Advanced search
Publication Cover
International Studies in the Philosophy of Science Volume 25, 2011 - Issue 2
Submit an article Journal homepage
945
Views
87
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
ARTICLES

Mechanistic Evidence: Disambiguating the Russo–Williamson Thesis

Phyllis McKay IllariCorrespondence[email protected]
View further author information
Pages 139-157 | Published online: 27 Jul 2011

Citations (87)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (6)

Adrian K. Yee & Kenji Hayakawa. (2023) Medical epistemology meets economics: how (not) to GRADE universal basic income research. Journal of Economic Methodology 30:3, pages 245-264.
Read now
Steven Tresker. (2021) Treatment Effectiveness and the Russo–Williamson Thesis, EBM+, and Bradford Hill's Viewpoints. International Studies in the Philosophy of Science 34:3, pages 131-158.
Read now
O. Çağlar Dede. (2019) Behavioral policies and inequities: the case of incentivized smoking cessation policies. Journal of Economic Methodology 26:3, pages 272-289.
Read now
Jon Williamson. (2019) Establishing Causal Claims in Medicine. International Studies in the Philosophy of Science 32:1, pages 33-61.
Read now
Derek Beach. (2016) It's all about mechanisms – what process-tracing case studies should be tracing. New Political Economy 21:5, pages 463-472.
Read now
Alessio Moneta & Federica Russo. (2014) Causal models and evidential pluralism in econometrics. Journal of Economic Methodology 21:1, pages 54-76.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (81)

Saúl Pérez-González. (2024) Evidence of mechanisms in evidence-based policy. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 103, pages 95-104.
Crossref
Jaakko Kuorikoski & Caterina Marchionni. (2023) Evidential Variety and Mixed-Methods Research in Social Science. Philosophy of Science 90:5, pages 1449-1458.
Crossref
Michael Wilde. (2023) The EBM+ movement. The International Journal of Biostatistics 19:2, pages 283-293.
Crossref
Mariusz Maziarz. (2023) Causal Pluralism in Medicine and its Implications for Clinical Practice. Journal for General Philosophy of Science.
Crossref
Nidia Yaneth Torres Merchan, Jordi Solbes, Camilo Arturo Suarez Ballesteros & José Luis Casas Hinestroza. (2023) Dificultades en el razonamiento causal y en los conceptos utilizados para explicar el efecto Mpemba. Educación Química 34:4, pages 119-134.
Crossref
Elena Rocca & Saúl Pérez‐González. (2023) Evaluating the relevance of epidemiological studies for the single patient: How can evidence of mechanisms help?. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice.
Crossref
Larry Dershem, Maya Komakhidze & Mariam Berianidze. (2023) Simple but not simplistic: Findings from a theory-driven retrospective evaluation of a small projects program. Evaluation and Program Planning 97, pages 102267.
Crossref
Somogy Varga. (2023) Understanding in Medicine. Erkenntnis.
Crossref
Élodie Giroux. 2023. Integrative Approaches in Environmental Health and Exposome Research. Integrative Approaches in Environmental Health and Exposome Research 129 171 .
Cristina Barés Gómez & Matthieu Fontaine. 2023. Handbook of Abductive Cognition. Handbook of Abductive Cognition 481 506 .
Mariusz Maziarz & Adrian Stencel. (2022) The failure of drug repurposing for COVID-19 as an effect of excessive hypothesis testing and weak mechanistic evidence. History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences 44:4.
Crossref
Michael Wilde. (2022) A Dilemma for the Russo–Williamson Thesis. Erkenntnis.
Crossref
Virginia Ghiara. (2022) Taking the Russo-Williamson thesis seriously in the social sciences. Synthese 200:6.
Crossref
Stuart Glennan, Phyllis Illari & Erik Weber. (2021) Six Theses on Mechanisms and Mechanistic Science. Journal for General Philosophy of Science 53:2, pages 143-161.
Crossref
. 2022. Agent‐based Models and Causal Inference. Agent‐based Models and Causal Inference 127 148 .
Jacob Stegenga. (2022) Evidence of effectiveness. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 91, pages 288-295.
Crossref
Liam G. McCoy, Connor T.A. Brenna, Stacy S. Chen, Karina Vold & Sunit Das. (2022) Believing in black boxes: machine learning for healthcare does not need explainability to be evidence-based. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 142, pages 252-257.
Crossref
Raffaella CampanerRaffaella Campaner. 2022. Explaining Disease: Philosophical Reflections on Medical Research and Clinical Practice. Explaining Disease: Philosophical Reflections on Medical Research and Clinical Practice 45 63 .
Sepehr Ehsani. 2022. The Future Circle of Healthcare. The Future Circle of Healthcare 51 88 .
Cristina Barés Gómez & Matthieu Fontaine. 2022. Handbook of Abductive Cognition. Handbook of Abductive Cognition 1 26 .
Samantha Nicole Andrade Viera. (2021) Institucionalización de políticas anticorrupción a través del apoyo de misiones internacionales. OPERA:30, pages 197-213.
Crossref
Gianluca Pozzoni & Tuukka Kaidesoja. (2021) Context in Mechanism-Based Explanation. Philosophy of the Social Sciences 51:6, pages 523-554.
Crossref
Marina DiMarco. (2022) Wishful Intelligibility, Black Boxes, and Epidemiological Explanation. Philosophy of Science 88:5, pages 824-834.
Crossref
Yafeng Shan & Jon Williamson. (2021) Applying Evidential Pluralism to the social sciences. European Journal for Philosophy of Science 11:4.
Crossref
Nancy Cartwright. (2021) Rigour versus the need for evidential diversity. Synthese 199:5-6, pages 13095-13119.
Crossref
Derek Beach. (2021) Evidential pluralism and evidence of mechanisms in the social sciences. Synthese 199:3-4, pages 8899-8919.
Crossref
Carl F. Craver, Stuart Glennan & Mark Povich. (2021) Constitutive relevance & mutual manipulability revisited. Synthese 199:3-4, pages 8807-8828.
Crossref
Michael Wilde. (2021) Mechanistic reasoning and the problem of masking. Synthese 199:3-4, pages 6103-6118.
Crossref
Gianluca Manzo & Lucas Sage. 2007. The Blackwell Encyclopedia of Sociology. The Blackwell Encyclopedia of Sociology 1 10 .
Polly Mitchell & Anna Alexandrova. (2020) Well-Being and Pluralism. Journal of Happiness Studies 22:6, pages 2411-2433.
Crossref
Rosa W. Runhardt. (2021) Evidential Pluralism and Epistemic Reliability in Political Science: Deciphering Contradictions between Process Tracing Methodologies. Philosophy of the Social Sciences 51:4, pages 425-442.
Crossref
Yin Chung Au. (2021) Epistemic values of quantity and variety of evidence in biological mechanism research. European Journal for Philosophy of Science 11:2.
Crossref
Jon Williamson. (2018) Establishing the teratogenicity of Zika and evaluating causal criteria. Synthese 198:S10, pages 2505-2518.
Crossref
Christopher ChoGlueck. (2019) Broadening the scope of our understanding of mechanisms: lessons from the history of the morning-after pill. Synthese 198:3, pages 2223-2252.
Crossref
Derek Beach & Jonas Gejl Kaas. (2020) The Great Divides: Incommensurability, the Impossibility of Mixed-Methodology, and What to Do about It. International Studies Review 22:2, pages 214-235.
Crossref
Daniel Auker‐Howlett & Michael Wilde. (2019) Reinforced reasoning in medicine. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 26:2, pages 458-464.
Crossref
José Luis Luján & Oliver Todt. (2020) Standards of evidence and causality in regulatory science: Risk and benefit assessment. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A 80, pages 82-89.
Crossref
Elena Rocca & Rani Lill Anjum. (2020) Causal Evidence and Dispositions in Medicine and Public Health. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 17:6, pages 1813.
Crossref
Derek Beach. (2019) Multi-Method Research in the Social Sciences: A Review of Recent Frameworks and a Way Forward. Government and Opposition 55:1, pages 163-182.
Crossref
Pietro Ghezzi, Virginia Ghiara & Kevin Davies. 2020. Oxidative Stress. Oxidative Stress 13 27 .
Derek Beach. 2020. Handbuch Methoden der Politikwissenschaft. Handbuch Methoden der Politikwissenschaft 699 719 .
Catherine Belzung, Etienne Billette de Villemeur & Maël Lemoine. 2020. Uncertainty in Pharmacology. Uncertainty in Pharmacology 79 100 .
Veli-Pekka Parkkinen & Jon Williamson. 2020. Uncertainty in Pharmacology. Uncertainty in Pharmacology 59 78 .
Adam LaCaze & Karl Winckel. 2020. Uncertainty in Pharmacology. Uncertainty in Pharmacology 261 287 .
Jeffrey K. Aronson. 2020. Uncertainty in Pharmacology. Uncertainty in Pharmacology 3 38 .
Guillaume Fontaine, Cecilia Medrano Caviedes & Iván NarváezGuillaume Fontaine, Cecilia Medrano Caviedes & Iván Narváez. 2020. The Politics of Public Accountability. The Politics of Public Accountability 51 98 .
Adam La Caze. (2019) Better evaluating mechanisms in medicine. Book Review: Evaluating E vidence of M echanisms in M edicine . Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 25:6, pages 1228-1231.
Crossref
Jonathan M. Spring & Phyllis Illari. (2018) Building General Knowledge of Mechanisms in Information Security. Philosophy & Technology 32:4, pages 627-659.
Crossref
Bennett Holman. (2017) Philosophers on drugs. Synthese 196:11, pages 4363-4390.
Crossref
Daniel Auker-Howlett & Michael Wilde. (2019) Causality in medicine, and its relation to action, mechanisms, and probability. Metascience 28:3, pages 387-391.
Crossref
. 2019. Time and Causality across the Sciences. Time and Causality across the Sciences.
Stefan Dragulinescu. (2018) MEDICAL MECHANISMS AND THE RESILIENCE OF PROBABILITIES. Episteme 16:3, pages 322-339.
Crossref
Michael Wilde & Veli-Pekka Parkkinen. (2017) Extrapolation and the Russo–Williamson thesis. Synthese 196:8, pages 3251-3262.
Crossref
Sydney Katherine Hovda. (2018) Is EBM an Appropriate Model for Research into the Effectiveness of Psychotherapy?. Topoi 38:2, pages 401-409.
Crossref
Stefano Canali. (2019) Evaluating evidential pluralism in epidemiology: mechanistic evidence in exposome research. History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences 41:1.
Crossref
Caterina Marchionni & Samuli Reijula. (2019) What is mechanistic evidence, and why do we need it for evidence-based policy?. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A 73, pages 54-63.
Crossref
Derek Beach. (2017) Achieving Methodological Alignment When Combining QCA and Process tracing in Practice. Sociological Methods & Research 47:1, pages 64-99.
Crossref
Derek Beach. 2018. Handbuch Methoden der Politikwissenschaft. Handbuch Methoden der Politikwissenschaft 1 21 .
Veli-Pekka Parkkinen, Christian Wallmann, Michael Wilde, Brendan Clarke, Phyllis Illari, Michael P Kelly, Charles Norell, Federica Russo, Beth Shaw & Jon WilliamsonVeli-Pekka Parkkinen, Christian Wallmann, Michael Wilde, Brendan Clarke, Phyllis Illari, Michael P. Kelly, Charles Norell, Federica Russo, Beth Shaw & Jon Williamson. 2018. Evaluating Evidence of Mechanisms in Medicine. Evaluating Evidence of Mechanisms in Medicine 91 98 .
Veli-Pekka Parkkinen, Christian Wallmann, Michael Wilde, Brendan Clarke, Phyllis Illari, Michael P Kelly, Charles Norell, Federica Russo, Beth Shaw & Jon WilliamsonVeli-Pekka Parkkinen, Christian Wallmann, Michael Wilde, Brendan Clarke, Phyllis Illari, Michael P. Kelly, Charles Norell, Federica Russo, Beth Shaw & Jon Williamson. 2018. Evaluating Evidence of Mechanisms in Medicine. Evaluating Evidence of Mechanisms in Medicine 63 75 .
. 2017. Introduction à la philosophie des sciences médicales. Introduction à la philosophie des sciences médicales 187 206 .
Stefan Dragulinescu. (2016) Mechanisms and Difference-Making. Acta Analytica 32:1, pages 29-54.
Crossref
Federica Russo. 2017. Handbook of the Philosophy of Medicine. Handbook of the Philosophy of Medicine 839 849 .
Till Grüne-Yanoff. (2015) WHY BEHAVIOURAL POLICY NEEDS MECHANISTIC EVIDENCE. Economics and Philosophy 32:3, pages 463-483.
Crossref
Jacob Stegenga. (2016) Hollow Hunt for Harms. Perspectives on Science 24:5, pages 481-504.
Crossref
Michael Wilde & Jon Williamson. 2016. Statistics and Causality. Statistics and Causality 31 41 .
Phyllis Illari & Federica Russo. (2013) Information Channels and Biomarkers of Disease. Topoi 35:1, pages 175-190.
Crossref
Olaf Dammann. (2016) Causality, mosaics, and the health sciences. Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 37:2, pages 161-168.
Crossref
Alexander R. Fiorentino & Olaf Dammann. (2015) Evidence, illness, and causation: An epidemiological perspective on the Russo–Williamson Thesis. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 54, pages 1-9.
Crossref
Jacob Stegenga. (2015) Measuring effectiveness. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 54, pages 62-71.
Crossref
Adrien Barton & Till Grüne-Yanoff. (2015) From Libertarian Paternalism to Nudging—and Beyond. Review of Philosophy and Psychology 6:3, pages 341-359.
Crossref
Federica Russo. 2015. Handbook of the Philosophy of Medicine. Handbook of the Philosophy of Medicine 1 11 .
Brendan Clarke, Donald Gillies, Phyllis Illari, Federica Russo & Jon Williamson. (2013) Mechanisms and the Evidence Hierarchy. Topoi 33:2, pages 339-360.
Crossref
Wolfgang Pietsch. (2014) The Structure of Causal Evidence Based on Eliminative Induction. Topoi 33:2, pages 421-435.
Crossref
Jacob Stegenga. (2013) Down with the Hierarchies. Topoi 33:2, pages 313-322.
Crossref
Marielle Berriet-Solliec, Pierre Labarthe & Catherine Laurent. (2014) Goals of evaluation and types of evidence. Evaluation 20:2, pages 195-213.
Crossref
Julian Reiss. (2012) Causation in the sciences: An inferentialist account. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 43:4, pages 769-777.
Crossref
François Claveau. (2012) The Russo–Williamson Theses in the social sciences: Causal inference drawing on two types of evidence. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 43:4, pages 806-813.
Crossref
Federica Russo & Jon Williamson. (2012) EnviroGenomarkers: The Interplay Between Mechanisms and Difference Making in Establishing Causal Claims. Medicine Studies 3:4, pages 249-262.
Crossref
Federica Russo. (2011) Public health policy, evidence, and causation: lessons from the studies on obesity. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 15:2, pages 141-151.
Crossref
George Darby & Jon Williamson. (2011) Imaging Technology and the Philosophy of Causality. Philosophy & Technology 24:2, pages 115-136.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.