3,214
Views
59
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Articles

Focally Concerned About Focal Concerns: A Conceptual and Methodological Critique of Sentencing Disparities Research

Pages 1148-1175 | Received 13 Aug 2019, Accepted 22 Oct 2019, Published online: 12 Nov 2019

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Read on this site (14)

Jeffery T. Ulmer, Eric Silver & Lily S. Hanrath. (2023) Back to Basics: A Critical Examination of the Focal Concerns Framework from the Perspective of Judges. Justice Quarterly 40:6, pages 813-836.
Read now
Jason R. Silver & Jeffery T. Ulmer. (2023) Moral intuitions, punishment ideology, and judicial sentencing. Journal of Crime and Justice 0:0, pages 1-22.
Read now
William M. Casey, Jennifer E. Copp & Stephen Demuth. (2023) Disparities in the Pretrial Process: Race, Ethnicity, and Citizenship. Justice Quarterly 0:0, pages 1-23.
Read now
Erica Redner-Vera & Xia Wang. (2023) Examining Cumulative Disadvantage against American Indian Defendants in Federal Courts. Justice Quarterly 40:2, pages 263-290.
Read now
Tyler J. Vaughan & Lisa Bell Holleran. (2023) Adverse Childhood Experiences in Capital Sentencing: A Focal Concerns Approach to Understanding Capital Juror Leniency. Justice Quarterly 40:2, pages 187-210.
Read now
Kevin H. Wozniak, Justin T. Pickett & Elizabeth K. Brown. (2022) Judging Hardworking Robbers and Lazy Thieves: An Experimental Test of Act- vs. Person-Centered Punitiveness and Perceived Redeemability. Justice Quarterly 39:7, pages 1565-1591.
Read now
Miranda A. Galvin & Jeffery T. Ulmer. (2022) Expanding Our Understanding of Focal Concerns: Alternative Sentences, Race, and “Salvageability”. Justice Quarterly 39:6, pages 1332-1353.
Read now
Danielle M. Romain Dagenhardt, Amanda J. Heideman & Tina L. Freiburger. (2022) An examination of the direct and interactive effects of race/ethnicity and gender on charge reduction. Journal of Crime and Justice 45:3, pages 324-346.
Read now
Alisa Smith & Sean Maddan. (2022) The Interaction between Legal Representation and Extralegal Factors on Nonviolent Misdemeanor Case Outcomes. Justice System Journal 43:1, pages 102-127.
Read now
Daniel P. Mears, Jennifer M. Brown, Joshua C. Cochran & Sonja E. Siennick. (2021) Extended Solitary Confinement for Managing Prison Systems: Placement Disparities and Their Implications. Justice Quarterly 38:7, pages 1492-1518.
Read now
Synøve N. Andersen, Jordan M. Hyatt & Kjetil Telle. (2020) Exploring the unintended consequences of implementing electronic monitoring on sentencing in Norway. Nordic Journal of Criminology 21:2, pages 129-151.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (45)

Oshea D. Johnson, Nick Petersen & Brandon P. Martinez. (2022) Punishing Neighborhood “Outsiders”: Neighborhood Punishment Rates and the Spatial Mis(match) Between Defendants’ Residence and Arrest Locations. Crime & Delinquency 70:1, pages 206-233.
Crossref
Jeff Gruenewald, Brent R. Klein, Brittany E. Hayes, William S. Parkin & Taylor June. (2022) Examining Disparities in Case Dispositions and Sentencing Outcomes for Domestic Violent Extremists in the United States. Crime & Delinquency 70:1, pages 126-156.
Crossref
Nick Petersen, Yader R. Lanuza & Marisa Omori. (2024) Cumulative Colorism in Criminal Courts. Social Science Research 117, pages 102946.
Crossref
Gillian Slee. (2023) Of the State, against the State: Public Defenders, Street-Level Bureaucracy, and Discretion in Criminal Court. Social Service Review, pages 000-000.
Crossref
Leah Ouellet & Jennifer Wareham. (2023) Prosecutor Decision-Making Following Juvenile Life Without Parole Sentencing Reform. Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice 21:4, pages 325-349.
Crossref
Allison Kurpiel & Anthony Albanese. (2023) The Noncitizen Penalty in U.S. Federal Courts: Differences in Punishment by Region of Citizenship. Sociological Perspectives 66:5, pages 820-843.
Crossref
Bryan Holmes & Ben Feldmeyer. (2023) The Only Thing Constant is Change: Temporal Analyses of Racial/Ethnic Sentencing Disparities. American Journal of Criminal Justice 48:5, pages 1080-1104.
Crossref
Eric Silver, Jeffery T. Ulmer & Jason R. Silver. (2023) Do moral intuitions influence judges’ sentencing decisions? A multilevel study of criminal court sentencing in Pennsylvania. Social Science Research 115, pages 102927.
Crossref
Jordan Zvonkovich, Matthew Kleiman, Rhys Hester & C. Clare Strange. (2023) The Impact of COVID-19 on Sentencing Practices. American Journal of Criminal Justice.
Crossref
Andres F. Rengifo, Lorena Avila & David Ibañez. (2023) Criminal defense work in a sample of arrest hearings in three states of Mexico: the micro-dynamics of case-level engagement, influence, and strategy. Crime, Law and Social Change 79:5, pages 555-580.
Crossref
Jordan Zvonkovich & Jeffery T Ulmer. (2023) Segregation and Group Threat: Specifying Hispanic-White Punishment Disparity. Social Problems.
Crossref
Ebony L. Ruhland & Bryan Holmes. (2022) An examination of sentencing outcomes in rural and urban locations. American Journal of Criminal Justice 48:3, pages 701-722.
Crossref
John D. Crum & David M. Ramey. (2022) Impact of Extralegal and Community Factors on Police Officers’ Decision to Book Arrests for Minor Offenses. American Journal of Criminal Justice 48:3, pages 572-601.
Crossref
J.W. Andrew Ranson, Ashley N. Arnio & Jennifer E. Copp. (2023) Jurisdictional context and the (over)use of pretrial detention. Social Science Research 112, pages 102872.
Crossref
Yader R Lanuza, Nick Petersen & Marisa Omori. (2023) Colorism in Punishment among Hispanics in the Criminal Justice System. Social Problems 70:2, pages 275-296.
Crossref
Jennifer D. Wood, Amy C. Watson, Leah Pope, Amanda Warnock, Veronica Nelson, Nili Gesser, Adria Zern, Aaron Stagoff-Belfort, Jason Tan de Bibiana & Michael T. Compton. (2023) Contexts shaping misdemeanor system interventions among people with mental illnesses: qualitative findings from a multi-site system mapping exercise. Health & Justice 11:1.
Crossref
Brian Renauer, Christopher M. Campbell, Mark Harmon Leymon & Ann Leymon. (2023) Circumventing the Sentencing Grid: Encouraging Downward Departures in Presumptive Prison Cases. Criminal Justice Policy Review 34:3, pages 261-290.
Crossref
Patrick Moricette, Lisa Stolzenberg & Stewart J. D’Alessio. (2023) Race and the Sanctioning of Misdemeanor Defendants. American Journal of Criminal Justice 48:2, pages 345-367.
Crossref
Steven N. Zane & Jhon A. Pupo. (2023) The Political and Religious Context of Juvenile Punishment: A Multilevel Examination of Juvenile Court Dispositions in Three Southern States. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, pages 002242782311658.
Crossref
Jordan M. Hyatt & Michael Ostermann. (2023) Exploring Back-end Sentencing: A Study of Predictors of Parole Revocation through a Focal Concerns Theoretical Framework. Law & Social Inquiry, pages 1-31.
Crossref
Ioana Sendroiu. (2022) From reductive to generative crisis: businesspeople using polysemous justifications to make sense of COVID-19. American Journal of Cultural Sociology 11:1, pages 50-76.
Crossref
Miranda A. Galvin, Megan C. Kurlychek & Matthew Kleiman. (2023) The Collateral Cost of Juvenile Adjudications in Adult Sentencing Guideline Recommendations: The Contribution of Policy to Cumulative Disadvantage. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, pages 002242782311573.
Crossref
Yannick van den Brink. (2021) Equality in the Youth Court: Meaning, Perceptions and Implications of the Principle of Equality in Youth Justice. Youth Justice 22:3, pages 245-271.
Crossref
Shamika M. Kelley, Yan Zhang & Eryn Nicole O’Neal. (2021) To Report or Not to Report? A Focal Concerns Analysis of Victim Reporting Decisions Following Victimization. Journal of Interpersonal Violence 37:21-22, pages NP19880-NP19908.
Crossref
Luis C. Torres & Joshua H. Williams. (2022) Tired Judges? An Examination of the Effect of Decision Fatigue in Bail Proceedings. Criminal Justice and Behavior 49:8, pages 1233-1251.
Crossref
C. Clare Strange, Joshua C. Cochran, John Wooldredge & Ben Feldmeyer. (2021) Sentencing Add-Ons and Implications for Disparities in a Guidelines State. Crime & Delinquency 68:9, pages 1538-1578.
Crossref
Cortney A. Franklin, Leana A. Bouffard, Alondra D. Garza & Amanda Goodson. (2021) Focal Concerns and Intimate Partner Violence Case Processing: Predicting Arrest Using a Stratified Random Sample of Police Case File Data. Crime & Delinquency 68:9, pages 1402-1426.
Crossref
Lin Liu, R.R. Dunlea & Besiki Luka Kutateladze. (2021) Time for Time: Uncovering Case Processing Duration as a Source of Punitiveness. Crime & Delinquency 68:9, pages 1375-1401.
Crossref
Miranda A. Galvin. (2022) Stacking punishment: The imposition of consecutive sentences in Pennsylvania. Criminology & Public Policy 21:3, pages 567-594.
Crossref
Kathryne M. Young & Jessica Pearlman. (2021) Racial Disparities in Lifer Parole Outcomes: The Hidden Role of Professional Evaluations. Law & Social Inquiry 47:3, pages 783-820.
Crossref
Yannick van den Brink. (2021) Different but equal? Exploring potential catalysts of disparity in remand decision-making in the youth court. Social & Legal Studies 31:3, pages 477-500.
Crossref
Mary R. Rose & Meredith Martin Rountree. (2022) The focal concerns of jurors evaluating mitigation: Evidence from federal capital jury forms. Law & Society Review 56:2, pages 213-236.
Crossref
Colleen M. Berryessa. (2022) Modeling “Remorse Bias” in probation narratives: Examining social cognition and judgments of implicit violence during sentencing. Journal of Social Issues 78:2, pages 452-482.
Crossref
Bryan Holmes, Christopher D’Amato & Stephen T. Holmes. (2021) The Offense-Specific Nature of Gender and Familial Responsibility in United States Federal Sentencing, 2010–2016. Criminal Justice Policy Review 33:4, pages 399-428.
Crossref
Rory Monaghan & Kaitlyn Konefal. (2022) Presentence Investigation Reports and Racial/Ethnic Disparities in Sentencing. Crime & Delinquency, pages 001112872210776.
Crossref
Doyun Koo, Ben Feldmeyer & Bryan Holmes. (2021) Citizenship and Sentencing: Assessing Intersectionality in National Origin and Legal Migration Status on Federal Sentencing Outcomes. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 59:2, pages 203-239.
Crossref
Brian D. Johnson, Cassia Spohn & Anat Kimchi. (2021) Life lessons: Examining sources of racial and ethnic disparity in federal life without parole sentences*. Criminology 59:4, pages 704-737.
Crossref
Katrina Cole, Jason Rydberg & Michael Cassidy. (2020) Going Off the Grid: Assessing Sentencing Departures for Individuals Convicted of Sexual Offenses. Crime & Delinquency 67:11, pages 1676-1705.
Crossref
Yannick van den Brink. (2021) Remand decision-making in the youth court. A comparative analysis of youth remand and bail in England & Wales and the Netherlands. International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice 66, pages 100487.
Crossref
Rebecca L. Fix, Amanda M. Fanniff, Julia L. Kline & Elizabeth J. Letourneau. (2021) Disproportionate Minority Contact: An Expanded Examination of how Threat of Violent and Sexual Offending Impacts Court Outcomes. Race and Justice, pages 215336872110323.
Crossref
Jhon A. Pupo & Steven N. Zane. (2021) Assessing Variations in Juvenile Court Processing in Urban Versus Rural Courts: Revisiting “Justice by Geography”. Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice 19:3, pages 330-354.
Crossref
Alexander Testa & Jacqueline Lee. (2021) Drug overdose death rates and criminal sentencing of federal drug offenders in the United States. Journal of Criminal Justice 74, pages 101798.
Crossref
Aaron Gottlieb. (2021) Making Gideon Count? Public Defender Resources and Felony Case Outcomes for Black, White, and Latinx Individuals. Race and Justice, pages 215336872110064.
Crossref
Aaron Gottlieb, Pajarita Charles, Branden McLeod, Jean Kjellstrand & Janaé Bonsu. (2020) Were California’s Decarceration Efforts Smart? A Quasi-Experimental Examination of Racial, Ethnic, and Gender Disparities. Criminal Justice and Behavior 48:1, pages 116-134.
Crossref
Maarten Kunst, Giulia de Groot, Jelmar Meester & Janne van Doorn. (2021) The impact of victim impact statements on legal decisions in criminal proceedings: A systematic review of the literature across jurisdictions and decision types. Aggression and Violent Behavior 56, pages 101512.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.