Advanced search
Publication Cover
Numerical Heat Transfer, Part B: Fundamentals
An International Journal of Computation and Methodology
Volume 51, 2007 - Issue 6
Submit an article Journal homepage
1,046
Views
93
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Calculations of Steady and Pulsating Impinging Jets—An Assessment of 13 Widely used Turbulence Models

Herbert Martin Hofmann Institut für Thermische Verfahrenstechnik, Universität Karlsruhe (TH), Kaiserstr, Karlsruhe, GermanyCorrespondence[email protected]
View further author information
,
Rafael Kaiser Institut für Thermische Verfahrenstechnik, Universität Karlsruhe (TH), Kaiserstr, Karlsruhe, Germany
,
Matthias Kind Institut für Thermische Verfahrenstechnik, Universität Karlsruhe (TH), Kaiserstr, Karlsruhe, Germany
&
Holger Martin Institut für Thermische Verfahrenstechnik, Universität Karlsruhe (TH), Kaiserstr, Karlsruhe, Germany
Pages 565-583 | Received 08 Feb 2006, Accepted 06 Jan 2007, Published online: 11 May 2007

Citations (93)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (24)

Yuyan Tian, Wenhao Li, Pu Xue & Zhenxun Gao. (2022) Numerical Studies on Heat Transfer of Supersonic Combustion-Gas Jet Impingement on Perpendicular Flat Plate. Heat Transfer Engineering 43:8-10, pages 864-878.
Read now
Saeed Jahangiri, Amir Hossein Shiravi, Mostafa Hosseinalipour & Arun S. Mujumdar. (2021) Numerical study of the oscillation amplitude effect on the heat transfer of oscillatory impinging round jets. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part B: Fundamentals 79:2, pages 70-82.
Read now
Maheandera Prabu Paulraj, Chan Byon, Andrea Vallati & Rajesh Kanna Parthasarathy. (2020) A Numerical Investigation of Flow and Heat Transfer of Laminar Multiple Slot Jets Impinging on Multiple Protruding Heat Sources. Heat Transfer Engineering 41:1, pages 65-83.
Read now
Phani Krishna Kadiyala & Himadri Chattopadhyay. (2018) Numerical Analysis of Heat Transfer from a Moving Surface Due to Impingement of Slot Jets. Heat Transfer Engineering 39:2, pages 98-106.
Read now
Kai Chen, Pei-Xue Jiang, Jian-Nan Chen & Rui-Na Xu. (2018) Numerical Investigation of Jet Impingement Cooling of a Flat Plate with Carbon Dioxide at Supercritical Pressures. Heat Transfer Engineering 39:2, pages 85-97.
Read now
M. Cid Montoya, F. Nieto, A. J. Álvarez, S. Hernández, J. Á. Jurado & R. Sánchez. (2018) Numerical simulations of the aerodynamic response of circular segments with different corner angles by means of 2D URANS. Impact of turbulence modeling approaches. Engineering Applications of Computational Fluid Mechanics 12:1, pages 750-779.
Read now
Vladimir Kriventsev. (2016) A rule of minimal energy dissipation in modeling of channel flow turbulence. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part B: Fundamentals 69:2, pages 85-95.
Read now
Weihong Li, Jing Ren, Jiang Hongde & Phillip Ligrani. (2016) Assessment of six turbulence models for modeling and predicting narrow passage flows, part 1: Impingement jets. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part A: Applications 69:2, pages 109-127.
Read now
Peng Wang, Jizu Lv, Minli Bai, Yuyan Wang & Chengzhi Hu. (2014) Numerical investigation of the flow and heat behaviours of an impinging jet. International Journal of Computational Fluid Dynamics 28:6-10, pages 301-315.
Read now
Mirko Bovo & Lars Davidson. (2013) On the Numerical Modeling of Impinging Jets Heat Transfer—A Practical Approach. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part A: Applications 64:4, pages 290-316.
Read now
Ruijie Zhao, Louis Gosselin, Abdellah Ousegui, Mario Fafard & DonaldP. Ziegler. (2013) Heat Transfer and Airflow Analysis in the Upper Part of Electrolytic Cells Based on CFD. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part A: Applications 64:4, pages 317-338.
Read now
MichaelV. Jensen & JensH. Walther. (2013) Numerical Analysis of Jet Impingement Heat Transfer at High Jet Reynolds Number and Large Temperature Difference. Heat Transfer Engineering 34:10, pages 801-809.
Read now
S.Z. Shuja. (2013) Jet Impingement onto a Hole with Different Barreling: Flow and Heat Transfer Analysis. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part A: Applications 63:7, pages 549-562.
Read now
A. Ryfa, D. Ingham & R.A. Bialecki. (2012) Direct and Inverse Methods for an Air Jet Impingement. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part A: Applications 61:7, pages 547-568.
Read now
Anupam Dewan, Rabijit Dutta & Balaji Srinivasan. (2012) Recent Trends in Computation of Turbulent Jet Impingement Heat Transfer. Heat Transfer Engineering 33:4-5, pages 447-460.
Read now
Erhan Pulat, Mustafa Kemal Isman, Akın Burak Etemoglu & Muhiddin Can. (2011) Effect of Turbulence Models and Near-Wall Modeling Approaches on Numerical Results in Impingement Heat Transfer. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part B: Fundamentals 60:6, pages 486-519.
Read now
Tien-Mo Shih, Martinus Arie & Derrick Ko. (2011) Literature Survey of Numerical Heat Transfer (2000–2009): Part II. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part A: Applications 60:11-12, pages 883-1096.
Read now
T. Gebreegziabher, E.M. Sparrow, J.P. Abraham, E. Ayorinde & T. Singh. (2011) High-Frequency Pulsatile Pipe Flows Encompassing All Flow Regimes. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part A: Applications 60:10, pages 811-826.
Read now
Nadir Bekka, Rachid Bessaïh, Mohamed Sellam & Amer Chpoun. (2009) Numerical Study of Heat Transfer Around the Small Scale Airfoil Using Various Turbulence Models. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part A: Applications 56:12, pages 946-969.
Read now
R. D. Lovik, J. P. Abraham, W. J. Minkowycz & E. M. Sparrow. (2009) Laminarization and Turbulentization in a Pulsatile Pipe Flow. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part A: Applications 56:11, pages 861-879.
Read now
Deepak Jagannatha, Ramesh Narayanaswamy & TilakT. Chandratilleke. (2009) Analysis of a Synthetic Jet-Based Electronic Cooling Module. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part A: Applications 56:3, pages 211-229.
Read now
M. A. R. Sharif & K. K. Mothe. (2009) Evaluation of Turbulence Models in the Prediction of Heat Transfer Due to Slot Jet Impingement on Plane and Concave Surfaces. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part B: Fundamentals 55:4, pages 273-294.
Read now
MuhammadM. Rahman, JorgeC. Lallave & CesarF. Hernandez. (2008) Convective Heat Transfer from a Thick Hemispherical Plate during Free Liquid Jet Impingement. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part A: Applications 54:6, pages 581-602.
Read now
J. E. Jaramillo, C. D. Pérez-Segarra, I. Rodriguez & A. Oliva. (2008) Numerical Study of Plane and Round Impinging Jets using RANS Models. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part B: Fundamentals 54:3, pages 213-237.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (69)

Ammar Osman, Gilberto Moreno, Steve Myers, Joshua Major, Xuhui Feng, Sreekant V. J. Narumanchi & Yogendra Joshi. (2024) Automotive Silicon Carbide Power Module Cooling With a Novel Modular Manifold and Embedded Heat Sink. Journal of Electronic Packaging 146:2.
Crossref
Georges C. Saliba, Ahmad Batikh, Stéphane Colin & Lucien Baldas. (2023) Pulsed Impinging Jets for Heat Transfer: A Short Review. ASME Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 145:11.
Crossref
Bruno A.C. Barata, Jorge E.P. Navalho & José C.F. Pereira. (2023) Numerical investigation of an inertization system for a radiative coil coating oven. International Journal of Thermofluids 20, pages 100412.
Crossref
Fatih Demir, Oguz Turgut & Tamer Calisir. (2023) Investigation of swirling impinging jet at low nozzle to plate distances. Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry 148:21, pages 11999-12016.
Crossref
Sebastian Gurgul & Elzbieta Fornalik-Wajs. (2023) On the Measure of the Heat Transfer Performance of RANS Turbulence Models in Single Round Jet Impingement. Energies 16:21, pages 7236.
Crossref
Ammar Osman, Gilberto Moreno, Steve Myers, Sreekant V. J. Narumanchi & Yogendra Joshi. (2023) Single-Phase Jet Impingement Cooling for a Power-Dense Silicon Carbide Power Module. IEEE Transactions on Components, Packaging and Manufacturing Technology 13:5, pages 615-627.
Crossref
Usman Allauddin, Muhammad U. Sohail, Muhammad Sohaib, Mohammad A. Siddiqui, Muhammad H.U. Khan, Kashif Khan & Patrick G. Verdin. (2023) Heat transfer and fluid flow investigations in jet impingement system of a single and array of square jets formed under fixed mass flow rate. Computational Thermal Sciences: An International Journal.
Crossref
Flávia V. Barbosa, Senhorinha F.C.F. Teixeira & José C.F. Teixeira. (2023) Convection from multiple air jet impingement - A review. Applied Thermal Engineering 218, pages 119307.
Crossref
Deepak Kumar Sethy & Pandaba Patro. 2023. Recent Advances in Mechanical Engineering. Recent Advances in Mechanical Engineering 213 219 .
Bruno A. C. Barata, Jorge E. P. Navalho & José C. F. Pereira. (2022) Prediction of Self-Sustained Oscillations of an Isothermal Impinging Slot Jet. Fluids 8:1, pages 15.
Crossref
Ünal AKDAĞ, Selma AKÇAY & Mustafa Levent KARABAYIR. (2022) Düz bir yüzeye çarpan pulsatif jetin ısı transferi karakteristiğinin deneysel incelenmesi. Gazi Üniversitesi Mühendislik Mimarlık Fakültesi Dergisi 38:2, pages 889-900.
Crossref
C. Klinkhamer, S. Abishek, K.L.V. Iyer, R. Balachandar & R. Barron. (2022) Characterization of a Jet Impingement Heat Sink for Power Electronics Cooling. Thermal Science and Engineering Progress 34, pages 101408.
Crossref
Prasun Dutta & Himadri Chattopadhyay. (2022) Heat Transfer Due to Annular Jets Impinging on a Moving Surface. Journal of Heat Transfer 144:8.
Crossref
Rui Zhang, Zhenlei Li, Yansheng Zhang, Dong Chen & Guo Yuan. (2022) Numerical investigation of jet layout for annular jet cooling on a steel tube. Applied Thermal Engineering 213, pages 118825.
Crossref
Anuj Kumar Shukla & Anupam Dewan. (2021) Computational analysis of convective heat transfer properties of turbulent slot jet impingement. Engineering Computations 38:10, pages 3785-3808.
Crossref
Jun-Suk Youn, Won-Woo Choi & Sung-Min Kim. (2021) Numerical investigation of jet array impingement cooling with effusion holes. Applied Thermal Engineering 197, pages 117347.
Crossref
Erhan Pulat & Ebubekir Beyazoglu. (2021) Computational investigation of confined wall inclination effects on impinging jet fluid flow and heat transfer. International Journal of Thermal Sciences 163, pages 106749.
Crossref
M. A. Pakhomov & V. I. Terekhov. (2022) Influence of the Pulse Shape on Heat Transfer at the Stagnation Point of an Unsteady Axisymmetric Impinging Jet. High Temperature 59:2-6, pages 253-258.
Crossref
Hamad M. Alhajeri, Abdulrahman Almutairi, Abdulrahman Alenezi, Abdelaziz A.A. Gamil & M.H. Al-Hajeri. (2021) Effect of mist/steam uniformity on heat transfer characteristics in unconfined jet impingement. Applied Thermal Engineering 186, pages 116299.
Crossref
Alankrita Singh, Balaji Chakravarthy & BVSSS Prasad. (2020) Numerical simulations and optimization of impinging jet configuration. International Journal of Numerical Methods for Heat & Fluid Flow 31:1, pages 1-25.
Crossref
Ian J. Cormier, Andres Curbelo, Akshay Khadse & Jayanta Kapat. (2021) A RANS Approach to Supercritical CO 2 Single-Jet Impingement at Ultra-High Reynolds Numbers . A RANS Approach to Supercritical CO 2 Single-Jet Impingement at Ultra-High Reynolds Numbers .
Roman Alejandro Werner, Dominik Ulrich Geier & Thomas Becker. (2020) The Challenge of Cleaning Woven Filter Cloth in the Beverage Industry—Wash Jets as an Appropriate Solution. Food Engineering Reviews 12:4, pages 520-545.
Crossref
Ahmet Ümit Tepe, Yaşar Yetişken, Ünal Uysal & Kamil Arslan. (2020) Experimental and numerical investigation of jet impingement cooling using extended jet holes. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 158, pages 119945.
Crossref
Longfei Wang, Fengbo Wen, Songtao Wang, Xun Zhou & Zhongqi Wang. (2020) Application and Design of Multi-Impingement Cooling Channel in Turbine Blade Trail Edge. International Journal of Turbo & Jet-Engines 37:3, pages 241-256.
Crossref
M. Raizner & R. van Hout. (2020) Effect of impinging jet pulsation on primary and secondary vortex characteristics. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 151, pages 119445.
Crossref
Flávia V. Barbosa, Senhorinha F. C. F. Teixeira & José C. F. Teixeira. 2020. Computational Science and Its Applications – ICCSA 2020. Computational Science and Its Applications – ICCSA 2020 487 495 .
M. Raizner, V. Rinsky, G. Grossman & R. van Hout. (2019) The effect of jet pulsation on the flow field of a round impinging jet and the radially expanding wall jet. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 140, pages 606-619.
Crossref
Ahmet Ümit Tepe, Kamil Arslan, Yaşar Yetişken & Ünal Uysal. (2019) Effects of Extended Jet Holes to Heat Transfer and Flow Characteristics of the Jet Impingement Cooling. Journal of Heat Transfer 141:8.
Crossref
Andrea De Santis, Agustin Villa Ortiz, Afaque Shams & Lilla Koloszar. (2019) Modelling of a planar impinging jet at unity, moderate and low Prandtl number: Assessment of advanced RANS closures. Annals of Nuclear Energy 129, pages 125-145.
Crossref
Anupam Dewan & Anuj Kumar Shukla. Study of convective heat transfer in turbulent jet impingement using SAS and LES modelling. Study of convective heat transfer in turbulent jet impingement using SAS and LES modelling.
Keqian Zhu, Pingping Yu, Ningyi Yuan & Jianning Ding. (2018) Transient heat transfer characteristics of array-jet impingement on high-temperature flat plate at low jet-to-plate distances. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 127, pages 413-425.
Crossref
Javad Taghinia & Md Mizanur Rahman. (2018) Large eddy simulation of round impinging jet with one-equation subgrid scale model. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 116, pages 1250-1259.
Crossref
John M. Gorman, Ephraim M. Sparrow, Abhimanyu Ghosh & John P. Abraham. 2018. 1 41 .
B. Yang, S. Chang, H. Wu, Y. Zhao & M. Leng. (2017) Experimental and numerical investigation of heat transfer in an array of impingement jets on a concave surface. Applied Thermal Engineering 127, pages 473-483.
Crossref
Byeong Jo Hwang, Seon Ho Kim, Won Gu Joo & Hyung Hee Cho. (2017) Oblique Angle Effect of Impinging Jet on Heat Flow Characteristics of a Corrugated Structure. Journal of the Korean Society of Propulsion Engineers 21:2, pages 83-93.
Crossref
T. Furusawa, T. Fukue, H. Shirakawa & K. Hirose. (2017) Improvement of cooling performance of impinging air by intermittent flow control : Relationship between nozzle diameter and cooling performance. Improvement of cooling performance of impinging air by intermittent flow control : Relationship between nozzle diameter and cooling performance.
Nabil Kharoua, Lyes Khezzar, Zoubir Nemouchi & Mohamed Alshehhi. (2017) LES study of the combined effects of groups of vortices generated by a pulsating turbulent plane jet impinging on a semi-cylinder. Applied Thermal Engineering 114, pages 948-960.
Crossref
Prithvi Sai Penumadu & Arvind Gangoli Rao. (2017) Numerical investigations of heat transfer and pressure drop characteristics in multiple jet impingement system. Applied Thermal Engineering 110, pages 1511-1524.
Crossref
Takashi Fukue, Koichi Hirose, Hidemi Shirakawa, Hayate Natsusaka & Taiki Furusawa. (2016) Possibility of enhancement of cooling performance on heating surface by using intermittent jet flow. Possibility of enhancement of cooling performance on heating surface by using intermittent jet flow.
Harekrishna Yadav, Amit Agrawal & Atul Srivastava. (2016) Mixing and entrainment characteristics of a pulse jet. International Journal of Heat and Fluid Flow 61, pages 749-761.
Crossref
Mustafa Kemal Isman, Philip J. Morris & Muhiddin Can. (2015) Investigation of laminar to turbulent transition phenomena effects on impingement heat transfer. Heat and Mass Transfer 52:10, pages 2027-2036.
Crossref
Pourya Forooghi, Bettina Frohnapfel & Franco Magagnato. (2016) Simulation of a gaseous jet impinging on a convex heated surface – effect of inlet condition. Applied Thermal Engineering 105, pages 1076-1084.
Crossref
Sushil Kumar Rathore & Manab Kumar Das. (2016) Effect of Freestream Motion on Heat Transfer Characteristics of Turbulent Offset Jet. Journal of Thermal Science and Engineering Applications 8:1.
Crossref
Harekrishna Yadav, Atul Srivastava & Amit Agrawal. (2016) Characterization of Pulsating Submerged Jet—A Particle Image Velocimetry Study. Journal of Thermal Science and Engineering Applications 8:1.
Crossref
Sushil Kumar Rathore & Manab Kumar Das. (2015) Investigation on the relative performance of various low-Reynolds number turbulence models for buoyancy-driven flow in a tall cavity. Heat and Mass Transfer 52:3, pages 437-457.
Crossref
Yue-Tzu Yang, Yi-Hsien Wang & Jen-Chi Hsu. (2015) Numerical thermal analysis and optimization of a water jet impingement cooling with VOF two-phase approach. International Communications in Heat and Mass Transfer 68, pages 162-171.
Crossref
Beni Cukurel, Matthieu Fénot & Tony Arts. (2015) Conjugate Jet Impingement Heat Transfer Investigation via Transient Thermography Method. Journal of Thermophysics and Heat Transfer 29:4, pages 737-746.
Crossref
S.S. Feng, J.J. Kuang, T. Wen, T.J. Lu & K. Ichimiya. (2014) An experimental and numerical study of finned metal foam heat sinks under impinging air jet cooling. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 77, pages 1063-1074.
Crossref
Giovanni Maria Carlomagno & Andrea Ianiro. (2014) Thermo-fluid-dynamics of submerged jets impinging at short nozzle-to-plate distance: A review. Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science 58, pages 15-35.
Crossref
Sebastian Schulz, Simon Schueren & Jens von Wolfersdorf. (2014) A Particle Image Velocimetry-Based Investigation of the Flow Field in an Oblique Jet Impingement Configuration. Journal of Turbomachinery 136:5.
Crossref
Greg G. Gomang & Ann Lee. (2013) An Assessment of Turbulence Models in Simulating a Synthetic Jet. Applied Mechanics and Materials 465-466, pages 603-607.
Crossref
Yue-Tzu Yang, Shih-Chia Lin, Yi-Hsien Wang & Jen-Chi Hsu. (2013) Numerical simulation and optimization of impingement cooling for rotating and stationary pin–fin heat sinks. International Journal of Heat and Fluid Flow 44, pages 383-393.
Crossref
Rabijit Dutta, Anupam Dewan & Balaji Srinivasan. (2013) Comparison of various integration to wall (ITW) RANS models for predicting turbulent slot jet impingement heat transfer. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 65, pages 750-764.
Crossref
Mirko Bovo & Borja Rojo. Single Pulse Jet Impingement on Inclined Surface, Heat Transfer and Flow Field. Single Pulse Jet Impingement on Inclined Surface, Heat Transfer and Flow Field.
Yue-Tzu Yang, Shing-Cheng Chang & Chu-Shiang Chiou. (2013) Lattice Boltzmann method and large-eddy simulation for turbulent impinging jet cooling. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 61, pages 543-553.
Crossref
Simon Schueren, Florian Hoefler, Jens von Wolfersdorf & Shailendra Naik. (2013) Heat Transfer in an Oblique Jet Impingement Configuration With Varying Jet Geometries. Journal of Turbomachinery 135:2.
Crossref
M.A.R. Sharif & N.M. Ramirez. (2013) Surface roughness effects on the heat transfer due to turbulent round jet impingement on convex hemispherical surfaces. Applied Thermal Engineering 51:1-2, pages 1026-1037.
Crossref
A. A. Sedlov & V. L. Ivanov. (2013) Numerical simulation of gas dynamics and heat exchange of jet impinging on a surface. Russian Aeronautics (Iz VUZ) 55:4, pages 430-434.
Crossref
Maksim A. Pakhomov & Viktor I. Terekhov. (2012) Second-moment closure simulation of flow and heat transfer in a gas-droplets turbulent impinging jet. International Journal of Thermal Sciences 60, pages 1-12.
Crossref
Ching-Ming Chiang, Kuo-Hsiang Chien, Han-Ming Chen & Chi-Chuan Wang. (2012) Theoretical study of oscillatory phenomena in a horizontal closed-loop pulsating heat pipe with asymmetrical arrayed minichannel. International Communications in Heat and Mass Transfer 39:7, pages 923-930.
Crossref
Arkadiusz Ryfa & Ryszard A. Bialecki. (2011) Retrieving the heat transfer coefficient for jet impingement from transient temperature measurements. International Journal of Heat and Fluid Flow 32:5, pages 1024-1035.
Crossref
Yue-Tzu Yang, Tzu-Chieh Wei & Yi-Hsien Wang. (2011) Numerical study of turbulent slot jet impingement cooling on a semi-circular concave surface. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 54:1-3, pages 482-489.
Crossref
Richard J. Lozowy, Ahmed M. El-Shaboury, Hassan M. Soliman & Scott J. Ormiston. (2010) Simulation and performance enhancement of the air cooling system in the valve halls of a DC/AC power converter station. Building Simulation 3:3, pages 233-244.
Crossref
N. RajaratnamD. Z. ZhuS. P. Rai. (2010) Turbulence measurements in the impinging region of a circular jet. Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering 37:5, pages 782-786.
Crossref
N. Srinarayana, S.W. Armfield & Wenxian Lin. (2009) Laminar plane fountains impinging on a ceiling with an opposing heat flux. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 52:19-20, pages 4545-4552.
Crossref
Madhanabharatam Balasubramanyam, David Lineberry, Chien Chen & Vladimir Bazarov. (2009) Numerical Studies on Frequency Response to Mass Flow Rate Variations in a Hydromechanical Pulsator. Numerical Studies on Frequency Response to Mass Flow Rate Variations in a Hydromechanical Pulsator.
Giancarlo Alfonsi. (2009) Reynolds-Averaged Navier–Stokes Equations for Turbulence Modeling. Applied Mechanics Reviews 62:4.
Crossref
Guido Lodato, Luc Vervisch & Pascale Domingo. (2009) A compressible wall-adapting similarity mixed model for large-eddy simulation of the impinging round jet. Physics of Fluids 21:3.
Crossref
Mohamed Gadala. (2022) A Numerical Study of Two-Phase Cooling Phenomena in Steel Quenching Using Water Jet Impingement. SSRN Electronic Journal.
Crossref

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Order Reprints Request Corporate Permissions

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

Request Academic Permissions

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.