Advanced search
Publication Cover
Communication Monographs Volume 49, 1982 - Issue 1
Submit an article Journal homepage
49
Views
46
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

A comparison of normative and interactional explanations of group decision‐making: Social decision schemes versus valence distributions

Marshall Scott Poole Assistant professor of speech communication, University of Illinois, ; Visiting assistant professor of communication, University of Michigan,
,
Robert D. McPhee Assistant professor of speech communication, University of Illinois, Urbana‐Champaign
&
David R. Seibold Associate professor of speech communication, University of Illinois, Urbana‐Champaign
Pages 1-19 | Published online: 02 Jun 2009

Citations (46)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (18)

Sean J. Westwood. (2015) The Role of Persuasion in Deliberative Opinion Change. Political Communication 32:4, pages 509-528.
Read now
Nils Christian Sauer & Simone Kauffeld. (2013) Meetings as Networks: Applying Social Network Analysis to Team Interaction. Communication Methods and Measures 7:1, pages 26-47.
Read now
David R. Seibold, Daisy R. Lemus & Paul Kang. (2010) Extending the Conversational Argument Coding Scheme in Studies of Argument Quality in Group Deliberations. Communication Methods and Measures 4:1-2, pages 46-64.
Read now
Daniel J. Canary & David R. Seibold. (2010) Origins and Development of the Conversational Argument Coding Scheme. Communication Methods and Measures 4:1-2, pages 7-26.
Read now
Karen Lee Ashcraft, TimothyR. Kuhn & François Cooren. (2009) 1 Constitutional Amendments: “Materializing” Organizational Communication. The Academy of Management Annals 3:1, pages 1-64.
Read now
Steven R. Corman & Timothy Kuhn. (2005) The Detectability of Socio-Egocentric Group Speech: A Quasi-Turing Test. Communication Monographs 72:2, pages 117-143.
Read now
RenéeA. Meyers & DaleE. Brashers. (1998) Argument in group decision making: Explicating a process model and investigating the argument‐outcome link. Communication Monographs 65:4, pages 261-281.
Read now
AbranJ. Salazar. (1997) Communication effects on small group decision‐making: Homogeneity and task as moderators of the communication‐performance relationship. Western Journal of Communication 61:1, pages 35-65.
Read now
DennisS. Gouran. (1994) The future of small group communication research: Revitalization or continued good health?. Communication Studies 45:1, pages 29-39.
Read now
Charles Pavitt. (1993) Does communication matter in social influence during small group discussion? Five positions. Communication Studies 44:3-4, pages 216-227.
Read now
Melva Underbakke, JeanM. Borg & Donovan Peterson. (1993) Researching and developing the knowledge base for teaching higher order thinking. Theory Into Practice 32:3, pages 138-146.
Read now
RenéeA. Meyers, DavidR. Seibold & Dale Brashers. (1991) Argument in initial group decision‐making discussions: Refinement of a coding scheme and a descriptive quantitative analysis. Western Journal of Speech Communication 55:1, pages 47-68.
Read now
JohnF. Cragan & DavidW. Wright. (1990) Small group communication research of the 1980s: A synthesis and critique. Communication Studies 41:3, pages 212-236.
Read now
RenéeA. Meyers. (1989) Testing persuasive argument theory's predictor model: Alternative interactional accounts of group argument and influence. Communication Monographs 56:2, pages 112-132.
Read now
Susan Jarboe. (1988) A comparison of input‐output, process‐output, and input‐process‐output models of small group problem‐solving effectiveness. Communication Monographs 55:2, pages 121-142.
Read now
DanielJ. Canary, BrentG. Brossmann & DavidR. Seibold. (1987) Argument structures in decision‐making groups. Southern Speech Communication Journal 53:1, pages 18-37.
Read now
Carl Camden, Howard Mims & MichaelT. Motley. (1985) Convergent validity of three communication data collection techniques: An analysis of black American English grammatical usage. Western Journal of Speech Communication 49:3, pages 166-176.
Read now
Marshall Scott Poole, DavidR. Seibold & RobertD. McPhee. (1985) Group decision‐making as a structurational process. Quarterly Journal of Speech 71:1, pages 74-102.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (28)

David Dryden Henningsen & Mary Lynn Miller Henningsen. 2021. The Emerald Handbook of Group and Team Communication Research. The Emerald Handbook of Group and Team Communication Research 275 287 .
JOHN GASTIL, KATHERINE R. KNOBLOCH, DAN KAHAN & DON BRAMAN. (2016) PARTICIPATORY POLICYMAKING ACROSS CULTURAL COGNITIVE DIVIDES: TWO TESTS OF CULTURAL BIASING IN PUBLIC FORUM DESIGN AND DELIBERATION. Public Administration 94:4, pages 970-987.
Crossref
Gregory D. Paul & Ian M. Borton. (2014) Exploring Communities of Facilitators: Orientations toward Restorative Justice. Conflict Resolution Quarterly 31:2, pages 189-218.
Crossref
Sarah Harvey & Chia-Yu Kou. (2013) Collective Engagement in Creative Tasks. Administrative Science Quarterly 58:3, pages 346-386.
Crossref
Laurie R. Weingart. 2012. Looking Back, Moving Forward: A Review of Group and Team-Based Research. Looking Back, Moving Forward: A Review of Group and Team-Based Research 1 25 .
Dean E. Hewes. (2009) Elaborations on the Socioegocentric and Dual-Level Connectionist Models of Group Interaction Processes. Human Communication Research 35:2, pages 304-308.
Crossref
Dean E. Hewes. (2009) The Influence of Communication Processes on Group Outcomes: Antithesis and Thesis. Human Communication Research 35:2, pages 249-271.
Crossref
Kerry F. Milch, Elke U. Weber, Kirstin C. Appelt, Michel J.J. Handgraaf & David H. Krantz. (2009) From individual preference construction to group decisions: Framing effects and group processes. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 108:2, pages 242-255.
Crossref
David R. Seibold & Renee A. Meyers. (2016) Group Argument. Small Group Research 38:3, pages 312-336.
Crossref
Daisy R. Lemus, David R. Seibold, Andrew J. Flanagin & Miriam J. Metzger. (2004) Argument and Decision Making in Computer-Mediated Groups. Journal of Communication 54:2, pages 302-320.
Crossref
MG Cruz, DD Henningsen & MLM Williams. (2000) The presence of norms in the absence of groups?.. Human Communication Research 26:1, pages 104-124.
Crossref
Craig D. Parks & Norbert L. Kerr. (1999) Twenty-Five Years of Social Decision Scheme Theory. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 80:1, pages 1-2.
Crossref
C. Arthur Vanlear & Edward A. Mabry. (2016) Testing Contrasting Interaction Models for Discriminating between Consensual and Dissentient Decision-Making Groups. Small Group Research 30:1, pages 29-58.
Crossref
ABRAN J. SALAZAR. (1996) Ambiguity and Communication Effects on Small Group Decision-Making Performance. Human Communication Research 23:2, pages 155-192.
Crossref
L. RICHARD HOFFMAN. (1994) Reply to McPhee. Human Communication Research 21:1, pages 64-66.
Crossref
ROBERT D. McPHEE. (1994) Response to Hoffman and Kleinman. Human Communication Research 21:1, pages 60-63.
Crossref
L. RICHARD HOFFMAN & GARY B. KLEINMAN. (1994) Individual and Group in Group Problem Solving The Valence Model Redressed. Human Communication Research 21:1, pages 36-59.
Crossref
ABRAN J. SALAZAR, RANDY Y. HIROKAWA, KATHLEEN M. PROPP, KELLY M. JULIAN & GEOFF B. LEATHAM. (1994) In Search of True Causes:.. Human Communication Research 20:4, pages 529-599.
Crossref
FRANKLIN J. BOSTER, JOHN E. HUNTER & JEROLD L. HALE. (2016) An Information-Processing Model of Jury Decision Making. Communication Research 18:4, pages 524-547.
Crossref
Jeanne M. Brett. (2007) Negotiating Group Decisions. Negotiation Journal 7:3, pages 291-310.
Crossref
Teresa Chandler Sabourin & Patricia Geist. (2016) Collaborative Production of Proposals in Group Decision Making. Small Group Research 21:3, pages 404-427.
Crossref
Edward A. Mabry & Mark Duke Atiridge. (2016) Small Group Interaction and Outcome Correlates for Structured and Unstructured Tasks. Small Group Research 21:3, pages 315-332.
Crossref
MICHAEL J. BEATTY. (1989) Group Members' Decision Rule Orientations and Consensus. Human Communication Research 16:2, pages 279-296.
Crossref
RENÉE A. MEYERS. (1989) Persuasive Arguments Theory A Test of Assumptions. Human Communication Research 15:3, pages 357-381.
Crossref
Glen S. Aikenhead. (1989) Decision-making theories as tools for interpreting student behavior during a scientific inquiry simulation. Journal of Research in Science Teaching 26:3, pages 189-203.
Crossref
BRANT R. BURLESON, BARBARA J. LEVINE & WENDY SAMTER. (1984) DECISION-MAKING PROCEDURE AND DECISION QUALITY. Human Communication Research 10:4, pages 557-574.
Crossref
Peter R. Monge, Richard V. Farace, Eric M. Eisenberg, Katherine I. Miller & Lynda L. White. (1984) The Process of Studying Process in Organizational Communication. Journal of Communication 34:1, pages 22-43.
Crossref
Drew Margolin, Yu-Ru Lin & David Lazer. (2013) Why so Similar?: Identifying Semantic Organizing Processes in Large Textual Corpora. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.