The “ultimate empathy machine” as technocratic solutionism? Audience reception of the distant refugee crisis through virtual reality

ABSTRACT

This article aims to deconstruct the myth of technological utopianism which contends that immersive virtual reality (VR) can inevitably lead to a more moral and egalitarian world due to its promises of copresence, immediacy and transcendence in humanitarian communication. The problématique we explore is whether existing VR artifacts, as exemplars of the “ultimate empathy machine,” construct a technocratic solutionism which becomes constitutive of humanitarian crises themselves. Drawing upon empirical material from focus group discussions and in-depth interviews with VR audiences in China, Germany, and the UK, the findings show that VR may easily construct a depoliticized hyperreality of intense spectacularity and trap audiences within an improper distance, thereby reworking the colonial legacies of humanitarianism while also obfuscating complex asymmetries of power and structural political exclusion. These findings have important implications for reminding humanitarian news organizations and aid agencies that they should not rely entirely on the particular affordances of VR to gain a moral bond with the distant refugee crisis.

KEYWORDS:

• Cosmopolitanism
• mediation
• refugee
• technology
• virtual reality

Acknowledgments

We are very grateful to Martin Scott, Stefan Kramer, Paul Reilly, Virpi Salojärvi and two anonymous reviewers, for their constructive comments on earlier versions of this manuscript. In addition, a preliminary version of this article was presented at the IAMCR conference (2021): many thanks to the event participants for their excellent input and feedback.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).