The distinctiveness of Canadian immigration experience

ABSTRACT

Canada's experience with immigration has been comparatively positive and mass immigration has considerable popular support within the country. The distinctive Canadian policy model—including large numbers with skill-based selection, multiculturalism and other policies aimed at promoting integration, and provincial autonomy—deserves international attention. However, Canada's success with immigration is only partly related to its policies and these may not be easily transferable to other contexts. Skill-based immigrant selection may be the most important feature of the Canadian model contributing to its success, and the effectiveness of this policy is clearly contingent on border control, which in the case of Canada is facilitated by geographical isolation. Canada's symbolic commitment to multiculturalism emphasizes the social integration of immigrants and this goal is also served by significant social services supporting settlement and language acquisition. The most significant distinctive feature of the Canadian approach to immigration may be the belief that immigration represents a positive opportunity to build the economy and develop the country. This belief represents a resource helping the country address some of the current problems confronting immigration, including reduced employment success of immigrants and evidence that racial divisions have significance particularly for certain groups. The belief in mass immigration as a positive resource and development opportunity underlies much of the positive discourse on immigration in Canada.

Keywords:

• Canada
• discrimination
• employment
• Europe
• immigration
• integration
• multiculturalism
• policy
• racism

Notes

¹German Marshall Fund of the United States, Transatlantic Trends Immigration: Key Findings 2010 (Washington, DC: German Marshall Fund of the United States 2010).

² Globe and Mail newspaper article, 17 October 2008, A2.

³Martin Ådahl and Petter Hojem, Kanadamodellen: Hur invandring leder till job (Stockholm: FORES 2011).

⁴Jeffrey G. Reitz, ‘Canada: immigration and nation-building in the transition to a knowledge economy’, in Wayne Cornelius, Philip L. Martin, James F., Hollifield and Takeyuki Tsuda (eds), Controlling Immigration: A Global Perspective (Stanford CA: Stanford University Press 2004), 97–133.

⁵Jeffrey G. Reitz, ‘Pro-immigration Canada: social and economic roots of popular views’, IRPP Study, no. 20 (Montreal: Institute for Research on Public Policy October 2011).

⁶Alain Bélanger, and Eric Caron Malenfant, ‘Ethnocultural diversity in Canada: prospects for 2017’ (Statistics Canada Catalogue No. 11-008), Canadian Social Trends, winter 2005.

⁷Jeffrey G. Reitz, ‘Pro-immigration Canada: social and economic roots of popular views’.

⁸Peter M. Dungan, Morley Gunderson, and Tony Fang, ‘The macroeconomic impact of Canadian immigration: an empirical analysis using the FOCUS model’, Paper presented at the Citizenship and Immigration Canada Research Network meeting, Ottawa, 26 October 2010); George J. Borjas, Heaven's Door (Princeton: Princeton University Press 1999).

⁹Lesleyanne Hawthorne, ‘The impact of economic selection policy on labour market outcomes for degree-qualified migrants in Canada and Australia’, IRPP Choices, vol. 14, no. 5, May 2008, 1–47.

¹⁰Mark Cully, ‘Skilled migration selection policies: recent Australian reforms’, Migration Policy Practice, vol, 1, no. 1, October-November 2011, 4–7 (5).

¹¹Delphine Nakache and Paula J. Kinoshita, ‘The Canadian Temporary Foreign Worker Program: do short-term economic needs prevail over human rights concerns?’, IRPP Study, No. 5 (Montreal: Institute for Research on Public Policy, May 2010).

¹²Research and Evaluation Branch, Citizenship and Immigration Canada, Canada Facts and Figures: Immigration Overview. Permanent and Temporary Residents, 2010, 13.

¹³Philip Martin, ‘Temporary worker programs: US and global experiences’ (University of California-Davis, 15 March 2008).

¹⁴Jeffrey G. Reitz, ‘Selecting immigrants for the short term: is it smart in the long run?’, Policy Options, July/August 2010, vol. 31, no.7, 12–16.

¹⁵Nathan Glazer, We Are All Multiculturalists Now (Cambridge: Harvard University Press 1997).

¹⁶Arthur Schlesinger, The Disuniting of America: Reflections on a Multicultural Society (New York: W.W. Norton 1992).

¹⁷Brian Barry, Culture and Equality: An Egalitarian Critique of Multiculturalism, Harvard University Press 2001.

¹⁸Samuel Huntington, Who We Are: Challenges to America's National Identity, New York, Simon and Schuster 2004).

¹⁹Amartya Sen. ‘Two confusions, and counting’, Globe and Mail, 6 August 2006, and ‘The uses and abuses of multiculturalism: Chili and Liberty’, New Republic, 27 February 2006; see Paul Kelly (ed.), Multiculturalism Reconsidered: Culture and Equality and its Critics (London: Polity Press 2002).

²⁰Parliament of Canada, House of Commons Debates, 3rd session, 28th Parliament, volume 8, 8 October 1971, Ottawa: Queen's Printer.

²¹Margaret Young, ‘Immigration: the Canada-Quebec Accord’, Ottawa: Library of Parliament, Law and Government Division, 2004. http://www.parl.gc.ca/information/library/PRBpubs/bp252-e.htm.

²²Jeffrey G. Reitz, ‘Pro-immigration Canada’, 15.

²³Neil Bissoondath, Selling Illusions: The Cult of Multiculturalism in Canada (revised edition) (Toronto: Penguin 2002).

²⁴Will Kymlicka, Multicultural Citizenship: A Liberal Theory of Minority Rights (Oxford: Oxford University Press 1995).

²⁵Will Kymlicka, Finding Our Way: Rethinking Ethnocultural Relations in Canada (Oxford: Oxford University Press 1998).

²⁶Jeffrey G. Reitz and Raymond Breton, The Illusion of Difference: Realities of Ethnicity in Canada and the United States (Toronto: C.D. Howe Institute 1994).

²⁷Irene Bloemraad, Becoming a Citizen: Incorporating Immigrants and Refugees in the United States and Canada (Berkeley CA: University of California Press 2006).

²⁸Jeffrey G. Reitz, ‘Immigrant employment success in Canada, part II: understanding the decline’, Journal of International Migration and Integration, vol. 8, no. 1, 2007, 37–62.

²⁹Roy McMurtry and Dr Alvin Curling, Review of The Roots of Youth Violence: Findings, Analysis and Conclusions, vol. 1 (Toronto: Queen's Printer for Ontario 2008).

³⁰Stephen Lewis, Report to the Office of the Premier (Toronto: Government of Ontario 1992); Ratna Omidvar and Ted Richmond, ‘Immigrant settlement and social inclusion in Canada’, Perspectives on Social Inclusion, Laidlaw Foundation Working Paper Series (Toronto: Laidlaw Foundation 2003).

³¹Daniel Stoffman, Who Gets In: What's Wrong with Canada's Immigration Program—and How to Fix It (Toronto: Macfarlane, Walter and Ross 2002).

³²Jeffrey G. Reitz and Rupa Banerjee, ‘Racial inequality, social cohesion, and policy issues in Canada’ in Keith Banting, Thomas Courchene and Leslie Seidle (eds), Belonging? Diversity, Recognition and Shared Citizenship in Canada: The Art of the State, vol. 3 (Montreal: Institute for Research on Public Policy 2007) 489-545.

³³Jeffrey G. Reitz, Raymond Breton, Kenneth Dion and Karen Dion, Multiculturalism and Social Cohesion: Potentials and Challenges of Diversity (New York: Springer 2009).

³⁴Robert Putnam, ‘E Pluribus Unum: diversity and community in the twenty-first century: the 2006 Johan Skytte Prize Lecture’, Scandinavian Political Studies, vol. 30, no. 2, 2007, 137-74.