Sympathy or strategy: social capital drivers for collaborative contributions to the IS community

Abstract

Despite growing interest in delineating the social identity of Information Systems (IS) research and the network structures of its scholarly community, little is known about how the IS community network is shaped by individual conceptions and what motivates IS researchers to engage in research collaboration. Using an exploratory theoretical framework that is based on three dimensions of social capital theory, we examined 32 years of scientific co-authorship in an international IS researcher community. We formulated propositions to empirically examine the multi-level relationships between personal drivers and the resulting complex network organization of the IS community. Our propositions are refined with qualitative interviews and tested using a survey. This process revealed a collaborative research culture with several individual dispositions, including a strategic structural focus, a cognitive focus and a relational focus. These exist among actors displaying a range of differing behaviours such as active engagement and passive serendipity. Our study indicates individual differences at the conception stage of engaging in academic collaboration impact on the resulting network-level configuration. We identified that regional preference, maturity life cycles and lack of small-world properties highlight the important role of senior members as structural backbones and brokers within the IS community.

Keywords:

• IRIS research community
• co-authorship
• collaboration dispositions
• dynamic network analysis
• social capital

Additional information

Notes on contributors

Matthias Trier

About the authors

Matthias Trier is Associate Professor in the Department of IT Management at Copenhagen Business School. His research and publications focus on computer-mediated communication and collective processes of virtual interaction, dynamic social network analysis, social media implementation, information transfer and knowledge work.

Judith Molka-Danielsen

Judith Molka-Danielsen is Associate Professor of Information Science at Molde University College in Norway. She has published in the area of examination of collaborative networks. In 2011–2013 Molka-Danielsen is President of the Information Systems Researchers in Scandinavia Association (IRIS), a Chapter of the Association of Information Systems.