2,181
Views
90
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Research article

Evaluating the aesthetic value of cultural ecosystem services by mapping geo-tagged photographs from social media data on Panoramio and Flickr

&
Pages 266-281 | Received 16 Jun 2015, Accepted 20 Jan 2016, Published online: 18 May 2016

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Read on this site (7)

Rosie Brigham, Scott Allan Orr, Lyn Wilson, Adam Frost, Matija Strlič & Josep Grau-Bové. (2022) Using Citizen Heritage Science to Monitor Remote Sites Before and During the First COVID-19 Lockdown: A Comparison of Two Methods. Conservation and Management of Archaeological Sites 0:0, pages 1-16.
Read now
Derya Gülçin & Nermin Merve Yalçınkaya. (2022) Correlating fluency theory-based visual aesthetic liking of landscape with landscape types and features. Geo-spatial Information Science 0:0, pages 1-20.
Read now
Hongmei Zhang, Ruihong Huang, Yechen Zhang & Dimitrios Buhalis. (2022) Cultural ecosystem services evaluation using geolocated social media data: a review. Tourism Geographies 24:4-5, pages 646-668.
Read now
Ainhoa González Del Campo & Paola Gazzola. (2020) Untapping the potential of technological advancements in Strategic Environmental Assessment. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 63:4, pages 585-603.
Read now
Rachelle K. Gould, Alison Adams & Luis Vivanco. (2020) Looking into the dragons of cultural ecosystem services. Ecosystems and People 16:1, pages 257-272.
Read now
Flurina M. Wartmann, Elise Acheson & Ross S. Purves. (2018) Describing and comparing landscapes using tags, texts, and free lists: an interdisciplinary approach. International Journal of Geographical Information Science 32:8, pages 1572-1592.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (83)

Chang Li, Qifan Liang, Beiduo Lin & Jun Zhai. (2023) Landscape management and planning as a spatial organization method connecting CES supply-demand assessment and sustainable tourism development. Journal of Outdoor Recreation and Tourism 44, pages 100705.
Crossref
Tahlia Daymond, Margaret E. Andrew & Halina T. Kobryn. (2023) Crowdsourcing social values data: Flickr and public participation GIS provide different perspectives of ecosystem services in a remote coastal region. Ecosystem Services 64, pages 101566.
Crossref
Wei-Lun Tsai, Nathaniel H. Merrill, Anne C. Neale & Madeline Grupper. (2023) Using cellular device location data to estimate visitation to public lands: Comparing device location data to U.S. National Park Service’s visitor use statistics. PLOS ONE 18:11, pages e0289922.
Crossref
Charity Nyelele, Catherine Keske, Min Gon Chung, Han Guo & Benis N. Egoh. (2023) Using social media data and machine learning to map recreational ecosystem services. Ecological Indicators 154, pages 110606.
Crossref
Nicolas Urbina-Cardona, Vivian Ochoa Cardona & Sergio Cuellar. (2023) Uncovering thematic biases in ecosystem services mapping: Knowledge shortfalls and challenges for use in conservation. Biological Conservation 283, pages 110086.
Crossref
Haiyun Xu, Guohan Zhao, Yan Liu & Meng Miao. (2023) Using Social Media Camping Data for Evaluating, Quantifying, and Understanding Recreational Ecosystem Services in Post-COVID-19 Megacities: A Case Study from Beijing. Forests 14:6, pages 1151.
Crossref
Yan Chen, Kate Sherren, Michael Smit & Kyung Young Lee. (2021) Using social media images as data in social science research. New Media & Society 25:4, pages 849-871.
Crossref
Madalina Gugulica & Dirk Burghardt. (2023) Mapping indicators of cultural ecosystem services use in urban green spaces based on text classification of geosocial media data. Ecosystem Services 60, pages 101508.
Crossref
Betul Tulek. (2023) Investigation of cultural ecosystem services supply in a river landscape: a case study in the Lower Rhine area using social media images. One Ecosystem 8.
Crossref
Manob Das, Arijit Das & MD Tushar Ali. 2023. Advancements in Urban Environmental Studies. Advancements in Urban Environmental Studies 233 245 .
Müjde TAŞ & E. Seda ARSLAN. (2022) Kültürel Ekosistem Hizmetlerinin Maksimum Entropi Algoritması Kullanılarak ModellenmesiModelling of Cultural Ecosystem Services Using Maximum Entropy Algorithm. Türkiye Peyzaj Araştırmaları Dergisi 5:2, pages 93-101.
Crossref
Mariusz Ciesielski, Ewelina Dobrowolska & Grzegorz Krok. (2022) Tourism and recreation in Polish national parks based on social media data. Acta Scientiarum Polonorum Administratio Locorum 21:4, pages 513-528.
Crossref
Maximilian C. Hartmann, Moritz Schott, Alishiba Dsouza, Yannick Metz, Michele Volpi & Ross S. Purves. (2022) A text and image analysis workflow using citizen science data to extract relevant social media records: Combining red kite observations from Flickr, eBird and iNaturalist. Ecological Informatics 71, pages 101782.
Crossref
Anton Stahl Olafsson, Ross S. Purves, Flurina M. Wartmann, Maria Garcia-Martin, Nora Fagerholm, Mario Torralba, Christian Albert, Laura N.H. Verbrugge, Vuokko Heikinheimo, Tobias Plieninger, Claudia Bieling, Roope Kaaronen, Maximilian Hartmann & Christopher M. Raymond. (2022) Comparing landscape value patterns between participatory mapping and geolocated social media content across Europe. Landscape and Urban Planning 226, pages 104511.
Crossref
Wendy Fjellstad, Sebastian Eiter, Oskar Puschmann & Svein Olav Krøgli. (2022) Planning the first view: Establishing a landscape monitoring scheme based on photography. Landscape and Urban Planning 226, pages 104470.
Crossref
Samantha G. Winder, Heera Lee, Bumsuk Seo, Emilia H. Lia & Spencer A. Wood. (2022) An open‐source image classifier for characterizing recreational activities across landscapes. People and Nature 4:5, pages 1249-1262.
Crossref
Nathan Fox, Brent Chamberlain, Mark Lindquist & Derek Van Berkel. (2022) Understanding Landscape Aesthetics Using a Novel Viewshed Assessment of Social Media Locations Within the Troodos UNESCO Global Geopark, Cyprus. Frontiers in Environmental Science 10.
Crossref
Manuel Ebner, Uta Schirpke & Ulrike Tappeiner. (2022) How do anthropogenic pressures affect the provision of ecosystem services of small mountain lakes?. Anthropocene 38, pages 100336.
Crossref
Ping Chang & Anton Stahl Olafsson. (2022) The scale effects of landscape variables on landscape experiences: a multi-scale spatial analysis of social media data in an urban nature park context. Landscape Ecology 37:5, pages 1271-1291.
Crossref
Maximilian C. Hartmann, Olga Koblet, Manuel F. Baer & Ross S. Purves. (2022) Automated motif identification: Analysing Flickr images to identify popular viewpoints in Europe’s protected areas. Journal of Outdoor Recreation and Tourism 37, pages 100479.
Crossref
Nathan Fox, Laura J. Graham, Felix Eigenbrod, James M. Bullock & Katherine E. Parks. (2022) Geodiversity Supports Cultural Ecosystem Services: an Assessment Using Social Media. Geoheritage 14:1.
Crossref
Jarmila Makovníková, Stanislav Kološta, Filip Flaška & Boris Pálka. (2022) Regional Differentiations of the Potential of Cultural Ecosystem Services in Relation to Natural Capital—A Case Study in Selected Regions of the Slovak Republic. Land 11:2, pages 270.
Crossref
O. Llanos-Paez & V. Acuña. (2022) Analysis of the socio-ecological drivers of the recreational use of temporary streams and rivers. Science of The Total Environment 807, pages 150805.
Crossref
Juan Astaburuaga, Michael E. Martin, Agnieszka Leszczynski & JC Gaillard. (2022) Maps, volunteered geographic information (VGI) and the spatio-discursive construction of nature. Digital Geography and Society 3, pages 100029.
Crossref
Wei Jiang & Rainer Marggraf. (2021) Making Intangibles Tangible: Identifying Manifestations of Cultural Ecosystem Services in a Cultural Landscape. Land 11:1, pages 26.
Crossref
Franziska Richter, Pierrick Jan, Nadja El Benni, Andreas Lüscher, Nina Buchmann & Valentin H. Klaus. (2021) A guide to assess and value ecosystem services of grasslands. Ecosystem Services 52, pages 101376.
Crossref
Uta Schirpke, Erich Tasser, Manuel Ebner & Ulrike Tappeiner. (2021) What can geotagged photographs tell us about cultural ecosystem services of lakes?. Ecosystem Services 51, pages 101354.
Crossref
F.M. Wartmann, M.F. Baer, K.T. Hegetschweiler, C. Fischer, M. Hunziker & R.S. Purves. (2021) Assessing the potential of social media for estimating recreational use of urban and peri-urban forests. Urban Forestry & Urban Greening 64, pages 127261.
Crossref
Nathan Fox, Laura J. Graham, Felix Eigenbrod, James M. Bullock & Katherine E. Parks. (2021) Reddit: A novel data source for cultural ecosystem service studies. Ecosystem Services 50, pages 101331.
Crossref
Nathan Fox, Laura J. Graham, Felix Eigenbrod, James M. Bullock & Katherine E. Parks. (2021) Enriching social media data allows a more robust representation of cultural ecosystem services. Ecosystem Services 50, pages 101328.
Crossref
Yaella Depietri, Andrea Ghermandi, Salvatore Campisi-Pinto & Daniel E. Orenstein. (2021) Public participation GIS versus geolocated social media data to assess urban cultural ecosystem services: Instances of complementarity. Ecosystem Services 50, pages 101277.
Crossref
Zhenhua Bing, Yishu Qiu, Heping Huang, Tingzhen Chen, Wei Zhong & Hong Jiang. (2021) Spatial distribution of cultural ecosystem services demand and supply in urban and suburban areas: A case study from Shanghai, China. Ecological Indicators 127, pages 107720.
Crossref
Wei Jiang & Rainer Marggraf. (2021) Ecosystems in Books: Evaluating the Inspirational Service of the Weser River in Germany. Land 10:7, pages 669.
Crossref
Nan Cui, Nick Malleson, Victoria Houlden & Alexis Comber. (2021) Using VGI and Social Media Data to Understand Urban Green Space: A Narrative Literature Review. ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information 10:7, pages 425.
Crossref
Mesut GÜZEL & Murat YEŞİL. (2021) Rekreasyon Alanlarında Ziyaretçi Tercihlerinin Sosyal Medya Verileri Kullanılarak Değerlendirilmesi: Ordu İli Örneği. ODÜ Sosyal Bilimler Araştırmaları Dergisi (ODÜSOBİAD).
Crossref
Silvia de Juan, Andrés Ospina-Álvarez, Sebastián Villasante & Ana Ruiz-Frau. (2021) A Graph Theory approach to assess nature’s contribution to people at a global scale. Scientific Reports 11:1.
Crossref
Hongchao Zhang, Derek van Berkel, Peter D. Howe, Zachary D. Miller & Jordan W. Smith. (2021) Using social media to measure and map visitation to public lands in Utah. Applied Geography 128, pages 102389.
Crossref
E. Seda Arslan & Ömer K. Örücü. (2020) MaxEnt modelling of the potential distribution areas of cultural ecosystem services using social media data and GIS. Environment, Development and Sustainability 23:2, pages 2655-2667.
Crossref
Derya GÜLÇİN. (2020) Mapping cultural ecosystem services using social media data: The case of Datça peninsula. Turkish Journal of Forestry | Türkiye Ormancılık Dergisi, pages 407-416.
Crossref
Derya GÜLÇİN. (2020) Peyzajın Görsel Estetik Değeri ve Peyzaj Çeşitliliği Arasındaki İlişkinin Objektif Paradigma ile DeğerlendirilmesiEvaluation of the Relationship between the Visual Aesthetic Liking of Landscapes and Landscape Diversity with the Objective Paradigm. Bartın Orman Fakültesi Dergisi 22:3, pages 802-818.
Crossref
Craig W. McDougall, Richard S. Quilliam, Nick Hanley & David M. Oliver. (2020) Freshwater blue space and population health: An emerging research agenda. Science of The Total Environment 737, pages 140196.
Crossref
A.S. Gosal & G. Ziv. (2020) Landscape aesthetics: Spatial modelling and mapping using social media images and machine learning. Ecological Indicators 117, pages 106638.
Crossref
Ibrahim Niankara, Muhammad Noor Al adwan & Aminata Niankara. (2020) The Role of Digital Media in Shaping Youth Planetary Health Interests in the Global Economy. Journal of Open Innovation: Technology, Market, and Complexity 6:3, pages 49.
Crossref
Petina L. Pert, Lauric Thiault, Matthew I. Curnock, Susanne Becken & Joachim Claudet. (2020) Beauty and the reef: Evaluating the use of non-expert ratings for monitoring aesthetic values of coral reefs. Science of The Total Environment 730, pages 139156.
Crossref
Yan Chen, Camille Caesemaecker, HM Tuihedur Rahman & Kate Sherren. (2020) Comparing cultural ecosystem service delivery in dykelands and marshes using Instagram: A case of the Cornwallis (Jijuktu'kwejk) River, Nova Scotia, Canada. Ocean & Coastal Management 193, pages 105254.
Crossref
Nathan Fox, Tom August, Francesca Mancini, Katherine E. Parks, Felix Eigenbrod, James M. Bullock, Louis Sutter & Laura J. Graham. (2020) “photosearcher” package in R: An accessible and reproducible method for harvesting large datasets from Flickr. SoftwareX 12, pages 100624.
Crossref
Vanessa Teles da Mota & Catherine Pickering. (2020) Using social media to assess nature-based tourism: Current research and future trends. Journal of Outdoor Recreation and Tourism 30, pages 100295.
Crossref
Ilan Havinga, Patrick W. Bogaart, Lars Hein & Devis Tuia. (2020) Defining and spatially modelling cultural ecosystem services using crowdsourced data. Ecosystem Services 43, pages 101091.
Crossref
Muhe Yang. (2020) Investigating seasonal color change in the environment by color analysis and information visualization. Color Research & Application 45:3, pages 503-511.
Crossref
Oleksandr Karasov, Stien Heremans, Mart Külvik, Artem Domnich & Igor Chervanyov. (2020) On How Crowdsourced Data and Landscape Organisation Metrics Can Facilitate the Mapping of Cultural Ecosystem Services: An Estonian Case Study. Land 9:5, pages 158.
Crossref
Asmaa AbualhagagIstván Valánszki. (2020) RETRACTED: Mapping Indicators of Cultural Ecosystem Services: Review and Relevance to Urban Context. Journal of Landscape Ecology 13:1, pages 4-24.
Crossref
Jean-Christophe Foltête, Jens Ingensand & Nicolas Blanc. (2020) Coupling crowd-sourced imagery and visibility modelling to identify landscape preferences at the panorama level. Landscape and Urban Planning 197, pages 103756.
Crossref
Yuno Do & Ji Yoon Kim. (2020) An assessment of the aesthetic value of protected wetlands based on a photo content and its metadata. Ecological Engineering 150, pages 105816.
Crossref
Andrea Ghermandi, Vera Camacho-Valdez & Hector Trejo-Espinosa. (2020) Social media-based analysis of cultural ecosystem services and heritage tourism in a coastal region of Mexico. Tourism Management 77, pages 104002.
Crossref
Oleksandr Karasov, António Avelino Batista Vieira, Mart Külvik & Igor Chervanyov. (2020) Landscape coherence revisited: GIS-based mapping in relation to scenic values and preferences estimated with geolocated social media data. Ecological Indicators 111, pages 105973.
Crossref
Andrea Ros-Candeira, Ricardo Moreno-Llorca, Domingo Alcaraz-Segura, Francisco Javier Bonet-García & Ana Sofia Vaz. (2020) Social media photo content for Sierra Nevada: a dataset to support the assessment of cultural ecosystem services in protected areas. Nature Conservation 38, pages 1-12.
Crossref
Andrea Ros-Candeira, Ricardo Moreno-Llorca, Domingo Alcaraz-Segura, Francisco Javier Bonet-García & Ana Sofia Vaz. (2020) Social media photo content for Sierra Nevada: a dataset to support the assessment of cultural ecosystem services in protected areas. Nature Conservation 38, pages 1-12.
Crossref
Catherine Pickering, Chelsey Walden-Schreiner, Agustina Barros & Sebastian Dario Rossi. (2020) Using social media images and text to examine how tourists view and value the highest mountain in Australia. Journal of Outdoor Recreation and Tourism 29, pages 100252.
Crossref
Neven Tandarić, Christopher D Ives & Charles Watkins. (2020) Can we plan for urban cultural ecosystem services?. Journal of Urban Ecology 6:1.
Crossref
Barbara Martinez, Jamie K. Reaser, Alex Dehgan, Brad Zamft, David Baisch, Colin McCormick, Anthony J. Giordano, Rebecca Aicher & Shah Selbe. (2019) Technology innovation: advancing capacities for the early detection of and rapid response to invasive species. Biological Invasions 22:1, pages 75-100.
Crossref
Rebecca L. Hale, Elizabeth M. Cook & Bray J. Beltrán. (2019) Cultural ecosystem services provided by rivers across diverse social-ecological landscapes: A social media analysis. Ecological Indicators 107, pages 105580.
Crossref
Flurina M. Wartmann, Koen F. Tieskens, Boris T. van Zanten & Peter H. Verburg. (2019) Exploring tranquillity experienced in landscapes based on social media. Applied Geography 113, pages 102112.
Crossref
Ariane Walz, Katja Schmidt, Ana Ruiz-Frau, Kimberly A. Nicholas, Adéline Bierry, Aster de Vries Lentsch, Apostol Dyankov, Deirdre Joyce, Anja H. Liski, Nuria Marbà, Ines T. Rosário & Samantha S. K. Scholte. (2019) Sociocultural valuation of ecosystem services for operational ecosystem management: mapping applications by decision contexts in Europe. Regional Environmental Change 19:8, pages 2245-2259.
Crossref
Ana Sofia Vaz, João F. Gonçalves, Paulo Pereira, Frederico Santarém, Joana R. Vicente & João P. Honrado. (2019) Earth observation and social media: Evaluating the spatiotemporal contribution of non-native trees to cultural ecosystem services. Remote Sensing of Environment 230, pages 111193.
Crossref
Fulvia Calcagni, Ana Terra Amorim Maia, James John Timothy Connolly & Johannes Langemeyer. (2019) Digital co-construction of relational values: understanding the role of social media for sustainability. Sustainability Science 14:5, pages 1309-1321.
Crossref
S. Scott Ogletree, Robert B. Powell, Robert F. Baldwin & Paul B. Leonard. (2019) A framework for mapping cultural resources in landscape conservation planning. Conservation Science and Practice 1:6.
Crossref
Michael Sinclair, Andrea Ghermandi, Sheela A. Moses & Sabu Joseph. (2019) Recreation and environmental quality of tropical wetlands: A social media based spatial analysis. Tourism Management 71, pages 179-186.
Crossref
Yuno Do. (2019) Valuating aesthetic benefits of cultural ecosystem services using conservation culturomics. Ecosystem Services 36, pages 100894.
Crossref
Inês T. Rosário, Rui Rebelo, Paulo Cardoso, Pedro Segurado, Ricardo Nogueira Mendes & Margarida Santos-Reis. (2019) Can geocaching be an indicator of cultural ecosystem services? The case of the montado savannah-like landscape. Ecological Indicators 99, pages 375-386.
Crossref
Paul Brindley, Ross W. Cameron, Ebru Ersoy, Anna Jorgensen & Ravi Maheswaran. (2019) Is more always better? Exploring field survey and social media indicators of quality of urban greenspace, in relation to health. Urban Forestry & Urban Greening 39, pages 45-54.
Crossref
Andrea Ghermandi & Michael Sinclair. (2019) Passive crowdsourcing of social media in environmental research: A systematic map. Global Environmental Change 55, pages 36-47.
Crossref
Caglar Koylu, Chang Zhao & Wei Shao. (2019) Deep Neural Networks and Kernel Density Estimation for Detecting Human Activity Patterns from Geo-Tagged Images: A Case Study of Birdwatching on Flickr. ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information 8:1, pages 45.
Crossref
Marina Gribok & Tatiana Gorbunova. (2019) Development of the concept of GIS for research of the aesthetic value of natural landscapes. InterCarto. InterGIS 25:2, pages 321-329.
Crossref
Nigel S. Cooper. 2019. Sustainability and the Humanities. Sustainability and the Humanities 239 266 .
Maxime Lenormand, Sandra Luque, Johannes Langemeyer, Patrizia Tenerelli, Grazia Zulian, Inge Aalders, Serban Chivulescu, Pedro Clemente, Jan Dick, Jiska van Dijk, Michiel van Eupen, Relu C. Giuca, Leena Kopperoinen, Eszter Lellei-Kovács, Michael Leone, Juraj Lieskovský, Uta Schirpke, Alison C. Smith, Ulrike Tappeiner & Helen Woods. (2018) Multiscale socio-ecological networks in the age of information. PLOS ONE 13:11, pages e0206672.
Crossref
Michael Sinclair, Andrea Ghermandi & Albert M. Sheela. (2018) A crowdsourced valuation of recreational ecosystem services using social media data: An application to a tropical wetland in India. Science of The Total Environment 642, pages 356-365.
Crossref
Flurina M. Wartmann & Ross S. Purves. (2018) Investigating sense of place as a cultural ecosystem service in different landscapes through the lens of language. Landscape and Urban Planning 175, pages 169-183.
Crossref
Mario V Balzan & Iain Debono. (2018) Assessing urban recreation ecosystem services through the use of geocache visitation and preference data: a case-study from an urbanised island environment. One Ecosystem 3, pages e24490.
Crossref
Uta Schirpke, Claude Meisch, Thomas Marsoner & Ulrike Tappeiner. (2018) Revealing spatial and temporal patterns of outdoor recreation in the European Alps and their surroundings. Ecosystem Services 31, pages 336-350.
Crossref
M. Hilal, D. Joly, D. Roy & G. Vuidel. (2018) Visual structure of landscapes seen from built environment. Urban Forestry & Urban Greening 32, pages 71-80.
Crossref
Ted R. Angradi, Jonathon J. Launspach & Rick Debbout. (2018) Determining preferences for ecosystem benefits in Great Lakes Areas of Concern from photographs posted to social media. Journal of Great Lakes Research 44:2, pages 340-351.
Crossref
Ana Sofia Vaz, Pilar Castro-Díez, Oscar Godoy, Álvaro Alonso, Montserrat Vilà, Asunción Saldaña, Hélia Marchante, Álvaro Bayón, Joaquim S. Silva, Joana R. Vicente & João P. Honrado. (2018) An indicator-based approach to analyse the effects of non-native tree species on multiple cultural ecosystem services. Ecological Indicators 85, pages 48-56.
Crossref
Yu-Pin Lin, Wei-Chih Lin, Hsin-Yi Li, Yung-Chieh Wang, Chih-Chen Hsu, Wan-Yu Lien, Johnathen Anthony & Joy R. Petway. (2017) Integrating Social Values and Ecosystem Services in Systematic Conservation Planning: A Case Study in Datuan Watershed. Sustainability 9:5, pages 718.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.