Effects of between-batch variability on the type I error rate in biosimilar development

Abstract

Biological products are known to have some between-batch variation. However, the traditional method to assess biosimilarity does not consider such between-batch variation. Beta-binomial models and linear random effect models are considered in order to incorporate between-batch variation for the binary endpoints and the continuous endpoints, respectively. In this article, emphasis is on the beta-binomial models for the binary endpoint case. For the linear random effect models of the continuous endpoint case, we cite relevant references along with conducting some simulation studies. Overall, we show that the type I error rates are inflated when biosimilarity is evaluated by the traditional method, which ignores between-batch variation.

KEYWORDS:

• Random effect model
• Beta-binomial model
• Follow-on biologic
• Equivalence test

Funding

This research was supported by the Basic Science Research Program through the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) funded by the Ministry of Education (2016R1D1A1A09916819).