Beyond the excused/unexcused absence binary: classifying absenteeism through a voluntary/involuntary absence framework

Abstract

Student absenteeism in secondary schools has received international academic attention for quite some time. Absenteeism has been linked to diminished academic outcomes and is one of the leading causes of high school dropout. Although absenteeism is a serious concern for educational scholars, the definitions of absences and their subtypes are inadequately developed in academic literature. The overreliance on excused/unexcused absences that posit the school and the family as the arbitrators of the validity of an absence is a troubling concern, as it glosses over the underlying causes for an absence. This study outlines and critiques the varying conceptions of absenteeism found in the literature and proposes the use of the voluntary/involuntary absenteeism framework as a viable approach to studying non-attendance. The voluntary absence concept is cognizant of the motivational factors affecting student attendance. When the school is perceived as a hostile environment that is often equated with failure some pupils may voluntarily choose to avoid the institution. Involuntary absences refer to absences that are imposed on the student by the conditions of her or his life. Having to work to supplement familial income can often negate a youth’s ability to be present in school. This framework provides an opportunity to both acknowledge the students’ agency in deciding when to attend and to investigate deeper the students’ life circumstances that hinder regular attendance.

Keywords:

• truancy
• absenteeism
• secondary school attendance
• school refusal
• voluntary/involuntary absence

Acknowledgments

The author would like to thank Richard Barwell, Gene Vasilopoulos, and Joel Westheimer for their assistance and guidance in this endeavor.

Disclosure statement

The author will not receive any financial interest or benefit from the direct application of this research.