratigya Marhatta. (2023) Learning to ask their own questions: How elementary students develop social studies inquiry questions. Teaching and Teacher Education 127, pages 104094.
Crossref
Tina Lane Heafner. 2023. Handbook of Research on Solutions for Equity and Social Justice in Education. Handbook of Research on Solutions for Equity and Social Justice in Education 263 297 .
Katherine Perrotta. (2023) Stuck in a box: Elementary teacher education students’ perspectives of the impact of edTPA on social studies instruction. The Journal of Social Studies Research 47:1, pages 3-14.
Crossref
William Toledo & Esther A. Enright. (2022) Reconceptualizing Civic Perspective-Taking. The Elementary School Journal 123:1, pages 64-98.
Crossref
Vural TÜNKLER. (2022) SOSYAL BİLGİLER DERSİNDE ÖĞRENCİ MOTİVASYONU: BEKLENTİ-DEĞER YAKLAŞIMISTUDENT MOTIVATION IN SOCIAL STUDIES CLASS: AN EXPECTANCY-VALUE APPROACH. Milli Eğitim Dergisi 51:233, pages 219-236.
Crossref
Thomas C. Hammond, Julie L. Oltman & Meghan M. Manfra. 2022. Research Anthology on Computational Thinking, Programming, and Robotics in the Classroom. Research Anthology on Computational Thinking, Programming, and Robotics in the Classroom 79 93 .
Shira Eve Epstein & Brett L. M. Levy. (2021) Chapter 7: Learning to Teach for Civic Engagement: Opportunities and Constraints for Three Teachers in One Urban Elementary School. Teachers College Record: The Voice of Scholarship in Education 123:13, pages 1-28.
Crossref
Alyssa J. Whitford. (2021) Exploring the impact of interactive read-alouds on student perceptions of women’s history. Social Studies Research and Practice 16:2, pages 144-157.
Crossref
Rachel Roegman, Rachael Kenney, Yukiko Maeda & Gary Johns. (2019) When Data-Driven Decision Making Becomes Data-Driven Test Taking: A Case Study of a Midwestern High School. Educational Policy 35:4, pages 535-565.
Crossref
Stephanie Schroeder, Natasha C. Murray-Everett, Jacob Gates & Sarah B. Shear. (2023) Informing, transforming, inquiring: Approaches to elementary social studies in methods course syllabi. The Journal of Social Studies Research 45:2, pages 102-117.
Crossref
Justin D. Garwood, Stephen Ciullo, Daniel R. Wissinger & John W. McKenna. (2020) Civics Education for Students With Learning Disabilities and Emotional and Behavioral Disorders. Intervention in School and Clinic 56:4, pages 250-254.
Crossref
Nicholas Lawrence, Joseph O'Brien, Brian Bechard, Ed Finney & Kimberly Gilman. 2020. Research Anthology on Instilling Social Justice in the Classroom. Research Anthology on Instilling Social Justice in the Classroom 1312 1331 .
Elizabeth Kenyon & Andrea Christoff. (2023) Global citizenship education through global children's literature: An analysis of the NCSS Notable Trade Books. The Journal of Social Studies Research 44:4, pages 397-408.
Crossref
Marcus W. Johnson & Maureen W. Nicol. (2020) Introducing Curricular and Pedagogical Resuscitation (CPR): A Black Approach to Reviving the Self and Collective through Social Studies. Urban Education, pages 004208592094894.
Crossref
Katie Z. Revelle, Crystal N. Wise, Nell K. Duke & Anne‐Lise Halvorsen. (2019) Realizing the Promise of Project‐Based Learning. The Reading Teacher 73:6, pages 697-710.
Crossref
Thomas C. Hammond, Julie L. Oltman & Meghan M. Manfra. 2019. Handbook of Research on Integrating Computer Science and Computational Thinking in K-12 Education. Handbook of Research on Integrating Computer Science and Computational Thinking in K-12 Education 1 16 .
Jennifer Johnson. (2019) Using found poetry to cultivate student literacy, empathy, and creativity. Social Studies Research and Practice 14:3, pages 335-348.
Crossref
Tina L. Heafner, Phillip J. VanFossen & Paul G. Fitchett. (2023) Predictors of Students’ Achievement on Naep-Economics: A Multilevel Model. The Journal of Social Studies Research 43:4, pages 327-341.
Crossref
Harper B. Keenan. (2019) Selective Memory: California Mission History and the Problem of Historical Violence in Elementary School Textbooks. Teachers College Record: The Voice of Scholarship in Education 121:8, pages 1-28.
Crossref
Annie McMahon Whitlock & Kristy A. Brugar. (2023) Teaching Elementary Social Studies during Snack Time and other Unstructured Spaces. The Journal of Social Studies Research 43:3, pages 229-239.
Crossref
Tina L. Heafner & Jessica Norwood. (2023) An Elementary Social Studies Teacher's Quest to Develop Democratic Citizens: The Boundaries of Ambitious Teaching. The Journal of Social Studies Research 43:3, pages 187-198.
Crossref
Janie Hubbard. (2023) K-6 Pre-Service Teachers’ Emerging Professional Identities as Social Studies Educators. The Journal of Social Studies Research 43:3, pages 269-283.
Crossref
Tracey S. Hodges, Katherine Landau Wright, Julianne M. Coleman, Holly Hilboldt Swain, Claire Schweiker & Behzad Mansouri. (2019) Elementary classroom libraries and social studies trade books. Social Studies Research and Practice 14:1, pages 14-27.
Crossref
Kristy A. Brugar & Annie McMahon Whitlock. (2019) “I like […] different time periods:” elementary teachers’ uses of historical fiction. Social Studies Research and Practice 14:1, pages 78-97.
Crossref
Katherina A. Payne & Wayne Journell. (2019) “We have those kinds of conversations here …”: Addressing contentious politics with elementary students. Teaching and Teacher Education 79, pages 73-82.
Crossref
Phyllis Gray, Audrey C. Rule & Mindy Gordon. (2015) Black Fifth Graders Make Dioramas of Traditional African Cultures to Explore Racial Identity, Cultural Universals, and Spatial Thinking. Urban Education 54:2, pages 274-308.
Crossref
Nicholas Lawrence, Joseph O'Brien, Brian Bechard, Ed Finney & Kimberly Gilman. 2019. Emerging Trends in Cyber Ethics and Education. Emerging Trends in Cyber Ethics and Education 40 64 .
Reinhold Hedtke, Andrea Szukala & Claude Proeschel. 2019. Bildung und Konventionen. Bildung und Konventionen 281 307 .
Dana Mitra. (2018) Student voice in secondary schools: the possibility for deeper change. Journal of Educational Administration 56:5, pages 473-487.
Crossref
Jason Niedermeyer. (2018) Making the Science Classroom a Place for Wonder. The American Biology Teacher 80:6, pages 416-422.
Crossref
Tina L. Heafner. (2023) More social studies?: Examining instructional policies of time and testing in elementary school. The Journal of Social Studies Research 42:3, pages 229-237.
Crossref
S. G. Grant. 2018. The Wiley International Handbook of History Teaching and Learning. The Wiley International Handbook of History Teaching and Learning 419 448 .
Nick Lawrence & Joe O'Brien. 2018. Social Media in Education. Social Media in Education 219 233 .
Jonathan A. Plucker & Scott J. Peters. (2017) Closing Poverty-Based Excellence Gaps: Conceptual, Measurement, and Educational Issues. Gifted Child Quarterly 62:1, pages 56-67.
Crossref
Kristy A. Brugar & Kathryn L. Roberts. (2023) Elementary students’ challenges with informational texts: Reading the words and the world. The Journal of Social Studies Research 42:1, pages 49-59.
Crossref
Tina L. Heafner & Paul G. Fitchett. (2023) US History Content Knowledge and Associated Effects of Race, Gender, Wealth, and Urbanity: Item Response Theory (IRT) Modeling of NAEP-USH Achievement. The Journal of Social Studies Research 42:1, pages 11-25.
Crossref
Michael Alan Neel & Amy Palmeri. (2017) Meeting the demands of the C3 framework in elementary social studies methods. Social Studies Research and Practice 12:3, pages 358-371.
Crossref
Heather Rogers Haverback. (2017) Why don’t we teach social studies? Preservice teachers’ social studies self-efficacy. Social Studies Research and Practice 12:3, pages 245-257.
Crossref
Smith Grinell & Colette Rabin. (2017) Caring Enough to Teach Science. Science & Education 26:7-9, pages 813-839.
Crossref
Paul G. Fitchett & Tina L. Heafner. (2017) Student demographics and teacher characteristics as predictors of elementary-age students' history knowledge: Implications for teacher education and practice. Teaching and Teacher Education 67, pages 79-92.
Crossref
Katherina Ann Payne, James V. Hoffman & Samuel DeJulio. (2017) Doing democracy through simulation, deliberation, and inquiry with elementary students. Social Studies Research and Practice 12:1, pages 56-69.
Crossref
Kristy A. Brugar & Kathryn L. Roberts. (2017) Seeing Is Believing. Journal of Teacher Education 68:3, pages 262-279.
Crossref
Emma S. Thacker, John K. Lee & Adam M. Friedman. (2023) Teaching with the C3 Framework: Surveying Teachers' Beliefs and Practices. The Journal of Social Studies Research 41:2, pages 89-100.
Crossref
Paul G. Fitchett & Tina L. Heafner. 2017. The Wiley Handbook of Social Studies Research. The Wiley Handbook of Social Studies Research 68 94 .
S. G. Grant. 2017. The Wiley Handbook of Social Studies Research. The Wiley Handbook of Social Studies Research 461 476 .
Ilene R. Berson, Michael J. Berson, Danielle V. Dennis & Rebecca Lovering Powell. 2017. The Wiley Handbook of Social Studies Research. The Wiley Handbook of Social Studies Research 414 439 .
Anne‐Lise Halvorsen. 2017. The Wiley Handbook of Social Studies Research. The Wiley Handbook of Social Studies Research 385 413 .
Margaret Smith Crocco & Ellen Livingston. 2017. The Wiley Handbook of Social Studies Research. The Wiley Handbook of Social Studies Research 360 384 .
Sohyun An. (2023) Preparing Elementary School Teachers for Social Studies Instruction in the Context of Edtpa. The Journal of Social Studies Research 41:1, pages 25-35.
Crossref
Kathryn Haughney & Diane Browder. 2017. Curricula for Teaching Students with Autism Spectrum Disorder. Curricula for Teaching Students with Autism Spectrum Disorder 137 160 .
Tina L. Heafner & Michelle Plaisance. (2016) Exploring how Institutional Structures and Practices Influence English Learners’ Opportunity to Learn Social Studies. Teachers College Record: The Voice of Scholarship in Education 118:8, pages 1-36.
Crossref
Elizabeth E. Saylor. (2023) Book Review: Civic Education in Elementary Grades: Promoting Student Engagement in An Era of Accountability (2016). The Journal of Social Studies Research 40:3, pages 245-247.
Crossref
Theresa A. Deeney. (2016) Pre- and in-Service Teachers Reading and Discussing Informational Texts. SAGE Open 6:2, pages 215824401664799.
Crossref
Kristy A. Brugar. (2017) Teaching Social Studies/History to Elementary School Students through a Discipline-Specific Approach. Journal of Education 196:2, pages 101-110.
Crossref
Brandt W. Pryor, Caroline R Pryor & Rui Kang. (2023) Teachers’ Thoughts on Integrating Stem into Social Studies Instruction: Beliefs, Attitudes, and Behavioral Decisions. The Journal of Social Studies Research 40:2, pages 123-136.
Crossref
Thomas A. Lucey. 2016. International Handbook of Financial Literacy. International Handbook of Financial Literacy 655 673 .
Annie McMahon Whitlock, Kristy A. Brugar & Anne-Lise Halvorsen. 2016. Rethinking Social Studies Teacher Education in the Twenty-First Century. Rethinking Social Studies Teacher Education in the Twenty-First Century 167 187 .
Debby Shulsky & Elaine Y. Hendrix. 2016. Rethinking Social Studies Teacher Education in the Twenty-First Century. Rethinking Social Studies Teacher Education in the Twenty-First Century 101 119 .
Tina L. Heafner, Paul G. Fitchett & Ryan T. Knowles. 2016. Rethinking Social Studies Teacher Education in the Twenty-First Century. Rethinking Social Studies Teacher Education in the Twenty-First Century 359 383 .
Wayne Journell. (2015) We Still Need You! An Update on the Status of K-12 Civics Education in the United States. PS: Political Science & Politics 48:04, pages 630-634.
Crossref
Hyeri Hong & Gregory E. Hamot. (2023) The Associations of Teacher Professional Characteristics, School Environmental Factors, and State Testing Policy on Social Studies Educators’ Instructional Authority. The Journal of Social Studies Research 39:4, pages 225-241.
Crossref
Andrea M. Hawkman, Antonio J. Castro, Linda B. Bennett & Lloyd H. Barrow. (2023) Where is the Content?: Elementary Social Studies in Preservice Field Experiences. The Journal of Social Studies Research 39:4, pages 197-206.
Crossref
Beverly Milner Bisland. (2014) An Exploration of the Impact of Accountability Testing on Teaching in Urban Elementary Classrooms. The Urban Review 47:3, pages 433-465.
Crossref
Jeremy Hilburn & Brad M. Maguth. (2023) Spatial Citizenship Education: Civic Teachers’ Instructional Priorities and Approaches. The Journal of Social Studies Research 39:2, pages 107-118.
Crossref
Tina L. Heafner, Eric Groce, Elizabeth Bellows, Heather Coffey & Mette Evelyn Bjerre. 2015. Curriculum Design and Classroom Management. Curriculum Design and Classroom Management 1314 1357 .
Tina L. Heafner, Eric Groce, Elizabeth Bellows, Heather Coffey & Mette Evelyn Bjerre. 2015. Exploring the Effectiveness of Online Education in K-12 Environments. Exploring the Effectiveness of Online Education in K-12 Environments 385 429 .
Paul G. Fitchett, Tina L. Heafner & Richard Lambert. (2014) Assessment, Autonomy, and Elementary Social Studies Time. Teachers College Record: The Voice of Scholarship in Education 116:10, pages 1-34.
Crossref
Paul G. Fitchett, Tina L. Heafner & Richard G. Lambert. (2012) Examining Elementary Social Studies Marginalization. Educational Policy 28:1, pages 40-68.
Crossref
Tina L. Heafner, George B. Lipscomb & Paul G. Fitchett. (2023) Instructional Practices of Elementary Social Studies Teachers in North and South Carolina. The Journal of Social Studies Research 38:1, pages 15-31.
Crossref
Janie Hubbard. (2023) Social studies marginalization: Examining the effects on K-6 pre-service teachers and students. The Journal of Social Studies Research 37:3, pages 137-150.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.