A Cross-Cultural Study of the Role of Efficacious Beliefs and Perceived Media Effects on Threat Perception in Predicting COVID-19 Compliance in China and the United States

ABSTRACT

Self-centered vs. collective-oriented perceptions and beliefs have bearings on an individual’s behavior. In the context of the global coronavirus pandemic, this study attempts a cross-cultural analysis of public compliance with COVID-19 prevention measures in China and the United States. Using data collected from two parallel surveys, we explore how individualism and collectivism have affected respondents’ efficacious beliefs, perception bias and compliance behaviors. Findings show that higher self-efficacy in individualistic cultures tends to produce a wider self-other perceptual gap. Further, we found that individual-referenced variables (i.e. self-efficacy and perceived media effects on threat perception on oneself) play a stronger role in predicting public compliance in America. In comparison, collective-oriented and other-referenced measures (i.e. collective efficacy and perceived media effects on threat perception on others) are a stronger predictor of compliance in China than in the United States. The theoretical implications of the culturally rooted locus of reference (self vs. others) for compliance behaviors are discussed.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).

Notes

1. For the survey in China the quotas were set for age and gender based on the latest China population census (National Bureau of Statistics in China, 2013). To control the quality of the sample, we used two trap questions to filter out invalid respondents. The sample distributions in terms of age and gender are comparable to the characteristics of the 2013 China population census. The mean age in the sample was 33.14 years as compared to 37.1 years in the census; 44.5% of the respondents were women while 48.73% were women in the census.