1,382
Views
70
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

“Guys Can't Say That to Guys”: Four Experiments Assessing the Normative Motivation Account for Deficiencies in the Emotional Support Provided by MenFootnote

Pages 468-501 | Published online: 03 Feb 2007

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Read on this site (30)

Reed M. Reynolds, Amanda J. Holmstrom, Samantha J. Shebib, David D. Clare, Ashley A. H. Edwards, Allison P. Mazur, Travis L. Poland, Morgan E. Summers, Haley R. Royer & Lu Zhang. (2024) The Impact of Effort Attributions on the Quality of Esteem Support Messages Produced. Communication Studies 75:3, pages 302-321.
Read now
Jocelyn M. DeGroot. (2024) “You Think This is Hard? Just Wait…”: Memorable Messages in Motherhood. Western Journal of Communication 88:2, pages 418-435.
Read now
Emily M. Buehler, Andrew C. High, Rachael E. Bishop, Joshua D. Johnson, Daniel A. Lee, Amanda E. Lilly & Kelly Sweeney. (2024) Examining the Attributional Links Between Message Quality and Outcomes of Emotional Support Received on Facebook. Communication Studies 75:2, pages 132-150.
Read now
Kellie St.Cyr Brisini & Ningyang Wang. (2024) Support features, psychological reactance, and support outcomes: evaluating social network support for friends and daters. Communication Quarterly 72:1, pages 1-27.
Read now
Navjotpal Kaur, Rosemary Ricciardelli, Amber Fletcher & R. Nicholas Carleton. (2023) ‘You are safe. You are not alone:’ gender and Social Support Coping (SSC) in public safety personnel. Journal of Gender Studies 32:4, pages 343-358.
Read now
Samantha J. Shebib, Amanda J. Holmstrom, Adam J. Mason, Allison P. Mazur, Lu Zhang & Amanda Allard. (2020) Sex and Gender Differences in Esteem Support: Examining Main and Interaction Effects. Communication Studies 71:1, pages 167-186.
Read now
Nicolas Mascret, Olivier Vors, Tanguy Marqueste, Rémy Casanova & François Cury. (2019) Social support from evaluative familiar persons – a buffer against stress? Preliminary evidence of neuroendocrine and psychological responses. Anxiety, Stress, & Coping 32:5, pages 534-544.
Read now
Stephen A. Rains, Chelsie Akers, Corey A. Pavlich, Eric Tsetsi & Michael Appelbaum. (2019) Examining the quality of social support messages produced face-to-face and in computer-mediated communication: The effects of hyperpersonal communication. Communication Monographs 86:3, pages 271-291.
Read now
Susanne M. Jones, Graham D. Bodie, Lucas Youngvorst, Michael Navarro & Carly Danielson. (2018) Mapping the terrain of person-centered supportive conversations. Communication Monographs 85:4, pages 467-490.
Read now
Graham D. Bodie, Shaughan A. Keaton & Susanne M. Jones. (2018) Individual Listening Values Moderate the Impact of Verbal Person Centeredness on Helper Evaluations: A Test of the Dual-Process Theory of Supportive Message Outcomes. International Journal of Listening 32:3, pages 127-139.
Read now
Jennifer Gill Rosier & James M. Tyler. (2017) Finding the Love Guru in You: Examining the Effectiveness of a Sexual Communication Training Program for Married Couples. Marriage & Family Review 53:1, pages 65-87.
Read now
Jacquelyn Harvey-Knowles & Meara Faw. (2016) The Provider Expressions of Verbal Person-Centeredness (PE-VPC) Scale: Development and Initial Validation. Communication Reports 29:1, pages 35-49.
Read now
Jennifer S. Priem & Denise Haunani Solomon. (2015) Emotional Support and Physiological Stress Recovery: The Role of Support Matching, Adequacy, and Invisibility. Communication Monographs 82:1, pages 88-112.
Read now
Andrew C. High & Denise Haunani Solomon. (2014) Communication Channel, Sex, and the Immediate and Longitudinal Outcomes of Verbal Person-centered Support. Communication Monographs 81:4, pages 439-468.
Read now
Ira A. Virtanen & Pekka Isotalus. (2014) Talking troubles with Finnish men: meaningful contexts of ‘supportive silence’. NORMA 9:2, pages 111-125.
Read now
Heiko Motschenbacher. (2014) FOCUSING ON NORMATIVITY IN LANGUAGE AND SEXUALITY STUDIES. Critical Discourse Studies 11:1, pages 49-70.
Read now
Graham D. Bodie, Andrea J. Vickery & Christopher C. Gearhart. (2013) The Nature of Supportive Listening, I: Exploring the Relation between Supportive Listeners and Supportive People. International Journal of Listening 27:1, pages 39-49.
Read now
ErinaL. MacGeorge & Kristi Wilkum. (2012) Predicting Comforting Quality in the Context of Miscarriage. Communication Reports 25:2, pages 62-74.
Read now
AndrewC. High & James Price Dillard. (2012) A Review and Meta-Analysis of Person-Centered Messages and Social Support Outcomes. Communication Studies 63:1, pages 99-118.
Read now
Jennifer Waldeck, Cathryn Durante, Briana Helmuth & Brandon Marcia. (2012) Communication in a Changing World: Contemporary Perspectives on Business Communication Competence. Journal of Education for Business 87:4, pages 230-240.
Read now
Erin E. Crockett, Timothy J. Loving, Benjamin Le & Miriam S. Korn. (2011) Predicting Women's and Men's Reactions to Geographic Separation: Relational Interdependence Matters. The Journal of Social Psychology 151:6, pages 710-726.
Read now
BrantR. Burleson, LisaK. Hanasono, GrahamD. Bodie, AmandaJ. Holmstrom, JenniferD. McCullough, JessicaJ. Rack & Jennifer Gill Rosier. (2011) Are Gender Differences in Responses to Supportive Communication a Matter of Ability, Motivation, or Both? Reading Patterns of Situation Effects Through the Lens of a Dual-Process Theory. Communication Quarterly 59:1, pages 37-60.
Read now
SarahE. Dirks & Sandra Metts. (2010) An Investigation of the Support Process: Decision, Enactment, and Outcome. Communication Studies 61:4, pages 391-411.
Read now
Jennifer P. Agans, Steven Hanna, Katrina Black Reed, Cami Stillwell & Sunhye Bai. Leisure and psychosocial functioning during the COVID-19 pandemic: Exploring data from adolescents and parents of adolescents. Journal of Leisure Research 0:0, pages 1-21.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (40)

Y. Anthony Chen & Runzhi Mary Lu. (2023) Texting or face-to-face for support-seeking in romantic relationships: The role of affordances and attachment. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 41:5, pages 1136-1156.
Crossref
Yi Zhu, Siyuan Ma & Mary Bresnahan. (2024) A quantitative study on Chinese international students’ support mechanisms to address alienation caused by COVID-19 stigma encounters in the United States. International Journal of Intercultural Relations 98, pages 101926.
Crossref
Jenny L. Crowley, Andrew C. High, Michael R. Kotowski & Dennis N. McCarty. (2023) Conflicting Goals When Seeking Support for Mental Health Concerns: Testing a Stigma Support Activation Model. Communication Research.
Crossref
Roxy Ackerman, Brittany Watson, James Serpell, Chelsea L. Reinhard & Lauren Powell. (2023) Understanding the Motivations of Foster Caregivers at Animal Shelters. Animals 13:17, pages 2694.
Crossref
Nirit Geva, Sari Golan, Lior Pinchas & Ruth Defrin. (2023) Sex effects in the interaction of acute stress and pain perception. Pain 164:3, pages 587-597.
Crossref
Emily M. Buehler & Lucas J. Youngvorst. (2022) Online support-seeking in the context of grief: How support-seeking message content and communication channels shape support providers’ impressions of the bereaved. Computers in Human Behavior 137, pages 107428.
Crossref
Erica Szkody & Cliff McKinney. (2021) Evaluating comforting messages with the sentiment analysis and social cognition engine. Applied Psychology: Health and Well-Being 14:2, pages 645-662.
Crossref
Amanda J. Holmstrom, Samantha J. Shebib, Josephine K. Boumis, Amanda Allard, Adam J. Mason & Jong In Lim. (2021) Support gaps during the COVID-19 pandemic: Sex differences and effects on well-being. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 38:10, pages 2985-3009.
Crossref
Randall A. Renstrom & Victor C. Ottati. (2020) “I feel your pain”: The effect of displaying empathy on political candidate evaluation. Journal of Social and Political Psychology 8:2, pages 767-787.
Crossref
Stephen A. Rains, Corey A. Pavlich, Eric Tsetsi & Chelsie Akers. (2019) Evaluating the Scope and Theoretical Mechanisms of Person-Centered Social Support: The Case of the Comforting Computer Program. Communication Research 47:4, pages 512-540.
Crossref
Stephen A. Rains, Corey A. Pavlich, Bethany Lutovsky, Eric Tsetsi & Anjali Ashtaputre. (2019) Support seeker expectations, support message quality, and supportive interaction processes and outcomes: The case of the comforting computer program revisited. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 37:2, pages 647-666.
Crossref
Stephen A. Rains, Eric Tsetsi, Chelsie Akers, Corey A. Pavlich & Michael Appelbaum. (2018) Factors Influencing the Quality of Social Support Messages Produced Online: The Role of Responsibility for Distress and Others’ Support Attempts. Communication Research 46:6, pages 866-886.
Crossref
Susanne M. Jones, Graham D. Bodie & Sam D. Hughes. (2016) The Impact of Mindfulness on Empathy, Active Listening, and Perceived Provisions of Emotional Support. Communication Research 46:6, pages 838-865.
Crossref
Mair Underwood & Rebecca Olson. (2018) ‘Manly tears exploded from my eyes, lets feel together brahs’: Emotion and masculinity within an online body building community. Journal of Sociology 55:1, pages 90-107.
Crossref
Shardé M Davis & Tamara D Afifi. (2019) The Strong Black Woman Collective Theory: Determining the Prosocial Functions of Strength Regulation in Groups of Black Women Friends†. Journal of Communication 69:1, pages 1-25.
Crossref
Meara H. Faw. (2016) Supporting the supporter. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 35:2, pages 202-223.
Crossref
Mair Underwood. 2018. Digital Intimate Publics and Social Media. Digital Intimate Publics and Social Media 161 176 .
Alexa Paynter & Campbell Leaper. (2016) Heterosexual Dating Double Standards in Undergraduate Women and Men. Sex Roles 75:7-8, pages 393-406.
Crossref
Andrew C. High & Denise Haunani Solomon. (2016) Explaining the Durable Effects of Verbal Person-Centered Supportive Communication: Indirect Effects or Invisible Support?. Human Communication Research 42:2, pages 200-220.
Crossref
Heiko MotschenbacherHeiko Motschenbacher. 2016. Language, Normativity and Europeanisation. Language, Normativity and Europeanisation 51 115 .
Brian Joseph Gillespie, Janet Lever, David Frederick & Tracy Royce. (2014) Close adult friendships, gender, and the life cycle. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 32:6, pages 709-736.
Crossref
Amanda J. Holmstrom, Graham D. Bodie, Brant R. Burleson, Jennifer D. McCullough, Jessica J. Rack, Lisa K. Hanasono & Jennifer G. Rosier. (2013) Testing a Dual-Process Theory of Supportive Communication Outcomes: How Multiple Factors Influence Outcomes in Support Situations. Communication Research 42:4, pages 526-546.
Crossref
Amanda J. Holmstrom. (2012) Interpersonal Esteem Enhancement. Communication Research 42:2, pages 281-313.
Crossref
Chris R. Morse & Walid A. Afifi. (2012) I’m Not Rude, I’m Just Moody. Communication Research 42:1, pages 87-106.
Crossref
Andrew C. High & Denise Haunani Solomon. (2014) Motivational systems and preferences for social support strategies. Motivation and Emotion 38:4, pages 463-474.
Crossref
Meara H. Faw. (2014) Young Adults’ Strategies for Managing Social Support During Weight-Loss Attempts. Qualitative Health Research 24:2, pages 267-278.
Crossref
Nathan M. Swords, Mark P. Orbe, Angela Cooke-Jackson & Amber L. Johnson. (2014) Exploring the Coordinated Management of Meaning of Sex: The Social Construction of Male College Student Logical Forces. Creative Education 05:15, pages 1383-1395.
Crossref
Ira A. Virtanen, Pekka Isotalus & Shaughan A. Keaton. (2014) “Offer No Readymade Solutions”: Men's support provision in specific episodes with an upset friend. Studies in Communication Sciences 14:1, pages 54-60.
Crossref
Mark T. Morman, Paul Schrodt & Michael J. Tornes. (2012) Self-disclosure mediates the effects of gender orientation and homophobia on the relationship quality of male same-sex friendships. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 30:5, pages 582-605.
Crossref
Graham D. Bodie. (2011) The Role of Thinking in the Comforting Process. Communication Research 40:4, pages 533-558.
Crossref
Erin L. Spottswood, Joseph B. Walther, Amanda J. Holmstrom & Nicole B. Ellison. (2013) Person-Centered Emotional Support and Gender Attributions in Computer-Mediated Communication. Human Communication Research 39:3, pages 295-316.
Crossref
Ira A. Virtanen & Pekka Isotalus. (2013) A Clear Mirror on Which to Reflect. Qualitative Communication Research 2:2, pages 133-158.
Crossref
Graham D. Bodie, Brant R. Burleson, Amanda J. Holmstrom, Jennifer D. McCullough, Jessica J. Rack, Lisa K. Hanasono & Jennifer G. Rosier. (2011) Effects of Cognitive Complexity and Emotional Upset on Processing Supportive Messages: Two Tests of a Dual-Process Theory of Supportive Communication Outcomes. Human Communication Research 37:3, pages 350-376.
Crossref
JENNIFER S. PRIEM & DENISE H. SOLOMON. (2011) Relational uncertainty and cortisol responses to hurtful and supportive messages from a dating partner. Personal Relationships 18:2, pages 198-223.
Crossref
Paul M. Brunet & Louis A. Schmidt. (2009) Sex Differences in the Expression and Use of Computer-Mediated Affective Language. Social Science Computer Review 28:2, pages 194-205.
Crossref
JENNIFER S. PRIEM, DENISE HAUNANI SOLOMON & KELI RYAN STEUBER. (2009) Accuracy and bias in perceptions of emotionally supportive communication in marriage. Personal Relationships 16:4, pages 531-552.
Crossref
Ashley M. Smith, Timothy J. Loving, Erin E. Crockett & Lorne Campbell. (2009) What’s Closeness Got to Do with It? Men’s and Women’s Cortisol Responses When Providing and Receiving Support. Psychosomatic Medicine 71:8, pages 843-851.
Crossref
Paul M. Brunet, Has Donnan, Gary McKeown, Ellen Douglas-Cowie & Roddy Cowie. (2009) Social signal processing: What are the relevant variables? And in what ways do they relate?. Social signal processing: What are the relevant variables? And in what ways do they relate?.
Brant R. Burleson & Amanda J. Holmstrom. 2008. The International Encyclopedia of Communication. The International Encyclopedia of Communication.
Brant R. Burleson, Meina Liu, Yan Liu & Steven T. Mortenson. (2016) Chinese Evaluations of Emotional Support Skills, Goals, and Behaviors. Communication Research 33:1, pages 38-63.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.