Advanced search
Publication Cover
West European Politics Volume 42, 2019 - Issue 6: Varieties of Populism in Europe in Times of Crises
Submit an article Journal homepage
4,008
Views
112
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Articles

Beyond left and right: the eclectic populism of the Five Star Movement

Lorenzo Moscaa Department of Social and Political Sciences, State University of Milan, Milan, ItalyCorrespondence[email protected]
ORCID Iconhttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-3248-0489
ORCID Icon &
Filippo Tronconib Department of Political and Social Sciences, University of Bologna, Bologna, ItalyORCID Iconhttps://orcid.org/0000-0003-4529-5968
ORCID Icon
Pages 1258-1283 | Published online: 13 May 2019

Citations (112)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (40)

Reinhard Heinisch & Viktoria Jansesberger. (2024) Lacking control – analysing the demand side of populist party support. European Politics and Society 25:2, pages 266-285.
Read now
Francesco Maria Scanni. (2024) Populism and the New Radical Right: A Necessary Distinction. Social Epistemology 0:0, pages 1-17.
Read now
Michela Ceccorulli, Fabrizio Coticchia & Stella Gianfreda. (2023) The government of change? Migration and defence policy under Giuseppe Conte’s first cabinet. Contemporary Italian Politics 15:4, pages 432-449.
Read now
Mirko Crulli. (2023) The three faces of a populist party: insights into the organizational evolution of the Five-star Movement. Contemporary Italian Politics 15:4, pages 413-431.
Read now
David Swanson & Sergiu Gherghina. (2023) From opposition to government: how populist parties change their political communication in Northern Ireland. Irish Political Studies 38:4, pages 489-515.
Read now
Lorenzo Mosca & Davide Vittori. (2023) A digital principal? Substantive representation in the case of the Italian Five Star Movement. European Societies 25:4, pages 627-656.
Read now
Michael W. Bauer. (2023) Public Administration Under Populist Rule: Standing Up Against Democratic Backsliding. International Journal of Public Administration 0:0, pages 1-13.
Read now
Jonathan Pratschke, Tommaso Vitale, Niccolò Morelli, Bruno Cousin, Matteo Piolatto & Matteo Del Fabbro. (2023) Electoral support for the 5 Star Movement in Milan: An ecological analysis of social and spatial factors. Journal of Urban Affairs 45:5, pages 998-1021.
Read now
Jakob Schwörer, Belén Fernández-García & Manuela Caiani. (2023) Challengers or the Establishment? How Populists Talk About Populists. German Politics 0:0, pages 1-25.
Read now
Enzo Loner. (2023) Enemies and friends. The instrumental social construction of populist identity through twitter in Italy at the time of COVID-19. European Journal of Cultural and Political Sociology 10:2, pages 279-308.
Read now
Emidio Diodato. (2023) The UE turn of a populist movement: at the roots of the Five-star Movement’s foreign-policy agenda. Contemporary Italian Politics 15:1, pages 60-74.
Read now
Matteo C. M. Casiraghi & Margherita Bordignon. (2023) The rhetorical contestation of populism in four European parliaments (2010–2020). West European Politics 46:1, pages 173-195.
Read now
Nicolò Conti, Danilo Di Mauro & Vincenzo Memoli. (2022) Think European, act local: do Italians think of Europe when they vote in national elections?. European Politics and Society 23:5, pages 617-638.
Read now
Felipe G. Santos & Dorit Geva. (2022) Populist strategy in the European parliament: How the anti-gender movement sabotaged deliberation about sexual health and reproductive rights. European Journal of Cultural and Political Sociology 9:4, pages 475-501.
Read now
Soraya Hamdaoui. (2022) A “stylistic anti-populism”: an analysis of the Sardine movement’s opposition to Matteo Salvini in Italy. Social Movement Studies 21:4, pages 436-452.
Read now
Bálint Mikola. (2022) A programme written by citizens? Agenda-setters and veto players in drafting the 2018 election manifesto of the Five-star Movement. Contemporary Italian Politics 14:3, pages 293-313.
Read now
Luana Russo & Marco Valbruzzi. (2022) The impact of the pandemic on the Italian party system. The Draghi government and the ‘new’ polarisation. Contemporary Italian Politics 14:2, pages 172-190.
Read now
Andrea Pettrachin & Fred Paxton. (2022) How do populists make decisions? The Five Star Movement and the Lega in local government during the ‘refugee crisis’. Contemporary Italian Politics 14:1, pages 24-48.
Read now
Vincenzo Emanuele, Andrés Santana & José Rama. (2022) Anatomy of the Italian populist breakthrough: a ‘demarcationist’ fuel driving Lega and Five-star Movement electoral success?. Contemporary Italian Politics 14:1, pages 49-67.
Read now
Luca Carrieri & Davide Vittori. (2021) Defying Europe? The Euroscepticism of radical right and radical left voters in Western Europe. Journal of European Integration 43:8, pages 955-971.
Read now
Steve Wood. (2021) Where is the middle? Considering the socio-political centre in Germany. European Politics and Society 22:5, pages 733-756.
Read now
Fred Paxton. (2021) Varieties of inclusionary and exclusionary populism in the Italian regional elections 2018-20. Contemporary Italian Politics 13:4, pages 402-422.
Read now
Silvia Bolgherini, Selena Grimaldi & Aldo Paparo. (2021) National and local effects in the Italian regional elections (2018-2020). Beyond second-order election expectations?. Contemporary Italian Politics 13:4, pages 441-461.
Read now
Dan Mercea & Lorenzo Mosca. (2021) Understanding movement parties through their communication. Information, Communication & Society 24:10, pages 1327-1343.
Read now
Lorenzo Mosca & Mario Quaranta. (2021) Are digital platforms potential drivers of the populist vote? A comparative analysis of France, Germany and Italy. Information, Communication & Society 24:10, pages 1441-1459.
Read now
Andrea Ceron, Alessandro Gandini & Patrizio Lodetti. (2021) Still ‘fire in the (full) belly’? Anti-establishment rhetoric before and after government participation. Information, Communication & Society 24:10, pages 1460-1476.
Read now
Davide Angelucci & Davide Vittori. (2021) Are All Populist Voters the Same? Institutional Distrust and the Five Star Movement in Italy. South European Society and Politics 26:3, pages 303-327.
Read now
Robert A. Huber, Tomas Maltby, Kacper Szulecki & Stefan Ćetković. (2021) Is populism a challenge to European energy and climate policy? Empirical evidence across varieties of populism. Journal of European Public Policy 28:7, pages 998-1017.
Read now
Francesco Bloise, Daniela Chironi & Mario Pianta. (2021) Inequality and voting in Italy’s regions. Territory, Politics, Governance 9:3, pages 365-390.
Read now
Manuela Caiani & Tiago Carvalho. (2021) The use of religion by populist parties: the case of Italy and its broader implications. Religion, State and Society 49:3, pages 211-230.
Read now
Lorenzo Cladi & Andrea Locatelli. (2021) Explaining Italian foreign policy adjustment after Brexit: a Neoclassical realist account. Journal of European Integration 43:4, pages 459-473.
Read now
Davide Vampa. (2021) The 2020 regional elections in Italy: sub-national politics in the year of the pandemic. Contemporary Italian Politics 13:2, pages 166-180.
Read now
Alessandro Pellegata & Francesco Visconti. (2021) Transnationalism and Welfare Chauvinism in Italy: Evidence from the 2018 Election Campaign. South European Society and Politics 26:1, pages 55-82.
Read now
Nicolò Conti, Andrea Pedrazzani & Federico Russo. (2020) Policy Polarisation in Italy: The Short and Conflictual Life of the ‘Government of Change’ (2018–2019). South European Society and Politics 25:3-4, pages 317-350.
Read now
Filippo Tronconi & Marco Valbruzzi. (2020) Populism Put to the Polarisation Test: The 2019–20 Election Cycle in Italy. South European Society and Politics 25:3-4, pages 475-501.
Read now
Andrew Geddes & Andrea Pettrachin. (2020) Italian migration policy and politics: Exacerbating paradoxes. Contemporary Italian Politics 12:2, pages 227-242.
Read now
Gianfranco Pasquino & Marco Valbruzzi. (2019) The 2019 European Elections: a ‘second-order’ vote with ‘first-order’ effects. Journal of Modern Italian Studies 24:5, pages 736-756.
Read now
Manuela Caiani & Paolo Graziano. (2019) Understanding varieties of populism in times of crises. West European Politics 42:6, pages 1141-1158.
Read now
Sarah Engler, Bartek Pytlas & Kevin Deegan-Krause. (2019) Assessing the diversity of anti-establishment and populist politics in Central and Eastern Europe. West European Politics 42:6, pages 1310-1336.
Read now
Silvia Decadri & Fedra Negri. Playing populist: the relationship of convenience between populist language and demarcationist ideological positions in the Italian parliament (1948-2020). South European Society and Politics 0:0, pages 1-26.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (72)

Carlo Berti. (2024) A tale of multiple crises: Populist and non-populist narratives in European institutions from the Great Recession to the 2024 European elections. Catalan Journal of Communication & Cultural Studies 16:1, pages 129-138.
Crossref
Daniela Giannetti, Karen Umansky & Itai Sened. (2022) The Entry of the M5S and the Reshaping of Party Politics in Italy (2008–2018). Government and Opposition 59:2, pages 464-481.
Crossref
Camille Bedock & Bartolomeo Cappellina. (2023) Beyond digital populism: civic culture and visions of political participation among Five Star Movement activists. Italian Political Science Review/Rivista Italiana di Scienza Politica 54:1, pages 70-83.
Crossref
Francesco Bloise, Daniela Chironi, Donatella della Porta & Mario Pianta. (2023) Inequality and Elections in Italy, 1994–2018. Italian Economic Journal 10:1, pages 1-23.
Crossref
Alice Sibley. (2023) Behind the British New Far-Right’s veil: Do individuals adopt strategic liberalism to appear more moderate or are they semi-liberal?. The British Journal of Politics and International Relations 26:1, pages 79-95.
Crossref
MATTEO C. M. CASIRAGHI, LUIGI CURINI & ALESSANDRO NAI. (2023) Populism in the eye of the beholder? A conjoint experiment on citizens’ identification of populists. European Journal of Political Research 63:1, pages 214-235.
Crossref
Felipe G. Santos & Dan Mercea. (2024) Young democrats, critical citizens and protest voters: studying the profiles of movement party supporters. Acta Politica.
Crossref
Carlo Berti, Arantxa Capdevila & Carlota M. Moragas-Fernández. (2024) What is populism anyway? Newspaper representations of populism in Spain and Italy between emptiness and political partisanship. Journalism.
Crossref
Gabriele Di Cicco, Laura Prislei & Gilda Sensales. 2024. Political Psychology Perspectives on Populism. Political Psychology Perspectives on Populism 347 404 .
Valerio Pellegrini, Mauro Giacomantonio & Luigi Leone. 2024. Political Psychology Perspectives on Populism. Political Psychology Perspectives on Populism 139 185 .
Saija Räsänen, Roberto De Rosa & Dario Quattromani. 2024. Populism, Twitter and the European Public Sphere. Populism, Twitter and the European Public Sphere 117 143 .
Mirko Crulli & Gabriele Pinto. (2023) The urban roots of populism: Mapping and explaining populist strongholds within major Italian cities (2013–2022). European Urban and Regional Studies.
Crossref
Manuela Caiani & Jessica Di Cocco. (2023) Populism and emotions: a comparative study using Machine Learning. Italian Political Science Review/Rivista Italiana di Scienza Politica 53:3, pages 351-366.
Crossref
Silja Häusermann, Thomas Kurer & Delia Zollinger. (2023) Aspiration Versus Apprehension: Economic Opportunities and Electoral Preferences. British Journal of Political Science 53:4, pages 1230-1251.
Crossref
Daniel Bischof & Thomas Kurer. (2023) Place-Based Campaigning: The Political Impact of Real Grassroots Mobilization. The Journal of Politics 85:3, pages 984-1002.
Crossref
Luca Serafini, Anita Gottlob, Francesco Pierri, Francesca Ieva & Stefano Ceri. (2023) Risk Narratives on Immigration During the COVID-19 Crisis in Italy: A Comparative Analysis of Facebook Posts Published by Politicians and by News media. Journal of Communication Inquiry, pages 019685992311679.
Crossref
Antonio Martella & Elena Pavan. (2023) “We hate her . . . and you too”: Polarized intersectionality in Italy throughout changing political scenarios. New Media & Society, pages 146144482311607.
Crossref
Camilla Mariotto & Alessandro Pellegata. (2022) Should EU member states help each other? How the national context shapes individual preferences for European solidarity. Comparative European Politics 21:1, pages 42-63.
Crossref
Valerio Pellegrini. (2023) Populist ideology, ideological attitudes, and anti-immigration attitudes as an integrated system of beliefs. PLOS ONE 18:1, pages e0280285.
Crossref
Fabrizio Li Vigni & Enka Blanchard. (2023) « Partis plateforme » versus « partis en réseau ». Réseaux N° 236:6, pages 57-93.
Crossref
Riccardo Bruni, Alessandro Gioffré & Maria Marino. (2023) In-Group Bias in Preferences for Redistribution: A Survey Experiment in Italy. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Crossref
Balu Sunilraj & Aashti Salman. 2023. Encyclopedia of New Populism and Responses in the 21st Century. Encyclopedia of New Populism and Responses in the 21st Century 1 7 .
Fabrizio Coticchia & Bertjan Verbeek. 2023. Political Communication and Performative Leadership. Political Communication and Performative Leadership 125 145 .
Flaminia Saccà & Donatella SelvaFlaminia Saccà & Donatella Selva. 2023. European Political Leaders and the Social Representation of the Covid-19 Crisis. European Political Leaders and the Social Representation of the Covid-19 Crisis 87 96 .
Manuela Caiani & Enrico PadoanManuela Caiani & Enrico Padoan. 2023. Populism and (Pop) Music. Populism and (Pop) Music 63 88 .
Manuela Caiani & Enrico PadoanManuela Caiani & Enrico Padoan. 2023. Populism and (Pop) Music. Populism and (Pop) Music 1 62 .
Thorsten WojczewskiThorsten Wojczewski. 2023. The Inter- and Transnational Politics of Populism. The Inter- and Transnational Politics of Populism 327 342 .
Thorsten WojczewskiThorsten Wojczewski. 2023. The Inter- and Transnational Politics of Populism. The Inter- and Transnational Politics of Populism 73 104 .
Marco R. Di Tommaso, Elena Prodi, Dante Di Matteo & Ilaria Mariotti. (2022) Local public spending, electoral consensus, and sustainable structural change. Structural Change and Economic Dynamics 63, pages 435-453.
Crossref
Hugo Marcos-Marne. (2021) The Effects of Basic Human Values on Populist Voting. An Analysis of 13 European Democracies. Political Behavior 44:4, pages 1863-1881.
Crossref
Fabrizio Li Vigni. (2022) Un cube idéal-typique pour l’étude de la plateformisation de la politique. Terminal:134-135.
Crossref
Alain Van Hiel, Jasper Van Assche, Tessa Haesevoets, David De Cremer & Gordon Hodson. (2021) A Radical Vision of Radicalism: Political Cynicism, not Incrementally Stronger Partisan Positions, Explains Political Radicalization. Political Psychology 43:S1, pages 3-28.
Crossref
Alice Cavalieri & Caterina Froio. (2021) The behaviour of populist parties in parliament. The policy agendas of populist and other political parties in the Italian question time. Italian Political Science Review/Rivista Italiana di Scienza Politica 52:3, pages 283-296.
Crossref
İhsan KONAK. (2022) İTALYAN BEŞ YILDIZ HAREKETİ ÜZERİNE BİR DEĞERLENDİRMEAN EVALUATION OF THE ITALIAN FIVE STAR MOVEMENT. Bingöl Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü Dergisi:24, pages 424-440.
Crossref
Kenneth M. Roberts. (2021) Populism and Polarization in Comparative Perspective: Constitutive, Spatial and Institutional Dimensions. Government and Opposition 57:4, pages 680-702.
Crossref
Lorenzo Mosca. 2013. The Wiley-Blackwell Encyclopedia of Social and Political Movements. The Wiley-Blackwell Encyclopedia of Social and Political Movements 1 3 .
Antonio Benasaglio Berlucchi. (2021) Populism without host ideologies: A new home for voters with exclusionary attitudes in Italy’s Five Star Movement?. Party Politics 28:5, pages 811-825.
Crossref
Hadas Aron & Chiara Superti. (2021) Protest at the ballot box: From blank vote to populism. Party Politics 28:4, pages 638-650.
Crossref
Fernando Casal Bértoa & José Rama. (2021) Paying for appeasement: On the moderating role of public subsidies in East Central European party politics. Party Politics 28:4, pages 611-624.
Crossref
Manuela Caiani, Enrico Padoan & Bruno Marino. (2021) Candidate Selection, Personalization and Different Logics of Centralization in New Southern European Populism: The Cases of Podemos and the M5S. Government and Opposition 57:3, pages 404-427.
Crossref
Ali ÇARKOĞLU, Ezgi ELÇİ, Fatih EROL & Cansu PAKSOY. (2022) Popülizm Teorileri Işığında Türkiye’de Popülizmin Tarihsel Gelişimi: Siyasi Partiler Üzerine Bir İnceleme. Anadolu Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi 22:1, pages 323-348.
Crossref
Marco Salvati, Mauro Giacomantonio, Valerio Pellegrini, Valeria De Cristofaro & Luigi Leone. (2022) Conspiracy beliefs of Italian voters for populist parties: The moderated mediational role of political interest and ideological attitudes. Acta Psychologica 223, pages 103508.
Crossref
Oscar Mazzoleni & Gilles Ivaldi. 2022. Populism and Science in Europe. Populism and Science in Europe 255 284 .
Rosanna De Rosa. 2022. Constituency Communication in Changing Times. Constituency Communication in Changing Times 157 197 .
Jon Bertilsson, Andrea Lucarelli & Gregorio Fuschillo. 2022. Political Branding in Turbulent times. Political Branding in Turbulent times 103 121 .
Fabrizio Coticchia. (2021) A sovereignist revolution? Italy’s foreign policy under the “Yellow–Green” government. Comparative European Politics 19:6, pages 739-759.
Crossref
Hugo Marcos-Marne. (2020) A Tale of Populism? The Determinants of Voting for Left-Wing Populist Parties in Spain. Political Studies 69:4, pages 1053-1071.
Crossref
Cas Mudde. (2021) Populism in Europe: An Illiberal Democratic Response to Undemocratic Liberalism (The Government and Opposition /Leonard Schapiro Lecture 2019) . Government and Opposition 56:4, pages 577-597.
Crossref
Benjamin Höhne. (2021) How Democracy Works within a Populist Party: Candidate Selection in the Alternative for Germany. Government and Opposition, pages 1-19.
Crossref
Leila Simona Talani & Fabiana De Bellis. (2021) The Response to COVID-19 by the Italian Populist Government: Is It Populism or Neo-Liberalism That Makes the Response to the Pandemic Inadequate?. Social Sciences 10:9, pages 336.
Crossref
Manuela Caiani & Enrico Padoan. (2020) Populism and the (Italian) crisis: The voters and the context. Politics 41:3, pages 334-350.
Crossref
Giuseppe Maglione. (2021) Techno-sovereignism: the political rationality of contemporary Italian populism. Theory and Society 50:5, pages 791-813.
Crossref
Gianfranco Baldini & Matteo F.N. Giglioli. (2020) Bread or Circuses? Repoliticization in the Italian Populist Government Experience. Government and Opposition 56:3, pages 505-524.
Crossref
Hugo Marcos-Marne, Carolina Plaza-Colodro & Ciaran O’Flynn. (2021) Populism and new radical-right parties: The case of VOX. Politics, pages 026339572110195.
Crossref
Kjell Noordzij, Willem de Koster & Jeroen van der Waal. (2020) “They don’t know what it’s like to be at the bottom”: Exploring the role of perceived cultural distance in less‐educated citizens’ discontent with politicians. The British Journal of Sociology 72:3, pages 566-579.
Crossref
Arthur Capozzi, Gianmarco De Francisci Morales, Yelena Mejova, Corrado Monti, André Panisson & Daniela Paolotti. (2021) Clandestino or Rifugiato?Anti-immigration Facebook Ad Targeting in Italy✱. Clandestino or Rifugiato?Anti-immigration Facebook Ad Targeting in Italy✱.
Dante Di Matteo & Ilaria Mariotti. (2020) Italian discontent and right‐wing populism: determinants, geographies, patterns. Regional Science Policy & Practice 13:2, pages 371-396.
Crossref
Lorenzo Cladi & Andrea Locatelli. (2021) Italy in the EU after Brexit: carrying through or taking a bet?. Politique européenne N° 70:4, pages 94-115.
Crossref
Katharine Dommett, Jasmin Fitzpatrick, Lorenzo Mosca & Paolo Gerbaudo. (2020) Are digital parties the future of party organization? A symposium on The Digital Party: Political Organisation and Online Democracy by Paolo Gerbaudo . Italian Political Science Review/Rivista Italiana di Scienza Politica 51:1, pages 136-149.
Crossref
Leila Simona TalaniLeila Simona Talani. 2021. The International Political Economy of Migration in the Globalization Era. The International Political Economy of Migration in the Globalization Era 325 357 .
Stella GianfredaStella Gianfreda. 2021. Where Do the Parties Stand?. Where Do the Parties Stand? 147 159 .
Stella GianfredaStella Gianfreda. 2021. Where Do the Parties Stand?. Where Do the Parties Stand? 91 112 .
Donatella Campus, Niko Switek & Marco ValbruzziDonatella Campus, Niko Switek & Marco Valbruzzi. 2021. Collective Leadership and Divided Power in West European Parties. Collective Leadership and Divided Power in West European Parties 133 180 .
Anna Molnár & Anna Urbanovics. 2021. Research and Innovation Forum 2020. Research and Innovation Forum 2020 661 673 .
Giuliano Bobba & Antonella Seddone. 2021. Europe and the Left. Europe and the Left 167 188 .
Manuel Sánchez de Dios. (2020) El avance electoral de la extrema derecha en el siglo XXI y sus efectos en los sistemas de partidos europeos. Política y Sociedad 57:3, pages 747-768.
Crossref
Fabrizio Coticchia & Valerio Vignoli. (2020) Populist parties and foreign policy: The case of Italy’s Five Star Movement. The British Journal of Politics and International Relations 22:3, pages 523-541.
Crossref
Anna Molnár & Anna Urbanovics. (2020) The role of e-democracy in Italy and Hungary. Transforming Government: People, Process and Policy 14:3, pages 545-560.
Crossref
Mattia Zulianello. (2019) Varieties of Populist Parties and Party Systems in Europe: From State-of-the-Art to the Application of a Novel Classification Scheme to 66 Parties in 33 Countries. Government and Opposition 55:2, pages 327-347.
Crossref
Arthur Capozzi, Gianmarco De Francisci Morales, Yelena Mejova, Corrado Monti, André Panisson & Daniela Paolotti. 2020. Social Informatics. Social Informatics 43 57 .
Luca Bellodi, Massimo Morelli & Matia Vannoni. (2021) A Costly Commitment: Populism, Government Performance, and the Quality of Bureaucracy. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Crossref
Marco Rodolfo Di Tommaso, Elena Prodi, Dante Di Matteo & Ilaria Mariotti. (2021) Local Public Spending, Political Consensus, and Sustainable Structural Change. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.