The effect of breed and feed-type on the sensory profile of breast meat in male broilers reared in an organic free-range system

Abstract

1. Studies on the sensory profiling of male broiler breast meat were carried out to evaluate the effect of two very different broiler breeds (JA757 and New Hampshire), two different feed types (broiler and grower feed) and age at slaughter (82 and 110 d).

2. The sensory profiling consisted of a pilot study, 4 training sessions, and finally the assessment. During the training session a panel of 9 assessors defined 17 attributes, which were used to describe the smell, texture and flavour of the breast fillets. Each attribute was evaluated on a 15-cm unstructured line scale.

3. The breast meat became significantly less hard, and more juicy and tender in the New Hampshire at 110 d of age, whereas the opposite was found in JA757, which also acquired a more “sourish” flavour with age. The smell of “sweet/maize” and “bouillon” became weaker with age in JA757, but not in New Hampshire.

4. Several significant differences in relation to the main factors of breed and age were found. The traditional broiler hybrid JA757 did best for most smell and flavour attributes, whereas New Hampshire did best for the texture attributes. Age had a negative effect on the flavours and smell attributes “fresh chicken”, “neck of pork” and “sweet maize”, but a positive effect on the texture attribute “crumbly”. In addition meat was more “stringy” at 110 d of age.

5. The flavours “neck of pork” and “umami” were significantly improved when JA757 was fed on the broiler feed and when New Hampshire was given the grower feed. The meat smelt more “sourish” at 82 d of age and less “sourish” at 110 d of age when the grower feed was consumed. Meat was significantly harder and stringier when JA757 was fed on the grower feed. This was not the case for New Hampshire. In general, the meat was significantly less crumbly and stringier with the grower feed.

6. Overall a very distinct difference in sensory profile was found between the two breeds. In addition different slaughter ages and feeding strategies should be taken into consideration in a niche production based on alternative genotypes.

Acknowledgements

We thank the International Centre for Research in Organic Food Systems (ICROFS) for financial support, and Fejoe Research Orchard for allowing us to do the experiment.