Comparison of Seven SO₄-S Extraction Methods for Analysis by Turbidimetry or ICP Spectrometry

Abstract

Soil sulfur (S) analyses for fertilizer recommendations in the northern Great Plains often do not reflect crop S requirements. Seven SO₄-S extraction methods with S determination by either turbidometry or inductively coupled plasma emission spectroscopy including Ca(H₂PO₄)₂ and KH₂PO₄ (both containing 500 ug/l P), 0.25 M KCl (40 ºC) and 0.25 M KCl (room temperature), H₂O, DTPA, and Mehlich 3 extractants. Three horizon depths of three soils from a previous field study were used for these comparisons. Average standard deviations for turbidometric determinations were 4.3 times greater than ICP determinations. With turbidometry, S values were H₂O > KH₂PO₄ > Ca(H₂PO₄)₂ > KCl (40 ºC) = KCl, while with ICP, the values were Mehlich 3 > KCl (40 ºC) = KCl > DTPA (diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid) > KH₂PO₄ > H₂O > Ca(H₂PO₄)₂. Extraction with KCl at room temperature with ICP determination appears to show promise, but further method evaluation is necessary before it can be recommended as a SO₄-S test method.

Keywords:

• Extraction methods
• ICP
• inductively coupled plasma emission spectroscopy
• soil sulfur
• soil testing
• turbidometry

Additional information

Funding

The author gratefully acknowledges the partial support of the USDA North Central Region Canola Research Program and the North Dakota State Board of Agricultural Research and Extension.