Advanced search
Publication Cover
Justice Quarterly Volume 37, 2020 - Issue 6
Submit an article Journal homepage
6,112
Views
83
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Police Officers as Warriors or Guardians: Empirical Reality or Intriguing Rhetoric?

Kyle McLeanCollege of Criminology and Criminal Justice, Florida State University, Tallahassee, FL, USA; Correspondence[email protected]
View further author information
,
Scott E. WolfeSchool of Criminal Justice, Michigan State University, East Lancing, MI, USA; View further author information
,
Jeff RojekDepartment of Criminal Justice, University of Texas at El Paso, El Paso, FL, USA; View further author information
,
Geoffrey P. AlpertDepartment of Criminology and Criminal Justice, University of South Carolina, Columbia, SC, USA; View further author information
&
Michael R. SmithCollege of Public Policy, University of Texas at San Antonio, San Antonio, TX, USAView further author information
Pages 1096-1118 | Received 08 May 2018, Accepted 01 Oct 2018, Published online: 23 Jan 2019

Citations (83)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (19)

Kristina Murphy & Molly McCarthy. (2023) Confirming or resisting the ‘racist cop’ stereotype?: the importance of a police officer’s ‘guardian’ identity in moderating support for procedural justice. Psychology, Crime & Law 29:10, pages 1031-1053.
Read now
Logan J. Somers & Jacob T. Foster. (2023) Going above and beyond: assessing the characteristics of officers who complete additional in-service training. Police Practice and Research 24:6, pages 646-660.
Read now
Kyle McLean, Terry Cherry & Geoffrey P. Alpert. (2023) Recruiting for change: shifting focus to address a workforce crisis. Police Practice and Research 24:4, pages 446-460.
Read now
Galia Cohen & Matt Bagwell. (2023) The state of mental health training in basic police curricula: A national level examination. Journal of Public Affairs Education 29:3, pages 327-349.
Read now
Jacob T. Foster, Michael T. Rossler & Charles Scheer. (2023) An empirical analysis of depolicing behavior. Police Practice and Research 0:0, pages 1-18.
Read now
Kathleen E. Padilla, Kelsey E. Tom & Adam D. Fine. (2023) Accepting the Challenge: Understanding Police Officers’ Perceptions of a Community-Based, Youth Empowerment Program. Justice Evaluation Journal 6:1, pages 1-19.
Read now
Colin Atkinson. (2023) Deception: a critical discourse analysis of undercover policing and intelligence operations in Star Wars: The Clone Wars. Journal of Policing, Intelligence and Counter Terrorism 18:1, pages 95-111.
Read now
Harley Williamson, Kristina Murphy & Natasha S. Madon. (2023) The negative implications of relative deprivation: an experiment of vicarious police contact and Muslims’ perceptions of police bias. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 49:1, pages 66-84.
Read now
Omeed S. Ilchi, James Frank & Shamma J. Hickling. (2022) Policing the police: predicting citizen support for police accountability. Police Practice and Research 23:6, pages 722-738.
Read now
Jacinta M. Gau, Eugene A. Paoline$suffix/text()$suffix/text() & Nicholas D. Paul. (2022) De-policing as a result of public scrutiny: examining officers’ perceptions of negative media attention and willingness to engage in self-initiated activity. Journal of Crime and Justice 45:5, pages 539-551.
Read now
John J. Sloan$suffix/text()$suffix/text() & Eugene A. Paoline$suffix/text()$suffix/text(). (2022) A National Comparison of Police Academies Operated by Academic Institutions and by Law Enforcement Agencies: Different Strokes for Different Folks?. Journal of Criminal Justice Education 33:4, pages 467-490.
Read now
Eugene A. Paoline$suffix/text()$suffix/text() & John J. Sloan$suffix/text()$suffix/text(). (2022) Women in the Police Academy: A National-Level Exploration of the Gendered Nature of Non-Completion. Women & Criminal Justice 0:0, pages 1-19.
Read now
Michael K. Logan & Gina S. Ligon. (2022) Come one, come all: individual-level diversity among anti-fascists. Dynamics of Asymmetric Conflict 15:1, pages 78-93.
Read now
Spencer G. Lawson, Scott E. Wolfe, Jeff Rojek & Geoffrey P. Alpert. (2022) Occupational stress and attitudes toward misconduct in law enforcement: The moderating role of organizational justice. Police Practice and Research 23:1, pages 95-110.
Read now
Lauren Gant & Lonnie Schaible. (2022) The impact of policing styles on officers’ willingness to make referrals into pre-arrest diversion initiatives. Police Practice and Research 23:1, pages 20-33.
Read now
Camilla De Camargo. (2022) ‘It's tough shit, basically, that you're all gonna get it': UK virus testing and police officer anxieties of contracting COVID-19. Policing and Society 32:1, pages 35-51.
Read now
Meret S. Hofer. (2021) “It's a Constant Juggling Act”: Toward Coherent Priorities for U.S. Policing. Justice Quarterly 38:7, pages 1448-1470.
Read now
Michael K. Logan & Gina S. Ligon. (2021) Come one, come all: individual-level diversity among anti-fascists. Dynamics of Asymmetric Conflict 14:2, pages 209-224.
Read now
Jose Torres & Timothy Reling. (2020) Under-policing and apprehensiveness toward stopping minorities across white and nonwhite officers post-Ferguson. Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice 18:4, pages 282-314.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (64)

Logan J. Somers & William Terrill. (2023) Assessing the relationship between officers' broad cultural attitudes and their situational perceptions of firearm danger. Policing: An International Journal 46:5/6, pages 751-765.
Crossref
Mario S Staller & Swen Koerner. (2022) A case example of teaching reflective policing to police students. Teaching Public Administration 41:3, pages 351-366.
Crossref
Ziv Gilad, Michal Raz‐Rotem, Amikam Harpaz & Haim Omer. (2023) Implementing a constructive struggle approach: Insights from a training program for security forces prior to executing a government evacuation policy in the context of a protracted conflict. Conflict Resolution Quarterly.
Crossref
Darryl B. Rice, Paul Prosper, Doug A. Franklin & William Luse. (2023) Examining the relationship between law enforcement agency support of anti-black racism and black people’s evaluations of policing style: the moderating impact of sex. Current Psychology.
Crossref
Jacinta M. Gau, Eugene A. PaolineIIIIII & Krystle L. Roman. (2021) Hispanic and Latinx Police Officers’ Perceptions of the Working Environment. Crime & Delinquency 69:9, pages 1567-1589.
Crossref
Ryan M. Welch, Jack Mewhirter, James E. WrightIIII & Jeongmin Oh. (2023) Evaluating the determinants of support for police militarization among officers. Politics & Policy 51:4, pages 636-660.
Crossref
Molly McCarthy, Kyle McLean & Geoff Alpert. (2023) The Influence of Guardian and Warrior Police Orientations on Australian Officers’ Use of Force Attitudes and Tactical Decision-Making. Police Quarterly.
Crossref
Jill A Davis, Darwin A Baluran & Shahidul Hassan. (2023) Support for Democratic Policing Among Frontline Police Officers: The Role of Social Dominance Orientation. The British Journal of Criminology.
Crossref
Rafael Alcadipani, Gabriela Lotta & Nissim Cohen. (2023) Natural born violence? Understanding street‐level bureaucrats' use of violence: Police officers and protests . Public Administration Review.
Crossref
Perfecta Delgado Oxholm & Jack Glaser. (2023) Goals and outcomes of police officer communication: Evidence from in-depth interviews. Group Processes & Intergroup Relations 26:4, pages 875-890.
Crossref
Jason R. Ingram, Eugene A. PaolineIIIIII, Alexis R. Rockwell & Andia M. Azimi. (2022) Police Chief Culture: A View From the Top. Police Quarterly 26:2, pages 245-273.
Crossref
Swen Körner & Mario S. Staller. (2023) Kontrolle der KontrolleSystemtheoretische Überlegungen zur Gewalt im System der Polizei. Soziale Systeme 27:1-2, pages 35-61.
Crossref
Jacob Herrera & Lonnie Schaible. (2023) When Prosecution Is Declined: Factors Influencing Prosecutorial Portrayal of Officers Involved in Shootings. Criminal Justice Policy Review 34:3, pages 211-235.
Crossref
Ashleigh N. Wojslawowicz, Robert J. Doan, Jacqueline T. Fish & James A. Spencer. (2023) Gauging the impact of negative media publicity on career decisions: exploring police recruit motivations during a recruitment crisis. Policing: An International Journal 46:2, pages 383-400.
Crossref
Anthony M Triola & Joshua Chanin. (2022) Police culture, transparency and civilian oversight: A case study of the National City Police Department. International Journal of Police Science & Management 25:1, pages 81-95.
Crossref
Kyle McLean, Arif Alikhan & Geoffrey P. Alpert. (2022) Re-examining the Use of Force Continuum: Why Resistance is Not the Only Driver of Use of Force Decisions. Police Quarterly 26:1, pages 85-110.
Crossref
Mario S. Staller, Swen Koerner, Valentina Heil, Andrew Abraham & Jamie Poolton. (2022) The planning and reflection of police use of force training: a German case study. Security Journal 36:1, pages 118-140.
Crossref
Eugene A. Paoline III & Jacinta M. Gau. (2022) Police stress: the role of occupational culture and officer characteristics. Policing: An International Journal 46:1, pages 194-208.
Crossref
Beck M. Strah, Joycelyn M. Pollock & Laurie T. Becker. (2022) Shifting From Warriors to Guardians: Officer Reflections on Law Enforcement Training in Washington State. Crime & Delinquency 69:2, pages 439-463.
Crossref
Swen Koerner, Mario S. Staller & Benjamin Zaiser. 2023. Handbuch Polizeipsychologie. Handbuch Polizeipsychologie 91 108 .
Benjamin Zaiser, Mario S. Staller & Swen Koerner. 2023. Handbuch Polizeipsychologie. Handbuch Polizeipsychologie 421 440 .
Swen Koerner, Mario S. Staller & Benjamin Zaiser. 2023. Handbuch Polizeipsychologie. Handbuch Polizeipsychologie 357 377 .
Swen Koerner, Mario S. Staller & Benni Zaiser. 2023. Police Conflict Management, Volume I. Police Conflict Management, Volume I 61 84 .
Stefan Schade & Markus M. Thielgen. 2023. Police Conflict Management, Volume I. Police Conflict Management, Volume I 223 247 .
Michael C. Gearhart. (2022) Social cohesion, mutual efficacy and informal social control: Collective efficacy and community-based crime prevention. International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice 71, pages 100548.
Crossref
Abigail R. Henson. (2022) “Dickheads” and “Cool Cops”: The Impact of Officers’ Perceived Cultural and Contextual Competence on Black Men's Appraisals of Police. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, pages 002242782211373.
Crossref
Cassandra K. Crifasi, Rebecca G. Williams, Marisa D. Booty, Jessica L. Owens-Young, Daniel W. Webster & Shani A.L. Buggs. (2022) Community perspectives on gun violence and safety: The role of policing in Baltimore City. Journal of Criminal Justice 83, pages 101964.
Crossref
Camilla De Camargo. (2021) The postcode lottery of safety: COVID-19 guidance and shortages of personal protective equipment (PPE) for UK police officers. The Police Journal: Theory, Practice and Principles 95:3, pages 537-561.
Crossref
Michelle N. Eliasson. 2022. Research Anthology on Modern Violence and Its Impact on Society. Research Anthology on Modern Violence and Its Impact on Society 783 804 .
Stefan Schade & Markus M. Thielgen. (2022) Commentary: Problems With Police Reports as Data Sources: A Researchers' Perspective. Frontiers in Psychology 13.
Crossref
Angelique Nairn & Ruby Roebuck. (2022) Promoting the police: A thematic analysis of the New Zealand Police recruitment campaigns and the construction of officers’ identities. Journal of Criminology 55:2, pages 221-238.
Crossref
Edward R. Maguire & Howard Giles. (2021) Public Expressions of Empathy and Sympathy by U.S. Criminal Justice Officials After Controversial Police Killings of African-Americans. Journal of Language and Social Psychology 41:1, pages 49-75.
Crossref
Cassandra D. Chaney. 2022. Encyclopedia of Violence, Peace, & Conflict. Encyclopedia of Violence, Peace, & Conflict 727 739 .
Swen Koerner & Mario Staller. 2022. Handbuch polizeiliches Einsatztraining. Handbuch polizeiliches Einsatztraining 947 958 .
Mario Staller & Swen Koerner. 2022. Handbuch polizeiliches Einsatztraining. Handbuch polizeiliches Einsatztraining 559 576 .
Mario Staller, Swen Koerner & Benjamin Zaiser. 2022. Handbuch polizeiliches Einsatztraining. Handbuch polizeiliches Einsatztraining 41 59 .
Valentina Heil & Michelle Bechold. 2022. Handbuch polizeiliches Einsatztraining. Handbuch polizeiliches Einsatztraining 379 390 .
Benjamin Zaiser, Mario Staller & Swen Koerner. 2022. Handbuch polizeiliches Einsatztraining. Handbuch polizeiliches Einsatztraining 279 295 .
Benjamin Zaiser, Mario Staller & Swen Koerner. 2022. Handbuch polizeiliches Einsatztraining. Handbuch polizeiliches Einsatztraining 257 277 .
Mario Staller, Benjamin Zaiser & Swen Koerner. 2022. Handbuch polizeiliches Einsatztraining. Handbuch polizeiliches Einsatztraining 243 256 .
Mario Staller, Swen Koerner & Benjamin Zaiser. 2022. Handbuch polizeiliches Einsatztraining. Handbuch polizeiliches Einsatztraining 223 241 .
Mario Staller, Swen Koerner & Valentina Heil. 2022. Handbuch polizeiliches Einsatztraining. Handbuch polizeiliches Einsatztraining 203 221 .
Natalie Todak, Susan Boyd, Rachel Tolber & Renée J. Mitchell. 2022. Rethinking and Reforming American Policing. Rethinking and Reforming American Policing 175 199 .
Eugene A. PaolineIIIIII, William Terrill & Logan J. Somers. (2021) Police Officer Use of Force Mindset and Street-Level Behavior. Police Quarterly 24:4, pages 547-577.
Crossref
John J. SloanIIIIII & Eugene A. PaolineIIIIII. (2021) “They Need More Training!” A National Level Analysis of Police Academy Basic Training Priorities. Police Quarterly 24:4, pages 486-518.
Crossref
Rosemary Ricciardelli, Elizabeth Andres, Meghan M Mitchell, Bastien Quirion, Diane Groll, Michael Adorjan, Marcella Siqueira Cassiano, James Shewmake, Martine Herzog-Evans, Dominique Moran, Dale C Spencer, Christine Genest, Stephen Czarnuch, James Gacek, Cramm Heidi, Katharina Maier, Jo Phoenix, Michael Weinrath, Joy MacDermid, Margaret McKinnon, Stacy Haynes, Helen Arnold, Jennifer Turner, Anna Eriksson, Alexandra Heber, Gregory Anderson, Renee MacPhee & Nicholas Carleton. (2021) CCWORK protocol: a longitudinal study of Canadian Correctional Workers’ Well-being, Organizations, Roles and Knowledge. BMJ Open 11:12, pages e052739.
Crossref
Jacinta M. Gau, Erika J. Brooke, Eugene A. Paoline III & Krystle L. Roman. (2021) Military experience among police officers: an examination of veterans' attitudes toward the community. Policing: An International Journal 44:6, pages 1060-1076.
Crossref
Jason R Ingram, Alexis R Rockwell, Chris Guerra & Eugene A Paoline III. (2021) An Examination of Officer Job Satisfaction and Workgroup Cultural Fit. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice 15:3, pages 1713-1728.
Crossref
Stacey Clifton, Jose Torres & James Hawdon. (2021) Examining Guardian and Warrior Orientations Across Racial and Ethnic Lines. Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology 36:3, pages 436-449.
Crossref
Michael D White, Victor Mora & Carlena Orosco. (2021) Exploring Variation in Police Perceptions of De-Escalation: Do Officer Characteristics Matter?. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice 15:2, pages 727-740.
Crossref
Michelle N. Eliasson. 2021. Invisible Victims and the Pursuit of Justice. Invisible Victims and the Pursuit of Justice 41 62 .
Lonnie Schaible, Lauren Gant & Stephanie Ames. (2020) The Impact of Police Attitudes Towards Offenders on Law-Enforcement Assisted Diversion Decisions. Police Quarterly 24:2, pages 205-232.
Crossref
Anaís M. Passos. (2020) Breaking the Law to Ensure Order: The Case of Tijuana (2007–2012). Bulletin of Latin American Research 40:2, pages 251-266.
Crossref
Joseph A Hamm & Scott E Wolfe. (2021) Using public priorities to disentangle the dimensions of procedural justice and trustworthiness in police–citizen interactions. The British Journal of Criminology 61:2, pages 558-579.
Crossref
John A. Shjarback & Edward R. Maguire. (2019) Extending Research on the “War on Cops”: The Effects of Ferguson on Nonfatal Assaults Against U.S. Police Officers. Crime & Delinquency 67:1, pages 3-26.
Crossref
James McGuire, Emily Evans & Eddie KaneJames McGuire, Emily Evans & Eddie Kane. 2021. Evidence-Based Policing and Community Crime Prevention. Evidence-Based Policing and Community Crime Prevention 1 26 .
Scott Wolfe, Spencer G. Lawson, Jeff Rojek & Geoffrey Alpert. (2020) Predicting Police Officer Seat Belt Use: Evidence-Based Solutions to Improve Officer Driving Safety. Police Quarterly 23:4, pages 472-499.
Crossref
Swen Koerner & Mario S. Staller. (2020) Commentary: Does the Norwegian Police Force Need a Well-Functioning Combat Mindset?. Frontiers in Psychology 11.
Crossref
Dylan B. Jackson, Alexander Testa & Michael G. Vaughn. (2020) Low Self-control and Legal Cynicism among At-Risk Youth: An Investigation into Direct and Vicarious Police Contact. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 57:6, pages 741-783.
Crossref
Dylan B. Jackson, Alexander Testa, Michael G. Vaughn & Daniel C. Semenza. (2020) Police stops and sleep behaviors among at-risk youth. Sleep Health 6:4, pages 435-441.
Crossref
Mario S. Staller & Swen Körner. (2020) Komplexe GewaltpräventionComplex violence prevention. Österreichische Zeitschrift für Soziologie 45:S1, pages 157-174.
Crossref
Jacinta M. Gau & Eugene A. PaolineIIIIII. (2020) Equal under the Law: Officers' Perceptions of Equitable Treatment and Justice in Policing. American Journal of Criminal Justice 45:3, pages 474-492.
Crossref
Kimberly C. Burke. (2020) Democratic Policing and Officer Well-Being. Frontiers in Psychology 11.
Crossref
Gabriel T Cesar. (2020) Ross Deuchar (2018). Gangs and Spirituality: Global Perspectives. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.