A critical analysis of the surgical outcomes for the treatment of Peyronie’s disease

Peer review under responsibility of Arab Association of Urology.

Figures & data

Table 1 Outcomes of the Nesbit, plication and I&G procedures for PD.

Year	Ref.	No. of patients	Mean follow-up (months)	Overall satisfaction (%)	Penile straightening (%)	Penile shortening (%)	Sensory changes (%)	Postop ED (%)
Nesbit
2005	[38]	40	81	N/A	87.5	100	20	5
2004	[36]	218	89	83.5	86.3	17.4	11	11.5
2003	[37]	42	84	76.2	90.5	50	21.4	2.3
1997	[39]	28	22	79	79	37	14	4
1995	[34]	359	21	N/A	82	100	N/A	1.6
1994	[40]	78	50	79	N/A	40	3.8	23
Plication
2004	[41]	28	30	67.8	82.1	74	35.7	28
2002	[42]	124	31	96	85	41	6	6
2001	[43]	44	49	N/A	29	90	36	48
1998	[44]	29	34	62	79.3	8.3	37.9	6.8
1997	[45]	22	19.5	N/A	91	9	9	4.5
1996	[46]	28	34	82	57.1	N/A	3.5	17.9
I&G (graft material)
2011	[47]	86 (mixed)	83	34.9	58.1	11.6	–	N/A
2009	[48]	15 (buccal)	12	93	100	0	–	0
2008	[49]	70 (vein)	41.7	87.1	75.7	N/A	–	8.6
2006	[50]	14 (fascia lata)	31	93	79	29	–	7
2005	[51]	113 (vein)	12	92.9	85.8	25.7	–	8.8
2005	[52]	26 (buccal)	38	N/A	92.3	15.4	–	7.7
2002	[53]	51 (vein)	24	92.2	82.4	35.3	–	7.8
2000	[54]	50 (vein)	32	88.0	80.0	40.0	–	6.0
1998	[55]	112 (vein)	N/A	92.0	96.4	17.0	–	11.6