Advanced search
Publication Cover
Emerging Microbes & Infections Volume 8, 2019 - Issue 1
Submit an article Journal homepage
4,590
Views
63
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Articles

Immunization with whole cell but not acellular pertussis vaccines primes CD4 TRM cells that sustain protective immunity against nasal colonization with Bordetella pertussis

Mieszko M. WilkImmune Regulation Research Group, School of Biochemistry and Immunology, Trinity Biomedical Sciences Institute, Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, IrelandORCID Iconhttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-7947-633XView further author information
ORCID Icon,
Lisa BorknerImmune Regulation Research Group, School of Biochemistry and Immunology, Trinity Biomedical Sciences Institute, Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, IrelandView further author information
,
Alicja MisiakImmune Regulation Research Group, School of Biochemistry and Immunology, Trinity Biomedical Sciences Institute, Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, IrelandView further author information
,
Lucy CurhamImmune Regulation Research Group, School of Biochemistry and Immunology, Trinity Biomedical Sciences Institute, Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, IrelandView further author information
,
Aideen C. AllenImmune Regulation Research Group, School of Biochemistry and Immunology, Trinity Biomedical Sciences Institute, Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, IrelandView further author information
&
Kingston H. G. MillsImmune Regulation Research Group, School of Biochemistry and Immunology, Trinity Biomedical Sciences Institute, Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, IrelandCorrespondence[email protected]
ORCID Iconhttps://orcid.org/0000-0003-3646-8222View further author information
ORCID Icon
Pages 169-185 | Received 26 Sep 2018, Accepted 21 Dec 2018, Published online: 21 Jan 2019

Citations (63)

Keep up to date with the latest research on this topic with citation updates for this article.

Subscribe to citation updates

Read on this site (1)

Geraldine Blanchard-Rohner. (2022) Novel approaches to reactivate pertussis immunity. Expert Review of Vaccines 21:12, pages 1787-1797.
Read now

Articles from other publishers (62)

Zhannan Wang, Yingkai He, Wenfeng Wang, Yawen Tian, Chongbo Ge, Futing Jia, Tongyu Zhang, Gerui Zhang, Mingyue Wang, Jinshuo Gong, Haibin Huang, Jianzhong Wang, Chunwei Shi, Wentao Yang, Xin Cao, Yan Zeng, Nan Wang, Aidong Qian, Yanlong Jiang, Guilian Yang & Chunfeng Wang. (2023) A novel “prime and pull” strategy mediated by the combination of two dendritic cell-targeting designs induced protective lung tissue-resident memory T cells against H1N1 influenza virus challenge. Journal of Nanobiotechnology 21:1.
Crossref
Kingston H. G. Mills. (2023) How immunology can help reverse the pertussis vaccine failure. Nature Immunology 24:11, pages 1779-1780.
Crossref
Pauline Schmitt, Lisa Borkner, Seyed Davoud Jazayeri, Karen N McCarthy & Kingston HG Mills. (2023) Nasal vaccines for pertussis. Current Opinion in Immunology 84, pages 102355.
Crossref
Beatriz Miguelena Chamorro, Karelle De Luca, Gokul Swaminathan, Stéphanie Longet, Egbert Mundt & Stéphane Paul. (2023) Bordetella bronchiseptica and Bordetella pertussis: Similarities and Differences in Infection, Immuno-Modulation, and Vaccine Considerations. Clinical Microbiology Reviews 36:3.
Crossref
Rita Soares Barbosa Cardona, Lily Yin Weckx, Maria Isabel de Moraes-Pinto, Bárbara Cristina Ferreira Ramos, Andréia Regina Augusto dos Santos, Fernanda Garcia Spina, Beatriz Collaço de Araújo, Ralf Clemens & Sue Ann Costa Clemens. (2023) Pertussis antibodies and vaccination coverage among healthcare professionals in Brazil is inadequate: A cross-sectional serological study. Vaccine 41:39, pages 5769-5774.
Crossref
Ricardo da Silva Antunes, Emily Garrigan, Lorenzo G. Quiambao, Sandeep Kumar Dhanda, Daniel Marrama, Luise Westernberg, Eric Wang, Adam Abawi, Aaron Sutherland, Sandra K. Armstrong, Timothy J. Brickman, John Sidney, April Frazier, Tod J. Merkel, Bjoern Peters & Alessandro Sette. (2023) T cell reactivity to Bordetella pertussis is highly diverse regardless of childhood vaccination. Cell Host & Microbe 31:8, pages 1404-1416.e4.
Crossref
Colleen J. Sedney & Eric T. Harvill. (2023) The Neonatal Immune System and Respiratory Pathogens. Microorganisms 11:6, pages 1597.
Crossref
Kacy S. Yount, Jesse M. Hall, Kyle Caution, Mohamed M. Shamseldin, Myra Guo, Keirsten Marion, Audra R. Fullen, Yimin Huang, Jennifer A. Maynard, Sally A. Quataert, Rajendar Deora & Purnima Dubey. (2023) Systemic priming and intranasal booster with a BcfA-adjuvanted acellular pertussis vaccine generates CD4+ IL-17+ nasal tissue resident T cells and reduces B. pertussis nasal colonization. Frontiers in Immunology 14.
Crossref
Béré K. Diallo, Caitlín Ní Chasaide, Ting Y. Wong, Pauline Schmitt, Katherine S. Lee, Kelly Weaver, Olivia Miller, Melissa Cooper, Seyed D. Jazayeri, F. Heath Damron & Kingston H. G. Mills. (2023) Intranasal COVID-19 vaccine induces respiratory memory T cells and protects K18-hACE mice against SARS-CoV-2 infection. npj Vaccines 8:1.
Crossref
Lucy M. Curham, Jenny M. Mannion, Clíodhna M. Daly, Mieszko M. Wilk, Lisa Borkner, Stephen J. Lalor, Rachel M. McLoughlin & Kingston H.G. Mills. (2023) Bystander activation of Bordetella pertussis ‐induced nasal tissue‐resident memory CD4 T cells confers heterologous immunity to Klebsiella pneumoniae . European Journal of Immunology 53:5.
Crossref
Baifeng Yang, Dewu Zhu, Yisi Zhou, Beizhe Gong, Yuan Hu, Jiayou Zhang, Shihe Huang, Xuanxuan Nian, Xinghang Li, Xinguo Li, Kai Duan & Xiaoming Yang. (2023) Liposome and QS-21 Combined Adjuvant Induces theHumoral and Cellular Responses of Acellular Pertussis Vaccine in a Mice Model. Vaccines 11:5, pages 914.
Crossref
Xuanxuan Nian, Hongbo Liu, Mengyao Cai, Kai Duan & Xiaoming Yang. (2023) Coping Strategies for Pertussis Resurgence. Vaccines 11:5, pages 889.
Crossref
Kathryn M Edwards & Michael D Decker. (2023) An alternative route to pertussis protection?. The Lancet 401:10379, pages 800-801.
Crossref
Amanda D. Caulfield, Maiya Callender & Eric T. Harvill. (2023) Generating enhanced mucosal immunity against Bordetella pertussis: current challenges and new directions. Frontiers in Immunology 14.
Crossref
Kathryn M. Edwards, Michael D. Decker & F. Heath Damron. 2023. Plotkin's Vaccines. Plotkin's Vaccines 763 815.e19 .
Ewa Szwejser-Zawislak, Mieszko M. Wilk, Piotr Piszczek, Justyna Krawczyk, Daria Wilczyńska & Daniela Hozbor. (2022) Evaluation of Whole-Cell and Acellular Pertussis Vaccines in the Context of Long-Term Herd Immunity. Vaccines 11:1, pages 1.
Crossref
Evi van Schuppen, Janeri Fröberg, Prashanna Balaji Venkatasubramanian, Pauline Versteegen, Hans de Graaf, Jana Holubová, Joshua Gillard, Pieter G. M. van Gageldonk, Irma Joosten, Ronald de Groot, Peter Šebo, Guy A. M. Berbers, Robert C. Read, Martijn A. Huynen, Marien I. de Jonge & Dimitri A. Diavatopoulos. (2022) Prior exposure to B. pertussis shapes the mucosal antibody response to acellular pertussis booster vaccination. Nature Communications 13:1.
Crossref
Viviana Valeri, Akhésa Sochon, Clara Cousu, Pascal Chappert, Damiana Lecoeuche, Pascal Blanc, Jean-Claude Weill & Claude-Agnès Reynaud. (2022) The whole-cell pertussis vaccine imposes a broad effector B cell response in mouse heterologous prime-boost settings. JCI Insight 7:21.
Crossref
G. I. Karataev, A. Yu. Medkova, E. G. Semin, L. N. Sinyashina, R. A. Sioundioukova, S. V. Kulikov, N. A. Snegireva, I. N. Chernishova, M. V. Gavrilova, K. K. Bushkova, A. A. Lidzhieva, L. V. Kolobukhina, I. S. Kruzhkova, L. N. Merkulova, M. G. Rusanova, M. V. Bazarova, N. A. Antipyat, S. V. Smetanina, E. A. Smolyarchuk & I. N. Dyakov. (2022) Development of a Method and a Scheme for the Use of a Live Recombinant Vaccine "GamLPV". Safety and Tolerability of Double Intranasal Vaccination of Healthy Adult Volunteers. Drug development & registration 11:3, pages 202-208.
Crossref
Karolina Ucieklak. (2022) Krztusiec I „Efekt Czerwonej Królowej”. Postępy Mikrobiologii - Advancements of Microbiology 61:3, pages 133-145.
Crossref
Eline F de Jonge & Jan Tommassen. (2022) Conditional growth defect of Bordetella pertussis and Bordetella bronchiseptica ferric uptake regulator (fur) mutants . FEMS Microbiology Letters 369:1.
Crossref
Nela Klimova, Jana Holubova, Gaia Streparola, Jakub Tomala, Ludmila Brazdilova, Ondrej Stanek, Ladislav Bumba & Peter Sebo. (2022) Pertussis toxin suppresses dendritic cell-mediated delivery of B. pertussis into lung-draining lymph nodes. PLOS Pathogens 18:6, pages e1010577.
Crossref
Ming Z.M. Zheng & Linda M. Wakim. (2022) Tissue resident memory T cells in the respiratory tract. Mucosal Immunology 15:3, pages 379-388.
Crossref
Jana Holubova, Ondrej Stanek, Attila Juhasz, Illiassou Hamidou Soumana, Peter Makovicky & Peter Sebo. (2022) The Fim and FhaB adhesins play a crucial role in nasal cavity infection and Bordetella pertussis transmission in a novel mouse catarrhal infection model. PLOS Pathogens 18:4, pages e1010402.
Crossref
Soumik Barman, Dheeraj Soni, Byron Brook, Etsuro Nanishi & David J. Dowling. (2022) Precision Vaccine Development: Cues From Natural Immunity. Frontiers in Immunology 12.
Crossref
Kelly L. Weaver, Catherine B. Blackwood, Alexander M. Horspool, Gage M. Pyles, Emel Sen-Kilic, Emily M. Grayson, Annalisa B. Huckaby, William T. Witt, Megan A. DeJong, M. Allison Wolf, F. Heath Damron & Mariette Barbier. (2022) Long-Term Analysis of Pertussis Vaccine Immunity to Identify Potential Markers of Vaccine-Induced Memory Associated With Whole Cell But Not Acellular Pertussis Immunization in Mice. Frontiers in Immunology 13.
Crossref
Mohammad Alghounaim, Zainab Alsaffar, Abdulla Alfraij, Saadoun Bin-Hasan & Entesar Hussain. (2022) Whole-Cell and Acellular Pertussis Vaccine: Reflections on Efficacy. Medical Principles and Practice 31:4, pages 313-321.
Crossref
Marta Prygiel, Ewa Mosiej, Karol Wdowiak, Paulina Górska, Maciej Polak, Klaudia Lis, Katarzyna Krysztopa-Grzybowska & Aleksandra Anna Zasada. (2021) Effectiveness of experimental and commercial pertussis vaccines in the elimination of Bordetella pertussis isolates with different genetic profiles in murine model. Medical Microbiology and Immunology 210:5-6, pages 251-262.
Crossref
Rui Yuan, Jiang Yu, Ziqiao Jiao, Jinfei Li, Fang Wu, Rongkai Yan, Xiaojie Huang & Chen Chen. (2021) The Roles of Tissue-Resident Memory T Cells in Lung Diseases. Frontiers in Immunology 12.
Crossref
Julie Tomas, Yoon Koo, Dimitri Popoff, Vilma Arce-Gorvel, Sean Hanniffy, Jean-Pierre Gorvel & Cyrille Mionnet. (2021) PTX Instructs the Development of Lung-Resident Memory T Cells in Bordetella pertussis Infected Mice. Toxins 13:9, pages 632.
Crossref
Lisa Borkner, Lucy M. Curham, Mieszko M. Wilk, Barry Moran & Kingston H.G. Mills. (2021) IL-17 mediates protective immunity against nasal infection with Bordetella pertussis by mobilizing neutrophils, especially Siglec-F+ neutrophils. Mucosal Immunology 14:5, pages 1183-1202.
Crossref
Anja Saso, Beate Kampmann & Sophie Roetynck. (2021) Vaccine-Induced Cellular Immunity against Bordetella pertussis: Harnessing Lessons from Animal and Human Studies to Improve Design and Testing of Novel Pertussis Vaccines. Vaccines 9:8, pages 877.
Crossref
Elissa G. Currie & Scott D. Gray-Owen. (2021) Exploring the Ability of Meningococcal Vaccines to Elicit Mucosal Immunity: Insights from Humans and Mice. Pathogens 10:7, pages 906.
Crossref
Michael Super, Edward J. Doherty, Mark J. Cartwright, Benjamin T. Seiler, Fernanda Langellotto, Nikolaos Dimitrakakis, Des A. White, Alexander G. Stafford, Mohan Karkada, Amanda R. Graveline, Caitlin L. Horgan, Kayla R. Lightbown, Frank R. Urena, Chyenne D. Yeager, Sami A. Rifai, Maxence O. Dellacherie, Aileen W. Li, Collin Leese-Thompson, Hamza Ijaz, Amanda R. Jiang, Vasanth Chandrasekhar, Justin M. Scott, Shanda L. Lightbown, Donald E. Ingber & David J. Mooney. (2021) Biomaterial vaccines capturing pathogen-associated molecular patterns protect against bacterial infections and septic shock. Nature Biomedical Engineering 6:1, pages 8-18.
Crossref
Violaine Dubois & Camille Locht. (2021) Mucosal Immunization Against Pertussis: Lessons From the Past and Perspectives. Frontiers in Immunology 12.
Crossref
Janeri Fröberg & Dimitri A. Diavatopoulos. (2021) Mucosal immunity to severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 infection. Current Opinion in Infectious Diseases 34:3, pages 181-186.
Crossref
Ricardo da Silva Antunes, Ferran Soldevila, Mikhail Pomaznoy, Mariana Babor, Jason Bennett, Yuan Tian, Natalie Khalil, Yu Qian, Aishwarya Mandava, Richard H. Scheuermann, Mario Cortese, Bali Pulendran, Christopher D. Petro, Adrienne P. Gilkes, Lisa A. Purcell, Alessandro Sette & Bjoern Peters. (2021) A system-view of Bordetella pertussis booster vaccine responses in adults primed with whole-cell versus acellular vaccine in infancy. JCI Insight 6:7.
Crossref
Camille Locht. (2021) The Path to New Pediatric Vaccines against Pertussis. Vaccines 9:3, pages 228.
Crossref
M. Allison Wolf, Dylan T. Boehm, Megan A. DeJong, Ting Y. Wong, Emel Sen-Kilic, Jesse M. Hall, Catherine B. Blackwood, Kelly L. Weaver, Claire O. Kelly, Caleb A. Kisamore, Graham J. Bitzer, Justin R. Bevere, Mariette Barbier & F. Heath Damron. (2021) Intranasal Immunization with Acellular Pertussis Vaccines Results in Long-Term Immunity to Bordetella pertussis in Mice. Infection and Immunity 89:3.
Crossref
Violaine Dubois, Jonathan Chatagnon, Anaïs Thiriard, Hélène Bauderlique-Le Roy, Anne-Sophie Debrie, Loïc Coutte & Camille Locht. (2021) Suppression of mucosal Th17 memory responses by acellular pertussis vaccines enhances nasal Bordetella pertussis carriage. npj Vaccines 6:1.
Crossref
Ricardo da Silva Antunes, Lorenzo G. Quiambao, Ferran Soldevila, Aaron Sutherland, Bjoern Peters & Alessandro Sette. (2021) Lack of evidence supporting a role of IFN-β and TGF-β in differential polarization of Bordetella pertussis specific-T cell responses. Cytokine 137, pages 155313.
Crossref
Puja Bagri, Ramtin Ghasemi, Joshua J. C. McGrath, Danya Thayaparan, Emma Yu, Andrew G. Brooks, Martin R. Stämpfli & Charu Kaushic. (2020) Estradiol Enhances Antiviral CD4 + Tissue-Resident Memory T Cell Responses following Mucosal Herpes Simplex Virus 2 Vaccination through an IL-17-Mediated Pathway . Journal of Virology 95:1.
Crossref
Leah E. Cole, Jinrong Zhang, Kristl M. Pacheco, Philippe Lhéritier, Natalie G. Anosova, Julie Piolat, Lingyi Zheng & Nathalie Reveneau. (2020) Immunological Distinctions between Acellular and Whole-Cell Pertussis Immunizations of Baboons Persist for at Least One Year after Acellular Vaccine Boosting. Vaccines 8:4, pages 729.
Crossref
Nicolas Rouleau, Emilie Proust & Martine Chabaud-Riou. (2020) A Novel Outbred Mouse Model to Study Lung Memory Immunological Response Induced by Pertussis Vaccines. ImmunoHorizons 4:12, pages 762-773.
Crossref
Jana Holubová, Ondřej Staněk, Ludmila Brázdilová, Jiří Mašín, Ladislav Bumba, Andrew R. Gorringe, Frances Alexander & Peter Šebo. (2020) Acellular Pertussis Vaccine Inhibits Bordetella pertussis Clearance from the Nasal Mucosa of Mice. Vaccines 8:4, pages 695.
Crossref
Caitlín Ní Chasaide & Kingston H.G. Mills. (2020) Next-Generation Pertussis Vaccines Based on the Induction of Protective T Cells in the Respiratory Tract. Vaccines 8:4, pages 621.
Crossref
Jan T. Poolman. (2020) Expanding the role of bacterial vaccines into life-course vaccination strategies and prevention of antimicrobial-resistant infections. npj Vaccines 5:1.
Crossref
Elodie Lesne, Breeze E. Cavell, Irene Freire-Martin, Ruby Persaud, Frances Alexander, Stephen Taylor, Mary Matheson, Cécile A. C. M. van Els & Andrew Gorringe. (2020) Acellular Pertussis Vaccines Induce Anti-pertactin Bactericidal Antibodies Which Drives the Emergence of Pertactin-Negative Strains. Frontiers in Microbiology 11.
Crossref
Anne Zeddeman, Evi van Schuppen, Kristianne E. Kok, Marjolein van Gent, Kees J. Heuvelman, Marieke J. Bart, Han G. J. van der Heide, Joshua Gillard, Elles Simonetti, Marc J. Eleveld, Fred J. H. van Opzeeland, Saskia van Selm, Ronald de Groot, Marien I. de Jonge, Frits R. Mooi & Dimitri A. Diavatopoulos. (2020) Effect of FHA and Prn on Bordetella pertussis colonization of mice is dependent on vaccine type and anatomical site. PLOS ONE 15:8, pages e0237394.
Crossref
F. Heath Damron, Mariette Barbier, Purnima Dubey, Kathryn M. Edwards, Xin-Xing Gu, Nicola P. Klein, Kristina Lu, Kingston H. G. Mills, Marcela F. Pasetti, Robert C. Read, Pejman Rohani, Peter Sebo & Eric T. Harvill. (2020) Overcoming Waning Immunity in Pertussis Vaccines: Workshop of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases. The Journal of Immunology 205:4, pages 877-882.
Crossref
Audra R. Fullen, Kacy S. Yount, Purnima Dubey & Rajendar Deora. (2020) Whoop! There it is: The surprising resurgence of pertussis. PLOS Pathogens 16:7, pages e1008625.
Crossref
Eleonora E. Lambert, Véronique Corbière, Jacqueline A. M. van Gaans-van den Brink, Maxime Duijst, Prashanna Balaji Venkatasubramanian, Elles Simonetti, Martijn Huynen, Dimitri D. Diavatopoulos, Pauline Versteegen, Guy A. M. Berbers, Françoise Mascart & Cécile A. C. M. van Els. (2020) Uncovering Distinct Primary Vaccination-Dependent Profiles in Human Bordetella pertussis Specific CD4+ T-Cell Responses Using a Novel Whole Blood Assay. Vaccines 8:2, pages 225.
Crossref
Maryam Sadat Soltani, Fereshteh Eftekhar, Fereshteh Shahcheraghi, Mojtaba Noofeli & Seyed Reza Banihashemi. (2020) Extraction of Outer membrane Vesicles from Vaccinal Strain of Bordetella Pertussis as the First Step of a Vaccine Candidate Study Against Pertussis Infection. Iranian Journal of Medical Microbiology 14:3, pages 213-226.
Crossref
Ricardo da Silva Antunes, Lorenzo G. Quiambao, Aaron Sutherland, Ferran Soldevila, Sandeep Kumar Dhanda, Sandra K. Armstrong, Timothy J. Brickman, Tod Merkel, Bjoern Peters & Alessandro Sette. (2020) Development and Validation of a Bordetella pertussis Whole-Genome Screening Strategy . Journal of Immunology Research 2020, pages 1-11.
Crossref
Ang Lin, Danijela Apostolovic, Maja Jahnmatz, Frank Liang, Sebastian Ols, Teghesti Tecleab, Chenyan Wu, Marianne van Hage, Ken Solovay, Keith Rubin, Camille Locht, Rigmor Thorstensson, Marcel Thalen & Karin Loré. (2020) Live attenuated pertussis vaccine BPZE1 induces a broad antibody response in humans. Journal of Clinical Investigation 130:5, pages 2332-2346.
Crossref
Joanne M. O'Hara, Naresh S Redhu, Elaine Cheung, Nahid G. Robertson, Izabel Patik, Shorouk El Sayed, Claudette M. Thompson, Muriel Herd, Katherine B. Lucas, Evan Conaway, Cynthia C. Morton, Donna L. Farber, Richard Malley & Bruce H. Horwitz. (2020) Generation of protective pneumococcal-specific nasal resident memory CD4+ T cells via parenteral immunization. Mucosal Immunology 13:1, pages 172-182.
Crossref
Monica C. Gestal, Hannah M. Johnson & Eric T. Harvill. (2019) Immunomodulation as a Novel Strategy for Prevention and Treatment of Bordetella spp. Infections. Frontiers in Immunology 10.
Crossref
Bianchini, Argentiero, Camilloni, Silvestri, Alunno & Esposito. (2019) Vaccination against Paediatric Respiratory Pathogens. Vaccines 7:4, pages 168.
Crossref
Juan Carlos Sanz Moreno & Belén Ramos Blázquez. (2019) Papel del estado de portador en el control de enfermedades infecciosas y su relación con la vacunación. Revista Madrileña de Salud Pública 2:10, pages 1-8.
Crossref
Dylan T. Boehm, M. Allison Wolf, Jesse M. Hall, Ting Y. Wong, Emel Sen-Kilic, Hayden D. Basinger, Sebastian A. Dziadowicz, Maria de la Paz Gutierrez, Catherine B. Blackwood, Shelby D. Bradford, Katherine A. Begley, William T. Witt, Melinda E. Varney, Mariette Barbier & F. Heath Damron. (2019) Intranasal acellular pertussis vaccine provides mucosal immunity and protects mice from Bordetella pertussis. npj Vaccines 4:1.
Crossref
Susanna Esposito, Paola Stefanelli, Norman K. Fry, Giorgio Fedele, Qiushui He, Pauline Paterson, Tina Tan, Markus Knuf, Carlos Rodrigo, Catherine Weil Olivier, Katie L. Flanagan, Ivan Hung, Iria Lutsar, Kathryn Edwards, Miguel O'Ryan & Nicola Principi. (2019) Pertussis Prevention: Reasons for Resurgence, and Differences in the Current Acellular Pertussis Vaccines. Frontiers in Immunology 10.
Crossref
Eleonora E. Lambert, Anne-Marie Buisman & Cécile A. C. M. van Els. 2019. Pertussis Infection and Vaccines. Pertussis Infection and Vaccines 81 98 .

Related research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.