ABSTRACT
In this wide-ranging interview Priscilla Alderson discusses how she came to research parental and childhood consent and became a sociologist and how, late in her career, she became convenor of the critical realism group started by Roy Bhaskar at the Institute for Education in London. She discusses aspects of her seminal research over the years on multiple subjects, such as the rights of children, and reflects on what critical realism has added to her social research.
Disclosure statement
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).
Notes
4 Note from Jamie: see, for example, British Paediatric Association (1992); Alderson (Citation2001a).
5 Note from Jamie: for example, re ethics, Priscilla and colleagues have made numerous contributions to the European Association of Centers of Medical Ethics (EACME) publication, Bulletin of Medical Ethics. The EACME has become a major network of bioethics researchers. See, for example, Alderson (Citation1990c, Citation1992a, Citation1995a, Citation1995b, Citation1998c, Citation1998d, Citation2002d, Citation2005d); Goodey, Alderson, and Appelby (Citation1999); Alderson, Madden, Oakley and Wilkins(Citation1994); Alderson and Nicholson (Citation1997). And Visit: https://eacmeweb.com
6 Note from Jamie: for an indication of the cumulative range of Priscilla’s work and collaborations over the years see, for example, Alderson (Citation1991a, Citation1992b, Citation1992c, Citation1992d, Citation1993b, 1994, Citation1996a, Citation1998a, Citation2000a, Citation2000b, Citation2001b, Citation2002a, Citation2002b, Citation2004a, Citation2005a, Citation2005b, Citation2005c, Citation2006a, Citation2007b, Citation2007c, Citation2008b, Citation2010a, Citation2011a, Citation2012a, Citation2012b, Citation2014a, Citation2014b, Citation2015a, Citation2018a, Citation2019a, Citation2020c); Alderson and Goodey (Citation1998c); Alderson and Montgomery (Citation1993); Farsides, Williams, and Alderson (Citation2004); Williams, Alderson, and Farsides (Citation2001, Citation2002).
9 Also, notably, the National Perinatal Epidemiology Unit precursor to Cochrane the movement that promotes EBM, evidence based medicine.
11 Note from Jamie: for biographical social history of the time from an influential feminist see Rowbotham (Citation2021). For realist discussion of various waves of feminism etc. see van Ingen, Grohmann, and Gunnarsson (Citation2020); Saavedra and Pilgrim (Citation2021); Gunnarsson, Dy, and van Ingen (Citation2016). For an example of applied ecofeminism see Topić (Citation2022).
12 Note from Priscilla: my emphasis.
13 Note from Jamie: emphasizing of course that ontology is still theory … theory whose situational argument and claims are different than epistemology.
14 Note from Priscilla: NHS Community Health Councils (CHCs) during 1974–2003 in England were composed of volunteers and local authority councillors. They officially represented patients, formally evaluated local health services and could work very effectively to raise standards of care. I was a CHC member 1976–1980.
17 Note from Jamie: see, for example, Flatschart (Citation2017).
19 Note from Jamie: the exchange between David Pilgrim and Jason Summersell illustrates something of the range and different concerns and foci. For example, Pilgrim (Citation2018); Summersell (Citation2018).
24 Note from Jamie, for a special issue of Globalizations on this subject, including work from the well known realist Clive Spash see introduction Gills and Morgan (Citation2021).
25 Note from Priscilla: I’m assuming readers are familiar with the four stage MELD dialectic, an acronym for 1M first moment, 2E second edge, 3L third level and 4D fourth dimension.
Alderson, P. 2001a. On Doing Qualitative Research Linked to Ethical Health Care. London: Wellcome Trust. ISBN: 1841290319. Alderson, P. 1990c. “Consumer Views on Gene Therapy.” Bulletin of Medical Ethics 58: 14–20. Alderson, P. 1992a. “Consent, Young People and Psychiatry.” Bulletin of Medical Ethics 84: 43–43. Alderson, P. 1995a. “A National Research Ethics Committee?” Bulletin of Medical Ethics 107: 13–16. Alderson, P. 1995b. “Ethics and Social Research: Principles Plus Personal, Practical and Political Concerns.” Bulletin of Medical Ethics 115: 13–14. Alderson, P. 1998c. “Ethical and Social Aspects of Genetics and Neuro-Science: The Wellcome Proposals.” Bulletin of Medical Ethics 136: 20–21. Alderson, P. 1998d. “When Things go Wrong, What Should be Said?” Bulletin of Medical Ethics 141: 13–21. Alderson, P. 2002d. “The new Genetics: Promise or Threat to Children?” Bulletin of Medical Ethics 176: 13–18. Alderson, P. 2005d. “Complications Within Consent.” Bulletin of Medical Ethics 210: 15–19. Goodey, C., P. Alderson, and J. Appelby. 1999. “The Ethical Implications of Antenatal Screening for Down's Syndrome.” Bulletin of Medical Ethics 147: 13–17. Alderson, P., M. Madden, A. Oakley, and R. Wilkins. 1994. “Access and Multi-Centre Research.” Bulletin of Medical Ethics 105: 13–16. Alderson, P., and R. Nicholson. 1997. “Deciding When to Withhold or Withdraw Life-Sustaining Treatment for Children.” Bulletin of Medical Ethics 127: 13–20. Alderson, P. 1991a. “Out of the Darkness.” The Health Service Journal 101 (5272): 22–24. Alderson, P. 1992b. “Defining Ethics in Nursing Practices.” Nursing Standard 6: 33–35. Alderson, P. 1992c. “In the Genes or in the Stars? Children's Competence to Consent.” Journal of Medical Ethics 18: 119–124. Alderson, P., ed. 1992d. Young People, Psychiatric Treatment and Consent. London: Institute of Education. Alderson, P., ed. 1993b. Disabled People and Consent to Medical Treatment and Research. London: Institute of Education. Alderson, P. 1996a. “Equipoise as a Means of Managing Uncertainty: Personal, Communal and Proxy.” Journal of Medical Ethics 117: 135–139. Alderson, P. 1998a. ““Talking to Children - and Talking with Them.”.” In The Genetic Testing of Children, edited by A. Clarke, 27–36. Oxford: Bios Scientific Publishers. Alderson, P. 2000a. “School Students’ Views on School Councils and Daily Life at School.” Children &Society 14 (2): 121–134. Alderson, P. 2000b. ““Children’s Rights: A New Approach to Studying Childhood.”.” In Early Childhood Services, edited by H. Penn. Milton Keynes: Open University Press. Chp. 7. Alderson, P. 2001b. “Research by Children: Rights and Methods.” International Journal of Social Research Methodology: Theory and Practice 4 (2): 139–153. Alderson, P. 2002a. ““Young Children's Health Care Rights.”.” In The New Handbook of Children's Rights, edited by B. Franklin, 155–167. London: Routledge/Falmer. Alderson, P. 2002b. ““Children, Healing, Suffering and Voluntary Consent.”.” In Gender, Health and Healing: Conference in Honour of Meg Stacey, edited by G. Bendelow, M. Carpenter, C. Vautier, and S. Williams, 198–211. London: Routledge/Falmer. Alderson, P. 2004a. “Ethics.” In Doing Research with Children and Young People, edited by S. Fraser, V. Lewis, S. Ding, M. Kellett, and C. Robinson, 97–112. London: Sage/Open University. Alderson, P. 2005a. “Children’s Rights: A new Approach to Studying Childhood.” In Understanding Early Childhood: Ideas and Controversies, edited by H. Penn, 127–141. Buckingham: Open University Press. Alderson, P. 2005b. “Designing Ethical Research with Children.” In Exploring Ethical Research with Children, edited by A. Farrell, 27–36. Buckingham: Open University Press. Alderson, P. 2005c. “More Questions Than Answers: Research and Ethics.” Sociology Review 2: 6–8. Alderson, P. 2006a. “Parents’ Experience of Sharing Neonatal Information and Decisions.” Social Science & Medicine 62: 1319–1329. Alderson, P. 2007b. “Competent Children? Minors’ Consent to Health Care Treatment and Research.” Social Science & Medicine 65 (11): 2272–2283. Alderson, P. 2007c. “The Ethics of Space in Clinical Practice.” Clinical Ethics 2 (2): 85–91. Alderson, P. 2008b. “Economic Alternatives and Childhood Poverty.” International Journal of Green Economics 2 (1): 77–94. Alderson, P. 2010a. “Younger Children’s Individual Participation in Matters That Affect Them.” In Handbook of Children’s Participation, edited by B. Percy-Smith, and N. Thomas, 88–96. London: Routledge. Alderson, P. 2011a. “Children’s Rights in Research About Religion and Spirituality.” In The Study of Children in Religions: A Methods Handbook, edited by S. Ridgely, 50–66. New York: New York University Press. Alderson, P. 2012a. “Green Economics: As if Younger Generations Matter.” In Handbook of Green Economics: A Practitioner's Guide, edited by M. Kennet, E. Courea, K. Black, A. Bouquet, and I. Pipinyte, 271–274. Reading: Green Economics Institute. Alderson, P. 2012b. “Young Children’s Human Rights: A Sociological Analysis.” International Journal of Children’s Rights 20: 177–198. Alderson, P. 2014a. “Ethics.” In Understanding Research with Children and Young People, edited by A. Clark, R. Flewitt, M. Hammersley, and M. Robb, 85–102. London: Sage. Alderson, P. 2014b. “Children as Patients.” In The Sage Handbook of Child Research, edited by G. Melton, A. Ben-Arieh, J. Cashmore, G. Goodman, and N. Worley, 100–117. London: Sage. Alderson, P. 2015a. “Reforms to Healthcare Systems and Policies Influences from Children’s Rights and Childhood Studies.” In Enhancing Children's Rights: Connecting Research, Policy and Practice, edited by A. Smith, 17–32. Basingstoke: Palgrave. Alderson, P. 2018a. ““Common Criticisms of Children’s Rights and 25 Years of the IJCR.”.” In Children’s Rights: New Issues, New Themes, New Perspectives, edited by M. Freeman, 39–50. Leiden: Brill. Alderson, P. 2019a. “Ethics in Health Research.” In Researching Health: Qualitative, Quantitative and Mixed Methods, edited by M. Saks, and J. Allsop, 3rd ed., 389–408. London: Sage. Alderson, P. 2020c. “Powerful Knowledge, Myth or Reality? Four Necessary Conditions if Knowledge is to be Associated with Power and Social Justice.” London Review of Education 18 (1): 96–106. Alderson, P., and C. Goodey. 1998c. “Doctors, Ethics and Special Education.” Journal of Medical Ethics 24: 49–55. Alderson, P., and J. Montgomery. 1993. “Can Children Withhold Consent to Treatment? Abstract Debate is Unhelpful.” British Medical Journal 307: 260–261. Farsides, B., C. Williams, and P. Alderson. 2004. “Aiming Towards ‘Moral Equilibrium’: Health Care Professionals’ Views on Working Within the Morally Contested Field of Antenatal Screening.” Journal of Medical Ethics 30 (5): 505–509. Williams, C., P. Alderson, and B. Farsides. 2001. “Conflicting Perceptions of the Fetus: Person, Patient, Nobody, Commodity?” New Genetics and Society 20 (3): 225–238. Williams, C., P. Alderson, and B. Farsides. 2002. “Too Many Choices? Hospitals and Community Staff Reflect on the Future of Prenatal Screening.” Social Science & Medicine 55 (5): 743–753. Alderson, P. 1982. Your Baby in Special Care. London: National Association for the Welfare of Children in Hospital. NAWCH. 1980. Coming Into Hospital. London: National Association for the Welfare of Children in Hospital. Alderson, P., and M. O’Toole. 1981. Your Child in Hospital: A Parents’ Handbook. London: National Association for the Welfare of Children in Hospital. Alderson, P., and C. Goodey. 1996. “Research with Disabled Pupils: How Useful is a Child-Centred Ethics?” Children & Society 10 (2): 106–116. Alderson, P., and C. Goodey. 1998b. “Theories of Consent.” British Medical Journal 317: 1313–1315. Alderson, P., and C. Goodey. 1999. “Autism in Special and Inclusive Schools: ‘there has to be a Point to Their Being There’.” Disability & Society 14 (2): 249–261. Archer, M. S., and J. Morgan. 2020. “Contributions to Realist Social Theory: An Interview with Margaret S. Archer.” Journal of Critical Realism 19 (2): 179–200. Rescher, N., and J. Morgan. 2020. “Philosophical Purpose and Purposive Philosophy: An Interview with Nicholas Rescher.” Journal of Critical Realism 19 (1): 58–77. Porpora, D. V., and J. Morgan. 2020. “American Sociology, Realism, Structure and Truth: An Interview with Douglas V. Porpora.” Journal of Critical Realism 19 (5): 522–544. Norrie, A., and J. Morgan. 2021. “Realism, Dialectic, Justice and Law: An Interview with Alan Norrie.” Journal of Critical Realism 20 (1): 98–122. Lawson, T., and J. Morgan. 2021a. “Cambridge Social Ontology, the Philosophical Critique of Modern Economics and Social Positioning Theory: An Interview with Tony Lawson, Part 1.” Journal of Critical Realism 20 (1): 72–97. Lawson, T., and J. Morgan. 2021b. “Cambridge Social Ontology, the Philosophical Critique of Modern Economics and Social Positioning Theory: An Interview with Tony Lawson, Part 2.” Journal of Critical Realism 20 (2): 201–237. Jessop, B., and J. Morgan. 2022. “The Strategic-Relational Approach, Realism and the State: From Regulation Theory to Neoliberalism via Marx and Poulantzas, an Interview with Bob Jessop.” Journal of Critical Realism 21 (1): 83–118. Elder-Vass, D., and J. Morgan. 2022. “Materially Social Critical Realism: An Interview with Dave Elder-Vass.” Journal of Critical Realism, forthcoming. https://doi.org/10.1080/14767430.2022.2028233 Sayer, A., and J. Morgan. 2022. “A Realist Journey Through Social Theory and Political Economy: An Interview with Andrew Sayer.” Journal of Critical Realism, doi:10.1080/14767430.2022.2049078. Rowbotham, S. 2021. Daring to Hope: My Life in the 1970s. London: Verso. van Ingen, M., S. Grohmann, and L. Gunnarsson, eds. 2020. Critical Realism, Feminism and Gender: A Reader. London: Routledge. Saavedra, G., and D. Pilgrim. 2021. “Review of Critical Realism, Feminism and Gender: A Reader.” Journal of Critical Realism. doi:10.1080/14767430.2021.1993702 Gunnarsson, L., A. Dy, and M. van Ingen. 2016. “Critical Realism, Gender and Feminism: Exchanges, Challenges, Synergies.” Journal of Critical Realism 15 (5): 433–439. Topić, M. 2022. Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Affairs in the British Press: An Ecofeminist Critique of Neoliberalism. London: Routledge. Flatschart, E. 2017. “Feminist Standpoints and Critical Realism. The Contested Materiality of Difference in Intersectionality and New Materialism.” Journal of Critical Realism 16 (3): 284–302. Pilgrim, D. 2018. “Reclaiming Reality and Redefining Realism: The Challenging Case of Transgenderism.” Journal of Critical Realism 17 (3): 308–324. Summersell, J. 2018. “Trans Women are Real Women: A Critical Realist Intersectional Response to Pilgrim.” Journal of Critical Realism 17 (3): 329–336. Gills, B., and J. Morgan. 2021. “Economics and Climate Emergency.” Globalizations 18 (7): 1071–1086. Additional information
Notes on contributors
Priscilla Alderson
Priscilla Alderson is Professor Emerita of Childhood Studies, Social Science Research Unit, Social Research Institute, University College London. She is the author of numerous books and articles. Additional detail is given in the interview.
Jamie Morgan
Jamie Morgan is Professor of Economic Sociology at Leeds Beckett University. He co-edits the Real-World Economics Review with Edward Fullbrook. He has published widely in the fields of economics, political economy, philosophy, sociology and international politics.