https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1686-8328
![Sample our Humanities journals, sign in here to start your FREE access for 14 days]({"type":"image" , "src" : "/sda/5939/TOC-Subject-Sample-2021-Humanities.jpg"})
ABSTRACT
The British Empire was at the height of its power in the late nineteenth century. Most scholars focus on imperial expansion. However, not much light has been shed on the process of consolidation, which I term pacification. This paper tries to cover this historiographical slip by making a case study of British pacification of the Lushai Hills of North-East India. While analysing this micro region, I shall contextualise it within the broader policies of the British imperium. Both Callwell and some of the modern commentators are wrong in asserting that British Empire building involved a display of brute force in curbing the insurrectionary natives. Overall, British consolidation policy was more complex. Repeated application of a moderate amount of violence through the medium of small war prepared the ground for pacification. The non-military components of pacification (construction of roads, schools and a job creation programme) are equivalent to what modern-day scholars term winning the hearts and minds of the populace of the disturbed regions. Use of proportionate force and implementation of certain non-military schemes enabled a small number of white men to rule over millions of brown people for more than a century.
Acknowledgements
I am grateful to three of my research scholars, Dr Moumita Chowdhury, Mr Aryama Ghosh and Ms Sohini Mitra, for providing me with some of the materials used in this paper. The author is Guru Nanak Chair Professor at the Department of History, Jadavpur University, Kolkata, India, and a Global Fellow at the Peace Research Institute Oslo (PRIO), Norway. The research is done at both the institutions.
Disclosure Statement
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).
Notes
1 The two most important works are Moreman, The Army in India and Roe, Waging War in Afghanistan.
2 Sen, ‘Genealogies of Exception: Writing Histories of North-East India,’ 1–16.
3 Neeladri Bhattacharya and Joy L.K. Pachuau, ‘Introduction,’ 1–20.
4 Kolsky, ‘Introduction,’ 1–15.
5 Baruah, In the Name of the Nation.
6 One exception is Franke, War and Nationalism in South Asia.
7 Quoted from Callwell, Small Wars, 21.
8 Beckett, Modern Insurgencies and Counter-Insurgencies, 32.
9 Clausewitz, On War, 479–83.
10 Heuser, The Evolution of Strategy, 391.
11 Note by the Commander-in-Chief on the Finance Member's Proposals for Reduction of the Native Army, Para. 9, 1Q/21, 4 Aug. 1894, George White Collection, MSS.EUR.F.108/24, Asia, Pacific and Africa Collections (APAC), British Library (BL), London.
12 Howard, The Franco-Prussian War, 62.
13 Callwell, Small Wars.
14 Noelle, State and Tribe in Nineteenth-Century Afghanistan, 38–59.
15 Callwell, Small Wars, 21.
16 Ian Beckett, ‘The Campaign of the Lost Footsteps,’ 996.
17 Collins, ‘Defining Victory in Victorian Warfare, 1860–1882,’ 895–929.
18 Beckett, ‘How Wars End,’ 29–44.
19 Gwynn, Imperial Policing.
20 Notes on the Expedition, p. 9, Consultation C, Proceedings, Foreign Department, 1871, National Archives of India (NAI), New Delhi.
21 Whittingham, ‘“Savage Warfare”,’ 591–607.
22 Howe and Brice (eds.), Brill's Companion to Insurgency and Terrorism in the Ancient Mediterranean.
23 Mockaitis, British Counterinsurgency; Thornton, ‘The British Army and the Origins of its Minimum Force Philosophy,’ 83–106.
24 One example is Bayly, Indian Society and the Making of British Empire. He argues that mainly economic collaboration between the British overseas merchants and Indian landlords, banias and moneylenders resulted in the expansion of the British Empire in late eighteenth-century South Asia. The role of organised violence is almost deleted from the equation.
25 See, for instance, Bennett, ‘“A Very Salutary Effect”,’ 415–44.
26 Porch, Counterinsurgency, xi, 1–2.
27 Gott, Britain's Empire.
28 Gopal, Insurgent Empire.
29 Woodthorpe, The Lushai Expedition, 5–6.
30 Cederlöf, Founding an Empire on India's North-Eastern Frontiers 1790–1840, 3–5.
31 Spate and Learmonth, India and Pakistan, 601–03.
32 Spate and Learmonth, India and Pakistan, 609.
33 Military Report on the Chin-Lushai Country, 1, Simla: Government Central Printing Office, 1893, Assam State Archives (ASA), Guwahati.
34 Pau, ‘Administrative Rivalries on a Frontier,’ 188; Guite, Against State, against History, 50; Military Report on the Chin-Lushai Country, 5–6.
35 Beattie, Imperial Frontier, 52.
36 Woodthorpe, The Lushai Expedition, 3.
37 Zou, ‘Raiding the Dreaded Past,’ 75–105; Kar ‘Heads in the Naga Hills,’ 335–69.
38 Mitchell, Carbon Democracy.
39 Mackenzie, Hill Tribes of North-East Frontier of Bengal, 287, 289.
40 The Lushais 1873 to 1889, 6, Shillong: Assam Secretariat Press, 1889, ASA, Guwahati.
41 Porter, Military Orientalism, 1.
42 Maher in Salafi-Jihadism shows how radical aggressive militant Islamism emerged due to internal fault lines in several Islamic societies of West Asia.
43 Guite, ‘Colonialism and its Unruly,’ 1188–232; Guite, Against State, against History.
44 Scott, Art of Not Being Governed.
45 Administration Report of the North Lushai Hills for the Year 1895–96, 1, Shillong: Assam Secretariat Printing Office, 1896, 117D/303, ASA, Guwahati.
46 Goswami, The History of Assam, 138–39.
47 Notes on the Indian Army of Bengal, Its Present Material and Organization, as Compared with the Past, 8, L/MIL/17/2/468, APAC, BL, London.
48 Cederlöf, ‘“Natural Boundaries”,’ 64.
49 Mackenzie, Hill Tribes of North-East Frontier of Bengal, 292; Kelly, Military Report on the Chin-Lushai Country, 2.
50 Goswami, History of Assam, 139.
51 Kelly, Military Report on the Chin-Lushai Country, 3, 7.
52 Charles Wood to John Lawrence, no. 72, 1 Sept. 1864, Letters from Secretary of State, Dec. 1863–Dec. 1864, vol. 1, John Lawrence Collection, MSS.EUR.F.90/25, APAC, BL, London.
53 Kelly, Military Report on the Chin-Lushai Country, 4–6.
54 Survey Operations in the Naga Country, 60/D, 227, 59-C, ASA, Guwahati.
55 Quoted from Woodthorpe, The Lushai Expedition, 6.
56 Roberts, Forty-One Years in India, 310–11.
57 Shannon, ‘The Native American Way of War in the Age of Revolutions,’ 149.
58 Cardew, A Sketch of the Services of the Bengal Native Army, 320–21.
59 Tone, ‘Partisan Warfare in Spain and Total War,’ 243–59.
60 Gait, A History of Assam, 408.
61 Reid, History of the Frontier Areas Bordering on Assam, 1.
62 The Lushais 1873 to 1889, 5.
63 Gott, Britain's Empire, 20–21.
64 Reid, History of the Frontier Areas bordering on Assam, 1.
65 Beattie, Imperial Frontier, 164–66.
66 Chambers, Report of the Chittagong Column, 11.
67 Chambers, Report of the Chittagong Column, 11.
68 Reid, Chin-Lushai Land, 48–59.
69 Frontiers and Overseas Expeditions, vol. 5, 316–41.
70 Porch, Counterinsurgency, 20–22.
71 Wazirs, no. 4, pp. 7–8, MSS.EUR.F.163/3, APAC, BL, London.
72 Ward, ‘The American Militias: “The Garnish of a Table”,’ 169.
73 Minute by C.B. Pritchard, Enclosure no. 2, 1Q/14, 29 Aug. 1893, George White Collection, MSS.EUR.F.108/24, APAC, BL, London.
74 Proportion of British to Native Troops in India, Geo. S. White, Para. 43, 1Q/10, 28 July 1893, George White Collection, MSS.EUR.F.108/24, APAC, BL, London.
75 Military Report on the Chin-Lushai Country, 1.
76 Minute by C.B. Pritchard, Enclosure no. 2, Para. 23, 1Q/14, 29 Aug. 1893, George White Collection, MSS.EUR.F.108/24, APAC, BL, London.
77 Broers, ‘Revolt and Repression in Napoleonic Italy: 1796–1814,’ 197–217.
78 Lees, Bureaucratic Culture in Early Colonial India.
79 Memorandum on the Different Systems adopted on the North-Western Frontier for the Employment of Local Levies, 11, Simla: Govt Central Press, 1888, MSS.EUR.F.163/7, APAC, BL, London.
80 General Frederick Roberts, Correspondence with the Viceroy of India (The Marquis of Dufferin and Ava) with Commander-in-Chief India: 1885–88, vol. 4, Calcutta: Superintendent of Govt. Printing, 1890, 30, 32, L/MIL/17/5/1615, Part IV, APAC, BL, London.
81 Roberts, Correspondence with the Viceroy of India: 1885–88, 32, vol. 4.
82 General Frederick Roberts, Correspondence with the Viceroy of India (The Marquess of Lansdowne) with Commander-in-Chief in India: 26 Nov. 1888–2 April 1893, 140, vol. 5, Calcutta: Superintendent of Govt Printing, 1893, L/MIL/17/5/1615, Part V, APAC, BL, London; Shakespear, History of the Assam Rifles, 82.
83 Administration Report of the North Lushai Hills for the Year 1894–95, 5-6, Shillong, Assam Secretariat Printing Office, 1895, ASA, Guwahati.
84 From the Officiating Secretary to the Chief Commissioner of Assam to the Secretary to the GOI, Foreign Department, 6 July 1898, in Administration Report of the North Lushai Hills for the year 1897–98, Shillong: Assam Secretariat Printing Office, 1898, ASA, Guwahati.
85 Batalas, ‘Send a Thief to Catch a Thief,’ 149–77.
86 Memorandum on the Different Systems adopted on the North-Western Frontier for the Employment of Local Levies, 9-10, MSS.EUR.F.163/7, APAC, BL, London.
87 Quoted from Letter from Govt of India, Foreign Department to George Hamilton 14 July 1896, in Military Operations on the North-West Frontier of India, vol. 2, 1897–98, London: HMSO, 1898, MSS.EUR.F.163/15 (b), APAC, BL, London.
88 Sen, ‘The Law of Emptiness,’ 207–36.
89 Administration Report of the North Lushai Hills for the Year 1894–95, 5.
90 Report on the Administration of the South Lushai Hills for the Year 1897–98, 5, 117-D/240, Calcutta: Bengal Secretariat Press, 1898, ASA, Guwahati.
91 Report on the Administration of the South Lushai Hills for the Year 1897–98, 7.
92 Administration Report of the Lushai Hills for the Year 1899–1900, 10, Shillong: Assam Secretariat Printing Office, 1900, ASA, Guwahati.
93 Administration Report of the North Lushai Hills for the Year 1895–96, 5–6.
94 Administration Report of the Lushai Hills for the Year 1899–1900, 12.
95 Rid, ‘The Nineteenth Century Origins of Counterinsurgency Doctrine,’ 735–43.
96 Measures for Dealing with Lushai Raiders, Bengal Government, File no. 2368, 22 May 1871, Foreign Department Political A, Aug. 1871, NAI, New Delhi.
97 Administration Report of the Lushai Hills for the Year 1899–1900, 10–12.
98 Field Operations, Lushai, 1892, WO 106/6303, Public Record Office, Kew.
99 Quoted from Administration Report of the North Lushai Hills for the Year 1894–95, 12. 16 annas = Rs 1.
100 Administration Report of the North Lushai Hills for the Year 1895–96, 6.
101 Administration Report of the North Lushai Hills for the Year 1896–97, 12, Shillong: Assam Secretariat Office, 1897, 117D/289, ASA, Guwahati.
102 Quoted from Administration Report of the North Lushai Hills for the Year 1896–97, 12.
103 Pau, Indo-Burma Frontier and the Making of the Chin Hills, 156–57.
104 Quoted from Report on the Administration of the South Lushai Hills for the Year 1897–98, 8.
105 From the Officiating Secretary to the Chief Commissioner of Assam to the Secretary to the GOI, Foreign Department, 6 July 1898, in Administration Report of the North Lushai Hills for the year 1897–98.
106 Administration Report of the North Lushai Hills for the year 1897–98, 16.
107 Singha, Coolie's Great War.
108 Kuss, German Colonial Wars and the Context of Military Violence, 37–75.
109 Erickson, ‘The Armenians and Ottoman Military Policy,’ 141–67.
110 Finch, A Progressive Occupation?
111 Gopal, Insurgent Empire.
112 Stannard, American Holocaust.
113 Whittingham, Charles E. Callwell and the British Way in Warfare, 42–44.
114 Berman, et al., Small Wars, Big Data.