Advanced search
Publication Cover
Third World Quarterly Volume 25, 2004 - Issue 3
Submit an article Journal homepage
3,525
Views
93
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

The ambiguity of participation: a qualified defence of participatory development

Trevor Parfitt View further author information
Pages 537-555 | Published online: 24 Jan 2007

Citations (93)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (26)

Marlie Holtzhausen & Cori Wielenga. (2023) A relational approach to human development in a crisis: perspectives from two case studies in South Africa during COVID-19. Development Studies Research 10:1.
Read now
Ferry van de Mosselaer, Dominique Vanneste & Patrick van der Duin. (2023) The Productive Role of Future Expectations in Participatory Spatial Planning. A Case Study on Urban Park Development in The Netherlands. Planning Theory & Practice 24:5, pages 607-620.
Read now
Felix Ampadu. (2023) Changing discourse, politics, and the practices of participation in development. Development in Practice 33:6, pages 721-727.
Read now
Evans Sakyi Boadu & Isioma Ile. (2023) Evaluation innovation in Africa: Towards indigenously responsive evaluation (IRE) philosophies, methods and practices in Ghana. African Journal of Science, Technology, Innovation and Development 15:5, pages 624-636.
Read now
Tania Sharmin & Rihab Khalid. (2022) Post occupancy and participatory design evaluation of a marginalized low-income settlement in Ahmedabad, India. Building Research & Information 50:5, pages 574-594.
Read now
Adrian Robert Bazbauers. (2020) World Bank technical assistance: participation, policy movement, and sympathetic interlocutors. Policy Studies 41:6, pages 567-585.
Read now
Seohee Kwak. (2019) Deconstructing the multi-layered nature of citizen participation in Vietnam: conceptual connotations, discourses of international development, and the country’s institutional context. Asian Journal of Political Science 27:3, pages 257-271.
Read now
Abdelhalim Khaled. (2018) Stakeholders’ relations and power dynamics in development cooperation: lessons learnt from Egypt. Development in Practice 28:6, pages 785-798.
Read now
Martin Galvin & Geraldine Mooney Simmie. (2017) Theorising participation in urban regeneration partnerships: an adult education perspective. Journal of Education Policy 32:6, pages 809-831.
Read now
Namita Singh, Chris High, Andy Lane & Sue Oreszczyn. (2017) Building agency through participatory video: insights from the experiences of young women participants in India. Gender, Technology and Development 21:3, pages 173-188.
Read now
Greg Acciaioli, Helen Brunt & Julian Clifton. (2017) Foreigners Everywhere, Nationals Nowhere: Exclusion, Irregularity, and Invisibility of Stateless Bajau Laut in Eastern Sabah, Malaysia. Journal of Immigrant & Refugee Studies 15:3, pages 232-249.
Read now
Riccarda Flemmer & Almut Schilling‐Vacaflor. (2016) Unfulfilled promises of the consultation approach: the limits to effective indigenous participation in Bolivia’s and Peru’s extractive industries. Third World Quarterly 37:1, pages 172-188.
Read now
Grant A. Fore. (2013) Leading while being led: developing the developer at a Catholic NGO in Cape Town. Anthropology Southern Africa 36:1-2, pages 80-90.
Read now
Grant A. Fore. (2013) Leading while being led: developing the developer at a Catholic NGO in Cape Town. Anthropology Southern Africa 36:1-2, pages 80-90.
Read now
Esther Turnhout & Mariëlle Van der Zouwen. (2010) ‘Governance without governance’ : how nature policy was democratized in the Netherlands. Critical Policy Studies 4:4, pages 344-361.
Read now
Edward R. Carr. (2010) The place of stories in development: creating spaces for participation through narrative analysis. Development in Practice 20:2, pages 219-226.
Read now
Robin Nunkoo & Haywantee Ramkissoon. (2010) Community perceptions of tourism in small island states: a conceptual framework. Journal of Policy Research in Tourism, Leisure and Events 2:1, pages 51-65.
Read now
Said Adejumobi. (2009) Popular Participation and Africa's Development Agenda: Projecting a Citizen-Based United States of Africa. Politikon 36:3, pages 403-422.
Read now
MichaelA. Di Giovine. (2009) Revitalization and counter‐revitalization: tourism, heritage, and the Lantern Festival as catalysts for regeneration in Hội An, Việt Nam. Journal of Policy Research in Tourism, Leisure and Events 1:3, pages 208-230.
Read now
Bereket Kebede. (2009) Community Wealth Ranking and Household Surveys: An Integrative Approach. The Journal of Development Studies 45:10, pages 1731-1746.
Read now
ThomasW. D. Davis. (2009) The Politics of Human Rights and Development: The Challenge for Official Donors. Australian Journal of Political Science 44:1, pages 173-192.
Read now
Gina Porter & Albert Abane. (2008) Increasing children's participation in African transport planning: reflections on methodological issues in a child-centred research project. Children's Geographies 6:2, pages 151-167.
Read now
Katharine McKinnon. (2007) Postdevelopment, Professionalism, and the Politics of Participation. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 97:4, pages 772-785.
Read now
Ilan Kapoor. (2005) Participatory development, complicity and desire. Third World Quarterly 26:8, pages 1203-1220.
Read now
Jay Drydyk. (2005) When is Development More Democratic?. Journal of Human Development 6:2, pages 247-267.
Read now
Faranak Miraftab. (2004) Making neo-liberal governance: the disempowering work of empowerment. International Planning Studies 9:4, pages 239-259.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (67)

Rehema M. White, Birgit Schmook, Sophie Calmé, Anthony J. Giordano, Yves Hausser, Lynn Kimmel, Lou Lecuyer, Mauro Lucherini, Crisol Méndez‐Medina & Juan L. Peña‐Mondragón. (2023) Facilitating biodiversity conservation through partnerships to achieve transformative outcomes. Conservation Biology 37:3.
Crossref
Jacques Walter Beukes & Laurika Elouise Beukes. (2023) Proposing a Social Justice Approach to Diaconia for a South African Context. Religions 14:5, pages 668.
Crossref
Serene Ho, Pranab R. Choudhury & Richa Joshi. (2023) Community participation for inclusive land administration: A case study of the Odisha urban slum formalization project. Land Use Policy 125, pages 106457.
Crossref
Freddy Nogueira, Filipe Moura & Ana Morais de Sá. (2023) The phase of experimentation in public spaces: the cases of Milan, Barcelona and Rio de Janeiro. Transportation Research Procedia 72, pages 3419-3426.
Crossref
Abeer Abdulnabi Ali, Yuliya Golbert, Abdul Fikri Angga Reksa, Michael M. Kretzer & Stefan Schweiger. 2023. Environmental Governance in Indonesia. Environmental Governance in Indonesia 329 351 .
Mudit Kumar Singh. 2022. Community Participation and Civic Engagement in the Digital Era. Community Participation and Civic Engagement in the Digital Era 87 101 .
Mudit Kumar Singh & James Moody. (2021) Do social capital and networks facilitate community participation?. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 42:5/6, pages 385-398.
Crossref
Matthew C. Canfield, Jessica Duncan & Priscilla Claeys. (2021) Reconfiguring Food Systems Governance: The UNFSS and the Battle Over Authority and Legitimacy. Development 64:3-4, pages 181-191.
Crossref
Alexander Betts, Naohiko Omata & Olivier Sterck. (2021) Transnational blindness: International institutions and refugees’ cross-border activities. Review of International Studies 47:5, pages 714-742.
Crossref
Fauster Agbenyo, Wisdom N-Yil-Yari & Bernard Affiik Akanpabadai Akanbang. (2021) Stakeholder Perspectives on Participatory Monitoring and Evaluation in Educational Projects in Upper West Region, Ghana. Journal of Planning and Land Management 2:1, pages 50-64.
Crossref
Sait Sarr, Bunny Hayes & Daniel A. DeCaro. (2021) Applying Ostrom’s Institutional Analysis and Development framework, and design principles for co-production to pollution management in Louisville's Rubbertown, Kentucky. Land Use Policy 104, pages 105383.
Crossref
Erick O. Ananga, Resty Naiga, Stephen G. Agong’, Ambe J. Njoh & Haley P. Vickers. (2021) Examining the contribution of community participation in water resource production and management: perspectives from developing countries. SN Social Sciences 1:1.
Crossref
Reena Tiwari, Jessica Winters & Neeti Trivedi. 2021. Resilient Urban Regeneration in Informal Settlements in the Tropics. Resilient Urban Regeneration in Informal Settlements in the Tropics 127 147 .
Octavio López-Martínez & Heriberto Emilio Cuanalo de la Cerda. (2017) Participatory action research in the design, construction and evaluation of improved cook stoves in a rural Yucatec Maya community. Action Research 18:4, pages 490-509.
Crossref
Clarissa D. Ruzol, April Charmaine D. Camacho, Lorena L. Sabino, Josephine E. Garcia, Dixon T. Gevaña & Leni D. Camacho. (2020) A materialist-idealist divide? Policy and practice in participatory mangrove rehabilitation in the Philippines. Environmental Science & Policy 112, pages 394-404.
Crossref
Jackie Shaw, Jo Howard & Erika López Franco. (2020) Building inclusive community activism and accountable relations through an intersecting inequalities approach. Community Development Journal 55:1, pages 7-25.
Crossref
Evans Sakyi Boadu & Isioma Ile. (2019) Between power and perception: Understanding youth perspectives in participatory monitoring and evaluation (PM&E) in Ghana. Evaluation and Program Planning 77, pages 101683.
Crossref
Nadine Lehrer, Colleen Donovan & Maureen Gullen. (2019) Pairing a Q Study with Participatory Decision-making around Farmworker Safety: A Case in Washington's Tree Fruit Industry. Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development, pages 1-27.
Crossref
John‐Michael Davis & Yaakov Garb. (2018) Participatory shaping of community futures in e‐waste processing hubs: Complexity, conflict and stewarded convergence in a Palestinian context. Development Policy Review 37:1, pages 67-89.
Crossref
Arezoo Mirzaei, Andrea Knierim, Saeid Fealy Nahavand, Shahab Alddin Shokri & Hossein Mahmoudi. (2019) Assessment of policy instruments towards improving the water reservoirs’ governance in Northern Iran. Agricultural Water Management 211, pages 48-58.
Crossref
Pamela Zigomo & Richard Hull. (2018) Unlocking Doors: Decolonizing the Design of an Art Exhibition in Zimbabwe. Event Management 22:6, pages 997-1008.
Crossref
Mudit Kumar Singh. (2018) Gender and women empowerment approaches: Interventions through PRIs and CSOs in Northern India. Women's Studies International Forum 71, pages 63-67.
Crossref
Francesco M. Gimelli, Joannette J. Bos & Briony C. Rogers. (2018) Fostering equity and wellbeing through water: A reinterpretation of the goal of securing access. World Development 104, pages 1-9.
Crossref
I Fazey, E Carmen, FS ChapinIIIIII, H Ross, J Rao-Williams, C Lyon, ILC Connon, BA Searle & K Knox. (2018) Community resilience for a 1.5 °C world. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability 31, pages 30-40.
Crossref
Collin C. Mabiza. 2018. Integrated Water Resources Management, Institutions and Livelihoods under Stress. Integrated Water Resources Management, Institutions and Livelihoods under Stress 65 86 .
Zerihun Nigussie, Atsushi Tsunekawa, Nigussie Haregeweyn, Enyew Adgo, Logan Cochrane, Anne Floquet & Steffen Abele. (2018) Applying Ostrom’s institutional analysis and development framework to soil and water conservation activities in north-western Ethiopia. Land Use Policy 71, pages 1-10.
Crossref
Katherine N. Irvine, Liz O’Brien, Neil Ravenscroft, Nigel Cooper, Mark Everard, Ioan Fazey, Mark S. Reed & Jasper O. Kenter. (2016) Ecosystem services and the idea of shared values. Ecosystem Services 21, pages 184-193.
Crossref
Julia Morgan. (2016) Participation, empowerment and capacity building: Exploring young people's perspectives on the services provided to them by a grassroots NGO in sub-Saharan Africa. Children and Youth Services Review 65, pages 175-182.
Crossref
Raphaëlle Parizet. (2016) Le « pauvre d’abord ». Une analyse des dynamiques circulatoires de la participation populaire au développement. Participations N° 14:1, pages 61-90.
Crossref
Lorenza B. Fontana & Jean Grugel. (2016) The Politics of Indigenous Participation Through “Free Prior Informed Consent”: Reflections from the Bolivian Case. World Development 77, pages 249-261.
Crossref
J. Duncan. 2016. 137 161 .
ARIS KOMPOROZOS‐ATHANASIOU & MARK THOMPSON. (2015) THE ROLE OF EMOTION IN ENABLING AND CONDITIONING PUBLIC DELIBERATION OUTCOMES: A SOCIOLOGICAL INVESTIGATION. Public Administration 93:4, pages 1138-1151.
Crossref
Navé Wald. (2014) Anarchist Participatory Development: A Possible New Framework?. Development and Change 46:4, pages 618-643.
Crossref
Arielle Tozier de la Poterie & Marie-Ange Baudoin. (2015) From Yokohama to Sendai: Approaches to Participation in International Disaster Risk Reduction Frameworks. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science 6:2, pages 128-139.
Crossref
Sri Lestari, Koji Kotani & Makoto Kakinaka. (2015) Enhancing voluntary participation in community collaborative forest management: A case of Central Java, Indonesia. Journal of Environmental Management 150, pages 299-309.
Crossref
Christopher Kelty, Aaron Panofsky, Morgan Currie, Roderic Crooks, Seth Erickson, Patricia Garcia, Michael Wartenbe & Stacy Wood. (2014) Seven dimensions of contemporary participation disentangled. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology 66:3, pages 474-488.
Crossref
Kevin Grove & Jonathan Pugh. (2015) Assemblage Thinking and Participatory Development: Potentiality, Ethics, Biopolitics. Geography Compass 9:1, pages 1-13.
Crossref
Kerstin Nolte & Lieske Voget-Kleschin. (2014) Consultation in Large-Scale Land Acquisitions: An Evaluation of Three Cases in Mali. World Development 64, pages 654-668.
Crossref
U. Villalba, Y. Jubeto & L. Guridi. (2013) Participation and gender in Latin America: perspectives from decentralized cooperation and Local Human Development approaches. Community Development Journal 49:2, pages 228-244.
Crossref
Ioan Fazey, Lukas Bunse, Joshua Msika, Maria Pinke, Katherine Preedy, Anna C. Evely, Emily Lambert, Emily Hastings, Sue Morris & Mark S. Reed. (2014) Evaluating knowledge exchange in interdisciplinary and multi-stakeholder research. Global Environmental Change 25, pages 204-220.
Crossref
Francisco A. Magno. 2014. E-Governance and Social Inclusion. E-Governance and Social Inclusion 256 270 .
Vijay H Honkalaskar, Upendra V Bhandarkar & Milind Sohoni. (2013) Development of a fuel efficient cookstove through a participatory bottom-up approach. Energy, Sustainability and Society 3:1.
Crossref
Katharine Owens & Carl Zimmerman. (2013) Local Governance Versus Centralization: C onnecticut Wetlands Governance as a Model . Review of Policy Research 30:6, pages 629-656.
Crossref
IOAN FAZEY, ANNA C. EVELY, MARK S. REED, LINDSAY C. STRINGER, JOANNEKE KRUIJSEN, PIRAN C. L. WHITE, ANDREW NEWSHAM, LIXIAN JIN, MARTIN CORTAZZI, JEREMY PHILLIPSON, KIRSTY BLACKSTOCK, NOEL ENTWISTLE, WILLIAM SHEATE, FIONA ARMSTRONG, CHRIS BLACKMORE, JOHN FAZEY, JULIE INGRAM, JON GREGSON, PHILIP LOWE, SARAH MORTON & CHRIS TREVITT. (2012) Knowledge exchange: a review and research agenda for environmental management. Environmental Conservation 40:1, pages 19-36.
Crossref
Thomas Vervisch, Kristof Titeca, Koen Vlassenroot & Johan Braeckman. (2013) Social Capital and Post‐Conflict Reconstruction in Burundi: The Limits of Community‐based Reconstruction. Development and Change 44:1, pages 147-174.
Crossref
Mike Christie, Ioan Fazey, Rob Cooper, Tony Hyde & Jasper O. Kenter. (2012) An evaluation of monetary and non-monetary techniques for assessing the importance of biodiversity and ecosystem services to people in countries with developing economies. Ecological Economics 83, pages 67-78.
Crossref
Dorien Baelden, Leo Van Audenhove & Tania Vergnani. (2012) Using new technologies for stimulating interpersonal communication on HIV and AIDS. Telematics and Informatics 29:2, pages 166-176.
Crossref
Daniel Fischer. (2011) Educational Organisations as ‘Cultures of Consumption’: Cultural Contexts of Consumer Learning in Schools. European Educational Research Journal 10:4, pages 595-610.
Crossref
Helena Grunfeld, Sokleap Hak & Tara Pin. (2011) Understanding benefits realisation of iREACH from a capability approach perspective. Ethics and Information Technology 13:2, pages 151-172.
Crossref
Mary C. Thompson, Manali Baruah & Edward R. Carr. (2011) Seeing REDD+ as a project of environmental governance. Environmental Science & Policy 14:2, pages 100-110.
Crossref
Helena Grunfeld, Sriram Guddireddigari, Benita Marian, John Peter & Vijay Kumar. 2011. Frameworks for ICT Policy. Frameworks for ICT Policy 50 75 .
Haluk Geray & Funda Basaran Özdemir. 2011. Handbook of Research on Information Communication Technology Policy. Handbook of Research on Information Communication Technology Policy 599 615 .
Crescentia Y. DakuboCrescenti Y. Dakubo. 2010. Ecosystems and Human Health. Ecosystems and Human Health 57 69 .
Gerhard Göhler, Ulrike Höppner, Sybille De La Rosa & Stefan Skupien. (2010) Steuerung jenseits von HierarchiePolitics Beyond Hierarchy. Politische Vierteljahresschrift 51:4, pages 691-720.
Crossref
Jaqueline Ann Goldin. (2010) Water Policy in South Africa: Trust and Knowledge as Obstacles to Reform. Review of Radical Political Economics 42:2, pages 195-212.
Crossref
Stephen Morse. (2008) Post‐sustainable development. Sustainable Development 16:5, pages 341-352.
Crossref
Elisabeth Gotschi, Bernhard Freyer & Robert Delve. 2008. Doing Cross-Cultural Research. Doing Cross-Cultural Research 213 231 .
Rachel Pain & Sara Kindon. (2016) Participatory Geographies. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 39:12, pages 2807-2812.
Crossref
Chris Sneddon & Coleen Fox. (2007) Power, Development, and Institutional Change: Participatory Governance in the Lower Mekong Basin. World Development 35:12, pages 2161-2181.
Crossref
André Joyal & Kamal El Batal. (2007) Décentralisation et développement rural. Étude de cas québécois. Revue d’Économie Régionale & Urbaine juillet:2, pages 251-267.
Crossref
Giles Mohan. (2007) Participatory Development: From Epistemological Reversals to Active Citizenship. Geography Compass 1:4, pages 779-796.
Crossref
Eleanor Sanderson. (2007) The Challenge of Placing Spirituality within Geographies of Development. Geography Compass 1:3, pages 389-404.
Crossref
Scott A. Fritzen & Caroline Brassard. (2016) Multi-level assessments for better targeting of the poor. Progress in Development Studies 7:2, pages 99-113.
Crossref
Shweta Singh. (2006) Deconstructing ‘gender and development’ for ‘identities of women’. International Journal of Social Welfare 16:2, pages 100-109.
Crossref
John Rapley. (2016) State capacity and development in a post-modern age. Progress in Development Studies 6:2, pages 167-172.
Crossref
Dirk Kohnert. (2005) Country Concepts and the Rational Actor Trap - Limitations to Strategic Management of International NGOs. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Crossref
Ulrike HHppner & Dominik Nagl. (2009) Approaching Understanding: Governance and Governmentality as Concepts for the Analysis of Politics in (Post-)Colonial Spaces. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.