Advanced search
Publication Cover
Philosophical Magazine A Volume 58, 1988 - Issue 2
Journal homepage
334
Views
105
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

The pressure for dislocation loop punching by a single bubble

W. G. Wolfer Theoretical Division, Sandia National Laboratories, Livermore, California, 94550, U.S.A.
Pages 285-297 | Received 15 Apr 1987, Accepted 18 Aug 1987, Published online: 20 Aug 2006

Citations (105)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (10)

Nan Li, Michael Demkowicz, Nathan Mara, Yongqiang Wang & Amit Misra. (2016) Hardening due to Interfacial He Bubbles in Nanolayered Composites. Materials Research Letters 4:2, pages 75-82.
Read now
Robert E. Rudd. (2009) Void growth in bcc metals simulated with molecular dynamics using the Finnis–Sinclair potential. Philosophical Magazine 89:34-36, pages 3133-3161.
Read now
K. Morishita. (2007) Nucleation path of helium bubbles in metals during irradiation. Philosophical Magazine 87:7, pages 1139-1158.
Read now
Donald F. Cowgill. (2005) Helium Nano-Bubble Evolution in Aging Metal Tritides. Fusion Science and Technology 48:1, pages 539-544.
Read now
Mai. Ghaly, Kai. Nordlund & R.S. Averback. (1999) Molecular dynamics investigations of surface damage produced by kiloelectronvolt self-bombardment of solids. Philosophical Magazine A 79:4, pages 795-820.
Read now
G. T. McConville, D. A. Menke, D. West & C. M. Woods. (1995) The Effect of Helium Growth and Carbon Impurities on the Properties of Aged Metal Tritides. Fusion Technology 28:3P2, pages 1227-1232.
Read now
T. Diaz De La Rubia & M.W. Guinan. (1994) MD studies of high energy cascades in Cu. Radiation Effects and Defects in Solids 129:1-2, pages 31-39.
Read now
T. Schober & H. Trinkaus. (1992) 3He bubble formation in titanium tritides at elevated temperatures A TEM study. Philosophical Magazine A 65:5, pages 1235-1247.
Read now
W.G. Wolfer. (1989) Dislocation loop punching in bubble arrays. Philosophical Magazine A 59:1, pages 87-103.
Read now
W.G. Wolfer & W.J. Drugan. (1988) Elastic interaction energy between a prismatic dislocation loop and a spherical cavity. Philosophical Magazine A 57:6, pages 923-937.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (95)

Cuncai Fan, Shuai Pan, Xunxiang Hu, Binbin He & Mingxin Huang. (2023) Mechanisms of helium irradiation blistering and surface deformation in tungsten. Acta Materialia 254, pages 118993.
Crossref
Changqiu Ji, Jianqiao Hu, Zhuo Zhuang & Yinan Cui. (2023) Atomistically-informed hardening and kinetics models of helium bubble in irradiated tungsten. International Journal of Plasticity 165, pages 103620.
Crossref
W．Streit Cunningham, Yang Zhang, Spencer L. Thomas, Osman El-Atwani, Yongqiang Wang & Jason R. Trelewicz. (2023) Grain boundary softening from stress assisted helium cavity coalescence in ultrafine-grained tungsten. Acta Materialia 252, pages 118948.
Crossref
Chi Xu, Junjun Zhou, Tongmin Zhang, Jun Li, Long Kang, Shuai Xu & Bingsheng Li. (2023) Surface blistering and void swelling of α-Al2O3 irradiated with H2+ ions followed by 1000, 1200 °C annealing. Materials Today Energy 33, pages 101262.
Crossref
Zhenbo Zhu, Weichi Ji & Hefei Huang. (2023) In-situ TEM investigation on the evolution of He bubbles and dislocation loops in Ni-based alloy irradiated by & dual-beam ions . Journal of Materials Science & Technology 138, pages 36-49.
Crossref
Ke Xu, Shuo Jin, Yu-Hao Li, Hong-Bo Zhou, Hongxian Xie, Ning Gao, Fei Gao & Guang-Hong Lu. (2023) Insight into the loop-punching mechanism for He bubble growth: The plastic deformation modes and their competition. Computational Materials Science 216, pages 111825.
Crossref
S.A. Karpov & G.D. Tolstolutskaya. (2022) HELIUM AND HYDROGEN EFFECTS IN STRUCTURAL MATERIALS FOR NUCLEAR APPLICATIONS. Problems of Atomic Science and Technology, pages 3-24.
Crossref
Alberto Fraile, Prashant Dwivedi, Giovanni Bonny & Tomas Polcar. (2022) Analysis of hypervelocity impacts: the tungsten case. Nuclear Fusion 62:2, pages 026034.
Crossref
Ashutosh Rajput & Surajit Kumar Paul. (2021) Effect of void in deformation and damage mechanism of single crystal copper: a molecular dynamics study. Modelling and Simulation in Materials Science and Engineering 29:8, pages 085013.
Crossref
Z.J. Bergstrom, D. Perez & E. Martínez. (2021) The mobility of small, over-pressurized helium bubbles in tungsten at 2000 K. Journal of Nuclear Materials 557, pages 153306.
Crossref
X.Y. Liu, Y.P. Li, G. Ran, Q. Han & P.H. Chen. (2021) In situ transmission electron microscopy studies of 30 keV H2+ and He+ dual-beam irradiated Pd: defect generation and microstructural evolution under varied temperatures and foil thicknesses. Materials Today Energy 21, pages 100731.
Crossref
Miaomiao Jin, Yipeng Gao, Yongfeng Zhang, Chao Jiang & Jian Gan. (2021) Dissociated prismatic loop punching by bubble growth in FCC metals. Scientific Reports 11:1.
Crossref
W.W. Zhang, P.H. Shi, B.D. Yao, L. Wu, X.Y. Wu, L.Q. Shi & Y.X. Wang. (2021) Panorama of “fuzz” growth on tungsten surface under He irradiation. Applied Surface Science 542, pages 148543.
Crossref
L. Yang & B.D. Wirth. (2021) Evolution of pressurized xenon bubble and response of uranium dioxide matrix: A molecular dynamics study. Journal of Nuclear Materials 544, pages 152730.
Crossref
Xinlong Huang, Chenyangtao Lv & Haijian Chu. (2021) Anomalous shape effect of nanosized helium bubble on the elastic field in irradiated tungsten. Scientific Reports 11:1.
Crossref
Xiang Li, Yi-Hui Yin & Yuan-Zhang Zhang. (2021) Molecular dynamics simulation of helium bubble ultimate pressure in α-Fe. Acta Physica Sinica 70:7, pages 076101.
Crossref
Zhongxia Shang, Jie Ding, Cuncai Fan, Di Chen, Jin Li, Yifan Zhang, Yongqiang Wang, Haiyan Wang & Xinghang Zhang. (2020) He ion irradiation response of a gradient T91 steel. Acta Materialia 196, pages 175-190.
Crossref
Caitlin A. Taylor, Joshua D. Sugar, David B. Robinson, Norman C. Bartelt, Ryan B. Sills & Khalid Hattar. (2020) Using In Situ TEM Helium Implantation and Annealing to Study Cavity Nucleation and Growth. JOM 72:5, pages 2032-2041.
Crossref
Karl D. Hammond, Dimitrios Maroudas & Brian D. Wirth. (2020) Theoretical Model of Helium Bubble Growth and Density in Plasma-Facing Metals. Scientific Reports 10:1.
Crossref
Caitlin A. Taylor, Samuel Briggs, Graeme Greaves, Anthony Monterrosa, Emily Aradi, Joshua D. Sugar, David B. Robinson, Khalid Hattar & Jonathan A. Hinks. (2019) Investigating Helium Bubble Nucleation and Growth through Simultaneous In-Situ Cryogenic, Ion Implantation, and Environmental Transmission Electron Microscopy. Materials 12:16, pages 2618.
Crossref
Si-Mian Liu, Shi-Hao Li & Wei-Zhong Han. (2019) Effect of ordered helium bubbles on deformation and fracture behavior of α-Zr. Journal of Materials Science & Technology 35:7, pages 1466-1472.
Crossref
Shi-Hao Li, Jing-Ting Li & Wei-Zhong Han. (2019) Radiation-Induced Helium Bubbles in Metals. Materials 12:7, pages 1036.
Crossref
Haifeng Wang, Shuming Peng, Xiaosong Zhou, Xinggui Long & Huahai Shen. (2018) Evolution of 3He bubble microstructure in TiT2 films during aging. Journal of Nuclear Materials 509, pages 700-706.
Crossref
Karl D Hammond. (2017) Helium, hydrogen, and fuzz in plasma-facing materials. Materials Research Express 4:10, pages 104002.
Crossref
Shenyang Hu, Wahyu Setyawan, Vineet V. Joshi & Curt A. Lavender. (2017) Atomistic simulations of thermodynamic properties of Xe gas bubbles in U10Mo fuels. Journal of Nuclear Materials 490, pages 49-58.
Crossref
Long Yu, Xiazi Xiao, Lirong Chen, Haijian Chu & Huiling Duan. (2016) A micromechanical model for nano-metallic-multilayers with helium irradiation. International Journal of Solids and Structures 102-103, pages 267-274.
Crossref
S. Agarwal, P. Trocellier, D. Brimbal & S. Vaubaillon. (2016) An experimental study of helium diffusion and helium induced microstructural evolution in ion implanted polycrystalline titanium nitride. Acta Materialia 121, pages 1-14.
Crossref
Shenyang Hu, Douglas E. Burkes, Curt A. Lavender, David J. Senor, Wahyu Setyawan & Zhijie Xu. (2016) Formation mechanism of gas bubble superlattice in UMo metal fuels: Phase-field modeling investigation. Journal of Nuclear Materials 479, pages 202-215.
Crossref
Lucas M. Hale, Jonathan A. Zimmerman & Bryan M. Wong. (2016) Large-scale atomistic simulations of helium-3 bubble growth in complex palladium alloys. The Journal of Chemical Physics 144:19.
Crossref
Xiaojuan Peng, Wenjun Zhu, Kaiguo Chen, Xiaoliang Deng & Yongkai Wei. (2016) Molecular dynamics simulations of void coalescence in monocrystalline copper under loading and unloading. Journal of Applied Physics 119:16.
Crossref
Peter A Schultz & Clark S Snow. (2016) Mechanical properties of metal dihydrides. Modelling and Simulation in Materials Science and Engineering 24:3, pages 035005.
Crossref
Richard E. Baumer & Michael J. Demkowicz. (2016) A “figure of merit” for susceptibility of irradiated amorphous metal alloys to thermal spike-induced plasticity. Acta Materialia 102, pages 251-262.
Crossref
V.S. Krasnikov & A.E. Mayer. (2015) Plasticity driven growth of nanovoids and strength of aluminum at high rate tension: Molecular dynamics simulations and continuum modeling. International Journal of Plasticity 74, pages 75-91.
Crossref
B.D. Miller, J. Gan, D.D. KeiserJr.Jr., A.B. Robinson, J.F. Jue, J.W. Madden & P.G. Medvedev. (2015) Transmission electron microscopy characterization of the fission gas bubble superlattice in irradiated U–7 wt%Mo dispersion fuels. Journal of Nuclear Materials 458, pages 115-121.
Crossref
B. Li, L. Wang, J. C. E, H. H. Ma & S. N. Luo. (2014) Shock response of He bubbles in single crystal Cu. Journal of Applied Physics 116:21.
Crossref
Yuefei Zhang, Fei Wang, Peng Zang, Jin Wang, Shengcheng Mao, Xiaona Zhang & Junxia Lu. (2014) In-situ observation of crack propagation through the nucleation of nanoscale voids in ultra-thin, freestanding Ag films. Materials Science and Engineering: A 618, pages 614-620.
Crossref
Min Li, Jiechao Cui, Jun Wang & Qing Hou. (2014) Molecular dynamics simulations of cumulative helium bombardments on tungsten surfaces. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms 337, pages 45-54.
Crossref
X.S. Zhou, G.J. Chen, S.M. Peng, X.G. Long, J.H. Liang & Y.Q. Fu. (2014) Thermal desorption of tritium and helium in aged titanium tritide films. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 39:21, pages 11006-11015.
Crossref
Qian Li, C.M. Parish, K.A. Powers & M.K. Miller. (2014) Helium solubility and bubble formation in a nanostructured ferritic alloy. Journal of Nuclear Materials 445:1-3, pages 165-174.
Crossref
T. Jourdan, G. Bencteux & G. Adjanor. (2014) Efficient simulation of kinetics of radiation induced defects: A cluster dynamics approach. Journal of Nuclear Materials 444:1-3, pages 298-313.
Crossref
Faiza Sefta, Niklas Juslin & Brian D. Wirth. (2013) Helium bubble bursting in tungsten. Journal of Applied Physics 114:24.
Crossref
Danny Perez, Sheng-Nian Luo, Arthur F. Voter & Timothy C. Germann. (2013) Entropic Stabilization of Nanoscale Voids in Materials under Tension. Physical Review Letters 110:20.
Crossref
N. Li, M. Nastasi & A. Misra. (2012) Defect structures and hardening mechanisms in high dose helium ion implanted Cu and Cu/Nb multilayer thin films. International Journal of Plasticity 32-33, pages 1-16.
Crossref
Bingyun Ao, Piheng Chen, Peng Shi, Xiaolin Wang, Wangyu Hu & Liang Wang. (2015) Computer Simulation of Helium Effects in Plutonium During the Aging Process of Self-Radiation Damage. Communications in Computational Physics 11:4, pages 1205-1225.
Crossref
N Gao, M Victoria, J Chen & H Van Swygenhoven. (2011) Helium-vacancy cluster in a single bcc iron crystal lattice. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 23:24, pages 245403.
Crossref
Bao-Ling Zhang, Jun Wang & Qing Hou. (2011) Molecular dynamics study of helium bubble pressure in titanium. Chinese Physics B 20:3, pages 036105.
Crossref
Liang Wang, Wangyu Hu, Huiqiu Deng, Shifang Xiao, Jianyu Yang, Fei Gao, Howard L. Heinisch & Shilin Hu. (2011) Helium nanobubble release from Pd surface: An atomic simulation. Journal of Materials Research 26:3, pages 416-423.
Crossref
Yizhe Tang, Eduardo M. Bringa, Bruce A. Remington & Marc A. Meyers. (2011) Growth and collapse of nanovoids in tantalum monocrystals. Acta Materialia 59:4, pages 1354-1372.
Crossref
Eduardo M. Bringa, Sirirat Traiviratana & Marc A. Meyers. (2010) Void initiation in fcc metals: Effect of loading orientation and nanocrystalline effects. Acta Materialia 58:13, pages 4458-4477.
Crossref
Vasily V. Bulatov, Wilhelm G. Wolfer & Mukul Kumar. (2010) Shear impossibility: Comments on “Void growth by dislocation emission” and “Void growth in metals: Atomistic calculations”. Scripta Materialia 63:1, pages 144-147.
Crossref
Zhou Xiaosong, Long Xinggui, Zhang Lin, Peng Shuming & Luo Shunzhong. (2010) X-ray diffraction analysis of titanium tritide film during 1600 days. Journal of Nuclear Materials 396:2-3, pages 223-227.
Crossref
S. M. Hafez Haghighat, G. Lucas & R. Schäublin. (2009) State of a pressurized helium bubble in iron. EPL (Europhysics Letters) 85:6, pages 60008.
Crossref
Hai-Yan Wang, Wen-Jun Zhu, Shao-Jun Liu, Zhen-Fei Song, Xiao-Liang Deng, Xiang-Rong Chen & Hong-Liang He. (2009) Atomistic simulations of the elastic properties of helium bubble embedded aluminum. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms 267:5, pages 849-855.
Crossref
Marc A. Meyers, Sirirat Traiviratana, V. A. Lubarda, David J. Benson & Eduardo M. Bringa. (2009) The role of dislocations in the growth of nanosized voids in ductile failure of metals. JOM 61:2, pages 35-41.
Crossref
M.A. Meyers, H. Jarmakani, E.M. Bringa & B.A. Remington. 2009. 91 197 .
F. Montheillet, D. Delaplanche, A. Fabre, E. Munier & S. Thiébaut. (2008) A mechanical analysis of metallic tritide aging by helium bubble growth. Materials Science and Engineering: A 494:1-2, pages 407-415.
Crossref
Michael P. Surh, Jess B. Sturgeon & Wilhelm G. Wolfer. (2008) Void nucleation, growth, and coalescence in irradiated metals. Journal of Nuclear Materials 378:1, pages 86-97.
Crossref
K. Hattar, M.J. Demkowicz, A. Misra, I.M. Robertson & R.G. Hoagland. (2008) Arrest of He bubble growth in Cu–Nb multilayer nanocomposites. Scripta Materialia 58:7, pages 541-544.
Crossref
C.H. Zhang, J. Jang, M.C. Kim, H.D. Cho, Y.T. Yang & Y.M. Sun. (2008) Void swelling in a 9Cr ferritic/martensitic steel irradiated with energetic Ne-ions at elevated temperatures. Journal of Nuclear Materials 375:2, pages 185-191.
Crossref
R. E. Rudd, E. T. Seppälä, L. M. Dupuy & J. Belak. (2007) Void coalescence processes quantified through atomistic and multiscale simulation. Journal of Computer-Aided Materials Design 14:3, pages 425-434.
Crossref
B.Y. Ao, X.L. Wang, W.Y. Hu, J.Y. Yang & J.X. Xia. (2007) Atomistic study of small helium bubbles in plutonium. Journal of Alloys and Compounds 444-445, pages 300-304.
Crossref
W.G. Wolfer, B. Oudot & N. Baclet. (2006) Reversible expansion of gallium-stabilized δ-plutonium. Journal of Nuclear Materials 359:3, pages 185-191.
Crossref
F.A. Garner, E.P. Simonen, B.M. Oliver, L.R. Greenwood, M.L. Grossbeck, W.G. Wolfer & P.M. Scott. (2006) Retention of hydrogen in fcc metals irradiated at temperatures leading to high densities of bubbles or voids. Journal of Nuclear Materials 356:1-3, pages 122-135.
Crossref
D.C. Ahn, P. Sofronis & R. Minich. (2006) On the micromechanics of void growth by prismatic-dislocation loop emission. Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids 54:4, pages 735-755.
Crossref
Jianyu Yang, Bingyun Ao, Wangyu Hu & Xiaolin Wang. (2006) The Formation Energies and Binding Energies of Helium Vacancy Cluster: Comparative Study in Ni and Pd. Journal of Physics: Conference Series 29, pages 190-193.
Crossref
Benfu Hu, Hisao Kinoshita, Tamaki Shibayama & H. Takahashi. (2005) Damage Behavior of Electron/Helium Dual-Beam Irradiation on Fe-Cr-Mn (W, V) Alloy. Materials Science Forum 475-479, pages 1463-1466.
Crossref
ML Grossbeck, TR Allen, RG Lott & AS KumarCM Schaldach & WG Wolfe. 2004. Effects of Radiation on Materials: 21st International Symposium. Effects of Radiation on Materials: 21st International Symposium 479 491 .
R. N. Mulford, W. Brown, T. Huntley & J. Wendelberger. 2001. Ageing Studies and Lifetime Extension of Materials. Ageing Studies and Lifetime Extension of Materials 199 207 .
J. Chen, P. Jung & H. Trinkaus. (1999) Evolution of Helium Platelets and Associated Dislocation Loops in -SiC . Physical Review Letters 82:13, pages 2709-2712.
Crossref
R.S. AVERBACK & T. DIAZ DE LA RUBIA. 1998. Solid State Physics - Advances in Research and Applications. Solid State Physics - Advances in Research and Applications 281 402 .
V. Vishnyakov, G. Carter & S.E. Donnelly. 1996. Ion Beam Modification of Materials. Ion Beam Modification of Materials 972 977 .
V.I. Dubinko. (1995) Impact of glissile interstitial loop production in cascades on void ordering and swelling saturation under irradiation. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms 102:1-4, pages 125-131.
Crossref
Mai Ghaly, R.S. Averback & T. Diaz de la Rubia. (1995) Surface effects on damage production during ion bombardment: A molecular dynamics study. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms 102:1-4, pages 51-57.
Crossref
Mai Ghaly & R.S. Averback. (1994) The formation of vacancy-type defect clusters by ion bombardment: A problem revisited by molecular dynamics. Journal of Physics and Chemistry of Solids 55:10, pages 945-953.
Crossref
Mai Ghaly & R. S. Averback. (1994) Effect of viscous flow on ion damage near solid surfaces. Physical Review Letters 72:3, pages 364-367.
Crossref
V. I. Dubinko & A. A. Turkin. (1994) Self-organization of cavities under irradiation. Applied Physics A Solids and Surfaces 58:1, pages 21-34.
Crossref
H. Van Swygenhoven & A. Caro. (1993) Nanoscale phase transitions induced by heat spikes in collision cascades. Physical Review Letters 70:14, pages 2098-2101.
Crossref
G. C. Abell & D. F. Cowgill. (1991) Low-temperature NMR studies in aged palladium tritide . Physical Review B 44:9, pages 4178-4184.
Crossref
T. Diaz de la Rubia & M. W. Guinan. (1991) New mechanism of defect production in metals: A molecular-dynamics study of interstitial-dislocation-loop formation in high-energy displacement cascades. Physical Review Letters 66:21, pages 2766-2769.
Crossref
G. C. Abell. 1991. Fundamental Aspects of Inert Gases in Solids. Fundamental Aspects of Inert Gases in Solids 103 114 .
G. J. Thomas. 1991. Fundamental Aspects of Inert Gases in Solids. Fundamental Aspects of Inert Gases in Solids 95 102 .
T. Schober & H. Trinkaus. 1991. Fundamental Aspects of Inert Gases in Solids. Fundamental Aspects of Inert Gases in Solids 83 94 .
H. Trinkaus. 1991. Fundamental Aspects of Inert Gases in Solids. Fundamental Aspects of Inert Gases in Solids 369 383 .
H. Ullmaier. 1991. Fundamental Aspects of Inert Gases in Solids. Fundamental Aspects of Inert Gases in Solids 277 285 .
J. B. Adams, W. G. Wolfer, S. M. Foiles, C. M. Rohlfing & C. D. Van Siclen. 1991. Fundamental Aspects of Inert Gases in Solids. Fundamental Aspects of Inert Gases in Solids 3 16 .
H. Ullmaier. 1991. Atomic Defects in Metals. Atomic Defects in Metals 432 435 .
H. Ullmaier. 1991. Atomic Defects in Metals. Atomic Defects in Metals 417 431 .
H. Ullmaier. 1991. Atomic Defects in Metals. Atomic Defects in Metals 397 398 .
Qiang-Li, W. Kesternich, H. Schroeder, D. Schwahn & H. Ullmaier. (1990) Gas densities in helium bubbles in nickel measured by small angle neutron scattering. Acta Metallurgica et Materialia 38:12, pages 2383-2392.
Crossref
G. C. Abell, L. K. Matson, R. H. Steinmeyer, R. C. Bowman & B. M. Oliver. (1990) Helium release from aged palladium tritide. Physical Review B 41:2, pages 1220-1223.
Crossref
Kohji Kamada. (1989) Hydrogen implantation effects in the subsurface layer of aluminum -bubble pressure and surface modifications. Journal of Nuclear Materials 169, pages 141-150.
Crossref
H. Trinkaus. (1989) The effect of internal pressure on the coarsening of inert gas bubbles in metals. Scripta Metallurgica 23:10, pages 1773-1778.
Crossref
R. Lässer, K. Bickmann & H. Trinkaus. (1989) X-ray diffraction study of the lattice deformation due to bubble formation in a tantalum tritide . Physical Review B 40:5, pages 3306-3310.
Crossref
R. Lässer, L. Gain & H. Trinkaus. (1989) Gamma diffractometry of tantalum and niobium tritides. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms 43:1, pages 67-72.
Crossref
T. Schober, C. Dieker, R. Lässer & H. Trinkaus. (1989) Precision dilatometry of Nb, Ta, and Lu tritides. Physical Review B 40:2, pages 1277-1281.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.